Why can't other taxes pay for that? There are surely plenty of other tax revenue streams. My parents, who were on a fixed income, had to move from upstate NY in part because of property tax increases. You never truly get to own your house and are instead renting from the government.
You're not "renting" from the government. You're paying for the ongoing services you use, which are connected to your property (roads, police protection, etc.). As to having other taxes pay for it--that just shifts the tax burden onto other people.
The road to our house was awful and in disrepair. The plowing was decent, I'll give them that. I know your answer: we need yet more taxes. It couldn't be that these taxes enable all sorts of non-essential and wasteful programs, while what's truly essential gets neglected. Do we really need all those cops setting up speed traps and fleecing drivers? Or all the cops looking to catch someone growing a plant on their property? That's the only time the police ever came to our property, to look for suspicious plants. Would people really pay for that or consider that an essential service if they weren't forced?
You like having phone lines right? and power? and not being invaded by canada? The reason you've never needed to have police on your property is in large part because they're doing a good job and keeping crime down. Yes, the government is giant and stupid at allocating resources, but its also fairly stable and allows you to live your life in peace (with the occasional inspection for naughty plants).
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities
by supertrope on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:46AM
(#17451134)
Like income and sales tax? States with no income tax tend to have higher property and sales tax, and vice versa.
Or did you mean, why can't other people pay for that?
There are other ways to tax for that. I pay for garbage and water, both provided by the city. I pay for $133/year for fire and police as a separate tax item. I pay a 1% sales tax for all non-food items to pay for roads. I also pay property tax. Itemize a tax. Don't have a property tax.
I could happily do without all those things. Create a free-living zone where I could move with little tax. https://la.curbed.com/2015/3/13/9980908/slab-city-going-legi...
Re:How Property Taxes Shape Our Cities
by seanalltogether on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:15PM
(#17451376)
Where I live in the UK you pay a council tax as the resident of a home, instead of a property tax on the value of the property. It's an itemized tax like you describe. Do you want to know why? Because rich people owned huge swaths of land and wanted to sit on it forever without any pressure to sell.
Land is a finite resource and we should absolutely make ownership of it subject to tax.
So what? It's not like old people don't continue to use the roads, police services, etc. If they had kids, then they're also paying off what it cost to educate those kids (the property taxes they paid while their kids were in school covered only a fraction of the annual cost per student).