News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by cft on Thursday June 14, 2018 @06:09PM (#17315879)
Just the mere fact that the EU government can be so technically inept as to draft and circulate such a legislation makes me totally distrust its intentions.
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by skywhopper on Thursday June 14, 2018 @07:16PM (#17316214)
I don't think it's bad intentions, just very very poor intuition about how computers and software works. They take it as a given that software-based content filters can and do work reasonably well and that the exceptions are exceedingly rare. Just like the press and government and most Hacker News patrons think that self-driving cars are imminent and real AI is just around the corner, and electronic voting is a good idea; and how the press believe that there's probably a backdoor solution for encryption that is still totally safe.
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by cft on Thursday June 14, 2018 @07:25PM (#17316255)
I think their calculation is far more rational: "There are no large internet companies in Europe (due to their own anti-startup regulation and taxation regime btw), but there are large copyright owners. So let's at least maximize the the value to the EU copyright lobby without any regard for the EU internet lobby (since we have none)".
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by lumberjack on Friday June 15, 2018 @07:03AM (#17318876)
>due to their own anti-startup regulation and taxation regime

Mention one such law.

Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by Silhouette on Friday June 15, 2018 @08:48AM (#17319352)
Mention one such law.

EU law that creates a barrier for startups? Here are just a few examples that are likely to be relevant to a typical startup we might have been discussing on HN, in addition to the various attempted IP changes mentioned elsewhere in today's discussion:

* Article 82(c) (the foundation of the anti-price-discrimination regime)

* Consumer Rights Directive

* ePrivacy Directive

* VAT regulations (particularly the 2015 changes affecting digital services)

* GDPR

All of these could credibly have been introduced with good intentions. Many of us would probably support reasonable consumer rights protections or privacy provisions, for example.

However, all of them have been criticised for their practical implementation and their adverse (and possibly unintended) effects on smaller businesses.

Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by KozmoNau7 on Friday June 15, 2018 @04:48AM (#17318381)
>"anti-startup regulation and taxation regime"

Plenty of startups from the EU have made it big. Just off the top of my head Spotify and Sitecore are pretty big.

Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by pacnard on Friday June 15, 2018 @05:26AM (#17318522)
Europe has a bigger population than the US, it should have a lot more startups, but politicians, bureaucrats, existing rules, etc make the economy too unstable and incapable of welcoming new player. People here have learned to aspire for the 9-5 job and can't even imagine that problems are solved by entrepeneurs and not the government.
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by pavelludiq on Friday June 15, 2018 @06:55AM (#17318835)
The reason Europe doesn't have as many startups as the US is because nobody in their right mind would fund things like Juicero here, not because the bureaucracy. The "splash the spaghetti on the wall and see what sticks" approach isn't the only way to build businesses.

Frankly the myopia of SV culture is quite amusing to me. California just can't shake it's gold rush mentality it seems. I'm not saying it hasn't served a lot of people well( obviously it has, but to assume it's the best strategy is pretty short sighted, especially considering I've never seen any actual evidence that it produces a larger number of sustainable businesses. In fact most US startups seem to me to be more like schemes for getting aquihire, or straight up hail marries, rather that actual attempts to make money and build a sustainable business.

Also, any entrepreneur that takes the attitude of "it's impossible to do with all of these rules and bureaucracy" is hardly deserving of the name, especially considering it's not really that bad[1], if they were serious, they would find a way to use the rules to their advantage rather than finding excuses or complaining over nothing.

[1] For example in many parts of the EU, not only are taxes much lower than the rest, but costs of living and doing business are as well, and many of the rules are less enforced, maybe Europeans simply don't value collectible blockchain cat pictures or IoT fidget spinners as much as Americans do and are less willing to invest in them.

Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by eeZah7Ux on Friday June 15, 2018 @12:01PM (#17320766)
> nobody in their right mind would fund things like Juicero > US startups seem to me to be more like schemes

This has little to do with mindset and a lot to do with inequality. SV has the highest percentage of billionaires per million citizens in the world. They can afford funding pointless startups that buy each other's products - as a hobby.

This also explains the incredibly high salaries and cost of living.

When a good startup comes out there's enough wealth around to boost it into wild success, create more billionaires and the cycle continues.

Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by fjsolwmv on Friday June 15, 2018 @11:31AM (#17320451)
The same people that funded Juicero funded Google. It's called risk/reward, and it's a astronomically successful strategy.
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by stared on Friday June 15, 2018 @08:34AM (#17319271)
> I don't think it's bad intentions, just very very poor intuition

Good intentions coupled with poor knowledge is usually much worse than the lack of good intentions.

Vide "In Passing SESTA/FOSTA, Lawmakers Failed to Separate Their Good Intentions from Bad Law" from EFF: https://www.eff.org//deeplinks/2018/03/how-congress-censored...

Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by MaxBarraclough on Friday June 15, 2018 @08:10AM (#17319140)
> intuition

If that's it, the real question is why on Earth they're using their intuitions.

When I am ignorant of a field, I don't pretend to be knowledgeable, instead I consult an expert.

Politicians seem unwilling or unable to do this with technological matters.

Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by sfifs on Friday June 15, 2018 @12:29PM (#17321067)
Politicians generally don't draft regulations. They decide what to sell and then sell it to the public.

Lawyers (bureaucracy, politicians team, industry reps) draft regulations. It is unlikely that the lawyers who drafted GDPR for instance were unaware of possible side effects. Given the enormous amount of legal work in checks and certification that has come out of this for the legal industry, it may even have been intentional.

Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by mtgx on Friday June 15, 2018 @05:52AM (#17318603)
It's mostly bad intentions in this case. Gunther Oettinger is a corrupt piece of sht that has proposed things such as "EU carriers should consolidate and they should require consumers to be in 3-year contracts so they can innovate better". Because we all know that industry consolidation and longer forced contracts on users is what makes services better!

He's the one behind these dumb copyright ideas, and he pushed for similar stuff in Germany. He proposed/wrote them when he was still a Commissioner until a year or two ago.

Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by DanBC on Friday June 15, 2018 @08:15AM (#17319159)
Have you read the draft legislation? Where did you read it?
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by zavi on Thursday June 14, 2018 @06:22PM (#17315955)
I'm getting GDPR flashbacks.
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by bryanrasmussen on Thursday June 14, 2018 @09:10PM (#17316731)
GDPR benefited citizens and hurt big companies, article 13 benefits big companies and hurts everyone else
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by sfifs on Thursday June 14, 2018 @09:31PM (#17316827)
GDPR is helping US internet giants and squelching smaller players. I work in the media space and can see where advertiser money is flowing. Advertisers who had previously spread their money supporting smaller publishers including European publishers are now concentrating it in walled gardens to limit any potential liability reasoning that the walled gardens will better be able to handle any arising litigation through their bottomless cash reserves :-)
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by bryanrasmussen on Friday June 15, 2018 @03:24AM (#17318088)
I think the fine structure of GDPR means that what might otherwise appear to be bottomless cash reserves are in fact only significant cash reserves, furthermore not only the advertisers have made this mistake but also the big players who seem to be operating at least on a quasi-antagonistic mode.

So what I think is - when the antagonism ends up taking big chunks of money everyone will suddenly realize "oh shit, it's not bottomless" at which point there will opportunities to take advantage of.

But maybe my take is too reasonable and instead the advertisers will think oh damn, stuff is really messed up better stay the course with these big guys to get us through these troubled times!

Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by sincerely on Thursday June 14, 2018 @10:34PM (#17317108)
If the “smaller players” aren’t willing to the take the reasonable steps to protect user data that would cause them to not be sued, then I’m fine with that.
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by sfifs on Thursday June 14, 2018 @10:59PM (#17317212)
I believe you are missing the point of the comment.

Even if smaller players take all super duper steps to protect user data, advertisers have no real way of knowing if they are in fact compliant whereas they have a simple way of looking at the published balance sheets of the big players and seeing the huge cash pile and armies of lawyers. The scare caused by activists weilding "nightmare letters" doesn't help. Also there's a body of thought in legal circles that even vendor chains needs to be evaluated which is causing advertisers to be wary. Far simpler to just throw money at the biggies who will deal with this.

As usual, the smart money will be in the certification industry that will inevitably come up to tax the mid sized players while the small publishers will die out.

Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by TeMPOraL on Friday June 15, 2018 @04:22AM (#17318294)
I think the basis of GP's comment is the bias a lot of GDPR supporters - myself included - have: we'd like to see the entire advertising industry die. So even if the effects hit smaller publishers more than the large ones, as long as it causes enough damage to the whole business model and incentivizes people to look for alternatives, it's a step in the right direction.
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by JumpCrisscross on Friday June 15, 2018 @05:58AM (#17318632)
> even if the effects hit smaller publishers more than the large ones, as long as it causes enough damage to the whole business model and incentivizes people to look for alternatives, it's a step in the right direction

Remember the adage “divide and conquer”? If you want to destroy something, consolidating its power base (like GDPR does to advertising in Europe) is a poor first move.

Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by ivan_gammel on Saturday June 16, 2018 @06:45AM (#17326889)
That might be a good first move. It's much easier to regulate one or two evil big corporations than a sacred cow of small and medium business.
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by AnthonyMouse on Friday June 15, 2018 @08:37AM (#17319292)
> we'd like to see the entire advertising industry die

The GDPR doesn't only apply to advertising companies. When you're offering services in exchange for money you still have your customers' names, IP addresses etc. Even if you aren't using any of that information for advertising or data mining, you still have it, which means you still have the compliance cost. A lot of that cost is not proportional to how much data you have or what you do with it.

And that's the problem. The GDPR will never destroy Google or Facebook, but it can destroy a three person startup that has nothing to do with advertising and might have offered an ad-free alternative to some of their services.

If destroying the ad industry is the goal, why not just tax advertising at >90%?

Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by bryanrasmussen on Friday June 15, 2018 @03:13AM (#17318038)
Either that or new small players will spring up that do not base their business on the user as a commodity.
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by rmah on Friday June 15, 2018 @10:54AM (#17320176)
Problem is, those players will still incur the compliance costs. The GDPR rules are not simply penalties for bad behavior. They mandate proscriptive actions companies must take, policies they need to design, services they must perform on demand, etc. whether the company is engaging in bad behavior or not.
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by TJSomething on Thursday June 14, 2018 @11:04PM (#17317228)
I think the issue here is that advertisers are not willing to evaluate if clients can protect user data unless large sums of money are offered up front.

And if you don't profit from a website and just want to place advertisements to keep the lights on, you don't have that kind of money.

Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by adventured on Thursday June 14, 2018 @11:56PM (#17317454)
GDPR is an EU mandated protection for the US advertising giants. It guaranteed EU companies can never challenge them in the ad market. It guarantees the EU can never produce a Twitter, Snapchat, Reddit, Google, Facebook, YouTube, or any other consumer advertising platform of consequence. Meanwhile, the US ad market will continue to produce an infinite bounty of vast, expanding profit, filling the coffers of the US giants. Those giants will then leverage that to enter / operate in the EU (even if it requires subsidy from the US profit machine), comply with GDPR, and perpetuate their dominance.
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by ivan_gammel on Friday June 15, 2018 @02:26AM (#17317873)
How many Twitters EU produced before GDPR? Approximately, 0. If we'll go below that number now, it will be an economic miracle I'd really like to see it.

Now, seriously, there are so many other problems here and GDPR compliance is so easy when you've already paid attention to security of your service, that it really does not make sense to blame a good law. Losers who cannot comply just don't deserve to be on the market.

The story with copyright directive is completely different and has no connection to GDPR.

Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by sandov on Thursday June 14, 2018 @10:35PM (#17317112)
Big companies are made by citizens. GDPR hurt everyone.
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists by merinowool on Thursday June 14, 2018 @07:51PM (#17316382)
It is not about being inept but rather being willing to pass whatever someone pays you to pass. They simply don't care about the consequences because these will have nothing to do with them. If sh*t hits the fan, they'll retire on some island rich and happy.