News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by zinckiwi on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @08:00AM (#17557514)
I pledged a fraction of this fellow's total in Star Citizen, probably the lowest tier that would result in a digital copy of the game once complete. I was after a modern Privateer reboot, essentially, and figured it was worth the gamble.

I haven't followed the development with anything more than a casual, occasional glance and accompanying eye-roll. I doubt I'll ever see anything come of it. A shame, not necessarily a surprise.

I'm fully aware and prepared that kickstarting a game confers no guarantee, but the feature creep in this case is staggering. I suspect that if this case were to succeed they'd suddenly find themselves underwater with all the pledges clawed back once the precedent was set.

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by raesene9 on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:23AM (#17558123)
For me, Elite:Dangerous had a better model (although still not without it's troubles).

They delivered the base game in reasonable order and have been iterating and adding content since then.

Whilst the early game was pretty sparse in terms of content, at least it was delivered and reasonably complete.

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by skohan on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @10:30AM (#17558725)
I'm a huge fan in general of starting a project from a complete, well-polished core and growing outward gradually while maintaining quality. Once things get messy it's almost impossible to get back to that same level of refinement as if it was kept clean the whole time.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by panopticon on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @02:47PM (#17561032)
I imagine keeping the community interested, thriving, and paying for years of development is a tough nut to crack. Obviously it's not impossible (see Minecraft, Fortnite, etc), but the success ratio seems to be orders of magnitude lower than the traditional game development model.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by mo1ok on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @10:37AM (#17558789)
The tech industry learned this the hard way - MVP, then iterate is the way to go.

Star citizen abandoned its MVP (Squadron 42) awhile ago. That's why the combat sucks and there is still no core gameplay loop. A management fiasco that would be impressive to recover from.

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by rm_-rf_slash on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @04:32PM (#17561830)
Fortnite is another good example of this. It began as a zombie killer game that nobody played, but then they noticed all the money success and money that PUBG was getting, so they hacked together a Fortnite version of PUBG on a much smaller map with far fewer features (like vehicles).

Fortnite BR had very little beyond its core gameplay. There were few weapons and only a smattering of locations amidst a largely homogenous small island. But bit by bit, Epic added features, slowly, deliberately. They listened to their fans and made what they wanted as the game and the community progressed.

The result was one of the most successful, popular, and lucrative video games of all time.

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by djsumdog on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:37AM (#17558235)
That does seem like a better model. I might have to check that game out.

Games should produce the base game they promised, and then just add expansion packs or additional levels (free to initial backers) to try and get everything else in until the money runs out.

Maybe even the old shareware style route of releasing Episode 1, 2 and 3 (although in the shareware days, Ep1 was free and 2/3 were commercial .. like 1 was a really long game demo).

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by notjustanymike on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @11:28AM (#17559283)
I love Elite, just be prepared it's very much a make-your-own-adventure game.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by zchrykng on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @10:03AM (#17558446)
Elite:Dangerous is definitely worth a look. Gave money to both of these projects and don't want anything more to do with anything Chris Roberts touches.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by pearle on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @11:08AM (#17559114)
Elite is also one of the better VR games available.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by everyone on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @03:04PM (#17561182)
Its not feature creep that killed SC. I'm a game dev and I followed its development just out of sheer morbid curiosity.. Pretty much their entire process was fucked from the beginning, and they never corrected it. Its a huge case of 'Escalation of commitment' rather than feature creep, being the root cause.

At the very beginning Chris Roberts hired some artists to make a visual demo in Cryengine, to raise money. It worked, great! .. This is when they should have scrapped the demo, and hired a really great lead dev to plan out the full game. But, no, they kept building on this amateur Cryengine demo in a disorganized fashion and have been ever since.

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by benjaminsuch on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @05:26PM (#17562205)
Uhm sorry but what you just wrote are pure assumptions. And the fact that you are "a game developer" doesn't make your claims more true.

If you really followed the development process and watched their "Around the Verse" video series you cannot, by any means, call it a "Cryengine demo".

In late 2013 the scope of the game got totally changed. It turned from a small multiplayer space flight game to an MMORPG. So they literally had to start from zero and nobody has any insights about the game development and organization except the CIG developers themself.

A very weird post from you as "game developer".

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by Laforet on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @05:50PM (#17562361)
He's not entirely wrong though, CryEngine was and arguably still is wholly unsuited for anything that borders on MMO. Instead of realigning your plan around the changed scope, Chris Roberts decided to keep the glitter of CryEngine visuals and he is paying the price for this decision. Netcode is still affecting performance to this day and I doubt if it will ever be solvable.

We are long past the time when Iwata managed to single handedly refactor Earthbound in a few months with minimum external help. Complex projects carry so much inertia that makes it very hard to correct course once you have momentum in one (wrong) direction.

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by benjaminsuch on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:20PM (#17562529)
They switched 2 years ago from CryEngine to Lumberyard from Amazon which have an integrated feature for using AWS. They also stated that they completely rewrote the network part and still working on it to date.

They call it Object Container Streaming and Network Bind Culling (I'm not a network developer, so I have no idea about the technical side of it). I don't know how far along they are (they postponed the feature to the 3.3 update) but I'm confident in their abilites.

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by Laforet on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @10:50PM (#17563628)
You do realise that Lumberyard is just an licensed build of CryEngine with AWS related APIs added on top, right? As of alpha 3.2 there is still a very noticable network latency correlated to the number of active players per server. I will gladly change my opinion when CIG do manage to fix it.

Still, none of this would help to explain why SQ42 was postponed to 2019 and beyond.

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by benjaminsuch on Thursday July 19, 2018 @07:19AM (#17565310)

  You do realise that Lumberyard is just an licensed build of CryEngine with AWS related APIs added on top, right?
Yes I know this, but it doesn't change anything on my point that they are still working on the network part which isn't finished.

And thats why you still have huge network latencys. Wait until they finished their network module and then we can judge.

  Still, none of this would help to explain why SQ42 was postponed to 2019 and beyond.
CIG stated that a lot of things used in SQ42 is based on SC technology.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by _Codemonkeyism on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @08:21AM (#17557654)
I think they came to a point when they thought "This could be huge and mind blowing, and can't be done for a long time if we don't do it" and kept going.

I myself went from a critic to someone shouting "Go ahead!"

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by beaconstudios on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @08:31AM (#17557723)
However, in the process they seem to have fully embraced the waterfall method which seems to me to be the root cause of the problem. They could have delivered the original concept as an MVP and continued to build towards their long-term vision through patches and incremental updates, much like rockstar did with GTA V online. Instead they're working slowly towards shipping a gigantic monolith where all that's playable in the meantime are very small vertical slices that don't really represent a game in their own right.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by WorkLifeBalance on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @08:50AM (#17557867)
Compare the process for "Star Citizen" to "Rimworld", another kickstarted project which is nearing a 1.0 release after years of development.

Rimworld had a public beta and has been iterating and incorporating feedback and while the end-result might not be as ambitious as someone with $200m might care to dream up (rimworld raised ~$250k) but it's a very fun game which most importantly actually exists.

In fact existing in some form allowed the community to write mods and extensions many of which have ended up patched into the game itself as it nears release.

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by shusson on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:23AM (#17558128)
I think a closer comparison is Elite Dangerous.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by _Codemonkeyism on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:28AM (#17558169)
I regret backing Elite Dangerous, it's underwhelming.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by fcarraldo on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:39AM (#17558254)
And this is the unfortunate problem with the agile “release an MVP and iterate” approach when talking about a game. Unlike a SaaS product that might initially solve a problem, a game needs to be compelling, make a good first impression, and be fun, all out of the gate, to retain player interest. The Early Access model has continued to fail because people try the early version, dislike it (because it isn’t finished), then leave bad reviews and never return to see the game’s progress.

Elite continues to get better all the time and will likely eventually be a pretty good game, but it’ll never have the audience it would have if they had the budget to release a full and finished product on day 1.

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by beaconstudios on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:53AM (#17558345)
I think that's because many early access developers don't put enough focus on the "Viable" aspect, and focus too hard on "Minimum". For a game to be viable it should express its core gameplay features in a compelling way. Iteration should just be building additional content on top of that, or building new modules that live on top of the core (like the FPS aspects of Star Citizen arguably should be).
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by nightski on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @11:15AM (#17559174)
True but I'd say it's that minimum and viable are much closer to the final product with games making the whole notion less useful.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by beaconstudios on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:48PM (#17562981)
that is very true, but with a huge game like Star Citizen you could likely strip out a huge share of the intended final-cut content and still have a quality and complete product.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by sokoloff on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:55AM (#17558367)
Didn’t Minecraft release (obviously successfully) with this approach?
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by scrumbledober on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @10:39AM (#17558810)
Minecraft released in alpha where you couldn't even mine or craft yet. In alpha it was basically a voxel terrain generator with a 1st person flying around view
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by striking on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @02:28PM (#17560884)
No, in Alpha it was playable, with crafting and mining.

You're thinking of Classic or Pre-Classic. And IIRC, Survival Test (with mining and crafting) was the first thing you had to pay for to play. https://web.archive.org/web/20090904213840/http://www.minecr...

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by xioxox on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @01:08PM (#17560130)
Me too, it just felt dull. I particularly regret it as they promised a single player version that would work without a network, and delivered a network-only game that requires a server to run. I much prefer the X3 games than E:D. They have an interesting mixture of dog fighting, empire building and missions, although the learning curve is steep.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by deadbunny on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:35AM (#17558221)
The irony being that it's basically what SC promised in their KS.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by sgift on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:53AM (#17558344)
If E:D is what SC has promised in their KS they are finished. Fly around for half an hour in the SC dogfighting mode, fly a bit more in the open world, maybe do a mission. Done. You have now fully experienced E:D. And that's with the current state of the Alpha.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @08:50AM (#17557874)
Is GTA V Online a good example? Most of the delivered updates have just been additional vehicles and a few more game modes. I don't mean to sound like I'm shitting on the hard work they do, but GTA V Online wasn't really an "MVP".
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by beaconstudios on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @08:58AM (#17557936)
I was thinking specifically of how they originally shipped when the game first came out. I don't really play it much but my understanding is that the initial version didn't contain heists, corporations, warehouses, half the mission types, half the vehicles, and so on. It may not have evolved much recently and the initial scope may have been over 50% of the current feature set, but they're the best example I can think of for an MMO MVP. For singleplayer games, minecraft would be an obvious choice but it was also the progenitor of early access so that's more of a hit-and-miss.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by the4ner on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @04:11PM (#17612360)
This changed starting at the end of last year. They are on a quarterly release cycle now, and they've hit the last 2 quarterly deadlines.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by deadbunny on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:37AM (#17558233)
I'll preface with the fact I've not kept up with SC development at all. But haven't they released multiple "modules" as they've been going?
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by beaconstudios on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:59AM (#17558418)
yes, but they're not building those atop a functioning game platform. They're completely separate, like individual prototypes. If they were integrated into a whole that'd be a totally different story.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by plttn on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @02:04PM (#17560659)
They are though. You can go from flying a spaceship, land, get out, shoot some friends, get back in a spaceship and fly away. The module concept hasn't really been a thing for a while.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by sullyj3 on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:10PM (#17563319)
This is true, but I was under the impression that they were using separate mechanics for star Marine vs shooting in the persistent universe, which they're still in the process of merging together
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by the4ner on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @04:11PM (#17612367)
no longer true
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by EamonnMR on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:19AM (#17558092)
Part of the problem is that they're hacking MP into an engine that hasn't really been proven out for MP so until they get that sorted MP is gonna be rough.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by skohan on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @10:38AM (#17558805)
Yeah but it seems like a huge problem that this issue hasn't been sorted out years into development. The whole premise of the game is based around playing in a shared persistent world: they should have gotten the multiplayer experience working perfectly in a proof-of-concept stage, with characters running around blank environments full of grey boxes before anything else.

At the moment it seems like they are a content production company for a game that doesn't exist.

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by EamonnMR on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @03:07PM (#17561199)
That certainly would've been my first step.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by Zooper on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @11:56AM (#17559507)
Investors need to re-imagine epic games as platforms, a movie that plays for twenty-plus years, iteratively developed. This also tends to collapse genres (markets): the World-of-Warcraft effect, wherein all other games of the genre bleed-out to the big platform. Good if you're the Star Citizen in the room and succeed.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by wlesieutre on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @04:50PM (#17561939)
The thing I'm most skeptical of is them being able to balance the economy in a way that makes it a fun MMO. The technology parts of it seem more achievable.

If you backed in the first few years you'll have access to both the Star Citizen MMO universe and the Squadron 42 single player game. Both keep getting delayed, but the scope of Squadron 42 isn't as huge so I'm crossing my fingers that it'll be a 2019 release.

The Star Citizen alpha 3.3 release (end of Q3) will be a make or break point for the project's current schedule. That's when the "container streaming" system that lets them seamlessly load parts of the universe in and out is supposed to happen, along with Hurston, the second planet (and Loreville, the first planetside city area). If you have a beefy enough computer that's when I'd recommend coming back and giving it a play.

Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr... by m0llusk on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @11:15AM (#17559176)
The game he always wanted to make, he said. How can you creep from there?