News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by pimmen on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @10:28AM (#17450437)
In Sweden we removed the property tax completely which has shaped our housing market a lot. People over consume living area and use their homes as retirements savings since it’s dift cheap to sit on it, contributing to the housing crisis we’ve had for the past decade.
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by virmundi on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @10:40AM (#17450564)
Here's a counter-argument. Keeping property taxes means that old people have to pay yearly rent to the government to simply keep their house. In Florida that's about 2k a year for my home. That's fine when we have an income. It's a bit more problematic when that's 10-20% of a yearly retirement income from which one also has to pay for necessities.

As to the housing crisis, what laws are preventing multistory buildings? SF blocks a lot of housing over 3 stories since they want to keep the mystique of the city from the Full House days (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Full_House). This makes housing extremely expensive since no one can easily put up a 50 story luxury housing apartment complex (which could have 1.5k sq/ft for a mere $675k).

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by usaar333 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:08AM (#17450811)
> Keeping property taxes means that old people have to pay yearly rent to the government to simply keep their house. In Florida that's about 2k a year for my home.

I don't see why, at least in an area with any sort of constrained land supply, it is desired to keep old people in the same home (I can see same community, not same home).

From a land efficiency standpoint, where single family homes and apartments/condos both exist, you'd generally want to incentivize:

* childless folks (young people, empty nesters) in smaller homes (apartments, condos)

* families with children in larger homes (single family homes)

Property taxes are a powerful incentive to encourage people that become empty nesters to move to smaller locations. The lack of incentive to do this is part of why Bay Area single family home prices are surging - older demographics aren't selling their homes to families that really want to own for stability reasons.

(note: For the curious, in CA, Prop 13 doesn't per se create a disincentive as it allows moving the tax base to a new property for those older than 55 - but its presence removes what would be a strong incentive (cut taxes by moving). A strong tax disincentive to move though is capital gains tax structure on housing).

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by clarkmoody on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:22AM (#17450909)
Maybe you should let people decide for themselves where they want to live?
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by usaar333 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:12PM (#17451353)
Can you expand? All taxes are distortionary.. the tax system always creates some incentive that wouldn't be there without the tax. Might as well make it a good one.
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by toasterlovin on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @12:39AM (#17455302)
I’m all for that, as long as everybody is paying a fair amount of property taxes. In California, you can have two identical houses next to each other and the person who bought 40 years ago may be contributing to funding local government at < 1/10th the level of the person next door who bought last year.
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by virmundi on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:42AM (#17451094)
No, we cannot allow that. We have to allow the state to have absolute power to make poor decisions and then force everyone to conform to those poor decisions.

Look at SF. The right answer is to for old people that bought into the town during the Haight-Ashbury days to sell since they are too cash poor for the rents (property tax). The wrong decision is to change the zoning laws that prevent 5+ story apartment buildings that meet earthquake code.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by usaar333 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:19PM (#17451421)
Those are related things. A locality is more willing to solve a housing shortage if existing residents are also being punished for said shortage in the form of higher property taxes.
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by rayiner on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:14AM (#17450861)
> Here's a counter-argument. Keeping property taxes means that old people have to pay yearly rent to the government to simply keep their house.

So what? It's not like old people don't continue to use the roads, police services, etc. If they had kids, then they're also paying off what it cost to educate those kids (the property taxes they paid while their kids were in school covered only a fraction of the annual cost per student).

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by ahallock on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:23AM (#17450919)
Why can't other taxes pay for that? There are surely plenty of other tax revenue streams. My parents, who were on a fixed income, had to move from upstate NY in part because of property tax increases. You never truly get to own your house and are instead renting from the government.
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by rayiner on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:46AM (#17451132)
You're not "renting" from the government. You're paying for the ongoing services you use, which are connected to your property (roads, police protection, etc.). As to having other taxes pay for it--that just shifts the tax burden onto other people.
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by ahallock on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @01:17PM (#17451962)
The road to our house was awful and in disrepair. The plowing was decent, I'll give them that. I know your answer: we need yet more taxes. It couldn't be that these taxes enable all sorts of non-essential and wasteful programs, while what's truly essential gets neglected. Do we really need all those cops setting up speed traps and fleecing drivers? Or all the cops looking to catch someone growing a plant on their property? That's the only time the police ever came to our property, to look for suspicious plants. Would people really pay for that or consider that an essential service if they weren't forced?
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by wedn3sday on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @04:05PM (#17453245)
You like having phone lines right? and power? and not being invaded by canada? The reason you've never needed to have police on your property is in large part because they're doing a good job and keeping crime down. Yes, the government is giant and stupid at allocating resources, but its also fairly stable and allows you to live your life in peace (with the occasional inspection for naughty plants).
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by supertrope on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:46AM (#17451134)
Like income and sales tax? States with no income tax tend to have higher property and sales tax, and vice versa.

Or did you mean, why can't other people pay for that?

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by virmundi on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:20AM (#17450899)
There are other ways to tax for that. I pay for garbage and water, both provided by the city. I pay for $133/year for fire and police as a separate tax item. I pay a 1% sales tax for all non-food items to pay for roads. I also pay property tax. Itemize a tax. Don't have a property tax.

I could happily do without all those things. Create a free-living zone where I could move with little tax. https://la.curbed.com/2015/3/13/9980908/slab-city-going-legi...

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by seanalltogether on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:15PM (#17451376)
Where I live in the UK you pay a council tax as the resident of a home, instead of a property tax on the value of the property. It's an itemized tax like you describe. Do you want to know why? Because rich people owned huge swaths of land and wanted to sit on it forever without any pressure to sell.

Land is a finite resource and we should absolutely make ownership of it subject to tax.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by zpallin on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @10:55AM (#17450693)
But maybe old people shouldn't be living alone in a giant house. Maybe we need to establish rules where their children - or a community - are more incentivised to take care of the elderly than the elderly are incentivised to isolate themselves in a home they will be increasingly unable to take care of...
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by cletus on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @10:48AM (#17450628)
It's this kind of nonsense that allowed abominations like Prop 13 in CA to pass.

This particular fallacy is a classic false dichotomy. It's not an either-or situation. In CA the incumbents voted themselves a massive tax break ("because retirees") when, if retirees were something you really cared about, you could simply give them a lower rate of tax or no tax at all for their principal place of residence while still collecting taxes from non-retirees.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by drewg123 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:07AM (#17450808)
This 100%

I was disappointed they didn't have photos of row after row of poorly maintained multi-million dollar single-story ranch houses in the Bay Area. My old neighborhood in Mountain View was filled with retirees who were paying next to nothing to stay in the houses they bought in the 60s and 70s. These were the same people who would regularly vote against new housing because it "harmed the quality of the neighborhood." Every time I walked to work, I day-dreamed of how many people could live close enough to walk to work if we could put a 10 story apartment building over each of those junky old Eichlers.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by virmundi on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:16AM (#17450872)
Then you're showing a lot of favoritism. It's hard to universalize the idea that we should show favoritism. For example, historically we favored handicapped people. This was to their detriment. We paid for their subsistence living since we excluded them from having real jobs.

It's not a fallacy if you think people own land. They shouldn't have to pay a yearly fee to keep the government from taking their property. Think about applying the same thing to laptops. Laptops are tools, or at least may be tools, for production and income. Why not tax all laptops owned by software folk as we tax other business goods?

In general, this argument seems to come down to "the society provides so much, pay your damn share." How about no, I don't want the society to pay for so much? As a result, I want to pay less.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by mikeash on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:25AM (#17450939)
Laptops don’t require road maintenance, emergency services, schools, etc. Real estate does.

If you don’t want society to pay for so much, maybe move to somewhere without one. Most of us want to live in a place where we all pitch in to help provide public services.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by virmundi on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:46AM (#17451128)
While most want to live in a society that provides some base level of features, we have huge difference of opinion of what that is.

For example, police. If you legalized all drugs, you'd not need as many as you have. You could save money by not having their salaries, pensions, and benefits. You could also increase revenue by having reasonable taxes on the sale of the vice. Now you don't need to take land from people.

My whole point in all of this is that property taxes are not necessary. Rather they are used by people that don't want to think about ways to truly free their society. Those people limit building heights. They limit trade. They limit the very means that a state could make a reasonable income.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by mikeash on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:57AM (#17451222)
No individual tax is necessary, but if you agree that government funding is needed then it’s just a question of what you tax. I don’t see why property tax should be singled out as being particularly bad, and the argument you’re making seems to be more like “I don’t want to pay so much” rather than “property taxes are worse than these other taxes.”

Note than land value taxes, a special case of property taxes, are widely considered to be the most efficient means of taxation among economists.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by virmundi on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:17PM (#17451399)
The issue is you’re maintaining a tax on a purchase after it’s purchased. It’s perpetual sales tax. If we can tax in over ways, why create a specific instance for this kind of tax?
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by mikeash on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @08:46PM (#17460217)
Real estate is special in all sorts of legal and physical ways. I don't see why it’s weird that this would include taxes.
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by imh on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:50PM (#17451703)
Real estate doesn't require road maintenance, cars do. I agree that people have to pay the government to maintain these, but homes do remain relatively unique among people's possessions as a thing that you own, but have to pay ongoing taxes to keep owning. I don't think the reason why is as straightforward as "real estate needs roads/schools/etc"
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by mikeash on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @02:59PM (#17452798)
People require road maintenance, unless your population is completely immobile. Cars need more of it than other modes of transportation, but roads are necessary either way, to the point that there are a bunch do special cases in real estate laws dealing with access to roads.

Homes are relatively unique in being something you own and still have to pay taxes on. They’re also unique in being something whose ownership and location determines so much about your life, such as where you vote and who you vote for, whose taxes you pay (far beyond property taxes), where your children can go to school, which police department serves you, whose laws you have to follow... it seems reasonable that they would have a special tax status too.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by nimish on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @10:49AM (#17450641)
They can tap into the equity of their home to pay the taxes. Some jurisdictions allow for a property tax deferral until sale to avoid even this.

Property taxes fund the society they benefit from so it's only fair that they keep paying them.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by hadrian82 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:14AM (#17450859)
Yeah because who wants to keep the equity they build up while building the house and making it nice. As soon as it's paid off, let's take out a loan against it! That's the answer! "Tap" into the equity my ass, that line of thinking is the problem and why we are constantly over-spending as a civilization.

Property taxes means the government owns both your land and anything you have on it and you are merely renting from them. This is not OK in my opinion, and I believe all property taxes should be abolished as it requires people to continue paying rent to the government forever. My dad had to step in to prevent my 85 year old grandmother from being evicted and having her house auctioned off due to years of overdue property tax because (shocker) she didn't have any money. So let's evict this little old woman we should be taking care of and make them burdens on their families because her breadwinner spouse died years earlier and she couldn't afford to continue paying rent to the government who did nothing but bleed money from her and her husband their whole lives. Really considerate of us as a society. Luckily she had family to pick her up. What if she didn't.

I'm sorry but the government has done fuck all to make my land better other than be a pain in my ass when I want to make it better and force me to pay them in order to do any construction ON MY OWN.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by wedn3sday on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @04:12PM (#17453290)
> I'm sorry but the government has done fuck all to make my land better

You mean like stopping the chemical plant up the creek from dumping in your water supply? Or do you mean building the schools your children go to, or do you mean building the highways/ports that allowed your washing machine to be built/imported? Or by "fuck all" do you mean building the electricity grid and telecommunication infrastructure so you can sit in your living room and write nonsense on the internet?

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by usaar333 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:01PM (#17451259)
> government owns both your land

Yes, that's correct and why this is so controversial.

I believe society has a right to tax land, because owning a completely inelastic item like land prevents others from using it.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by logfromblammo on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @01:07PM (#17451880)
That's... the whole point of ownership. You can prevent all your neighbors from chopping down the nice shade tree in your front yard, and dragging it away for lumber or firewood.

The issue at hand is that if you do not pay property taxes, the government will take ownership of the land away from you. That undermines the ownership. (So does eminent domain and civil asset forfeiture.) The ability to keep out everybody except the government is still useful, but not nearly as valuable, since anyone that really wants to take something from you can just use the government to do it.

There are other sticks available to encourage people to contribute money to their communities. You could still assess someone's taxes based on the value of their land property, but rather than take the property, you cut off its access to municipality services. If you don't pay your vehicle tax, you don't lose your whole car, you just lose your license plate and the ability to drive your vehicle on public roads. Similarly, if you don't pay the property tax, maybe you lose the ability to connect to local utilities and make use of public services. Cops and firefighters charge fees to come to your property. Public schools charge your kids tuition to attend. Perhaps the city won't enforce street parking restrictions at the end of your driveway, and starts leaving the roadkill cleanup truck there. Or maybe the city just publishes a list of non-payers, and local businesses start refusing you service. Most critically, the local cops won't help you defend your property ownership.

The problem isn't that property taxes exist, it's what happens if you don't pay them. If the actual result for not paying property tax is identical to a landlord evicting a non-paying tenant, the actual relationship to the property is not ownership.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by nimish on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @03:04PM (#17452829)
That's an extreme interpretation of ownership, particularly of land, which is subject to the superior title of the government (eminent domain) anyway.

You choose to live in society you have to play by its rules. You have a vote as well, so it's not like you have no way to change things.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by logfromblammo on Thursday July 05, 2018 @11:37AM (#17464090)
Government only retains sovereign ownership for land in fee simple. Some property in the US is actually allodial--although enforcement generally treats it like fee simple anyway, and any attempt to assert the rights inherent in that form of title requires a lawyer, so only the rich can really take advantage of it.

Allodial title is a good thing. But the city still has to pay the bills.

The rule is that prudent management of the commons has a cost, and that cost must be paid. It is reasonable to divvy up the bill by the extent to which someone is likely to benefit from the commons. As it turns out, assessing local taxes based on the value of land property owned in the jurisdiction is a reasonable approximation, it turns the tax rolls into an easy correspondence with the plat maps and ownership records, and it is not very difficult to assess. It's fine to assess the tax based on value of owned property. My point is that the taxes should attach to the owner of record, and not the property itself. Indeed, the article details several unintended consequences from various methods of assessment.

It would also be reasonable to pay by a flat capitation, but that is a regressive tax in practice, despite being neutral in theory. Sales tax is more progressive, as the tax scales with the amount of money you can afford to spend. Income tax can also scale progressively, such that the people who can afford to pay more by virtue of higher incomes must do so. Those are all the responsibility of people. If they fail to pay, the punishment lands on them. And I think it is not proper to seize real property for debts that were unilaterally imposed on people without their explicit individual consent. Seize cash. Seize bank accounts. Seize stock certificates. Do not evict a family from their home. Do not take the vehicle they use to drive to work. And yet, those latter two are often the only asset classes subjected to property taxes.

I am already a bit hostile to eminent domain thanks to the Kelo v. New London case, which stretched the concept of "public use" beyond the point of reason. I vote my one vote as hard as I can, and yet society still remains unjust. This is a failure of society's rules. Those treated unfairly by them have always had the option to stop playing by that set of rules, and institute another that they find more suitable. You have no inherent obligation to a society that does not respect your contributions to it.

You have one vote. You also have one voice, that spreads based on the height of your soap box. You also have a wallet, which you can open or close based on the societal values behind those things you might wish to buy. And you have one clever ape brain, which has a built-in dislike of unfairness, and the ability to set goals and make plans.

It is reasonable that one might wish to protest the imprudent spending of municipal funds by refusing to pay tax? Or is it preferable that one pays the tax, as assessed and on time, and then assassinates the mayor and city council, because all other reasonable and effective means of protest have been rendered unusable? I would prefer that protest via withholding of material support remain a viable option.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @10:35AM (#17450506)
China lacks a property tax, which is a big reason for their huge housing bubble.
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by tryonqc on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @10:55AM (#17450699)
You are correct. China only tax when you sell / buy property. The porperty tax "reform" should be in place by the end of 2019 though.

I think house prices in china can't really be compared with other country for lots of reasons, eg: they don't own their homes (70y lease), very low interest on loans (1-2%), real estate is seen as a very good investment in china, etc.:)

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:09AM (#17450822)
The 70 year leases are probably going to be renewed very cheaply/easily as happened in Wenzhou when the middle class made a huge fuss over the early (shorter term) leases ending. The central government had to step in and make the local government renew them for basically nothing.

Also, China lacks very good investments (the stock market is still a joke), so real estate is seen as the only viable option to beat inflation. So even in hot markets like Beijing and Shanghai, lots of nice apartment buildings will have empty units, which are just being held as an asset and are not even renovated to be rented out.

China is not really that unique from other countries, it’s real estate market is quite expected considering the factors that created it.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by baybal2 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:38PM (#17451610)
Indeed, feel to be 1-to-1 parallel to property bubble in 200x Russia, except scaled to the size of China: Russian law effectively prevents people who can't pay for a personal financial lawyer to invest abroad, and for the short period of time the fun lasted people were investing in even crazier vanities than Chinese do now.

I believe that "you can't invest abroad unless you have money for a legal counsel" applies to a lot of countries.

Adding to you point on property taxes: Russian provinces with regional property taxes only saw, i think, 1/10th of the bubble in comparison to the rest of the country. At the time when an average private individual could buy 5 flats in 3 years in hopes of bubble growing faster than than interest on his loan, it will be pretty expensive to pay even 0.75% property tax, as it can easily be bigger than guy's annual income.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by fapjacks on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:11PM (#17451346)
It's important to state here that over-consumption of living space in Sweden means something almost completely different than what an American would think it means. Also, Swedish cities are small compared to American cities, but more dense, and of course more space-conscious in typical European style. Stockholm for example feels much more like Honolulu than Cincinnati. The Swedish housing crisis is basically that Swedes want to live close to the city center, and there simply aren't enough places to live there. If Swedes were willing to bear the burden of a typical American commute on their amazing public transit, nobody in the country would think there's a housing crisis. But there are other considerations at play, too, aren't there? For example, there's plenty of housing available in Kista...
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by pimmen on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @02:57PM (#17452783)
> But there are other considerations at play, too, aren't there?

Oh god, yes. The housing crisis is extremely complicated, what we see now in Sweden is the result of a perfect storm.

In the 90s Sweden had a surplus of houses from the 80s building craze and municipalities completely stopped building rentals. The municipalities in Sweden are extremely strong too and have a monopoly on what gets built on their land, and they don't want rentals they want expensive homes because expensive homes are inhabited by people paying good income taxes. So, they never took those plans for building new housing complexes off the shelves till very recently (but the municipalities still want expensive homes, especially in the bed communities outside Stockholm, Gothenburg and Malmö).

We've also had the start of the fourth baby boom very recently, that's put a lot of strain on our housing market. The kids from the third baby boom in the early 90s grew up to move out and they started getting their own babies. This is what happened in the mid to late 60s too with the people from the first baby boom during WWII grew up and Sweden launched the million program to cope (which the national government can't do this time with the current laws in place, it's up to the municipalities alone to predict this and solve it and they failed or didn't want to solve it).

In Sweden getting building permits is a very time consuming ordeal and can cost a lot in legal fees. Building in Stockholm is about twice the price of building in Berlin and will take about twice as long to negotiate with the local regulators.

We've had record immigration to the cities in recent years, some from foreign migrants but by far most of it has been internal migrants (since during most of this crisis municipalities could just say no to refugees and cite the housing crisis as a reason for it, which the big cities have taken advantage of multiple times. I grew up in one of the wealthiest parts of Sweden just outside Gothenburg, they've taken in a few hundred refugees since 2008 while tens of thousands of people have moved in from other parts of Sweden). This is also consistent with our previous history; in the 90s we had a very large immigration of refugees but the housing prices still took a dive.

And finally, this is just how Swedish culture has evolved and it's happened faster than we've had time to react. Compared to the rest of Europe, Sweden has an unusual amount of people living alone. We move out very early from our parents and divorce is uncomplicated here which instantly creates new demand for housing; where there was previously only demand for one home, now there is a demand for two.