Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by shusson on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:23AM
(#17558128)
I think a closer comparison is Elite Dangerous.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by _Codemonkeyism on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:28AM
(#17558169)
I regret backing Elite Dangerous, it's underwhelming.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by fcarraldo on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:39AM
(#17558254)
And this is the unfortunate problem with the agile “release an MVP and iterate” approach when talking about a game. Unlike a SaaS product that might initially solve a problem, a game needs to be compelling, make a good first impression, and be fun, all out of the gate, to retain player interest. The Early Access model has continued to fail because people try the early version, dislike it (because it isn’t finished), then leave bad reviews and never return to see the game’s progress.
Elite continues to get better all the time and will likely eventually be a pretty good game, but it’ll never have the audience it would have if they had the budget to release a full and finished product on day 1.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by beaconstudios on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:53AM
(#17558345)
I think that's because many early access developers don't put enough focus on the "Viable" aspect, and focus too hard on "Minimum". For a game to be viable it should express its core gameplay features in a compelling way. Iteration should just be building additional content on top of that, or building new modules that live on top of the core (like the FPS aspects of Star Citizen arguably should be).
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by nightski on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @11:15AM
(#17559174)
True but I'd say it's that minimum and viable are much closer to the final product with games making the whole notion less useful.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by beaconstudios on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:48PM
(#17562981)
that is very true, but with a huge game like Star Citizen you could likely strip out a huge share of the intended final-cut content and still have a quality and complete product.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by sokoloff on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:55AM
(#17558367)
Didn’t Minecraft release (obviously successfully) with this approach?
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by scrumbledober on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @10:39AM
(#17558810)
Minecraft released in alpha where you couldn't even mine or craft yet. In alpha it was basically a voxel terrain generator with a 1st person flying around view
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by striking on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @02:28PM
(#17560884)
No, in Alpha it was playable, with crafting and mining.
You're thinking of Classic or Pre-Classic. And IIRC, Survival Test (with mining and crafting) was the first thing you had to pay for to play. https://web.archive.org/web/20090904213840/http://www.minecr...
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by xioxox on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @01:08PM
(#17560130)
Me too, it just felt dull. I particularly regret it as they promised a single player version that would work without a network, and delivered a network-only game that requires a server to run. I much prefer the X3 games than E:D. They have an interesting mixture of dog fighting, empire building and missions, although the learning curve is steep.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by deadbunny on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:35AM
(#17558221)
The irony being that it's basically what SC promised in their KS.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by sgift on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:53AM
(#17558344)
If E:D is what SC has promised in their KS they are finished. Fly around for half an hour in the SC dogfighting mode, fly a bit more in the open world, maybe do a mission. Done. You have now fully experienced E:D. And that's with the current state of the Alpha.