I don't think a former personal relationship indicates the respective companies operate the same way.
> Even worse, people are actually PAYING quite a lot to get the privilege of having that company playing with your most private data.
Paying for something is a good thing. Historically in the Valley, companies for whose services you do not pay money tend to abuse your data as they use it as a source to earn money. I think in general, companies take more care of your data if the contract is explicit: I pay you money for this service, and expect corresponding controls over my privacy. Now, I'm not saying it's the case at all companies, just that I think the trend you mention is reversed.
> This field needs to be heavily regulated.
I agree. We absolutely should have better laws, and people should be able to delete their data without question (and not have remnants stored). In the EU, that wouldn't fly.
Disclaimer: I worked at 23andMe.
And claimed the laws are the ones preventing them from doing that.
I really doubt this. I've been genotyped by 23andMe and the most interesting information I've seen from their health reports are a handful of disease probabilities and some fairly useless-to-me traits (like, for instance, a probabilistic view of my hair color). Even if you jump into the fray with something like Promethease or look at data on SNPedia, each SNP only has a handful of studies and there's little to no research on hundreds of thousands of SNPs. Only a few sets have been analyzed for specific purposes like Alzheimer's and rare diseases, and those are indeed rare.
Science doesn't advance like the technology industry. It takes slow, methodical research to point to anything super conclusive. If we wanted a dystopia where job aptitude was determined by DNA, for example, we would need hundreds of studies and conclusive evidence that some genetic data indicates a very good match and not just a hunch. That research has to come from somewhere, continually be reproduced, and undergo the scientific process. That's all stuff that has to be paid for, which is something not a lot of people are willing to do.
> why would ANYONE in their right mind give their DNA to a company in Silicon Valley that is explicitely using Google as a model for Data privacy ?
It's more of a curiosity thing. I get a more complete view of myself, and we potentially help advance research in medicine and diseases. It's symbiotic.
This is about to change. The academic research going on is immense and GWAS studies coming in the 10 years will be characterizing everything - from your chance to develop cancer, to car crash or dropping out of school.
You need to be aware of what analyses of your data is being shown to you compared to what are possible and can be run in the background. It's a little bit like the Facebook telling things about you in ~2011 (your best friend is X) and then Cambridge Analytica pouring on it five years later to serve you ads that would best affect your voting pattern.
My father has Parkinson's and provided his DNA to 23AndMe using one of their free kits [1]. Companies like this represent a chance of finding a cure. There are certainly concerns with companies accumulating large amounts of genetic data, but huge data sets are required for deep learning and other AI methodologies. Sharing one's genetic data, and allowing other companies to form partnerships to gain access to that data, will likely represent a key step in identifying the cause (and hopefully potential cures) for such diseases.
What I would like to see is some tighter regulations around all of this: No sharing of specific data, complete anonymization of all the data sets would be a good start
I mean, it doesn't take very long before it's worth collecting a sample without your permission.
How can this be solved though? A model where DNA is only shared if you want to, and where you fully remain in control of your data.
A lot of things remain a mystery in our body, especially in our brain. I'm definitely not comfortable giving a perfect map of my body/brain to a private for-profit company in Silicon Valley.
I've been thinking about this a lot since you posted yesterday and I think you're doing yourself, your relatives, and your whole ethnicity a favor IF your data is used to build better drugs.
There's a huge issue with drug testing skewing against certain ethnicities, which is why some drugs are not effective for certain people. This seems like a good solution.
- So you paid to give them your data
- They patent something that in essence belongs to you
- You need that cure you need to pay them again.
Even worse, people are actually PAYING quite a lot to get the privilege of having that company playing with your most private data.
This field needs to be heavily regulated. In 20 years we will be able to extract all type of crazy information from DNA and it might be our biggest liability if it is shared across private companies. This will truly be the dystopian future, in which every business will make a decision based on your public DNA profile.
As everything in Silicon Valley, they are hiding behind the fact that it can be used to make "The world a better place" and cure sone diseases. It should be clear what the end goal is though.