This Saturday I went skydiving, and used a Groupon I purchased last month. The skydiving school had nothing but bad things to say about Groupon. According to the school, they were told that they would sell somewhere in the neighborhood of 200-300 skydives--they ending up selling closer to 1200. Now the fact that the number of Groupons wasn't capped at something more reasonable was most likely an oversight on the part of the merchant. However, Groupon's sales staff should have at the very least alerted the merchant to the potential risk. In this situation, it seems that Groupon was attempting to extract all possible value from merchant--Groupon had to have had some inkling that the deal was not going to be mutually beneficial.
Can you extrapolate this to all merchants using Groupon? No, but the study results certainly didn't surprise me.
Groupon have info online for merchants, advising them on how to deal with what they'll experience, but again it wouldn't surprise me if most merchants completely ignore it. People won't read instructions or advice unless you hold their eyelids open and force them to take it in. And small business owners (I'm one of them) are usually busier and more stressed than others, meaning we're even less likely to make use of such guides.
Regardless it sounds like a great challenge for Groupon to have. I'd rather have a near-endless stream of customers in this situation, than be at the beginning of it all trying to attract anyone to the site at all.
Did the merchant have a program in place to turn the one-time customers into continuing customers?
If they did, more customers would have cost them more in the short run but helped them more in the long run. If they didn't, one would assume it was a failure regardless of the numbers.
And did school waste the time they could have spent talking themselves up with talking Groupon down?
If Groupon can't explain itself and how it differs from established marketing, the kind the merchants are used to, then it will fail. It has to provide value to real merchants. That certainly includes educating them about what is going on with their service, especially concerning the risks.
If Groupon is selling group-discounts as commodity, then that it. It's your job to figure out how to use them. Google sells click-throughs and Home Depot sells cement. They might each be perfectly good but if you don't use them right, they won't do you any good.
If Groupon is like personal trainer and provides ongoing value, then does need to assure that its buyers achieve success.
Both business model-types can make money. Neither is going away. I don't know enough about Groupon to say which type they are.
Another anecdote, my friends 1 year old small business approached Groupon to do a deal, they turned him away and told him to come back when he has more press.
They do if they want to get them away from Groupon.
I have e-commerce customers who love Amazon Merchant because it's cheaper to acquire customers than SEO or buying mailing lists. But nothing pisses them off more than a customer who comes through Amazon a second time, costing them all their profit. They need to save the customer info in order to make the second sale a direct sale.
The same dynamic works with Groupon, except in person. If you don't follow up with them directly, there's a good chance they'll just wait for the next Groupon promotion, whether it's from you or your competitor. There's anecdotal evidence that this is already happening. A fresh coupon in your in box every day can get awfully addicting.
But for lots of retailers like salons, specialty shops, services, even restaurants, Groupon can be an effective way of building their customer book. When you call them back yourself, you have a much higher probability of converting them into a permanent customer.
The same reasoning for websites periodically sending their users emails is at work here. Remember how Facebook used to send email notifications that you've received a new Facebook message, but wouldn't tell you the content of that message in the email? "Hey, we have more goodies back here - come visit again."
My wife's favorite spa has also figured out that sending me follow-on ads is a pretty effective sales pitch, as I semi-routinely say 'hey, she deserves another half-day at the spa.' They got my email address from an initial online sale.
I don't get any follow-on advertising from donut places, but there's a local restaurant who uses email to fill out slow nights with some really nice prix fixe dinners. Every now and then one shows up in my inbox, sounds delicious, and I don't feel like cooking, and they make an additional sale. They started doing so after I made a reservation on OpenTable, and our dining frequency jumped substantially.
One merchant I bought from had a direct store and an Amazon store. The Amazon store price was higher (by about $1.50 on a $20-ish item), but I still ordered from Amazon because I expected the merchant to take care of Amazon customers better wrt shipping time etc. :)
As a buyer, given a choice I would rather order from the Amazon store than directly from a no-name merchant.
I think your e-commerce customers just need to raise their Amazon store prices.
Those who sell commodities don't have that option. Every time any of them has tried, sales went into the toilet. You have to stay competitive when Amazon's web page shows your item right next to your competitor's.
So maybe 15% isn't much when you consider how difficult it is to build your own e-store?
15% isn't much when you consider how difficult it is to acquire a customer.
Everyone I've loaded onto Amazon already has their own e-store. But here's what happens...Sales increases 10 to 20% almost instantly. But profits don't because of the 15% commission.
If you have a premium product with a large margin and no e-store, Amazon can be a great way to get orders. Otherwise, Amazon should be used to acquire customers for future direct sales. 15% is just too high for a commodity product.
I agree with the OP that 15% is pretty high for selling commodity stuff, but amazon seems, ah, sub optimal for lead generation because they make it look very similar to just buying from amazon. Like you, I've never gone from buying through amazon to buying direct from a merchant.
I think in some cases, the 15% might work out. As far as I can tell, when you buy in small lots you can often get a better deal than larger, more "reliable" lots, just 'cause someone further up the chain from you took a loss, (like someone bought a bunch, then went out of business and liquidated the lot at below-cost prices.) or because corruption is such a large problem (the larger the corporation, the more kickbacks are expected, as far as I can tell. If I own the company, kickbacks aren't going to get me to choose an overall more expensive vendor, it's my money, either way.)
either way, from what I've seen, often smaller lots from smaller resellers can be had cheaper than larger lots from more reputable resellers, even after you amortise out fraud/misrepresentation losses, so it's possible that the guy who sold me the cheap ESD wristbands on amazon really has more margin on the product than amazon direct would have.
So, I think it can be done, I'm just surprised that not more company do it...
But I guess that if Amazon bought them, it shows they were good at what they did :-)
I bought a groupon 1/2 price coupon for a fancy clothes store (Gap). I wouldn't normally go in there but for $10 they got me to go in and buy $50 worth of shirts. I will probably even go back.
Or they could have hired some 17 year old super model I have never heard of, for $Ms to promote them in a magazine I never read - but that wouldn't have got me in the door.
Amazon merchants have been doing this for years. Pay Amazon their commission for the first sale, then move the name to their permanent data base. 15% of the first sale is a reasonable customer acquisition cost; 15% of every sale is not sustainable (unless you have ridiculous margins).
Since many Groupon merchants meet their customers in person, an extra step is required: collecting personal info. Skip this step and you've just lost 2 things: your money and a name on your customer list.