It sounds to me like "informed world view" as a general standard for evaluation really just means "whatever world view is in vogue at the time", and is designed as an exclusive criteria. Think of how many cultures, customs, ethnicities, sexualities, philosophies, etc, were previously not part of the acceptable, "informed" world view, as well as those that previously were and are now considered taboo or unethical.
Corporate thought police are certainly bad, but not the worst possible thing - since they are corporate thought police instead of governmental ones, there will be ways of communicating without them (and I already have positions I hold but do not feel comfortable expressing publicly, and if I want to share them with people I will need to find private and point-to-point means of conveying them, and I already have means of doing that). And since they are corporations subject to government, there are already positions that you cannot post on social media without getting in legal trouble of various sorts.
And at least with thought police, you have a hope - maybe a slim one, but a hope nonetheless - of convincing them that your thoughts are fine and should not be policed. (with corporate thought police, you can also try outcompeting them, of course.) With a corporation that feels obligated to promote all thoughts no matter how awful, they will not shut down something that 99.9% of society believes is dangerous, for any reason.
Yes "whatever world view is in vogue at the time" is the informed world view. I wouldn't want to live by the rules of Genghis Khan, or the rules of Germany in late 1930s.
All of the things that are now considered taboo or unethical are taboo or unethical. For example, can you justify slavery through this lens?
One example of something widely believed to be unethical is nudity. There is a belief that seeing a human being in its natural, naked state is inherently harmful and that nakedness itself is shameful.
I'm not a nudist; I very much prefer wearing clothing. I just think it's a good example, because few people ever think about it. Everybody just wears clothing and only weirdos don't. The mechanism by which it causes harm is rarely examined.
(The increasing reverence towards natural things in recent years suggests to me that people may be more open to reexamining that belief, making it a more effective example.)
It's not that the majority are always wrong. Just sometimes. And not just in the past or in some other society.
As a society we are re-examining those beliefs and something that used to be considered normal (i.e. slavery) is now considered grossly unjust.
Just because someone is old, that person is not entitled to spew their racist, white nationalist beliefs.
I will repeat this again, I haven't hear a single instance of nudists building death camps.
Abortion is monsterous - it's genocide on an unfathomable scale.
Homosexuality is monsterous - it's unnatural and sinful.
Promoting (Christianity | Islam | athiesm) is monsterous - those belief systems lead to death and destruction.
Promoting (democracy | socialism) is monsterous - it leads to massive suffering inside and outside our borders.
Main point: Different people have diametrically different ideas of what's monsterous. I'm pretty sure you don't want to live in a land where some of those definitions are used to limit your speech.
This arguments ignore a ton of details most importantly the relationship between oppressed and oppressors. When Nazis are calling for extermination of people, they aren't going after white men.
In every example you have, there's oppressed group that have their rights that you completely ignore.
Abortion -- women right to control their body (the right that's being constantly challenged)
Homosexuality -- do I even need to make an argument here.
Religion -- it's not about any particular religion, it's oppressing religions minority by majority i.e Christians in predominantly Islamic country and vise versa.
Promoting democracy/socialism -- basically vilifying alternative form of government by people in power by cherry-picking examples (because no one would dare to criticize that argument).
My point is, Nazis are toxic and are always vilify and making scapegoats from people who are not in power, because those people can't answer.
I don't want to live in a land where it's okay to say we should kill this particular group of people, that speech be acceptable and eventually carried out.
The way they see it, a living person was created and attached to someone against their will and now the one who did that gets to just outright murder them because it's "inconvenient" under the guise of "right to control their body". Basically if I took out your kidneys, attached you to me so my kidneys would filter your blood as well, then decided I didn't want to do that anymore, so I let you die. (I know the example is kind of fucked, mainly because there is no good analog to pregnancy).
There's all sorts of things going on with the abortion debate that I can't really get behind anyone who frames it as a "simple" debate. I currently side with the opinion that it's a private matter and only the people involved should be the ones to wrestle with whatever ethical considerations that are tied up with it. The decision is too big for anyone to decide for someone else.
Regardless, his point isn't that those opinions he posted are correct, but what would happen if a group took power that pushed that view and "deplatformed" dissent. Because they had the "correct" view. No one actually thinks they're wrong.
Yes, thanks for the good summary of my point. Based on how down-voted my original post was, it appears I wasn't clear.
> And instead of actually having to defend the positions they put forth, they claim they're just playing the devil's advocate.
Thanks, I wasn't aware of that meme / idiom / whatever. It's good to know.
FWIW, in my OP, my point in claiming "devil's advocate" was to flag that I wasn't trying to advocate any of those individual positions I was citing. My larger point hinged simply on the sheer number of people holding views, regardless of the views' defensibly.
I wonder if "devil's advocate" was the wrong term for what I had in mind.
For instance I'd have brought up the various religious people who think they're right and have no regard for the free speech of other religious opinions. That they believe that those opinions are not only wrong, but dangerous and harmful to society.
Would you want any one of them deciding who gets a platform?
I got what you were putting down. But then again, I'm already of that opinion: That what can be used against my enemies can be used against me, so you better be damn careful about what tactics you allow.
But not everyone subscribes to that thought and people who are convinced that "there are no bad tactics, just bad targets" are hard to convince. They're already convinced of their moral righteousness, that they know the bad targets and that they'll never be the target because they aren't "bad".
And becoming a target doesn't necessarily change their mind either. For some people, that's enough. They realize that some tactics are bad. That the act of choosing to use them is bad. That not all tactics are applicable to all situations. That there is something called an inappropriate response. But others, they'll just figure that people who see them as bad are bad themselves. Their worldview doesn't really change. They cannot conceive a world in which their worldview doesn't eventually have power to right the wrongs because they are right.
The simple fact that some good people just won't like you doesn't cross their minds. That being right doesn't confer upon you any advantage in any sort of struggle is an absurd concept to them. That they may not even be right or that the situation may be more complicated than a simple right or wrong doesn't play to them.
In that case, I don't know what you do.
And instead of actually having to defend the positions they put forth, they claim they're just playing the devil's advocate.
No everyone have well informed world view.