News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by s73v3r_ on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @05:03PM (#17453605)
"As the activity it is certainly valuable to ensure the validity of the blockchain."

Not at the cost that it currently takes. Personally, I ascribe far, far, far less value (if any) to any cryptocurrency mining compared to using the energy for other stuff, or not using it (and not having the mark up on graphics cards).

"but I think eventually it'll settle down to some stable level that is acceptable to all market participants."

The "market participants" would only be those mining crypto, though.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by apr on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @05:29PM (#17453745)
Ah, but "personally" is the operative word here, other people obviously disagree.

> The "market participants" would only be those mining crypto, though.

Not only them. All people who would use bitcoin in some capacity and benefit from it, they all would be participants in that market. Miners could not exists without them, in the end of the day they get their pay from packing transactions into blocks, no transactions - no pay.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by s73v3r_ on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @07:30PM (#17454378)
Except this stuff doesn't happen in a vacuum. Them deciding to waste a whole bunch of energy on something like cryptocurrency has very real effects on everyone else.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by jacobush on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @08:11PM (#17454533)
Ah, but you see their right to do what they want with what they own is holy you see. Can't touch that. That would be blasphemy, which is punishable with spending more of your tax dollars lobbying for stronger property rights and the state machinery to back it up.
Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by throwaway37585 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @05:57PM (#17453892)
> Not at the cost that it currently takes. Personally, I ascribe...

Based on what? And if people aren't getting value from using the blockchain, why are they using it?

> far, far, far less value (if any)

Can you put a number on that, and justify it?

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by lmm on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @05:39AM (#17456200)
> Based on what? And if people aren't getting value from using the blockchain, why are they using it?

It creates value for individuals at a bigger cost to society - a classic negative externality. Making drug dealing easier is immensely profitable and that's where all blockchain profits eventually come from - everything else is a smokescreen of intermediaries to create just enough deniability to let respectable business participate in the drug trade. It's just like outsourcing manufacturing to countries with lower environmental standards to profit from pollution (another example of something that's negative-value overall, but positive-value for the individual engaging in it).

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by throwaway37585 on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @08:31AM (#17456857)
> It creates value for individuals at a bigger cost to society - a classic negative externality.

In what way?

> Making drug dealing easier is immensely profitable and that's where all blockchain profits eventually come from

Do you have a source for this, or is this just what you believe?

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by lmm on Thursday July 05, 2018 @04:31AM (#17461701)
> In what way?

Suppressing the drug trade is evidently something that society puts a high value on, given how much society spends on it.

> Do you have a source for this, or is this just what you believe?

Just looking at the whole blockchain ecosystem as a black box: any profit has to eventually come from outside, the rest is just moving that around. Speculators can move value around but aren't creating it. So who are the people getting something actually valuable in the real world from blockchain? I mean sure there's a bit of money laundering and evading capital controls, but the big one is drug dealing.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by s73v3r_ on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @07:32PM (#17454384)
"Based on what? And if people aren't getting value from using the blockchain, why are they using it?"

You're assuming rationality. You're also assuming they're actually paying for the electricity. And you're forgetting that they're not paying for the negative externalities of their energy waste.

"Can you put a number on that, and justify it?"

Take the smallest number you can think of. Now, take a number smaller than that.

Re:Extreme Bitcoin Mining Aids an Unexpected Revolution in I... by throwaway37585 on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @12:09AM (#17455215)
> You're assuming rationality.

Then explain why the people using bitcoin are being irrational. Are the miners processing transactions and receiving fees in return being irrational? Are the people using bitcoin to send and receive funds being irrational? Please enlighten us (and them, apparently).

> You're also assuming they're actually paying for the electricity.

They are.

> And you're forgetting that they're not paying for the negative externalities of their energy waste.

Classic case of moving the goalposts. The same applies to any economic activity requiring the use of electricity.

> Take the smallest number you can think of. Now, take a number smaller than that.

Dodging the question, I see.