News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by JumpCrisscross on Monday June 18, 2018 @11:25AM (#17338905)
I continue to regard this as the stupidest geopolitical dispute our reality can safely support.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by Foivos on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:03PM (#17339292)
What would it mean for Portugal if Spain decided to change its name to Iberia?

This is exactly what is happening here. They want to be named after a geographical region which is way bigger than their borders.

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by newfoundglory on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:19PM (#17339415)
Yea, it's as silly as a country claiming to be the "United States of America" when lol, Canada and Mexico and all of South America would like a word...
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by PhasmaFelis on Monday June 18, 2018 @03:06PM (#17340818)
I eventually figured out that this is largely an issue with terminology.

In Central/South America, it's generally taught that everything from Nunavut to Cape Horn is a single continent, America. When the US calls itself "America," that's seen as a deliberate attempt to claim primacy over the whole continent.

In English-speaking North America, it's generally taught that "America" is the country and "North America/South America" are the continents, so we're befuddled by the irritation.

This is why Canada, actually, doesn't appear to have an issue with the "America" thing.

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by romwell on Monday June 18, 2018 @04:41PM (#17341528)
>in English-speaking North America, it's generally taught that "America" is the country and "North America/South America" are the continents

aaaaaand you don't see any problem here, no?

Let's try again. With that logic, there'd be no problem with Germany calling itself "Europe":

"What's the problem? When we say 'Europe', we mean our home country, a large part of the region known as 'Western Europe', and disjoint from 'Eastern Europe' - everybody here is befuddled by why the Greeks are upset! The Austrians are totally on board with it, by the way."

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by pseudalopex on Monday June 18, 2018 @11:48PM (#17343683)
Words can mean different things in different languages and different contexts.

In English-speaking cultures, North and South America are separate continents. "America" is understood to mean the USA. The polite term for someone from the USA is "American". Calling a Canadian "American" is impolite.

In Spanish-speaking cultures, América is a single continent. "Estados Unidos" is understood to mean "de América", not "Mexicanos". People from the USA are commonly called "estadounidense", "norteamericano", or "americano". It's polite for outsiders to use "estadounidense".

Neither language is indigenous to the Americas, so why not just use the polite words in each language?

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by eftychis on Monday June 18, 2018 @06:42PM (#17342222)
However, United States of America does not claim in this situation historical figures of Canada, Mexico and rest of South America to be U.S.A. nationals, or publish maps with its aspired borders including Quebec or Mexico City. For instance, they claimed that Simon Bolivar was U.S. national.

The situation is way more complicated than people expect or are comfortable with. I am not objective in this situation to give you a full analysis, but I would suggest if you want to have a full picture to start by looking at Balkan Wars to get an idea about the imperialistic dreams of each country in the area and the events. WWI shows how things evolved afterwards. Just checking the alliances is enough.

Then read about WWII specifically in that area and about Josip Broz Tito [0] (for starters) and dig in why he introduced new history and an identity and what were the political aspirations after WWII and why Yugoslavia was created and the naming of its regions.

I tried to give an objective guide to read the situation. Again personally I am perhaps not objective, as I have a stake in the situation.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Josip_Broz_Tito

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by Sangermaine on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:42PM (#17339627)
Except, lol, it’s the reverse of the Macedonia-Greece issue: the US was the only recognized independent state in the Americas when they chose their name. If “Canada and Mexico and all of South America would like a word” they should invest in time machines.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by newfoundglory on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:54PM (#17339710)
No, I don't see how you think it's opposite. Macedonia is a name for a large area. FYROM/Northern Macedonia is being used to name a country that takes up only part of this area. Similarly, the Americas are two continents, and USA is being used to name a country that takes up only part of this area. Neither the USA nor FYROM are granted any claim to the rest of their nominal superset.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by Sangermaine on Monday June 18, 2018 @02:02PM (#17340273)
>No, I don't see how you think it's opposite.

Because you're misunderstanding the issue at hand.

Greece and Macedonia aren't having an abstract argument over sets. As the article explains, Greece has two specific objections to its neighbor using the name Macedonia: that the name (and certain actions) are thinly-disguised territorial claims against its own province of Macedonia, and are an attempt to lay lay claim to the historical/cultural legacy of the ancient Greeks.

This is why the US situation is the opposite, because the US as a separate nation predates all of the other nations you mentioned in the Americas. It therefore can't have been claiming territory of other neighboring states because there weren't any, nor were they claiming anyone's cultural legacy (except arguably the natives, but that's a charge that can be brought against every modern nation in the Americas).

It might help to recall that after the American Revolution the 13 colonies became 13 separate sovereign states that would only come together as a single nation in 1789 with the adoption of the U.S. Constitution. The new nation was a union of all then-extant states on an American continent, hence the United States of America. That other independent nations eventually came to be in the Americas has no bearing on what America chose to call itself at the time of its founding.

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by eftychis on Monday June 18, 2018 @06:56PM (#17342299)
To enrich:

FYROM (UN designated name) and to be Severna Makedonija has been actively teaching they are the descendants of Alexander the Great, raised statues [0](random article googled, you can find more) etc. Extremist groups also post maps [1] (also random googling you can find more). So I would say the claims are disguised only in talks with other country officials.

Don't take this dispute lightly; recall that country policies trying to force the dispute to end created the whole Middle East mess and the Balkan's has been a hotpot with the last war happening in the 90's (also because they forced together two different people (I am skimming on the subject please read into Yugoslavia)).

[0]https://www.pri.org/stories/2011-06-24/macedonia-gets-statue... [1] https://www.thenationalherald.com/172171/fyrom-map-claims-gr...

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by refoundglory on Monday June 18, 2018 @02:24PM (#17340453)
(logged out, discovered last pass doesn't have the password for hn: new account to continue) I think you skipped over the comment that I was responding to, which said this: > They want to be named after a geographical region which is way bigger than their borders.

Sounds exactly like the USA at the time of their founding, and is in no way describable as "the opposite".

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by grzm on Monday June 18, 2018 @02:54PM (#17340710)
If you have an email address associated with an account, you can reset your password.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by brazzledazzle on Monday June 18, 2018 @05:57PM (#17341973)
I say stick with “refoundglory”. It’s the better out of the two. And more creative.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by JumpCrisscross on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:12PM (#17339351)
> They want to be named after a geographical region which is way bigger than their borders

Ancient Athens once controlled the Aegean and its borders. Does this mean Anatolians should require Athens be re-named?

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by Foivos on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:37PM (#17339585)
They do not want just to be named after that region. They want their country to eventually be this region. This is very clear if you ever visit. You can see everywhere maps like [1]. The red part is the "borders of their heart". In this photo, they actually kept the current borders (usually this is not the case) and you can see that they claim parts of Serbia, Bulgaria, Albania and a huge part of Greece. Also, a large part of the population shares these views, so such events is not just a mindless ultra nationalist minority.

[1] http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/newpix/2018/03/04/02/49CB53830000...

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by mishkovski on Monday June 18, 2018 @08:31PM (#17342814)
So there are nationalists like everywhere in the world. Is that really an issue? Is this even remotely plausible. I mean Macedonia occupying parts of Greece? Doesn't that sound silly to you? Greece is NATO member which Macedonia is trying to join while being blocked by Greece. Do you think Macedonia will go to war with NATO? Come on, this problem was used by corrupted politicians on both sides as an excuse for bad governing. Oh it is hard to deal with the real issues so lets fight over irrational problems.

And no, large part of the population does not share those views. The reason is simple, those views are unrealistic and have no place in today's Europe.

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by StavrosK on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:21PM (#17339444)
Think of like a part of the US emigrating into Argentina, taking up a majority of the country, and then deciding to rename Argentina to "Inca Empire" and talk about how great their Inca ancestors were. Presumably Peru would be at least a bit miffed about it.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by flukus on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @01:49AM (#17352912)
> Ancient Athens once controlled the Aegean and its borders. Does this mean Anatolians should require Athens be re-named?

There concerns would have been well founded, the issue was settled in 1922: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greco-Turkish_War_%281919%E2%8...

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by LaMarseillaise on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:58PM (#17339746)
I find your comment ironic because, in fact, 'Spain' ('Hispania') has historically referred to the entire peninsula.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by nitwit005 on Monday June 18, 2018 @08:25PM (#17342783)
> What would it mean for Portugal if Spain decided to change its name to Iberia?

Fairly sure they'd laugh at them, and then get on with their lives.

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by lhorie on Monday June 18, 2018 @01:27PM (#17339997)
> They want to be named after a geographical region which is way bigger than their borders.

Surely that can't be the whole reason for this dispute. I mean, the name "United States of America" would also fall into that description, but nobody's up in arms about it.

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by jimmydddd on Monday June 18, 2018 @02:25PM (#17340466)
Think of it like a portion of Canada bordering Montana seceding from Canada and calling themselves Montana. Also, a lot of the people of a certain ethnicity from that portion of Canada move into Montana in the US. In time, the ex-Canada Montana people lay claim to the US Montana region. After all, it's all Montana, right? That's what they are worried about.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by kd5bjo on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @04:55AM (#17344848)
Historically, this is pretty much what happened with Texas. A bunch of Americans moved there, fought their own war of independence, and then immediately asked to join the US.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by GFischer on Monday June 18, 2018 @02:30PM (#17340502)
I mean, the name "United States of America" would also fall into that description, but nobody's up in arms about it.

Many people in South America think it's a ridiculous, pretentious name.

It's not even the only United States in America (for example, Mexico is formally United States of Mexico).

But nobody is that worried, it's true.

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by DC-3 on Monday June 18, 2018 @03:21PM (#17340935)
It's even worse than that - it's like Portugal changing its name to Iberia. The vast majority of historical 'Macedonia' is in Greece.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by _dps on Monday June 18, 2018 @05:28PM (#17341840)
I'm treading lightly here because this is a sensitive subject, and I am somewhat personally involved [0]. But the discussion here is missing important history that shapes this problem that others casually dismiss as "silly". Please, educate yourselves on the history of this area before making flippant comments.

You can't understand this problem without understanding the Greek Civil War and former Yugoslavia post WW2. The facts are disputed so rather than try to play historian on a subject on which I am biased, I encourage you to read the wikipedia page [1], and especially look for information regarding Slavic Macedonians, separatist groups that wanted to take Greece behind the Iron Curtain, and the claims made to a large chunk of territory within Greece by the separatists and by Greek communists specifically around the region we call Macedonia. Keep in mind that our current government openly calls itself the Radical Left Coalition.

Reach your own conclusions about whether Greeks should consider this a silly matter.

[0] My grandparents fought in the civil war against the separatists

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_Civil_War

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by fibbra on Monday June 18, 2018 @11:31AM (#17338978)
History is full of such issues. This case reached up to economic sanctions. It is good there was no war about this.
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by kingofhdds on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @05:29AM (#17345012)
Well, using word 'stupid' to describe things one doesn't understand is a sort of popular fallacy.

For both countries it's a real conflict which involves not only emotions (the way news websites make you see it), but economical interests, political perspectives, and safety.

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by jcranmer on Monday June 18, 2018 @11:34AM (#17339005)
What about the Persian Gulf naming "dispute"?
Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by JumpCrisscross on Monday June 18, 2018 @11:43AM (#17339084)
> What about the Persian Gulf naming "dispute"?

Silly dispute, but much less stupid. The Persian/Arabian Gulf dispute is the product of an ongoing and relatively-new geopolitical tension. Both sides have military assets in the Gulf, and those assets threaten a major trading corridor. As a result, there is a genuine threat of one side seizing strategic ground from the other. Neither side is losing economic activity as a result of the naming dispute per se. (Lots of other things would need to be resolved before they could trade with and invest in each other.) And given the lack of intermingling (or common allies), they can each call it what they want without the other side noticing.

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by jcranmer on Monday June 18, 2018 @11:55AM (#17339201)
I bring up the "dispute" in quotes because it's something that was entirely manufactured for the purposes of manufacturing a dispute. The Persian Gulf is an appellation that is millennia old, and the Arabs decided to call the gulf something else because they didn't like the Iranians... and then pretended to make up the entire fact that it's called the Persian Gulf as some weird Iranian conspiracy.

At least the dispute of Macedonia has some kernel of truth to it (the Slavic peoples who moved into the Balkans during the Age of Migrations bear no relation to the Ancient Macedonians).

Re:Macedonia changes name, ending bitter dispute with Greece by JumpCrisscross on Monday June 18, 2018 @11:59AM (#17339239)
> the Arabs decided to call the gulf something else because they didn't like the Iranians

This is a normal facet of disputes. It's silly. But it isn't stupid. Doing this in reverse, where a name dispute turns into a proper dispute, is stupid.