News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:48AM (#17609177)
TL; DR iPhones are pricey. Not sure how to interpret this article. Apple has never been about market share; it’s about profit share. I saw no case made that India’s lower middle class is a better bet than China’s fast-growing or India’s growing middle classes.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by narag on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:07AM (#17609835)
TL; DR iPhones are pricey. Not sure how to interpret this article. Apple has never been about market share

There's a slightly more complex factor. Economics work differently in different countries. It's not that there are less rich persons, but that being rich is less expensive because goods in general are cheaper: housing, food, transportation, etc. If you sell an article at the same price in such a country, it's like selling an iPhone in USA for $4k. Even middle class can't afford it, or even if they can, they would choose to expend the money on something else with better value.

In Spain we experience such an effect. We share the currency with our northern neighbourghs, but salaries are roughly half (guess what I'm doing next month). I own a €107 Xiaomi. I could buy an iPhone but I prefer to expend the (minimum config) 1159 - 107 € in better things:

https://www.apple.com/es/shop/buy-iphone/iphone-x

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by widdershins on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:20AM (#17609931)
Sure, but none of that changes the margins Apple wants to make per phone, and the cost of manufacturing. Therefore I guess they just accept "we won't sell many phones in country X" because they want that sweet sweet margin.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by umanwizard on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:11PM (#17610352)
This isn't really specific to iPhones. Any goods traded on the international market which cost a similar amount (in absolute dollar terms) in any country will feel more expensive in purchasing power terms to people in poorer countries.

This applies to Harley Davidson motorcycles (which I would guess are pretty rare in India) just as much as it applies in iPhones.

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by narag on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @07:58PM (#17614030)
It isn't specific to iPhones, why would it? Anyway any goods for which there are reasonable priced alternatives are specially sensible and are probably going to have extremely crappy sales. Also we're talking about phones, a common appliance, not a luxury item by itself, so the market share numbers will be ridiculous.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by scarface74 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:06AM (#17609299)
Doesn’t there have to be a tipping point where you have enough market share to make your platform viable enough for developers to even bother selling in a certain area or to localize your app for that market?

Second question (from complete ignorance on Indian culture), what does “localization” for the Indian market mean when there are at least 22 different languages there?

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by toast0 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:43AM (#17609616)
iPhone users are more attractive to developers than Android users because they're more likely to spend money in the app store. (This is an unobvious way that iPhones are even more expensive than the sticker price)

Localization for India is complex. To start with, you need to use their national rupee symbol. But also, many devices in the region may not have any Indian languages, or may only have Hindi; so you may need to go beyond the system apis. Some users don't know how to find the system settings, or aspirationally want to use English, but aren't very fluent. Literacy in general is a challenge. English tech words are commonly used in everyday speech in other languages, so you may not want to translate them.

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:44AM (#17609628)
> Literacy in general is a challenge

Amongst the part of the population who can afford an iPhone?

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by toast0 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:49AM (#17610164)
Less literate people may not be very likely to buy an iPhone, but a relative may buy them one or give them an old one.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by phobosdeimos on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:15PM (#17610380)
Can relate. I have an Android phone and I will never pay for an app. There are usually free alternatives for everything on F-droid. And I'm tech savvy enough to pirate when it is needed and I run an adblocker.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by scarface74 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @01:00PM (#17610802)
I don’t agree with piracy of apps. Developers should get paid. But looking through my apps on my iOS devices, I’ve only paid for three apps - a calculator app and one game to remove ads and Infinity Blade back in 2010-2011.

I do pay for services that have an iOS app but they are not just iOS apps. That includes Office365, Evernote, DirecTVNow, Hulu, Netflix (not really, its free with T-mobile), Apple Music, and so guess I could include various streaming apps that I can use via my DirecTV login.

I would have paid for Overcast to support Marco, but he started his own podcast display ad network and he monetizes that way. I usually pay to turn off ads on apps I use frequently but I find topic relevant podcast ads so relevant, I consider the ads to be a feature.

I’ve always said it was a fool’s errand trying to make money on $0.99 downloads. Either create a service that generates reoccurring revenue or develop apps for B2B deployments where a company is willing to pay a lot of money for custom deployments. That’s where I made money working for companies doing mobile development.

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by bena on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:20AM (#17609930)
> (This is an unobvious way that iPhones are even more expensive than the sticker price)

That's like saying hiring locksmiths is pricier than buying a crowbar.

Yeah, both will get you in doors, but one is a bit not legal.

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by izacus on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:26AM (#17609990)
A user opting for a free / cheaper / ad-supported app is not doing anything illegal or wrong. It's how free market works and benefits the consumer.

Implying that not buying into a more expensive platform with more expensive software is illegal is just wrong.

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by bena on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:39AM (#17610091)
I'm not implying that. I'm implying that a country where software piracy is rampant and 60% of all software is pirated that a platform in which pirating apps is easier would be more popular than one in which it is more difficult.

This drives the price down for other apps because not only do you have to compete with free versions that may be worse, but free, you also have to compete with a free version of your own app because someone distributed it for free.

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by izacus on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:10PM (#17610341)
Android is also a platform with significantly higher amount of free and opensource apps (with which you ALSO need to compete!) and TCO of such a phone is significantly lower.

And yet you immediately jump to conclusion that everyone is doing something illegal.

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by scarface74 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @03:28PM (#17612056)
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by bena on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @02:54PM (#17611792)
Call it an informal poll of people I know who have an Android. And a function of statistics.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by nmridul on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:23AM (#17609967)
'Localization' not just language customization. But also what locals want.

- Dual SIM phones. Most people have multiple SIM, mostly prepaid and recharge them based on the cheapest offer. Incoming calls are free. So if a provider has better offer on outgoing calls, that sim is used that month for making calls and next month they use the other number.

- SD card support. Best selling phones support this. People carry lots of movies and music with them, mostly pirated and takes lot of space. And you can normally buy SD cards pre-filled with popular songs and movies that you just insert into your phone when traveling.

- 3.5 inch headphone jack. Yes, people need this. Bluetooth sets are costly.. $30 for bt headphone, compare that to a $100 xiaomi phone.

- And of course, side loading of apps. Android allows this, iphone no. So you get apps from some one and just use it, without going to play store.

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by thesauri on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @02:08PM (#17611398)
Some of these aspects are rapidly changing. Since a new player, Jio, entered the telco market a couple of years ago prices on prepaid subscriptions have dropped significantly. All the telcos have be forced to offer cheap monthly packages which easily contain over a gigabyte of data per day plus virtually unlimited calls and texts. This for a mere 2-4$ per month which many people actually can afford. With the unlimited calls to all operators there's no need for dual SIM cards any more. Telcos also offer their own video and music streaming services (such as Jio Music) which are included in the monthly plans, reducing the need to pirate music as storing them locally. With extensive 4G coverage and over a gigabyte of data, per day, there's little need to download everything.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by jorvi on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:35AM (#17610054)
> SD card support. Best selling phones support this. People carry lots of movies and music with them, mostly pirated and takes lot of space. And you can normally buy SD cards pre-filled with popular songs and movies that you just insert into your phone when traveling.

With Android phones already being much less secure than iPhones (and doubly so because the cheaper Androids often run older versions) that seems like a terribly easy exploit vector.

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by newen on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:34PM (#17610544)
Now SD cards are a security vulnerability? You sound ridiculous.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by jorvi on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @06:47PM (#17613619)
Sticking an SD card preloaded with files of unknown, shady origin in your phone is not a vulnerability? You sound ridiculous. If you were visiting some random street stall in India or China and they offered you a USB stick that pinky-promise only contains clean warez, would you put it in your laptop?
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by scarface74 on Thursday July 26, 2018 @02:19AM (#17615412)
If Android is so insecure that reading media flies from an SD card can cause issues, that’s not a glowing recommendation of Android.

On second thought, you can’t even read media files securely on Android....

https://blog.trendmicro.com/trendlabs-security-intelligence/...

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by dingo_bat on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:55PM (#17610752)
Every feature that gives any sort of flexibility to the user is an attack vector for the lazy developer.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by newen on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @01:07PM (#17610875)
Yeah that's a great truism but using that as an argument against a feature doesn't help your case.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by scarface74 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @01:16PM (#17610966)
Why not? There are plenty of “features” that Android has that has caused vulnerabilities due to Googles not thinking through how the features need to be implemented.

A simple one is why is there even a permission to let an app read and write all contents on an SD card instead of only allowing apps to read files that a user specifically chooses from a file picker? Or worse case read and write from your photo library or music library.

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by dingo_bat on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:21PM (#17614848)
That was my point. Apple is so afraid/lazy that they don't implement useful features and cut out widely used ones.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by jorvi on Thursday July 26, 2018 @10:36AM (#17617815)
Apple isn’t ‘afraid’ or ‘lazy’. SD cards sound like a good idea, but the problem is phone manufacturers can’t guarantee the quality or class of a card, which can bog down the whole phone or cause corruption of files. Apple being typically Apple wanted total control over the performance of their phone, and thus the iPhones never gained an SD card slot.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by dingo_bat on Thursday July 26, 2018 @12:59PM (#17618944)
Those problems are pretty easy to solve. By your logic apple should not allow 3G sim cards in iphone either, but they do. And shitty wifi networks should be banned, but they aren't.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by jorvi on Thursday July 26, 2018 @02:31PM (#17619711)
How are they easy to solve? Most people (decidedly not the ones browsing HN) will just buy an el cheapo microSD from some random phone repair shop or google for ‘cheapest microSD 64gb’ and end up ordering some crappy card from AliExpress. If you do what Sony did with the Vita and PSP and force people to use proper (read: your) card then the cards turn out horribly expensive because economies of scale don’t kick in. It’s also decidedly an Apple-esque move.

Besides that, Apple can’t control the entire worlds cellular and WiFi coverage. Some parts of countries only have 3G, some buildings only have shity WiFi. However, Apple can control how their iPhone’s storage performs by not allowing you to use crappy SD cards and just having you opt for more internal storage.

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by ggg9990 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:51AM (#17609697)
The people in India who own an iPhone almost all read English perfectly.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by bad_user on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:03AM (#17609804)
Can't speak for India, I'm a Romanian, but my father does not speak English and he owned an iPhone that he ditched due to poor or missing translations for some apps he wanted to use.

He does have plenty of money to spend on crappy apps though, much more than your average teenager that's being spoiled by his parents.

Just saying, countries like India are growing markets and when Apple will want to enter it, it will find it is already too late. Because smartphones are becoming cheap commodities, just like PCs before them and in the future the luxury items will no longer be smartphones.

Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by thesauri on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:13AM (#17609877)
In India, the people who can afford an iPhone typically have pursued higher-level education. With almost all higher-level education being taught in English, iPhone owners will also likely be proficient in English.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by newen on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:06PM (#17610306)
Also most people, especially in the cities, who are middle-middle class or richer tend to send their kids to primary and secondary schools taught in english.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by ggg9990 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:42AM (#17610113)
India is different from Romania
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by slededit on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:40AM (#17609604)
It's not about the size of the audience. It's about how much they pay for apps. iPhone apps consistently sell for higher amounts.
Re:Why the iPhone can’t compete in India by scarface74 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:45AM (#17609638)
That’s true. But there is still a tipping point. With even a 10% market share (making up a number just to make a point) of a market as large as the mobile market and iPhone users being more affluent, it makes sense not to ignore iOS users. On the other hand, MacOS could be around 10% of the much smaller PC market and if you had a limited budget, you could safely ignore the Mac market - even though Mac users are more affluent.