News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's CEO: 'The Laws Are Written by Lobbyists' by jpwagner on Saturday October 02, 2010 @01:33PM (#1750881)
Your odds of swinging the election with your vote are 1 in 100 million

This assumption doesn't make sense

Re:Google's CEO: 'The Laws Are Written by Lobbyists' by yummyfajitas on Saturday October 02, 2010 @07:48PM (#1751665)
There are 100 million votes, one of which decided the election (the N+1'th vote on the winning side, assuming N votes on the losing side).

If you prefer, you can play with binomial distributions to calculate P(side X wins with N votes && side X wins with N-1 votes) [1]. Using the normal approximation and ignoring the normalization prefactor (an overestimate) exp[(n(p-0.5)^2 / 1(np(1-p))] odds of having your vote matter. For p=0.501 (i.e., voters are split 50.1%, 49.9%), that works out to about 10^{-87}. For p=0.51, double floats are incapable of representing a number that small.

I stand by my statement. Your vote doesn't matter.

[1] Conceptually, this is slightly different from computing the odds that you cast the deciding vote, but I realize it is more useful from a decision theoretic perspective.

Re:Google's CEO: 'The Laws Are Written by Lobbyists' by simonft1 on Sunday October 03, 2010 @02:02PM (#1753203)
Re:Google's CEO: 'The Laws Are Written by Lobbyists' by jpwagner on Saturday October 02, 2010 @08:19PM (#1751722)
There's no point in putting it to "hard numbers" if you make terribly impractical guesstimates.
Re:Google's CEO: 'The Laws Are Written by Lobbyists' by yummyfajitas on Saturday October 02, 2010 @08:30PM (#1751738)
Please explain which of my approximations you believe changes my results significantly.

(By "significantly", I mean "increases the odds of your vote mattering to a number greater than, say, 10^{-86}. )

Re:Google's CEO: 'The Laws Are Written by Lobbyists' by jpwagner on Sunday October 03, 2010 @02:05AM (#1752206)
I can't help you clean up the calculations because the entire premise that the probability of "your vote mattering" times your potential financial gain from one candidate over another gives any reasonable estimate of utility of a vote is absurd.
Re:Google's CEO: 'The Laws Are Written by Lobbyists' by yummyfajitas on Sunday October 03, 2010 @08:58AM (#1752639)
It doesn't have to be financial gain - it can be altruistic gain from policy choices. As I said in another post, if you personally would be willing to spend $50k to legalize gay marriage (for example), you can replace $50k of financial gain by $50k worth of utility derived from helping others.
Re:Google's CEO: 'The Laws Are Written by Lobbyists' by pradocchia on Saturday October 02, 2010 @06:52PM (#1751569)
The rational voter never votes. At best he spends his effort convincing other people to vote a certain way, persuading others that their vote does indeed count, all the while knowing his own vote doesn't. If he participates at all, he does so as demagogue and charlatan.
Re:Google's CEO: 'The Laws Are Written by Lobbyists' by ghurlman on Saturday October 02, 2010 @06:32PM (#1751526)
It makes sense... it's just wrong. The odds that your vote is the last one counted in a 100M vote election is 1 in 100 million.

The odds that the election would be decided by a single vote have not been considered.

Re:Google's CEO: 'The Laws Are Written by Lobbyists' by three14 on Saturday October 02, 2010 @05:35PM (#1751415)
For a presidential election, you think this estimate is too high?