News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by cletus on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @10:48AM (#17450628)
It's this kind of nonsense that allowed abominations like Prop 13 in CA to pass.

This particular fallacy is a classic false dichotomy. It's not an either-or situation. In CA the incumbents voted themselves a massive tax break ("because retirees") when, if retirees were something you really cared about, you could simply give them a lower rate of tax or no tax at all for their principal place of residence while still collecting taxes from non-retirees.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by drewg123 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:07AM (#17450808)
This 100%

I was disappointed they didn't have photos of row after row of poorly maintained multi-million dollar single-story ranch houses in the Bay Area. My old neighborhood in Mountain View was filled with retirees who were paying next to nothing to stay in the houses they bought in the 60s and 70s. These were the same people who would regularly vote against new housing because it "harmed the quality of the neighborhood." Every time I walked to work, I day-dreamed of how many people could live close enough to walk to work if we could put a 10 story apartment building over each of those junky old Eichlers.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by virmundi on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:16AM (#17450872)
Then you're showing a lot of favoritism. It's hard to universalize the idea that we should show favoritism. For example, historically we favored handicapped people. This was to their detriment. We paid for their subsistence living since we excluded them from having real jobs.

It's not a fallacy if you think people own land. They shouldn't have to pay a yearly fee to keep the government from taking their property. Think about applying the same thing to laptops. Laptops are tools, or at least may be tools, for production and income. Why not tax all laptops owned by software folk as we tax other business goods?

In general, this argument seems to come down to "the society provides so much, pay your damn share." How about no, I don't want the society to pay for so much? As a result, I want to pay less.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by mikeash on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:25AM (#17450939)
Laptops don’t require road maintenance, emergency services, schools, etc. Real estate does.

If you don’t want society to pay for so much, maybe move to somewhere without one. Most of us want to live in a place where we all pitch in to help provide public services.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by virmundi on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:46AM (#17451128)
While most want to live in a society that provides some base level of features, we have huge difference of opinion of what that is.

For example, police. If you legalized all drugs, you'd not need as many as you have. You could save money by not having their salaries, pensions, and benefits. You could also increase revenue by having reasonable taxes on the sale of the vice. Now you don't need to take land from people.

My whole point in all of this is that property taxes are not necessary. Rather they are used by people that don't want to think about ways to truly free their society. Those people limit building heights. They limit trade. They limit the very means that a state could make a reasonable income.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by mikeash on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:57AM (#17451222)
No individual tax is necessary, but if you agree that government funding is needed then it’s just a question of what you tax. I don’t see why property tax should be singled out as being particularly bad, and the argument you’re making seems to be more like “I don’t want to pay so much” rather than “property taxes are worse than these other taxes.”

Note than land value taxes, a special case of property taxes, are widely considered to be the most efficient means of taxation among economists.

Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by virmundi on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:17PM (#17451399)
The issue is you’re maintaining a tax on a purchase after it’s purchased. It’s perpetual sales tax. If we can tax in over ways, why create a specific instance for this kind of tax?
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by mikeash on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @08:46PM (#17460217)
Real estate is special in all sorts of legal and physical ways. I don't see why it’s weird that this would include taxes.
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by imh on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:50PM (#17451703)
Real estate doesn't require road maintenance, cars do. I agree that people have to pay the government to maintain these, but homes do remain relatively unique among people's possessions as a thing that you own, but have to pay ongoing taxes to keep owning. I don't think the reason why is as straightforward as "real estate needs roads/schools/etc"
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities by mikeash on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @02:59PM (#17452798)
People require road maintenance, unless your population is completely immobile. Cars need more of it than other modes of transportation, but roads are necessary either way, to the point that there are a bunch do special cases in real estate laws dealing with access to roads.

Homes are relatively unique in being something you own and still have to pay taxes on. They’re also unique in being something whose ownership and location determines so much about your life, such as where you vote and who you vote for, whose taxes you pay (far beyond property taxes), where your children can go to school, which police department serves you, whose laws you have to follow... it seems reasonable that they would have a special tax status too.