News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by chipperyman573 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:08PM (#17604944)
I don't disagree with you (I mean, facebook not being required to allow free speech isn't really even something you can disagree with to begin with anyway - it's a fact). However, a while ago someone made a comment that has stuck with me: Why do you want Facebook to silence people like this? Let them identify themselves as awful people, so you know you want nothing to do with them.

Instead of becoming friends with a closet racist, then finally getting to know them well enough to realize they're a terrible person, let them identify themselves outright so you waste no time involving them in your life.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by geofft on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:44PM (#17605207)
I've been thinking about this (and the obvious rebuttal of "What about the people who think $your_politics should be silenced in polite society"). I think my answer is that these particular ideas - ethnic nationalism and its friends - are deceptively simple explanations for problems in the world, and therefore platforms for publishing, especially platforms for short-attention-span publishing like Facebook or Twitter, should be particularly cautious in whether they let themselves be used by these ideologies.

It is easy to say that the reason that Americans or Greeks or Germans are struggling with their lives is all the Mexicans or Muslims or Jews, and that if only society weren't spending resources on these other people, things would be better for us. I can fit that in a sentence. It is much harder to talk about the complex effects of local, national, and international politics over decades if not centuries; about specific instances of poor leadership or corruption; about the proper interpretation of data; about things that really need papers or books to discuss. I claim that - universally - these longer explanations are more likely to be right. "It's these damn Others" is too simple to fit the observed data, but even listing each complexity in the observed data and whether the explanation fits or not it is a paper's worth of discussion.

Not everyone will recognize that these positions are the positions of awful people. Some will find the simplistic answer appealing. This is arguably a bug in human cognition - but if a platform is designed for humans, it makes perfect sense to take human bugs into account.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by smsm42 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @07:37PM (#17605797)
That would be very smart if we had some super-human bug-free angels to oversee the platform and fix out human bugs for us. In reality, since angels are otherwise engaged and unavailable to serve as Facebook moderators, what we'd end up with is one set of humans forcing their bugs onto other set of humans, motivating it as "we are fixing your bugs for your own benefit, you see!". I don't see any reason to prefer the bugs of an anonymous Facebook moderator to my own, at least I know my own and had time to learn to deal with them.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by geofft on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @08:53PM (#17606167)
But the buggy / fallen humans are already the people implementing the platform itself: writing algorithms to detect spam, writing the "algorithmic timeline," prioritizing some features over others, measuring and responding to engagement metrics, planning capacity expansions for particular APIs, etc. They already have some idea of what they expect platform usage to look like and are building a system that supports that. It'd be better if the incorruptible were doing this, sure, but sinful man already is designing the platform and its intended uses.

If you offer people a platform that lends itself to certain forms of abuses, those abuses are your responsibility, even if you didn't set out to cause them - just like outages are your responsibility even though you almost certainly did not set out to cause them. Sure, before the Fall, Adam could write code that never crashed. That doesn't mean we can absolve ourselves of the responsibility to attempt to fix and prevent crashes, even though we won't succeed perfectly. Nor can we absolve ourselves of the responsibility to make sure our platforms are being used for things we want them to be used for.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by smsm42 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @01:11AM (#17607030)
The problem is not buggy code - i.e. code that is meant to do one thing but actually does the other. The problem is buggy goals - e.g. goals that is meant to foster thoughtful discussion but actually create echo chamber increasingly intolerant to dissent and incapable of considering new ideas on merits instead of panicking on any deviation for the orthodoxy. Unless conscious and constant effort is taken to avoid it, it is very easy to get into such failure mode. Not because people are evil but because people are buggy and weak.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by opwieurposiu on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:49PM (#17605561)
So if someone advocates ethnic nationalism in a complex and multifaceted way, backed by data and statistics, You would allow it?
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by geofft on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @08:57PM (#17606186)
If they advocate it in a way that is not abusive (and there are certainly abuses of long-form platforms, too, mostly involving a Gish gallop and the use of too much data to check each case of misuse), sure. I think then the "best cure is more speech" argument kicks in, and people can just rebut the argument on its merits.

If you say the argument cannot be easily rebutted ... at some point the question turns into, "Ethnic nationalism is obviously wrong, but if someone made a coherent, logical, good-faith argument demonstrating that ethnic nationalism was definitely right, would you allow that argument despite it being obviously wrong?" which isn't very well-formed. :)

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by pornel on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @07:51PM (#17605864)
No. Immoral objective is still immoral even if backed by data supporting it.

Maybe it'd be easier to parse on a less controversial example:

> We should steal things instead of earning them. Here is the objective factual and irrefutable data showing that robbery is more profitable than hard work.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by mistermann on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @08:29PM (#17606033)
Japan has a rather objectively ethnically nationalist stance, do you consider Japanese people to be immoral? And when answering that question, consider the possible irony of your response.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by geofft on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @10:29PM (#17606510)
As a Christian this argument doesn't make sense to me. "All have sinned and fallen short of the glory of God." It's not super difficult (nor is it a high-information-content claim) to consider an entire nation immoral for a specific thing when you believe that everyone alive today does immoral things in their own ways.

And as a student of history, entire nations have certainly been immoral. The Confederate States of America is a good example, and a significant number of northerners were also morally wrong on the subject of slavery—almost all of them, a few generations back. There's also Godwin's favorite example, of course. There are the Carthaginians who sacrificed their children. There were the Indians—probably including some of my own ancestors—who practiced sati.

I'm certainly not expressing an opinion about Japan; I don't know enough to have a well-informed one. But I'm not going to ignore one possible conclusion because it would force me to say that the nation is immoral.

(You switch from "Japan" to "Japanese people" without support or reasoning; of course, we are talking about an organized nation and the culture and norms in power, not about ethnicity in its own right.)

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by mistermann on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @10:43PM (#17606567)
I don't disagree, but I asked a fairly specific question of someone else who was casting judgement based on the morality of a specific behavior, I would like them to defend that insult.

As for your final point, go watch some man on the street interviews on YouTube and you might be surprised, this is how they generally feel, it's just not based on any form of hatred, it just is how they think.

Lots of strong opinions on these topics, very few have the ability to defend those opinions.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by nextlevelwizard on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @01:55AM (#17607146)
I don't know if you are trying to build some kind of strawman or if you truly don't understand the difference.

Simply: for you to steal someone else needs to be earning, thus you premise doesn't work. Your data would show this immediately.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by pornel on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @01:10PM (#17610903)
No, I think you're falling for exactly the problem addition of data creates: the discussion has shifted to the data, and jumped past the whole issue of immorality.

It's now "we don't steal because it doesn't work (under implied assumption of some eventual equilibrium if everyone steals)". BTW, under assumption of that "we" steal from "them", and "they" don't steal from "us", the data could support stealing. The data, conditions and objectives to maximize can also imply moral judgements, but are easy to launder in datasets, e.g. "better for the economy" sounds objective, but who is given access to benefit from that economy is a very moral judgement (touching hot topics like immigration).

But the data is irrelevant, because the argument should stop at "we don't steal, period".

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by pixl97 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @07:10PM (#17605663)
What if science and facts support a terrible conclusion?

Do we ignore the science to feel better?

I'm not saying that any arguments put forth do, but what does a society that prides itself on logic and rationality do in such a case?

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by DuskStar on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @07:35PM (#17605792)
This sounds like Lysenkoism [0]. See, it was politically rather important for the Soviet Union to have heritability of acquired traits in humans, which necessarily implied the same in plants. So all that genetic inheritance and crop breeding? Useless quackery. Of course, in the Soviet Union, "quacks" were executed... And this contributed to ongoing crop yield deficiencies.

Facts supporting a terrible conclusion (that blank slate theory is not correct in plants) is not a reason that the facts should be ignored.

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysenkoism

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by bzbarsky on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @08:01PM (#17605912)
Amusingly enough, plants have way more heritability of acquired traits than humans do. Epigenetic effects in plants are stable across multiple generations to a much greater extent than in mammals, as far as recent studies can tell.

Of course "epigenetic effects are real and persist across many generations" is very different from the blank slate theory.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by tynpeddler on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:37PM (#17605500)
You make a good point but what you're talking about is effectively the beginning of the end of liberalism. While it sounds simple to say in this case that "people aren't rational, therefore we're going to control their speech and we're technically a private company so nah nah nah," you are in fact opening a huge can of worms with incredibly far reaching consequences. I don't blame Facebook for refusing to take a stand on this point. As much as people like to accuse Facebook and Zuckerberg of being greedy and arrogant, I think on this point they've shown a remarkable amount of humility. Sticking to the same principles that have guided humanity's most successful decisions for the past 200+ years while being constantly mocked by the mob shows an incredible amount of restraint. People who think no platforming tens of millions of people is a simple decision are the reckless and arrogant ones with no regard for how serious such a decision really is.

If tens of millions of Americans lack the competence and morality to be allowed to talk freely amongst themselves, why do we let them raise kids and vote?

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by bena on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:28AM (#17609059)
"When the mob and the press and the whole world tell you to move, your job is to plant yourself like a tree beside the river of truth, and tell the whole world-- "No, you move."
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by dnissley on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:43PM (#17605535)
So we can easily identify ethnic nationalism as one of the ways in which right wing politics can go very, very wrong. The problem with calling it out on it's own, without calling out something equally vile on the left, is that whoever does it ends up looking very partial to the left as a consequence.

Left wing politics can clearly go very wrong as well, but it's harder to identify what the destructive ideas on the left because they are cloaked in compassion for the downtrodden. Jordan Peterson has put forward the idea that it is something like the trifecta of "equity diversity and inclusion" that we need to look out for from the left, but obviously these are very desirable things on first glance, and so it isn't that simple to just put these ideas in a box that's off limits.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by exelius on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @07:10PM (#17605658)
Jordan Peterson is espousing the same tired homophobic, xenophobic arguments dressed up in modern clothes. He’s a hack who appeals to people because he tells them the things they’re already feeling without actually advancing the conversation. His arguments are only appealing if you’re already in a position of privilege. Basically, he’s an advocate for the status quo.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by dnissley on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @07:31PM (#17605768)
Perhaps you'd be willing to offer your own answer to the question he poses though, which I believe is a good one. When does the left go too far?

With the right, we have at least one clear cut answer: ethnic nationalism. With the left: nothing beyond vague handwaving about "when it gets violent" or "when it gets censorious".

FWIW, I'm a leftist but I see a lot of worrying things coming from the left these days. I figure we could do with a little more introspection considering the results of the last election, a little less derangement about Trump, and a little less paranoia about the supposed hidden agendas of canadian psychologists.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by exelius on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @07:06AM (#17608337)
My biggest criticism of Peterson is how he attacks “the left”.

“The left” is not one unified, cohesive group because it’s not centered on a single defining characteristic like white nationalism. “The left” includes everyone from teachers to catholic nuns to queer radical activists.

The defining characteristic of “the left” is that it is they are threatened by the advance of authoritarian, militaristic policies. Which is to say that they are the people who would lose out from white nationalism.

Therefore, the left is starting to organize around its opposition to white nationalism, but doesn’t yet know how to attack it because white nationalists deny their white nationalism. But the left is still just as fractured, divided, and focused on small specific things that don’t necessarily agree.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by dnissley on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:23AM (#17609963)
So Peterson characterizes the right as concerned with making sure that society functions efficiently and competently. And he characterizes the left as concerned with the inevitable fact that when a society is made to function efficiently and competently there are some people who get left out and fall to the bottom rung of society, and we need to make sure these people are taken care of and aren't completely neglected.

So both left and right are unified separately by their own ideals.

The right goes too far when it devolves into ethnic nationalism. When it says only people of race X are capable of being efficient and competent. The typical example here is Nazi Germany.

The left goes too far when... well, that's the question. But we still have plenty of good examples when it happens. Look at communist russia, communist china, (insert more communist countries here). Most of those states outright failed to function at some level, and plenty of them ended up being genocidal.

It looks to me that the left goes too far when it demonizes smart, efficient, competent people as thieves or other criminals, as the communists did.

We are on the verge of that right now as the left denigrates people for being privileged, in such a way as if it were some kind of crime. Or perhaps implying that crimes took place in the past that were not brought to justice, and not suggesting anything in particular but the obvious conclusion is that those crimes need to be brought to justice against the people who are benefitting from them now.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by exelius on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @05:55PM (#17613250)
But what you call “the left” is this disjointed set of — not even ideologies but desires. Guarantee that not everyone in BLM is an LGBTQ ally, for example. Nor is everyone who is upset about college tuition pro-choice politically. But Peterson lumps it all into two camps: one that is the defender of life as we know it, and the other.

But all his definition of “the left” means is that people who are afraid of losing their right to exist within the dominance of the white Christian patriarchy. Cause let me tell you, when it happens to you on an individual level, it’s not the kind of thing you forgive or forget easily.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by bena on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:00AM (#17609261)
I'd have to say because you're wrong-ish. Or at least off.

The left isn't comprised of people who would lose out from white nationalism. A lot of people on the left would benefit from white nationalism.

Because they're white. 72% of the people in the U.S. identify as white. There is literally no competition if it came down to sheer numbers. White nationalism would benefit most people in the U.S.

But it is wrong. Ethnic nationalism is wrong. The color of one's skin does not define one's character. Does not define one's ability. Does not define one's worth. Even a lot of people who are white recognize that simple fact.

The problem the left has is that the more extreme stop attacking white nationalism and just start attacking "white people". When privilege stops being descriptive and starts be pejorative. And it is used as a pejorative. Tell some group they have privilege and they will rail against it, telling you all the ways in which they are not privileged. But there are privileges to most situations. Some of those privileges aren't worth the situation. Some of those privileges don't make up for the disadvantages. But still, they exist. And some of those privileges are not the fault of the person receiving them. To bring up one, it is easier to get hired as a white male. That's not the fault of white males. That's the fault of people doing the hiring. It's been found to be a subconscious bias among more than white males. It's not just a matter of like hiring like. But you can't ask someone to not take a job. To give up their livelihood, their survival, to sacrifice themselves for someone else because their group has it better. We can't sacrifice the individual for the vague betterment of mankind. That's a whole other kind of monstrous.

But what's the answer? It's obviously complicated. We need to find ways to get underrepresented groups the opportunity to gain interest and skill in various fields. We need to find ways to make things like admission to jobs, colleges, home loans, apartment leases, etc more blind to irrelevant factors like race, sexuality, and gender. And we're trying. And that's what I feel liberalism is about-ish. Trying to make things more progressive, protecting society as a whole, but I'd rather not see it at the expense of individuals.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by geofft on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @09:01PM (#17606201)
> Perhaps you'd be willing to offer your own answer to the question he poses though, which I believe is a good one. When does the left go too far?

There's no a priori reason that one side of politics should go "too far" proportionate to the other.

Importantly, if you do assume such a reason exists, it gives cover for bad actors (of any side), who can then argue just as convincingly, I can't possibly be going "too far" because the other side isn't, and you're biased.

If the left is behaving reasonably and the right is not, or vice versa, have the moral courage to say what you observe.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by dnissley on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:32AM (#17610037)
I don't mean to discuss this in the abstract. The left and the right both have proven themselves to go too far and the end result is the same: genocide.

The issue is that we have an indicator for the right (ethnic nationalism) and that we don't have one for the left.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by bduerst on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @07:33PM (#17605783)
Because racists aren't interested in discourse or even slightly concerned with the hit to reputation in outing themselves. They're seeking platforms to reinforce and spread their prejudicial bias, which Facebook and Twitter provide.

I think Jean Paul-Sartre said it best:

>Never believe that anti-Semites are completely unaware of the absurdity of their replies. They know that their remarks are frivolous, open to challenge. But they are amusing themselves, for it is their adversary who is obliged to use words responsibly, since he believes in words. The anti-Semites have the right to play. They even like to play with discourse for, by giving ridiculous reasons, they discredit the seriousness of their interlocutors. They delight in acting in bad faith, since they seek not to persuade by sound argument but to intimidate and disconcert. If you press them too closely, they will abruptly fall silent, loftily indicating by some phrase that the time for argument is past.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by ekianjo on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @07:59PM (#17605907)
Funny that Sartre said that after being a lifelong champion of Lenin and Stalin's way of dealing with power which had nothing to do with free discourse. And that, even after we all knew about the atrocities of the soviet regime, when the honeymoon stage was clearly over.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by bduerst on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @08:08PM (#17605946)
Except he didn't.

Sartre was a Marxist and was critical of Leninism, publicly attacking the Soviet Union's abuses of human rights and freedom. He was one the first to out the Soviet labor camps.

Also, Sartre said that quote in the Anti-Semite and Jew in 1945, before most of his writing of the Soviet Union (not after).

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by deegles on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:43PM (#17605202)
> Why do you want Facebook to silence people like this?

Because people use it to recruit and radicalize more members. Because being exposed to those ideas makes them more acceptable over time. Because if no one tells them that those views are bad then they feel they are ok to keep repeating.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by mikec3010 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:40PM (#17605522)
> if no one tells them that those views are bad then they feel they are ok to keep repeating.

I'd say quite the opposite: the more "persecuted" your group claims to be, the more resilient and special they feel about themselves. This is true in highly manipulative individuals as well as radical political groups.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by sangnoir on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @01:16PM (#17610959)
There's nothing wrong with that. Sometimes containing a problem and more attainable than complete eradication.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by pjc50 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:12PM (#17604976)
Terrible people can organise terrible consequences that spread off facebook and into the "real world".
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by shittyadmin on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:14PM (#17604992)
Okay, but what of things like cannabis or prostitution. Major legal changes in these spaces have started online and many people would seek to see things like this banned in such a system.

Heck, I'm sure some people would describe those changes as "terrible consequences".

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by pjc50 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:17PM (#17605020)
That's what taking a side includes; Facebook have to listen to the politics and decide what's legitimately arguable either way and what's harmful per se.

It does not mean picking a side and then only allowing that side to post.

The opposite of this is iTunes' "ban all politics" policy.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by stevenwoo on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:22PM (#17605065)
The folks who run /r/askhistorians had to go through several years of adjusting their rules until they found a solution for holocaust deniers - don't give them a platform to speak - they are just trolling and wasting the time of rebuttals and any re-publication is used by holocaust deniers to authenticate their views. https://slate.com/technology/2018/07/the-askhistorians-subre...
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by prawn on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:41PM (#17605530)
I enjoy how strict r/askhistorians is, but the result of their policies is fewer (better) questions and definitely fewer comments. That won't fly with something like Facebook watching the bottom line, engagement, etc.

Strict policies on a subreddit essentially rule out a huge swathe of people who might be interested, but be unable/unwilling to pose a solid question or have the expertise to respond.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:00PM (#17605313)
I wonder if there's some organized downvoting happening in this thread. "History forum blocks mass Holocaust denial" should not be controversial, even on HN.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by bena on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:23PM (#17605444)
Especially when it's a simple statement of facts.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by prolepunk on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:14PM (#17604998)
Because when people like this aren't silenced and laughed at, from some angles they seem like normal people and not the ones promoting monstrous ideas.

No everyone have well informed world view.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by pandler on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:27PM (#17605100)
Which sounds like a fine argument to make when dealing with the more extreme cases, but where do you draw the line of who gets silenced? The question is whether we are comfortable with corporations assuming the role of thought police - corporations that are not subject to the same discrimination standards that we hold our government(s) to.

It sounds to me like "informed world view" as a general standard for evaluation really just means "whatever world view is in vogue at the time", and is designed as an exclusive criteria. Think of how many cultures, customs, ethnicities, sexualities, philosophies, etc, were previously not part of the acceptable, "informed" world view, as well as those that previously were and are now considered taboo or unethical.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by geofft on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:11PM (#17605368)
I am certainly more comfortable with a corporation assuming the role of thought police than with a corporation saying "Sorry, we are bound to promote things happening that everyone knows will be terrible for the world."

Corporate thought police are certainly bad, but not the worst possible thing - since they are corporate thought police instead of governmental ones, there will be ways of communicating without them (and I already have positions I hold but do not feel comfortable expressing publicly, and if I want to share them with people I will need to find private and point-to-point means of conveying them, and I already have means of doing that). And since they are corporations subject to government, there are already positions that you cannot post on social media without getting in legal trouble of various sorts.

And at least with thought police, you have a hope - maybe a slim one, but a hope nonetheless - of convincing them that your thoughts are fine and should not be policed. (with corporate thought police, you can also try outcompeting them, of course.) With a corporation that feels obligated to promote all thoughts no matter how awful, they will not shut down something that 99.9% of society believes is dangerous, for any reason.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by prolepunk on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:41PM (#17605190)
I just outlined the criteria in the comment above -- if you believe people who don't look like you aren't people, and don't deserve the same rights and shouldn't exist, you're a Nazi.

Yes "whatever world view is in vogue at the time" is the informed world view. I wouldn't want to live by the rules of Genghis Khan, or the rules of Germany in late 1930s.

All of the things that are now considered taboo or unethical are taboo or unethical. For example, can you justify slavery through this lens?

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by slavik81 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:14PM (#17605384)
There are lots of things that are widely believed unethical for no particularly good reason. People are raised into a set of beliefs and they mostly stick with them, especially when there's rarely a reason to re-examine those beliefs.

One example of something widely believed to be unethical is nudity. There is a belief that seeing a human being in its natural, naked state is inherently harmful and that nakedness itself is shameful.

I'm not a nudist; I very much prefer wearing clothing. I just think it's a good example, because few people ever think about it. Everybody just wears clothing and only weirdos don't. The mechanism by which it causes harm is rarely examined.

(The increasing reverence towards natural things in recent years suggests to me that people may be more open to reexamining that belief, making it a more effective example.)

It's not that the majority are always wrong. Just sometimes. And not just in the past or in some other society.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by prolepunk on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:25PM (#17605452)
Except we're talking about Nazis and not nudists.

As a society we are re-examining those beliefs and something that used to be considered normal (i.e. slavery) is now considered grossly unjust.

Just because someone is old, that person is not entitled to spew their racist, white nationalist beliefs.

I will repeat this again, I haven't hear a single instance of nudists building death camps.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by slavik81 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:28PM (#17605461)
I don't disagree that there are differences. I'm trying to point out that if you merely demand that Facebook take sides, they will probably take the side of the majority. Most of the time that's fine—like in the case of Nazis—but sometimes it will result in them suppressing minorities that deserve to be heard.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by DoofusOfDeath on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:33PM (#17605136)
I'm going to try making a counterpoint by playing devil's advocate for a moment. Please try to see the larger point I'm making, rather than the particulars:

Abortion is monsterous - it's genocide on an unfathomable scale.

Homosexuality is monsterous - it's unnatural and sinful.

Promoting (Christianity | Islam | athiesm) is monsterous - those belief systems lead to death and destruction.

Promoting (democracy | socialism) is monsterous - it leads to massive suffering inside and outside our borders.

Main point: Different people have diametrically different ideas of what's monsterous. I'm pretty sure you don't want to live in a land where some of those definitions are used to limit your speech.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by prolepunk on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:54PM (#17605278)
This is not wholly surprising, this site is full of hot takes of devil's advocates.

This arguments ignore a ton of details most importantly the relationship between oppressed and oppressors. When Nazis are calling for extermination of people, they aren't going after white men.

In every example you have, there's oppressed group that have their rights that you completely ignore.

Abortion -- women right to control their body (the right that's being constantly challenged)

Homosexuality -- do I even need to make an argument here.

Religion -- it's not about any particular religion, it's oppressing religions minority by majority i.e Christians in predominantly Islamic country and vise versa.

Promoting democracy/socialism -- basically vilifying alternative form of government by people in power by cherry-picking examples (because no one would dare to criticize that argument).

My point is, Nazis are toxic and are always vilify and making scapegoats from people who are not in power, because those people can't answer.

I don't want to live in a land where it's okay to say we should kill this particular group of people, that speech be acceptable and eventually carried out.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by bena on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:22PM (#17605438)
You do realize that there are plenty of people, atheists and women included, who feel that abortion is genocide and that the people who advocate for abortion are advocating for the extermination of people, right?

The way they see it, a living person was created and attached to someone against their will and now the one who did that gets to just outright murder them because it's "inconvenient" under the guise of "right to control their body". Basically if I took out your kidneys, attached you to me so my kidneys would filter your blood as well, then decided I didn't want to do that anymore, so I let you die. (I know the example is kind of fucked, mainly because there is no good analog to pregnancy).

There's all sorts of things going on with the abortion debate that I can't really get behind anyone who frames it as a "simple" debate. I currently side with the opinion that it's a private matter and only the people involved should be the ones to wrestle with whatever ethical considerations that are tied up with it. The decision is too big for anyone to decide for someone else.

Regardless, his point isn't that those opinions he posted are correct, but what would happen if a group took power that pushed that view and "deplatformed" dissent. Because they had the "correct" view. No one actually thinks they're wrong.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by DoofusOfDeath on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:25PM (#17605456)
> Regardless, his point isn't that those opinions he posted are correct, but what would happen if a group took power that pushed that view and "deplatformed" dissent. Because they had the "correct" view.

Yes, thanks for the good summary of my point. Based on how down-voted my original post was, it appears I wasn't clear.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by bena on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:30PM (#17605468)
I think explicitly saying you're going to play devil's advocate is pretty much dog-whistling whether you intend to or not.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by DoofusOfDeath on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:48PM (#17605558)
> People who claim to be "playing devil's advocate" are either people who just like arguing for its own sake, or use the excuse to espouse their own shitty beliefs.

> And instead of actually having to defend the positions they put forth, they claim they're just playing the devil's advocate.

Thanks, I wasn't aware of that meme / idiom / whatever. It's good to know.

FWIW, in my OP, my point in claiming "devil's advocate" was to flag that I wasn't trying to advocate any of those individual positions I was citing. My larger point hinged simply on the sheer number of people holding views, regardless of the views' defensibly.

I wonder if "devil's advocate" was the wrong term for what I had in mind.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by bena on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:42AM (#17609138)
I'm of the opinion, just state your case, make your examples, etc.

For instance I'd have brought up the various religious people who think they're right and have no regard for the free speech of other religious opinions. That they believe that those opinions are not only wrong, but dangerous and harmful to society.

Would you want any one of them deciding who gets a platform?

I got what you were putting down. But then again, I'm already of that opinion: That what can be used against my enemies can be used against me, so you better be damn careful about what tactics you allow.

But not everyone subscribes to that thought and people who are convinced that "there are no bad tactics, just bad targets" are hard to convince. They're already convinced of their moral righteousness, that they know the bad targets and that they'll never be the target because they aren't "bad".

And becoming a target doesn't necessarily change their mind either. For some people, that's enough. They realize that some tactics are bad. That the act of choosing to use them is bad. That not all tactics are applicable to all situations. That there is something called an inappropriate response. But others, they'll just figure that people who see them as bad are bad themselves. Their worldview doesn't really change. They cannot conceive a world in which their worldview doesn't eventually have power to right the wrongs because they are right.

The simple fact that some good people just won't like you doesn't cross their minds. That being right doesn't confer upon you any advantage in any sort of struggle is an absurd concept to them. That they may not even be right or that the situation may be more complicated than a simple right or wrong doesn't play to them.

In that case, I don't know what you do.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by DoofusOfDeath on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:39PM (#17605511)
Thanks, but I'm not sure I take your meaning. I'd be grateful if you could clarify.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by bena on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:43PM (#17605538)
People who claim to be "playing devil's advocate" are either people who just like arguing for its own sake, or use the excuse to espouse their own shitty beliefs.

And instead of actually having to defend the positions they put forth, they claim they're just playing the devil's advocate.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by timClicks on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:13PM (#17604989)
Social platforms amplify and normalize those messages. I'm willing to bet that they create more closet racists than they reveal.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by mikec3010 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:53PM (#17605582)
One angle that I haven't seen covered is the "gang" nature of hate groups. They advocate for the commission of murder, either directly or obliquely. That could be one line in the sand that could be drawn. No groups may promote the extermination of, or by extension, scapegoating society's problems on, a group of people. The scapegoating could be aligned to implicit murder because none of these groups is advocating for assisting or "rehabilitating" that scapegoated group.

Further, offering a means to join a hate group affords anyone an "immediate membership to a gang", in the sense that an otherwise disempowered person can quickly appear menacing by aligning himself with an established hate group and facebook is the vehicle he uses to advertise it

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:14PM (#17604999)
This has nothing to do with wanting Facebook to police your friends list for you. It's about allowing racists and other toxic bigots to use Facebook to push their agendas, recruit others, and harass their victims en masse.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by ThrowawayR2 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:21PM (#17605053)
> It's about allowing racists and other toxic bigots to use Facebook to push their agendas, recruit others, and harass their victims en masse."

If Facebook had existed in the 1950s:

"It's about allowing commies and other liberal lunatics to use Facebook to push their agendas, recruit others, and harass their victims en masse."

When you ask the tech industry to build a muzzle, don't forget that it fits onto you just as easily as onto the people you hate.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:50PM (#17605250)
That's an important consideration, but taken to extremes it's basically appeasement. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeasement Don't try to resist bad people, don't try to protect their victims, because they might turn around and push back.

Where does it end? When are we finally allowed to take action?

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by hamhock666 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:07PM (#17605349)
You take action with your own speech, not by using the power of the majority to censor opinions and ideas that the majority doesn't like. You have the ability to do this anytime without fear that someone will tell you your perspective and opinions are wrong.

If the roles were reversed and you were living in an authoritarian dictatorship, you might be considered a "bad person", and your speech might be censored or worse.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by potta_coffee on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:23PM (#17605446)
This is the first response in this conversation that has made any sense.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by staunch on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:05PM (#17605344)
A reasonable question but I think it's caused by confusion. The answer to bad speech is good speech, not censorship. The answer to unjust violence is just violence, not appeasement.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by prolepunk on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:17PM (#17605406)
> The answer to bad speech is good speech, not censorship.

Good luck wasting your precious time arguing with Nazis while Reichstag is burning.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by dang on Friday July 27, 2018 @03:54AM (#17624262)
We've banned this account for continuing to use HN for ideological battle after we asked you to stop.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by ThrowawayR2 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:34PM (#17605483)
> Where does it end? When are we finally allowed to take action?

Speech must only ever be met with speech if liberals want to keep the moral high ground. If you meet speech with oppression, how are you any better than the oppressors of the past that liberal movements fought and won victories against?

Now if you're facing oppression, that's a different story and at that point "taking action" (your words, not mine) might be justified.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:41PM (#17605527)
> Speech must only ever be met with speech if liberals want to keep the moral high ground.

Choosing not to actively expend resources to relay speech is itself an exercise of free speech rights. Private deplatforming isn't oppression, it is free speech. (Now, if a notionally private platform is a protected monopoly on an essential avenue of communication, you are in the domain of effective government action which is why common carriers exist; but while FB may be a popular social media venue, I don't think it reaches that level.)

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by ThrowawayR2 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @10:34PM (#17606540)
> Choosing not to actively expend resources to relay speech is itself an exercise of free speech rights. Private deplatforming isn't oppression, it is free speech.

Yet if a business used that line to refuse service to a minority, a religious person or atheist, a pro-choice advocate, or a LGBT person (in a nation where these are not protected groups or in a time before those groups were protected), you'd be up in arms about it even though it's the exact same excuse. See the double standard now?

The groups you oppose would absolutely love to be able to use that line of reasoning to defend themselves (remember the Colorado baker case?). The irony of people calling themselves liberals trying to use it to put an aura of legitimacy over their behavior too is delicious.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by ekiru on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:24AM (#17609036)
> Yet if a business used that line to refuse service to a minority, a religious person or atheist, a pro-choice advocate, or a LGBT person (in a nation where these are not protected groups or in a time before those groups were protected), you'd be up in arms about it even though it's the exact same excuse. See the double standard now?

In fact, major social media sites such as Youtube and Twitter frequently ban or otherwise sanction queer people for talking about their sexuality or gender and approximately no one cares.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:42AM (#17609140)
> Yet if a business used that line to refuse service to a minority, a religious person or atheist, a pro-choice advocate, or a LGBT person (in a nation where these are not protected groups or in a time before those groups were protected), you'd be up in arms about it even though it's the exact same excuse.

Yes, it's the same excuse, but it's not the same facts. There is, in general, a difference between regulating who you will do business with and regulating the content of the speech you will engage in.

> The groups you oppose would absolutely love to be able to use that line of reasoning to defend themselves (remember the Colorado baker case?).

I do remember Masterpiece Cakeshop, but I don't think you do, so CE it doesn't involve freedom in the a sense of a protected target group, but impermissible government animus toward religion in apply the existing protection of a protected group.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by jessaustin on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @08:43PM (#17606110)
You have summarized the view of the courts. Is that the most relevant perspective? Isn't the whole point convincing people not to be Nazis? If average private monopolistic platform users perceive Nazis to be subject to special treatment, it doesn't matter to them whether that's coming from the platform owner or from the government.

Although, let's not kid ourselves, Facebook would love to regulate themselves into even more of our lives. Would anyone be shocked to hear of some municipality requiring FB login in order to receive public services?