News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by Animats on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:23PM (#17358128)
This is a desperation move by Musk. Nothing in the complaint alleges interference with Tesla production. Just that the ex-employee leaked some data on Tesla's internal screwups. Yet Musk claimed this was an excuse for Tesla missing their 5000 units/week goal yet again. (Actual production is about 1500 units/week right now.[1])

Also, this is someone at the battery factory in Nevada, not the auto plant in Fremont. So this is totally unrelated to the auto plant problems.

Tesla will have a hard time showing actual losses from this.

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-tesla-tracker/

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by rory096 on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:34PM (#17358272)
For some clarification, since I got mixed up on this too, there were two separate emails this week — one about this employee, then the next morning one about this fire that "stop[ped] the body production line for several hours" (and vaguely insinuated sabotage).

Martin Tripp email, Sunday 11:57pm: "I was dismayed to learn this weekend about a Tesla employee who had conducted quite extensive and damaging sabotage to our operations..." (scroll down for text) https://www.cnbc.com/2018/06/18/elon-musk-email-employee-con...

The fire email, Monday 9:38am: "Late last night we had another strange incident that was hard to explain. Small fire on the body-in-white production line..." https://www.cnbc.com/2018/06/18/elon-musk-email-tesla-factor...

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by FireBeyond on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @03:32PM (#17358884)
That's such a weird email, the first.

Someone conducts sabotage that is "extensive and damaging"... and you, someone who is known for being blunt and direct (questions from shareholders are "boring, yawn", etc.)...

and you're "dismayed"...?

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by carlivar on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @11:55PM (#17362036)
Deflecting the analyst's question about Model 3 reservations was the opposite of blunt and direct.
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by brookside on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @05:37PM (#17360020)
While Tesla's claims are probably largely accurate, I agree this seems like a distraction / side narrative for when they don't hit their stated goals and need to raise more money ASAP.

Worked at a startup that used the "we had saboteurs in our midst, but they were discovered and now things will improve" story on the eve of needed new financing round. The story was somewhat accurate but had very little to do with the overall arc of growth or progress.

Tesla will need something to say about why they didn't make their targets, and this is going to be one of the things said.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by twhb on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:46PM (#17358411)
Musk says 3500/wk as of the 16th. Bloomberg says their model is slow to catch sudden increases in output.
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by greglindahl on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:51PM (#17358480)
And to put this in perspective, the graph shows a regular cycle of: peak, shutdown to improve the line, higher peak, shutdown to improve the line, etc. And there's a peak timed for the end of every quarter.

Animats always has the most possible negative thing to say about Tesla, and this comment is typical for him.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by Animats on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @03:01PM (#17358589)
graph shows a regular cycle of: peak, shutdown

That may reflect the problems being upstream of final assembly. Maybe they need more than a week to accumulate enough parts to run final assembly for a week.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by rconti on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:04PM (#17360693)
This occurred to me as well. It's still 'getting there', but without knowing whether the line is shutdown exclusively for improvements, or if there's some fudging involved in there as well, it's hard to say how far they are from being 'there'.
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by compcoffee on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @04:25PM (#17359422)
>Musk says

I often hear how Hackernews is such a bastion of objectivity and critical thinking.

So why does "Elon says..." hold so much sway? We would laugh if it was "Zuckerberg says..."

Elon has "said" many things for many years which have not come to fruition.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by labcomputer on Thursday June 21, 2018 @01:26AM (#17362358)
> So why does "Elon says..." hold so much sway?

Because he made an easily-falsifiable statement. Either you believe in a massive conspiracy involving Tesla's bankers, Tesla's auditors, Tesla's employees, and members of the public pretending to be Tesla's customers, or you believe that Tesla actually produced X cars last week.

If you're going the conspiracy route, you're also assuming that Musk is willing to risk jail time for... what exactly? To satisfy his ego? It's not like he's going to run out of money if Telsa goes bankrupt.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by abugheratwork on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:43PM (#17360534)
> We would laugh if it was "Zuckerberg says..."

I mean ... I laughed. Didn't you laugh?

> I often hear how Hackernews is such a bastion of objectivity and critical thinking.

That gave me another good chuckle.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by mschuster91 on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @05:41PM (#17360049)
> Elon has "said" many things for many years which have not come to fruition.

They eventually do get realized, and that in a way that many people feel will benefit society as a whole.

For example: Zuck/FB don't care a flying fuck about their userbase and only about advertisers (e.g. chronological feed, the entire handling of the "fake news"/propaganda episode, Cambridge Analytica, handing the American democracy over to Trump) and Zuck is doing nasty stuff like buying his neighbors' houses only to tear them down.

Elon Musk, on the other hand, isn't in the game for personal richness (or at least, he doesn't shove it in the face of everyone standing less than a shovel length away). He could have lived in the Bahamas and sipping Pina Colada for the rest of his life already after Paypal, but no, dude puts literally all his fortunes into SpaceX and Tesla, and makes them succeed (SpaceX at, well, providing humanity with re-usable, affordable rocketry after the corrupt, expensive, Russian-dependent clusterfuck of ULA and Tesla at proving electric-only vehicles can exist and are viable), and then still has not enough and pours more money into The Boring Company, oh and meanwhile also releasing everything regarding Hyperloop as Public Domain. And not to forget he could still exit from all the companies and spend the rest of his life sipping Pina Coladas, but not doing so.

Yes, there are valid points to flame Elon Musk on (especially the allegations of working standards violations, with massive overtime requirements etc.), but in the end Elon Musk wants to advance humanity, and Zuckerberg wants to advance his cash. Not difficult to say who deserves more support.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by tomp on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:30PM (#17358222)
> Yet Musk claimed this was an excuse for Tesla missing their 5000 units/week goal yet again.

Citation?

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by atomicUpdate on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:55PM (#17358530)
This CNBC article:

https://www.cnbc.com/2018/06/18/elon-musk-email-employee-con...

It states there was a fire and that Musk references possible Sabotage. Then Musk says there is a real saboteur.

> Musk said this person had conducted "quite extensive and damaging sabotage" to the company's operations, including by changing code to an internal product and exporting data to outsiders.

Most people (myself included) assumed the sabotage he hinted at was done by the saboteur they caught who was intentionally trying to slow down Model 3 production to benefit "short sellers and oil and gas companies". Instead, Tripp just offloaded some data from a completely unrelated factory.

It feels like Musk was intentionally trying to conflate the two, since another fire is obviously bad news and making people believe it was the result of sabotage (with a real saboteur already caught) rather than just poorly run operations is in his best interest.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by marvin on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @03:34PM (#17358906)
Unless I am misreading badly, Musk does not say anywhere in this e-mail that "this was an excuse for Tesla missing their 5000 units/week goal".

Musk states that Tesla is investigating whether this person was receiving any outside impetus, and warning employees to be extra vigilant for signs of sabotage during the next few weeks, but that wasn't what OP claimed.

Any deliberate attempt by Musk at conflating these different events is up to interpretation, but note that this is an internal e-mail and not a press release. It's easiest to just interpret this message at face value.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by avs733 on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @04:45PM (#17359591)
Yeah but thats the point...imply it through your language rather than state it explicitly. It's intellectually dishonest.
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by marvin on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @05:21PM (#17359898)
I don't read such an implication, honestly.

It certainly could be interpreted that way, but if one did, one would already have made some assumptions oneself. I just don't see how this matches up with Musk's brutally direct tone on other occasions. Misleading your own employees like this seems like it would be counterproductive.

Not to mention, it would be obvious to any insider that this wasn't the reason for the struggles with ramping production - they have been behind the (admittedly heavily accelerated, since the 2015 plan) schedule for months.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by mlindner on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @03:27PM (#17358845)
There is no citation. Animats is making things up to satisfy his hatred of Tesla.
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by dang on Friday June 22, 2018 @01:50AM (#17371673)
That crosses into personal attack, which is a bannable offense on HN, so please don't do this again.

Edit: since we've warned you before and you've done it repeatedly since then, I've banned this account. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by gamblor956 on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:32PM (#17358252)
The citation was provided...Bloomberg has been estimated Tesla production based on VIN numbers, etc.

It's a rough estimate that isn't really accurate on a daily or weekly scale but tends to be accurate at the monthly level.

At any rate, Tesla is purportedly redirecting finished cars to non-US buyers or is holding back finished cars to avoid triggering the phase-out of EV-related tax rebates once they hit the 200k car milestone.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by martythemaniak on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:39PM (#17358337)
> Yet Musk claimed this was an excuse for Tesla missing their 5000 units/week goal yet again

And where in your Bloomberg link does it say anything of the sort?

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by Diederich on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:36PM (#17358303)
I think the citation requested was for Musk claiming that they were missing their numbers because of this activity.
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by guntars on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:38PM (#17358321)
Huh? The citation that Elon blames the employee being sued for missing the 5000/wk plan.
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by GreenPlastic on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @03:13PM (#17358711)
I don't really believe that he was using it as an excuse to miss production targets because a) it was an internal memo and not a public press release and b) if he was full of crap and trying to use that as an excuse, his employees would know and see through it.
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by gwern on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @04:13PM (#17359298)
He must have known it would be leaked instantly.
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by Diederich on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:37PM (#17358310)
> Yet Musk claimed this was an excuse ...

Citation on that? Thanks.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by protonimitate on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:27PM (#17358187)
Kind of off topic - but how much hands-on would someone like Musk have in this situation? Wouldn't the Tesla legal team be making the calls on this one, or is Musk the final shot caller on legal issues like this?
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by jdavis703 on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:32PM (#17358253)
It really depends on the management style of the CEO. I've worked with CEOs who took great pains to make sure information and orders traveled down the chain of command. I've worked with others who have no problem getting a low-level person to do something.
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by lostlogin on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:29PM (#17358209)
You would hope that the CEO had a say.
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by gamblor956 on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:30PM (#17358225)
It's a huge concern that Musk (via his earlier tweets) blamed an employee in the Gigafactory in Sparks, NV for issues with Tesla production at the Fremont, CA factory 240 miles away.
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by dijit on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:52PM (#17358487)
Not apologising for anyone. And I really could be wrong here.

But to me it sounds like these guys are making battery powered cars and the sabetour worked in a battery plant..

Doesn’t that mean that if the battery line was sabotaged then they’d be unable to ship cars that need those batteries?

Or was it alleged that there were direct and tangible sabotages committed against the cars directly?

Edit: did I say something wrong? Forgive my ignorance on the topic and please explain to me why? A pipeline is a pipeline and if a component is missing you can’t call the product finished.

Edit2: By the downvotes and lack of reply I'm going to assume that people don't like that this question is raised. Why?

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by freerobby on Thursday June 21, 2018 @07:01AM (#17363867)
Nah, you're exactly right. There's further evidence of this in Tesla's early disclosure that Model 3 production was tied to getting the Gigafactory online.

HN has a lot of great discussions and smart people, but it also has a handful of armchair engineers who are eager to tear down highly successful ones like Musk. Your comment offers a rational explanation for his concern and behavior, so naturally folks pushing ulterior narratives won't like it.

Don't let downvotes get under your skin. It's way harder, more interesting, and more dignified to think and respond critically and put your name on a comment like you did, than to click a little triangle anonymously every time someone challenges your assumptions. When an earnest question like yours turns grey, it says much more about the HN community than it says about you.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by outworlder on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @07:29PM (#17360834)
> Edit2: By the downvotes and lack of reply I'm going to assume that people don't like that this question is raised. Why?

Because some people may be looking for validation on their preconceptions (in this case, "Musk is making excuses") instead of engaging in critical debate.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by GreenPlastic on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @03:20PM (#17358788)
It's an internal email warning folks to be vigilant, not a press release assigning fault.
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by thebluehawk on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @03:00PM (#17358573)
Um, you realize that the battery modules for the Model 3 are produced in the Gigafactory. So problems there would definitely impact vehicle production.

Also, time that Elon and other employees spend on this guy take time away from more important things.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by product50 on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @04:59PM (#17359715)
IP theft is a big deal regardless of whether Tesla sufferred from it or not. In the long term, Tesla will most likely suffer if other companies/countries know the trade secrets.
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by compcoffee on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @04:22PM (#17359399)
>This is a desperation move by Musk. Nothing in the complaint alleges interference with Tesla production.

It seems pretty obvious to me: this ex-employee stole (which is scummy) data from Tesla and leaked it to journalists (Business Insider). BI asked Tesla to comment on the data, they refused, then released an "email" that described the sabotage and data breach.

Is he a whistle-blower or a saboteur? That's the question.

Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by outworlder on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:10PM (#17360281)
> Also, this is someone at the battery factory in Nevada, not the auto plant in Fremont. So this is totally unrelated to the auto plant problems.

Right, completely unrelated, because Tesla cars do not require batteries. Or software, which was also tampered with.

Tesla has filed a lawsuit, they are not coming up with excuses. At no point in the internal memo do they say this is the reason why they are missing their targets.

> Tesla will have a hard time showing actual losses from this.

To a judge, or to shareholders? Because this employee is done for. People got criminally charged and slapped with multi-decade jail time for way less.

[dead]
Re:Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to... by zaroth on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @04:12PM (#17359276)
You can be right, but say it in a way that still makes you come out wrong.