Same thing with legislation. Take an issue like gay marriage. Everyone can understand it at some level, so everyone has an opinion on it and it becomes a popular subject to talk about when discussing politics.
Now take something like financial regulation. The future of the country is riding on it, but it's too complicated for most people and thus people fall asleep after 5 minutes of talking about it, so it's handed off to specialists and consultants who work for the finance industry.
So is deregulation the answer?
Well, no. When deregulation gets done, the bills are written mostly by lobbyists. The big corporations identify a few of their pain points and we happily eliminate those regulations, but we never worry about the things that are most burdensome to small businesses or the regulations that prohibit new companies from starting up at all. So deregulation tends to strengthen existing companies and reinforce the corporate oligarchy that already exists.
Basically, for the market to work better we need to increase competition, but Congress will never have any incentive to encourage increased competition. That proposition would pit the lobbying dollars of every existing company in an industry against the interests of companies that haven't been formed yet.
If this was a non-ideological/political position we would be having a civil war over bushes spending during his term.
You argue that financial regulation is important (and it is) but the problem with your statement is that the economy is all-important. I'm not going to argue that it isn't, rather I am merely goung to point out that people have very different ideas about what government is for.
For some there are many social issues that Are important to society as a whole. One could argue that freedom of religion is an unproductive distraction.
One can argue that we shouldn't legislate morality, which many clearly try to do, but we do that in many ways. Theft, murder, etc are all morality when it comes down to it.
If you approach democracy by saying "these people are irrational because issue X doesn't matter to the economy" you're not making any useful observation. In fact, it's a bit like arguing that the problem with democracy is that you don't get the outcome you want.
Suppose your personal stake in a presidential election is $50,000 (e.g., you make $500k/year, and Candidate 1 will raise or lower your taxes by 2.5%/year.) Your odds of swinging the election with your vote are 1 in 100 million (assuming 100 million voters).
Your expected gain from voting is $0.0005. Therefore, you will not rationally be willing to spend more than $0.0005 determining which candidate is best. Further, you might deliberately vote for the wrong candidate for expressive reasons. I.e., if you assign $0.25 worth of utility to supporting the guy you want to share a beer with [1], or to proving you aren't racist, you will vote for the worse candidate.
[1] Because the stakes are so low, most people didn't even bother learning that this candidate doesn't drink. That would take more than $0.25 worth of effort.
This assumption doesn't make sense
If you prefer, you can play with binomial distributions to calculate P(side X wins with N votes && side X wins with N-1 votes) [1]. Using the normal approximation and ignoring the normalization prefactor (an overestimate) exp[(n(p-0.5)^2 / 1(np(1-p))] odds of having your vote matter. For p=0.501 (i.e., voters are split 50.1%, 49.9%), that works out to about 10^{-87}. For p=0.51, double floats are incapable of representing a number that small.
I stand by my statement. Your vote doesn't matter.
[1] Conceptually, this is slightly different from computing the odds that you cast the deciding vote, but I realize it is more useful from a decision theoretic perspective.
[0] http://redbluerichpoor.com/blog/2008/10/what-is-the-probabil...
[1] http://www.stat.columbia.edu/~gelman/research/published/prob...
(By "significantly", I mean "increases the odds of your vote mattering to a number greater than, say, 10^{-86}. )
The odds that the election would be decided by a single vote have not been considered.
If I actually did have $50k riding on the election, I'd spend more than $0.0005 cents determining which candidate is best, because assessing risk is necessary to plan for the future.
...unless you are alturistic, and you value the impact on the other 300 million citizens (and the rest of the world). Then it can make sense to vote for who you think is best.
Altruistic value is usually very high in the issues that people seem to vote based on: gay marriage, government health care, military operations, etc. Many people do value these things much higher than their tax rate.
The problem arises when we treat dollars as the unit of value. Value is not possible to practically quantify, and using money as the common denominator pushes things that actually are money to the fore, and fails to expose the things that do matter to people.
$50,000? If so, repeat my calculation. $100,000? If so, then voting is worth $0.001 to you. $100 million? Then voting is actually worth $1 to you.
A much simpler explanation of voting behavior is the expressive value of voting. People devote great effort to cheering for their team and signalling allegiance - just look at sales of $50 Yankees pinstripes or $80 Paquiao jackets. Most people don't wait in line for 10 minutes just to donate $1 to a good cause.
Money has value, and events like law changes have value. However, both money and events have wildly varying value to different people. What a dollar is worth to me is different than what a dollar is worth to you, and indeed, what the millionth dollar is worth to me is far different than what the first one is.
The problem is this assumption that money is an appropriate expression of value. This is what I reject. It is an abstraction parallel to the bundles of mortgages that American banks were brought down by - putting it into a unit the MBAs and politicians can understand meant losing essentially all the meaning of what was bought and sold, and ignored fundamental fallacies in assumptions made.
The future that costs you $50,000 (or helps/hurts you via any of the mentioned surrogate currencies) is distasteful. Your irrational brain won't let you do nothing, and makes you go out and cast your vote, even though you may understand that it's a waste of time.
Alternative theory: Risk.
Highly publicized close elections create a scenario that looms large in your mind: The Bad Guy wins by one vote. (Or just a few). You would never forgive yourself. Even though you know it to be fantastically unlikely, you aren't willing to risk it.
/me doesn't vote.
For example, I consider time I spend reading on the toilet basically worthless. So when the voter guide comes in the mail, with the candidates' statements, text of propositions and submitted arguments for or against, it is less than $0.25 to multitask there.
Expected gain, though, is higher than just the tax cuts and beer-having. It can be fun to study that stuff. And, looking at the big picture, the collapse of our democracy by having an uninformed electorate would mean everyone loses everything that is based on the USD.
Taleb's talked about chasing activities where the black swans are positive: http://akkartik.name/blog/9400292
Why is there no net neutrality bill? The rich are overrepresented in our system for a reason. Sad but true.
What a jerk I would be if I said: "The best argument against industrialization is a five-minute conversation with the average construction worker" or something similar.
Nice turn of phrase. (Source?)
These three sources of failure (voters, politicians, lobbyists) don't have to be mutually exclusive. I'd say they're all broken, with the real problem resting in the idea that government is upwardly scalable. The inability of most people to understand actions and motivations other than their own (a requisite for computer security) leads them to thinking that affecting larger groups somehow solves more people's problems (while in fact the opposite is true).
Nobody in the world knows how to make all parts of the pencil. The graphite have to be mined. Somebody have to make coffee for the miners. Somebody have to truck the graphite to pencil making factory. Somebody have to chop down the wood.
Even programmers specialized. There's somebody who work on deploy tools, and there are some who are trying to make ruby faster.
Voters now have to decide between a wide range of policy stance that they probably don't know anything about. There are foreign policies, economic problems, etc. All of which are subjects that probably required lot of studying to get right. Than, those politicians, as generalist probably don't know these issue as well as they need to, or they are compromised by their own interests.
Programmers, doctors, etc are busy with their own profession trying to keep themselves competitive on the market and make decisions for their own lives. Sometime, they got it wrong.
If a lot of people can't make the right decisions for themselves, why do they expect them to make decisions concerning the leadership of a nation?
When you're deciding about wars, financial crisies, decimation of the middle class, increasingly extreme wealth distribution, etc., the former probably is the lesser of two evils.
The rules that prevent a president from too many reelections are similarly befeficial, and a lot cheaper even if not enough.
The voters have the voters' interests at heart. Businesses have their own interests at heart. But you're right: voters are often stupid, irrational, misinformed, etc.
I'll leave the last word to Churchill: democracy is the worst possible system for running a country, except for all the others.
This is one of those chants that everyone keeps repeating for fear of looking at the alternatives, or to excuse the horrors. Keep repeating the chant, and you don't have to take a close look at the problem.
Many people in history have thought their current way of doing things was pretty nifty and everything that came before was barbarism and idiocy. We have to be a little more open-minded than that to get at true or useful ideas. There is certainly something suboptimal about a government that can't pass a bill smaller than the size of a dictionary, or that in theory and practice protects concentrated interests at the expense of the broader good. I have my doubts that the American state is in a sustainable equilibrium given the astounding irrationality and paralysis of the legislative process.
On specialist websites, people might be familiar with the existence of an entire sub-discipline of economics dedicated to explaining the incentives facing voters and governments (Public Choice) and the historical lessons of hundreds of different governing forms in human history, so the discussion thankfully extends beyond Churchill's quote.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_choice_theory
that appears to explain some phenomena that are not readily explained on other grounds. Public choice theory was a big part of the content of the course on legislation in the first year of law school, and had much to do with why I don't expect to solve all of my country's problems by passing new laws.
> Many forms of Government have been tried and will be tried in this world of sin and woe. No one pretends that democracy is perfect or all-wise. Indeed, it has been said that democracy is the worst form of government except all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.
I wouldn't call China a democracy, but they have given up a lot of central power and are growing fast.
Certainly there are also example of successful societies that have lasted for very long periods of time that are not democracies, such as tribal communities. They don't exhibit significant economic growth, but they also are far less likely to make war, which would be a good candidate for being "Better" (it is bad to lose a generation of men every couple of generations.) Their lower economic growth may also be a result of their lower war making, but their higher standards of living of the populace relative to the overall standard of living, when compared to democracies, argues again for their form of government being superior.
My point being that it is very common for a culture to reinforce in its members a perception that the cultures way of doing things is "right" and that it produces a better outcome-- and it does it in such a way that people presume that this to be a fact, rather than a bias.
I think by most standards that most people would agree on, democracies come out well.
For example, consider life expectancy -- this is IMO a good measure because nearly everyone wants to be alive, and someone who is alive is (usually) better off than someone who is dead. If you look at countries with the highest life expectancy ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_Expectancy_by_Country ) democracies seem to be over-represented at the top. This is particularly the case if you discount territories that aren't counties (such as Hong Kong).
Of if you go by UN Human Development Index, you get a similar story.
> Certainly there are also example of successful societies that have lasted for very long periods of time that are not democracies, such as tribal communities. They don't exhibit significant economic growth, but they also are far less likely to make war
I'm not sure this is the case. Are you familiar with the high rate of homicide among the Yanomamo?
> My point being that it is very common for a culture to reinforce in its members a perception that the cultures way of doing things is "right" and that it produces a better outcome-- and it does it in such a way that people presume that this to be a fact, rather than a bias.
You're right that this is a cognitive bias we should guard against.
At any rate, I believe what you're seeing is the superiority of democracy as a form of tyranny, and I won't dispute that. Most of the comparisons, looking at those statistics are to other forms of tyranny. There are very few free countries, and few people who have been educated to respect human rights enough to take up arms to overthrow their government to defend them. When these people do this, though, as the somalis overthrew their dictator, they are visited by no end of warmaking from these so-called "peaceful" democracies. Somalia has been attacked without provocation by the US and UK many times since throwing off their dictator.
As for the Yanamamo, I'm not familiar with them, but it would be interesting to understand how many of these homicides are murders and how many are instances of the death penalty. (EG: crimes themselves or responses to crimes.) I, of course, can't say.
Other than people have a natural instinct for a form of morality, but this morality can be perverted by culture. (note americans propensity for supporting violence against the innocent in the forms of war and taxes.)
The Myth of the Rational Voter: Why Democracies Choose Bad Policies is a 2007 book written by Bryan Caplan challenging the notion that voters are reasonable people that society can trust to make laws. Rather, Caplan contends that voters are irrational in the political sphere and have systematically biased ideas concerning economics. ...
The book is notable in use of irrationality, a rare assumption in economics. Yet the work is also a challenge to conventional public choice, where voters are seen as rationally ignorant. Conventional public choice either emphasizes the efficiency of democracy (as in the case of Donald Wittman) or, more commonly, democratic failure due to the interaction between self-interested politicians or bureaucrats, well-organized, rent-seeking minority interests and a largely indifferent general public (as in the work of Gordon Tullock, James M. Buchanan, and many others). Caplan, however, emphasizes that democratic failure does exist and places the blame for it squarely on the general public. He makes special emphasis that politicians are often caught between a rock and a hard place: thanks to advisors, they know what policies would be generally beneficial, but they also know that those policies are not what people want. Thus they are balancing good economic policy (so they don’t get voted out of office due to slow growth) and bad economic policy (so they don’t get voted out of office due to unpopular policies).
https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/The_Myth_of_t...