News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by cletus on Thursday September 30, 2010 @04:21AM (#1742629)
One thing that doesn't make sense to me is that people are comparing the number of internet-connected devices to the size of the IPv4 address space, implying each device needs its own IPv4 address.

This is obviously not the case. NAT (Network Address Translation) techniques can hide thousands of devices behind one IP address. In fact, for security reasons, it's advisable to not have every device directly on the internet. I have an ADSL modem/router at home with NAT, which makes substandard firewall solutions as what is provided by Windows pretty much unnecessary.

So perhaps we simply need to reclaim large blocks (particularly those universities and companies that have large A blocks of ~16 million addresses) and save IP addresses for each machine for ISPs, servers and those that actually need them.

Of course that's hard to mandate but like many things you can solve it with market forces: charge people who have more than, say, 128 IP addresses on a scale such that the most economic thing to do is transition away from that and give up their addresses.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by loup-vaillant on Thursday September 30, 2010 @04:58AM (#1742697)
> implying each device needs its own IPv4 address.

This implication is basically correct, actually. Sure, not every machine needs to be a server, but every people should have at least one. Everyone should have his own mail server. Every blogger should have his own web server. And so on. It's just a matter of basic civil liberties, like privacy and free speech, which currently aren't fully enabled, because most people don't have the amount of control they should have.

If we let giant NAT routers spread further, such control will be effectively impossible. Even for computer nerds. Even for owners of a freedom box[1].

As a side note, the correct response for security is not using giant NAT routers. It's getting rid of Windows.

[1]: http://wiki.debian.org/FreedomBox

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by tptacek on Thursday September 30, 2010 @12:01PM (#1743695)
Why is a native IPv4 address a "basic civil liberty"? It's a technical detail. Surely the "liberty" is "first class citizen of the Internet", right? "The ability to publish content, the ability to build applications, the ability to pass traffic"?

If IP addresses were truly and in principle a right, then surely everyone would also be entitled to an ASN and the right to publish their IP address on the provider of their choosing. But they aren't; it costs hundreds of thousands of dollars to go from a standing start to default-less full peer.

Without peering, the IP address is just a totem. You think it matters, but it doesn't; you've simply been licensed to speak on the Internet by your ISP.

That doesn't really bother me, but it should bother you, if you take your principles seriously. IPv6 isn't going to solve that problem (IPv6 does not magically end BGP RIB bloat). But overlay networks, which don't care whether they're running on top of IPv4, CLNP, IPX, or IPv6, do solve it.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by loup-vaillant on Thursday September 30, 2010 @12:24PM (#1743790)
Well, actually, I do think that being your own ISP is very important, maybe even crucial. Alas, it's currently difficult, as more and more network providers don't want to peer with the small players.

I know nothing about overlay networks. I need to dig further before I update my beliefs.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by tptacek on Thursday September 30, 2010 @12:36PM (#1743848)
Realize that even in our bright and shiny IPv6 future, no top-tier provider is going to let you peer with them to publish your addresses. So long as routing is controlled by the majors, addresses are just totems.
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by jodrellblank on Thursday September 30, 2010 @03:09PM (#1744427)
Everyone should have his own mail server. Every blogger should have his own web server. And so on.

I want that about as much as I want my own personal DVD press, oil well, glass factory, operating theatre, coffee bean plantation and lawyer. (Although if my own mail server was as profitable as my own oil well, maybe...).

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by loupgarou21 on Thursday September 30, 2010 @09:28AM (#1743169)
You can running multiple web and mail servers behind a single IP address. I personally am not doing this though because I have 5 IP addresses allocated to me, so I take advantage of them.
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by loup-vaillant on Thursday September 30, 2010 @10:28AM (#1743344)
Yes you can, but if you don't have a public IP yourself, you have to find someone willing to share his own (supposing IP already ran out). Most likely, you'd have to trust him. So for maximum independence, you need to have your own IP.

I reckon relying on a friend is very close to ideal. But not strictly so.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by trezor on Friday October 01, 2010 @02:57AM (#1746285)
As a side note, the correct response for security is not using giant NAT routers. It's getting rid of Windows.

For an otherwise reasonable comment, I have to say: What a load of bull.

The only machine I have ever gotten hacked was a Linux machine, since practically all attacks flowing on the net are Linux attacks.

I run a mixed environment of Windows and Linux and have zero issues, despite my entire LAN being exposed to the internet via IPv6 (obviously firewalled though).

Windows itself isn't insecure. It's a very nice and secure platform. Locked down, there are no problems at all. Users aer insecure. They are the problem.

If Linux had near the same marketshare as Windows, they would require access to install whatever new and fancy thing which came around, would have to be locked up, and voila, Linux would be ridden with all the same problems Windows have now.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by nileshtrivedi on Thursday September 30, 2010 @04:37AM (#1742665)
I think the article made it clear that IPv4 is running out of addresses DESPITE using NAT heavily.

As far as reclaiming large A blocks is concerned, I read somewhere that we are exhausting addresses equivalent to an A-class block in 5 weeks. Easy to see that we are going to need a long-term solution anyhow.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by jodrellblank on Thursday September 30, 2010 @03:23PM (#1744472)
I linked this elsewhere, but you can see here: http://twitter.com/ipv4countdown from the history how fast they are being used up - a million every couple of days, or thereabouts.
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by LaGrange on Thursday September 30, 2010 @06:01AM (#1742780)
Actually, we still need external-to-internal connections (e.g. p2p file transfers, not only Bittorrent, but also IM file transfer, VoIP, game servers and so on) so the NAT gets punched through routinely.

The security isn't really provided by NAT, it's provided by the firewall; yes, a stateful protecting the entire end-user network is desirable, but NAT isn't really required for that to function effectively.

Even security-by-obscurity in case of a NAT router is doubtful, unless it's fronting a relatively big network. For home networks, the address of the network is identifying enough. By monitoring traffic you can even guess how big the network is.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by BerislavLopac on Thursday September 30, 2010 @06:22AM (#1742822)
Actually, that is the reason why the conversion to IPv6 has stalled for so long. Which is a bad thing, since for one, it's much simpler to set up networks if you don't have to worry about NATs, and second NAT make many of useful technologies (like some P2P applications much more difficult). And we shouldn't forget that IPv6 is not only about a larger address space; it brings many useful standards like mandatory network layer security, jumbograms etc.
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by draebek on Thursday September 30, 2010 @11:24AM (#1743549)
> it brings many useful standards like mandatory network layer security

Wikipedia and Google seem to confirm that IPsec is mandatory for IPv6 hosts, but how many hosts are really going to support it? I'm pretty sure I can turn on IPv6 on my Linux boxes a lot easier than I can turn on IPsec (step 1: figure out which implementation to install, step 2: figure out byzantine configurations, ...). I think my OS X box has IPv6 turned on out of the box, but I wasn't aware it'd do IPsec without being lovingly configured.

Like multicast and a better solution for portable IP space, I feel like mandatory IPsec will be just another purely theoretical benefit of IPv6. (Which is not to say that I'm not extremely interested in its highest profile promise: more address space.)

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by cletus on Thursday September 30, 2010 @09:08AM (#1743112)
But my point is that the safest thing for most end-devices is NOT to be directly addressable from the wider internet. Any network admin will tell you that so it'll be interesting to see how that unfolds in the IPv6 world (if it ever unfolds).
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by loup-vaillant on Thursday September 30, 2010 @10:45AM (#1743411)
The safest thing for most end-devices is not being servers in the first place.

Now, if the device is cracked through one of its client software (NATs don't prevent that), then it could start up a rogue server, while if it were behind a NAT it couldn't. That's no worse for the machine itself (it's hosed anyway), but you could argue that's worse for the rest of the network.

I think it's not. Botnets are annoying and dangerous when they act as clients. Spam, DDoS, automatic attacks are all client behaviour. Even if you want server behaviour, connections don't have to be initiated from the outside. The compromised device just have to know the relevant IP, and initiate the connexion itself.

Finally, if you want to block incoming connections anyway, a plain firewall is cleaner. At least FTP will work.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by jauer on Thursday September 30, 2010 @03:02PM (#1744405)
The point about NAT blocking unforwarded servers, not necessarily true: http://samy.pl/pwnat/

The goal of some botnets is to set up servers for software distribution or to host phishing sites. You can't characterize botnets activity as simply client behavior.

Thanks to UPnP being enabled on most modern consumer routers you can't even count on the NAT protecting you from having a unauthorized server.

Having end-devices NOT be servers is ignoring the fact that the UI for many home devices is delivered over a embedded web server. This is becoming more commonplace over time.

Ultimately you need a firewall that controls inbound and outbound traffic.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by calloc on Thursday September 30, 2010 @03:31PM (#1744502)
Why do firewalls suddenly go away when IPv6 is introduced? If NAT is the only thing stopping packets from coming into your network then that is bad. Set up appropriate firewall rules.
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by loup-vaillant on Thursday September 30, 2010 @04:59PM (#1744825)
They don't. And I'd still like to have one. I was just saying that the root of the problem is insecure services.
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by tjpick on Thursday September 30, 2010 @04:35AM (#1742659)
coming back after the fact and saying "I know you got a sweet deal on those IP addresses when they were going cheap but we've run out and want them back so we're going to charge you extra" isn't really going to fly. You could argue the same case with domain squatters, or real estate, but it just can't work that way. You could buy them back -- at a premium of course.
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by bostonvaulter2 on Thursday September 30, 2010 @04:46AM (#1742679)
You could hypothetically charge a small yearly fee for each IP Address owned. Of course there would be lots of financial hurdles with this approach.
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by wmf on Thursday September 30, 2010 @06:10PM (#1745095)
ARIN already charges fees for IP addresses; I suppose they take 'em back if you don't pay. https://www.arin.net/fees/fee_schedule.html

Note that legacy holders don't pay fees on their massive /8s.

Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by MarkSweep on Thursday September 30, 2010 @05:42AM (#1742753)
I would think it would be easy to provide the security side-effect of NAT through firewalls in routers. The concept of "you can't talk to me unless I initiated a connection" does not seem to require NAT.
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by dfox on Thursday September 30, 2010 @11:14AM (#1743507)
It is easy, the one iptables rule that does it is in fact slightly longer to write than rule for NAT, but at least makes sense and does not involve words like "MASQUERADE" :)
Re:There is no Plan B: why the IPv4-to-IPv6 transition will ... by jodrellblank on Thursday September 30, 2010 @03:06PM (#1744422)
which makes substandard firewall solutions as what is provided by Windows pretty much unnecessary.

Ahem. Are you, perhaps, basing this on Windows XP from several years ago instead of Windows 7? Because 7 (and 2008 R2 Server) have pretty comprehensive looking firewalling.