News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by roryisok on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @01:56PM (#17452312)
Stuff like this worries me. We should be doing everything we can to curb the energy and heat we produce and instead we're using vast amounts of energy to basically waste trillions of CPU cycles so that we can produce digital money that might never actually be worth anything. It's just about the most pointless use of planetary resources I can think of
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by apr on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @02:24PM (#17452552)
Why? Doing anything of value requires expending of energy and producing heat, this is unavoidable. Saying that this activity is pointless just because you are not seeing any value does not mean that it is actually pointless. In general anything that people are willing to pay money for is not pointless for someone, otherwise that money would be spent on something else. It is like saying why a farmer needs to drive that big tractor down the field using precious (for whom?) oil and polluting the air whereas I can do things manually on my pea patch just fine. If anything we should welcome higher and higher energy use because it means higher standard of living for the humankind. And just to address 'waste' here, energy is not free so 'waste' that actually wastes resources cannot go on for long lest the waster goes bankrupt.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by roryisok on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @03:23PM (#17452946)
There are so many things I could argue with here but I'm tired so I'll just pick one.

> If anything we should welcome higher and higher energy use because it means higher standard of living for the humankind.

Why would it mean that? If we were talking about households using more and more it might, but it might not. My tv uses far less energy than the one I had twenty years ago but there's no chance I'm going back to that heap of CRT junk. Likewise all my other appliances, my car etc. My life has improved as my energy usage has decreased. But even if the opposite were true, it's not households, but industry that in this case is consuming more and more power. An industry that produces no goods, provides no service, does no research, improves only the lives of the direct owners of that industry. It's as if they're building enormous, energy sucking diamond factories, but with the added chance that diamonds might be worthless by the time they have them.

Even if I'm wrong, even if higher energy usage means higher standard of living, that's a short term outlook, because over a hundred year period it will mean a much, much lower standard of living for everyone who hasn't drowned or starved yet

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by apr on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @04:06PM (#17453255)
You are taking a very narrow view on the energy use here. In modern economy you can think of pretty much any thing as made of energy. You are comparing how much your new tv is pulling out of a socket to your old tv, but did you figure the energy cost of producing that new tv into your calculations? I'd look at an even bigger picture. Like to travel? Now compare how much more energy must be used to go in an airplane fast compared to traveling on foot slow. You mention the car, now the radical thing to do would be to ditch the car completely, but then your life quality invariable would go down. It is great that waste goes down and we can argue that the fact that your old car consumed more fuel tells us that it was wasteful compared to the new one, but note even to cut that waste required energy expenditure in the form of people working on it, computer power for sims, etc, and, of course, manufacture.

And I disagree that higher energy expenditure overall will mean lower quality of life later on. We are swimming in energy even though we currently might not know how to convert some forms of it into productive use. That'll change.

By the way, don't get me wrong, I am totally for cutting waste on the local level just because it frees some of the money (and that is proxy for resources) for other, more productive uses.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by jdietrich on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @06:52PM (#17454206)
We're mostly being bitten on the arse by the Jevons paradox. Improving efficiency has a tendency to increase overall consumption.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by roryisok on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @06:17PM (#17454019)
> By the way, don't get me wrong, I am totally for cutting waste on the local level

Did you not just literally say that higher energy usage is itself a good thing?

Also on your point about production: My old tv had to be built, my old car also had to be built. It cost energy to replace them, but it does not equate to higher energy usage going forward.

I do agree with one thing you said though. We're swimming in unharnessed energy right now. If we can swap all the coal plants for fusion then maybe we can afford to waste energy on generating digital money, but right now bitcoin server farms mean more carbon in the atmosphere

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by robertAngst on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @06:22PM (#17454059)
Its important to stop being black and white here.

You both understand each others points.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by bigphishy on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:01PM (#17455022)
If there are other falacious points then please give evidence for their inaccuracy, otherwise it appears like you just picked an easy point to refute, but claimed the entire argument was false.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by roryisok on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @01:55AM (#17455499)
No. I've got nothing to prove to you, stranger. Arguing with people on the internet is almost as big a waste of energy as bitcoin mining. If you think I'm wrong I'm not going to convince you or that guy otherwise.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by wpietri on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @04:03PM (#17453225)
That's not a very good analogy. The way to measure waste is by seeing if you can deliver the same customer value using fewer resources.

If I'm generous with the definition of "value", Bitcoin's main demonstrated value is as a speculative instrument. That is, something people gamble on. There are plenty of things for people to gamble on that consume less energy. Or none at all. For example, they could be gambling on the weather (as the degree-day markets do). There are other practical reasons -- much less common ones --people use Bitcoin, but those too can be done more efficiently.

Doing anything of value does require expending energy. But expending energy is no proof that anything of value is happening.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by SilasX on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @04:51PM (#17453524)
It has also demonstrated value in being able to bypass the financial choke points that prevented people from (electronically) donating to Wikileaks.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by wpietri on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @10:02AM (#17457304)
Given that Wikileaks now takes credit cards, it doesn't seem like a major use case: https://shop.wikileaks.org/donate
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by SilasX on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @02:54PM (#17458859)
For a while, credit card processors in the US were pressured by the government not to authorize charges, even if Wikileaks would accept them as payment. That make it effectively impossible for Americans to donate that way.

Even if that’s different now (which I’m not sure it is), there will always be the next important cause.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by robertAngst on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @06:21PM (#17454047)
It avoids USD as currency.

The government will keep printing more USD and being opaque...

BTC has 21,000,000 solutions ever ever ever.

(and USD is a decent currency, there are countries with hyperinflation)

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by bigphishy on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @12:04AM (#17455199)
This is a great point thanks for making it. imho it could be worded better, but it subtaintially invalidates the arguments like "bitcoin can only be used to waste energy and buy buy drugs"
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by wpietri on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @10:06AM (#17457326)
There's no actual user value involved. "Avoids USD" is almost a religious statement. If one is concerned about volatility, then Bitcoin is a bad choice; it's more volatile than any major currency and most commodities. If one is concerned about the US government's future behavior, there are other major currencies. (And really, a currency is a bad place to park your wealth.) For any legitimate financial aim, there's a better solution than Bitcoin.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by bb88 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @07:27PM (#17454358)
> Bitcoin's main demonstrated value is as a speculative instrument.

I think it's primary value is for money laundering and hiding money transfers from the eyes of jealous lovers / spouses / governments.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by wpietri on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:28PM (#17455105)
Yeah, if you don't count speculation as value (and I'm happy not to), then I think light financial crime is the next biggest use case. Which is interesting in that a lot of money laundering is illegal because although it may be valuable to the launderer, the cash transfered often comes from something where systemic value is dropping. E.g. ransomware only makes the world worse, even if it makes the ransomer a profit.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by soundwave106 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @04:29PM (#17453398)
Doing anything of value requires expending of energy, but the way cryptocurrency is right now seems to encourage... inefficiencies.

That farmer driving the tractor down the field using energy in the form of oil is typically massively more productive than the manual pea patch laborer or even the era where "working animals" were helping with a lot of the farm work. Sure, the tractor using energy, but the tractor farmer is overall way more efficient.

It would be interesting to see how crypto's cost per unit compares with a relatively energy inefficient way of monetizing, paper currency and coins. Due to the various costs involved in manufacturing and distributing a coin or bill, I really can't say whether it's more efficient or less (and Google's not helping me here). What I think is fairly obvious is that most electronic cash systems do not have this initial upfront massive energy requirement crypto has, so best guess is from a resource perspective crypto is quite a bit less efficient than most electronic cash systems.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by s73v3r_ on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @03:58PM (#17453187)
"Doing anything of value requires expending of energy and producing heat, this is unavoidable."

I think the point is that cryptocurrency mining is not valuable, at least not compared to the amount of resources required for it.

"Saying that this activity is pointless just because you are not seeing any value does not mean that it is actually pointless."

It also doesn't mean that it's not pointless.

"If anything we should welcome higher and higher energy use because it means higher standard of living for the humankind."

No. That does not logically follow.

"And just to address 'waste' here, energy is not free so 'waste' that actually wastes resources cannot go on for long lest the waster goes bankrupt."

This also does not logically follow.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by apr on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @04:10PM (#17453276)
How would you value mining? What's the figure you'd assign to it? As the activity it is certainly valuable to ensure the validity of the blockchain. In my mind that's the function of the market to assign value. Of course with the technology being so new we can expect fluctuations, but I think eventually it'll settle down to some stable level that is acceptable to all market participants.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by s73v3r_ on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @05:03PM (#17453605)
"As the activity it is certainly valuable to ensure the validity of the blockchain."

Not at the cost that it currently takes. Personally, I ascribe far, far, far less value (if any) to any cryptocurrency mining compared to using the energy for other stuff, or not using it (and not having the mark up on graphics cards).

"but I think eventually it'll settle down to some stable level that is acceptable to all market participants."

The "market participants" would only be those mining crypto, though.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by apr on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @05:29PM (#17453745)
Ah, but "personally" is the operative word here, other people obviously disagree.

> The "market participants" would only be those mining crypto, though.

Not only them. All people who would use bitcoin in some capacity and benefit from it, they all would be participants in that market. Miners could not exists without them, in the end of the day they get their pay from packing transactions into blocks, no transactions - no pay.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by s73v3r_ on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @07:30PM (#17454378)
Except this stuff doesn't happen in a vacuum. Them deciding to waste a whole bunch of energy on something like cryptocurrency has very real effects on everyone else.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by jacobush on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @08:11PM (#17454533)
Ah, but you see their right to do what they want with what they own is holy you see. Can't touch that. That would be blasphemy, which is punishable with spending more of your tax dollars lobbying for stronger property rights and the state machinery to back it up.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by throwaway37585 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @05:57PM (#17453892)
> Not at the cost that it currently takes. Personally, I ascribe...

Based on what? And if people aren't getting value from using the blockchain, why are they using it?

> far, far, far less value (if any)

Can you put a number on that, and justify it?

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by lmm on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @05:39AM (#17456200)
> Based on what? And if people aren't getting value from using the blockchain, why are they using it?

It creates value for individuals at a bigger cost to society - a classic negative externality. Making drug dealing easier is immensely profitable and that's where all blockchain profits eventually come from - everything else is a smokescreen of intermediaries to create just enough deniability to let respectable business participate in the drug trade. It's just like outsourcing manufacturing to countries with lower environmental standards to profit from pollution (another example of something that's negative-value overall, but positive-value for the individual engaging in it).

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by throwaway37585 on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @08:31AM (#17456857)
> It creates value for individuals at a bigger cost to society - a classic negative externality.

In what way?

> Making drug dealing easier is immensely profitable and that's where all blockchain profits eventually come from

Do you have a source for this, or is this just what you believe?

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by lmm on Thursday July 05, 2018 @04:31AM (#17461701)
> In what way?

Suppressing the drug trade is evidently something that society puts a high value on, given how much society spends on it.

> Do you have a source for this, or is this just what you believe?

Just looking at the whole blockchain ecosystem as a black box: any profit has to eventually come from outside, the rest is just moving that around. Speculators can move value around but aren't creating it. So who are the people getting something actually valuable in the real world from blockchain? I mean sure there's a bit of money laundering and evading capital controls, but the big one is drug dealing.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by s73v3r_ on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @07:32PM (#17454384)
"Based on what? And if people aren't getting value from using the blockchain, why are they using it?"

You're assuming rationality. You're also assuming they're actually paying for the electricity. And you're forgetting that they're not paying for the negative externalities of their energy waste.

"Can you put a number on that, and justify it?"

Take the smallest number you can think of. Now, take a number smaller than that.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by throwaway37585 on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @12:09AM (#17455215)
> You're assuming rationality.

Then explain why the people using bitcoin are being irrational. Are the miners processing transactions and receiving fees in return being irrational? Are the people using bitcoin to send and receive funds being irrational? Please enlighten us (and them, apparently).

> You're also assuming they're actually paying for the electricity.

They are.

> And you're forgetting that they're not paying for the negative externalities of their energy waste.

Classic case of moving the goalposts. The same applies to any economic activity requiring the use of electricity.

> Take the smallest number you can think of. Now, take a number smaller than that.

Dodging the question, I see.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by chris_mc on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @02:25PM (#17452559)
>anything of value

Bitcoin's value (not price, mind you) is still very questionable.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by PerryCox on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @03:08PM (#17452855)
Even it's price is questionable. :P
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by apr on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @04:07PM (#17453261)
And that is totally allright. Question it all you want, that's what the market is for.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by robertAngst on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @06:23PM (#17454068)
There are 21,000,000 bitcoin ever ever ever.

If you can see that, you can begin to exclude yourself from fiat money which requires centralized control of currency.

I trust rare numbers more than I trust the United States government.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by roryisok on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @06:55PM (#17454218)
> I trust rare numbers more than I trust the United States government

That's such a silly statement. Rare numbers do not control the value of bitcoin, the market does. Your rare number might be worth half what it was in December 2017, and twice what it was a year before that. Tomorrow it might be worth nothing. Or $1000. Or $1. The rareness of the number is about as relevant as the colour of the dollar

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by drngdds on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @10:49PM (#17454989)
I don't. Do you really want to rely on a currency whose value fluctuates as wildly as Bitcoin's? I like knowing that the $X deposited in my bank account a few days ago will have approximately the same value in a few months or years.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by throwawayqdhd on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @03:13AM (#17455717)
This is pretty much the same attitude that will keep Bitcoin out of the mainstream.

Statements like that make Bitcoiners come across as digital survivalists, the internet equivalent of redneck militia.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by mikekchar on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @09:28PM (#17454764)
I'm going to play devil's advocate here. I know what you are saying and in general it's hard to argue against it. However, I've personally seen an improvement in my well being at the same time as I've reduced what most people would consider my "standard of living".

I used to have a 3000 sq ft house, a car, a job I spent 3 hours a day commuting to in my car, every labour saving gadget you can think of, climate controlled everything, etc. I even drove to the laundromat frequently to pay someone to do my laundry because I was too busy to do it myself.

Now, I live in a small apartment in the country side, generally only minimally heat and do not cool my apartment (temp ranges from 5C to 35C during the year), I work from home, do not drive, eat seasonal, local food, preserve my own food, etc. Admittedly I got married and my wife does the laundry :-P. The improvement in my life is like night and day.

Like I say, I'm playing devil's advocate and I don't really imagine that everybody would be happy with my lifestyle. However, I really do think that the assumption that more insulation from the reality of nature is not necessarily a "higher standard of living". For me, especially, it's quite the opposite -- which would have been very surprising to the younger version of myself.

Even economically, the modern world is moving inexorably towards a place where "labour" refers to mental labour, not physical labour. For people who frequent HN, I think it's kind of assumed that this all right and proper. However, when I was teaching English in the rural high school in Japan where I now live, most of my students wanted to be fishermen or farmers. But they know that this is the way to eternal poverty. You can't realistically make a living doing that kind of thing. They end up working unhappily in a factory.

As we've fuelled the increased standard of living by reducing prices for necessities, we've created a world where everything needs to be a massive enterprise with high volumes and super low margins. Even the other day I was joking with my wife that I will quit my current job as a programmer and open a shop making artisanal cheese. "How many cheeses do you think you'll have to make in a year?", she asked. "Only about 20,000 I think" was my reply. Again, in my rural Japanese town, only 20 years ago you would have found a tofu maker, a miso maker, a sake brewery, 4 or 5 fruit and veg stores all drawing from the produce of the local area. And while the JA (national food distributor) is great about prioritising local food distribution, gone are the days where you can set up a shop or produce a product for just your local area.

It's the ubiquitous cheap energy that enables this increase in scale. It expands deliverability (I can mail order low temp pasturised milk from 3 prefectures over and have it delivered in a refrigerated truck o_O). It allows super efficient, mega scale operations from far away to under cut local, high labour intensive operations and reduces prices. In may ways it's amazing.

But, I'm not sure "increased standard of living" is actually the best term for it.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by lmm on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @05:32AM (#17456169)
Commuting is pure misery, especially driving, and people tend to underestimate the effect of that. Avoiding a 3 hours/day commute is more than enough to explain why you'd be much happier/healthier/... even if everything else in your life had gone downhill. (A happy marriage is also a well-known source of happiness/contentment/etc.). I don't think the change in your wellbeing has anything to do with local cheeses or lack of temperature control or anything like that; if you'd switched to working from home and married but stayed in your climate-controlled big house you'd see the same improvement, maybe even a bigger one.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by roryisok on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @09:14AM (#17457075)
Eliminating a 3 hour commute every day would constitute a fairly considerable drop in energy usage
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by lmm on Thursday July 05, 2018 @04:34AM (#17461716)
Yeah. It's possible to use energy badly, so human value is something more subtle and detailed than energy usage. I do think it works as a crude proxy though.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by viburnum on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @10:10PM (#17454880)
It is pointless.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by throwaway37585 on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @12:48AM (#17455333)
If it is pointless, why do people use it?
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by coralreef on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @02:05PM (#17452391)
Heat pollution is something to worry about, as is the material construction of electronics/chipsets due to crypto mining.

However, one side effect of this is that increasing demand for clean, cheap electricity is a good thing. Miners are basically subsidizing the development of eco-friendly energy infrastructure which ends up being good for everyone.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by jacobush on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @02:13PM (#17452459)
Which MIGHT end up being good for everyone.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by coralreef on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @02:32PM (#17452618)
What would be the downsides of cheap, eco-friendly energy?
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by LeoPanthera on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @02:43PM (#17452697)
High demand for electricity may increase the price of energy as a whole, which may make the production of electricity from fossil fuels profitable enough to expand.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by sirsar on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @02:54PM (#17452763)
See Jevons paradox, where increasing coal-efficiency counterintuitively increased coal usage and pollution:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by jacobush on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @07:55PM (#17454478)
What are you going to use it for, if it's all dumped into the jaws of Mammon, quite literally, just to uphold status quo. (Mining.)
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by Applejinx on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @03:57PM (#17453185)
I agree. The big change in bitcoin is that it is a way to literally change energy into capital without doing a damn thing in any other way, or benefiting any human being, or anything else on the planet.

It's literally waste heat from conversion of energy that could do some good, into numbers controlled by rich people. We might do better to just say outright 'all rich people, you now have twice as much money just for being you' and use the energy elsewhere… or use less and avoid cooking the planet.

In practice this is a dumb, bad idea even if you stand to benefit.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by heptathorp on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @04:20PM (#17453331)
Why does it only benefit rich people?
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by throwaway37585 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @06:00PM (#17453912)
> or benefiting any human being

If bitcoin isn't benefiting any human being, why are so many human beings using it?

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by ux-app on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @10:25PM (#17454922)
>why are so many human beings using it?

honest question: isn't crypto currency a closed system of speculators selling to speculators? From the outside, to me at least, it seems like an incredibly energy hungry ponzi scheme designed around printing monopoly money using ultra rare deep sea squid ink.

So are people using it for any purpose other than to sell it to the next rube?

All honest questions. I really don't know of any economically useful way that crypto currency is currently used for.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by throwawayqdhd on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @03:17AM (#17455731)
Another problem I have with crypto is how elitist it all is, especially for an instrument with rather libertarian, even anarchist roots.

Mining BTC requires exceptional investment, which basically makes it feasible only for the rich.

Understanding BTC requires technical knowledge 99% of the world does not have.

Heck, with all the regulatory hurdles, even using BTC requires more effort than most people have the time to expend.

(Yes, you can transfer BTC from one wallet to another fairly easily. But turning that BTC into actually useful local currency can be ridiculously complicated, depending on your local laws.)

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by roryisok on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:06PM (#17455034)
I've never heard crypto summed up so well
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by throwaway37585 on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @12:06AM (#17455209)
On what basis do you claim this? Personal speculation?

To speak plainly, I highly doubt you believe what you're claiming to believe (that cryptocurrecy is being used solely for speculation), which leaves dishonest rhetoric as the only alternative.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by ux-app on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @01:04AM (#17455361)
>which leaves dishonest rhetoric as the only alternative.

not at all. These were honest questions. I don't personally closely follow crypto, and outside of the occasional web anecdote of "there was some guy somewhere who once paid for pizza with btc" I've not seen or heard of the currency used for practical purposes.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by mikec3010 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @05:07PM (#17453634)
> waste trillions of CPU cycles so that we can produce digital money

Point-of-sale systems have been doing this for 15-ish years (in the US). We found value in that over using cash, and now many are finding value in blockchain over banks.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by Sol- on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @05:10PM (#17453646)
Point-of-sale is pretty trivial computation and costs very little energy. Its value was also obvious.

>now many are finding value in blockchain over banks

Debatable, people are using it for speculation, yes. But 90% of the people hyping blockchain probably don't even know what specific problem it solves and when this trustless model is even useful. It usually doesn't hold up to closer inspection.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by mikec3010 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @06:10PM (#17453972)
Each unit is roughly the equivalent of an i960 risc system with cpu ram and a display running 24/7 powered by a heat-generating wall wart. Not even counting the network equipment, before broadband many gas stations had satellite uplinks. Multiply that millions of times and the power consumption adds up.

Bitcoin speculators have profited from bitcoin, just like ACH industry investors and executives profited from $0.50 per transaction ACH fees. The only difference I see is bitcoin hasn't driven up the cost of goods for everyone.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by paulmd on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @04:42AM (#17456026)
Bitcoin doesn't avoid the need for point-of-sale systems any more than Apple Pay does. We still need something to ring up your order, even if you can pay from your phone.

So to be clear, we still need the POS systems plus we would also need the computers doing a meaningless busy-work math problem to generate the blockchain.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by TangoTrotFox on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @02:27PM (#17452580)
Crypto in the longrun could create a world where people could instantly, anonymously, and freely exchange currency with one another. Imagine how liberating that would be for the world as a whole. Companies deciding to outsource various jobs to India really helped revolutionize their economy. The internet along with cryptocurrencies would take this corporate level development down to the individual. Think about mutually beneficial exchanges like tutoring. You want to hire a mathematics tutor for somebody. Somebody in e.g. the Philippines who has excellent English and Math skills wants to sell their service as a tutor at a rate that would be extremely desirable relative to western incomes but also extremely desirable relative to his locale's average incomes. Right now even if these people are able to connect, working out how to actually pay each other is very awkward.

Cryptos could remove all barriers to entry for inter-personal financial exchange. This is something we take for granted, without realizing how much such barriers are really holding us all back. Or maybe we do realize it, but imagine these are necessary obstacles. Think of the, what now probably numbers in the dozens of, different payment platforms people jump through just to try to be able to give their money to people who they want to give it to (and all the new tertiary problems those said platforms then introduce into the process). It's really quite remarkably how backwards our global financial capabilities truly are.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by throwawayqdhd on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @03:19AM (#17455740)
> Right now even if these people are able to connect, working out how to actually pay each other is very awkward

I'm one of those people. Paying me is honestly pretty damn trivial and a solved problem.

Heck, I've hired people in the US and paid them online right from my bank's interface.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by hcs on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @07:13PM (#17454295)
Isn't this article precisely about using the infrastructure for crypto mining for more practical computing?
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by roryisok on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @07:16PM (#17454308)
Yes, after bitcoin stops being profitable to mine. After we've pumped a few billion more tons of carbon into the air in the name of blockchain. And assuming of course that some newer crypto doesn't take bitcoin's place which it almost certainly will
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by cup-of-tea on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @02:53AM (#17455659)
There is just as much waste in the finance industry. It's strange that we can't seem to do money without using an incredible amount of energy.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by deltateam on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @02:34AM (#17455614)
input "article about recycling bitcoin mining infrastructure"

output "sound bite about bitcoin mining energy use unrelated to the article"

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by henryw on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @03:28PM (#17452974)
I also wonder why are humans wasting resource like this. Like all this compute power could be used towards curing cancer or something.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by ozmbie on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @06:37PM (#17454145)
People mine bitcoin because there are millions of dollars per day of bitcoin rewards available.

I would guess that collectively, millions of dollars are being spent each day on cancer research around the world.

These mining farms were built for a purpose. It’s not like all these spare ASICs were laying around waiting for somebody to find a use for them. The people running these farms would be on some other venture if cryptocurrency was never invented. And those ventures probably wouldn’t involve curing cancer either.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by jacobush on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @08:13PM (#17454539)
No, but it would not probably involve installing large space heaters for the crows.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by roryisok on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @07:11PM (#17454288)
Greed is usually the answer. Cancer research doesn't pay. Bitcoin does. If someone could just harness one to do the other. If there was a crypto currency whose calculations helped to cure cancer then we'd be on to something
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by GW150914 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @03:32PM (#17453003)
People as a group are selfish and short sighted, prone to maximizing personal gain. Individuals can be self sacrificing and possess a long view, but there will be a thousand others willing to work the system to death in their place. More specifically, there are almost limitless rationales to be employed if you stand to gain from turning entropy into personal wealth. “This compute power was never going to be used to cure cancer anyway...” that kind of thing.

More pernicious are people who cloak themselves in ideology or Utopianism somthst they convince themselves that this waste of resources is a good thing. Some may even believe it, but most just don’t care and are too busy finding greater fools so they can make money.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by Applejinx on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @04:02PM (#17453217)
Bitcoin is created through the use of exponentially increasing amounts of energy (I daresay there's a 'crash' scenario where it doesn't expand that way and also doesn't retain value as currently expected).

Bitcoin is VALUED in a way similar to the stock market, where people collectively decide it's super good and useful because they're invested into the system. This process is exploitable, and is purely social engineering.

If it gets too big to fail, we're all in bad trouble, but we were already in trouble from many other things that have financially become too big to fail.