News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by pzxc on Friday July 06, 2018 @12:26AM (#17468824)
You forgot Response #4: Ok. I'll take your word for it; here's a raise. (Aside to other managers: this guy is a flight risk. Don't offer him any promotions, and start thinking about how we might replace him.)

It happens. Not infrequently. It's why I never tell my employer when I get an offer. They might just give me the raise because it would hurt to lose me today but they can lose me in a couple months, and then the offer I had at the new company is long gone.

Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by vonmoltke on Friday July 06, 2018 @07:10AM (#17470459)
> You forgot Response #4: Ok. I'll take your word for it; here's a raise. (Aside to other managers: this guy is a flight risk. Don't offer him any promotions, and start thinking about how we might replace him.)

This seems like a counterproductive response if the labor market is tight.

Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by shawabawa3 on Friday July 06, 2018 @08:46AM (#17470938)
You know what I've never had in my entire career?

  Company: The market is competitive and your market rate has increased, so here's a raise (of more than 2-3%)
Every single time I've got a raise I've had to either fight for it or move, and then companies are wondering why so many people move...
Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by mlthoughts2018 on Friday July 06, 2018 @08:57AM (#17470993)
Definitely agree. The one time I ever got a significant raise required me to lobby unbelievably hard despite the fact that I was carrying the weight of my whole team and had to do an unreal amount of shit shoveling devops, web service, and data cleaning work in addition to all the machine learning work that was “actually” my job.

I was lucky that my direct manager valued me and guided me through the process of documenting my accomplishments in the right ways to present the case for a substantial promotion.

Apart from this one time, I have always been told the company can’t offer raises or discretionary bonuses beyond whatever the board grants for cost of living, and have to switch jobs repeatedly if I want to earn more.

I don’t get it. I feel like it must be some misaligned incentive problem with HR preferring to make executives believe turnover and constant hiring have to always be the norm, to justify their jobs, instead of cultivating a culture of long tenures by actually offering substantial raises or bonuses.

Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by nfriedly on Friday July 06, 2018 @09:27AM (#17471193)
It happened to me at IBM. I got a 5% raise the first year, and 10% the next; both we're suprises. (And I was making good money for the area when I started, so I don't think they were trying to catch me up.)

My direct managers were awesome, but I ended up leaving for other reasons.

Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by vonmoltke on Friday July 06, 2018 @09:26AM (#17471189)
You are right about that. This is a slightly different situation, though. What you describe is scenario #2 up-thread. The person I was responding to was posting an alternative to scenario #3. I'm just saying that in a tight labor market a company adopting response #4 instead of response #3 is cutting off their nose to spite your face.
Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by crdoconnor on Friday July 06, 2018 @04:33AM (#17469865)
If they promote the kinds of people who will cling on to a job for dear life (non-flight risks) they will not end up with good people at the top.
Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by bryanrasmussen on Friday July 06, 2018 @08:48AM (#17470943)
if they promote the kinds of people who don't like to look for new jobs they might or might not end up with good people at the top.
Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by mac01021 on Friday July 06, 2018 @12:52AM (#17468936)
So, having received an offer that you're inclined to accept, you will never be swayed by a counteroffer from your current employer? I suppose the logic is sound, especially if you know you aren't hard to replace.

I feel I need to at least go through the motion of entertaining the counteroffer, though. Otherwise they'll think I don't like them or be offended and I'll have maybe burnt a bridge. Of course, for the same reason, I was never looking for another job. That offer came to me on its own.

Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by joezydeco on Friday July 06, 2018 @01:01AM (#17468981)
You need to think back as to what made you start job hunting in the first place. It didn’t happen spontaneously.

Will a counteroffer change that situation?

Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by fsloth on Friday July 06, 2018 @04:31AM (#17469857)
Dude, sometimes people are in a financial stretch and the increase in compensation is the only reason to search for alternatives.

Especially in big corps there can be a policy of being stingy with the wages unless there is some scenario like a need for counteroffer for a high performing individual contributor.

Now, you can think the company is cheap and does not really earn you contribution.

However, the psychological reality is that people don't work in their companies - they work inside teams within companies, and the duties and the culture of the team can be great even if the company policy (likely sculpted out of feeling of ficudiary duty towards stockholders among other things) feels cheap.

Great teams and great managers are far more important for a great job than "great companies". Yes, the latent company culture affects team as well, but that's only one aspect of the whole.

Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by pnutjam on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:28AM (#17471627)
When HPE hired me on, I know I was about 20% more then the guy who had been doing the job for 20 years. Companies don't value you if you stick around. Your only hurting yourself.
Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by finaliteration on Friday July 06, 2018 @01:07AM (#17469008)
I’m actually sort of in this situation. I just interviewed for another position and it went extremely well. The thing is I’m pretty happy with my current job and role except for one dimension: Salary.

If they would pay me what the market says I’m worth (and I’ve done a ton of market research) then I’d be happy to stay where I am for the foreseeable future. But if another company offers me a job and the work and environment seem comparable but they’re willing to pay more... I’d seriously consider that offer and be prepared to leave. However, if my current employer comes back and says, “Actually we will beat that by x%” then I’d seriously consider staying.

It also helps that someone else in the company did just this and is still with the company a couple years later.

Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by ryandrake on Friday July 06, 2018 @02:58PM (#17474183)
If "not being paid enough" was what made you start job hunting, then a counteroffer would likely change the situation.

Last place I left, I made it exceedingly clear, a year before resignation, 6 months before resignation, and during resignation, that all they needed to do to retain me was to bring me back up to market rate. I would have definitely stayed if they were forthcoming with a counteroffer.

Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by ido on Friday July 06, 2018 @08:01AM (#17470682)
Depends on the situation, sometimes - sure.

I'm pretty happy where I am right now, but if you give me an offer to an attractive position for 20% more money I'd at the very least entertain the notion.

Re:Job-hopping increases, in possible boon to wage growth an... by joezydeco on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:24AM (#17471582)
My point is that an offer like that would seem attractive, but two things:

A) The company didn't value you until it was too late. Their opinion of you hasn't changed, just the pay rate.

B) The company now has painted a target on your back as someone that is "in it for the money" and doesn't have the best interests of the company in mind. It's bullshit, but that's now management thinks. Next time a budget cut or RIF is necessary, guess who is first in line?

In both cases, you need to weigh if that's worth sticking around for.