News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lonewolf22 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @11:47AM (#17256884)
More of us who know a thing or two about financial systems should get in the wealth redistribution business.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by Torwald on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:19PM (#17257247)
How do you define "wealth redistribution" that you can think it is a business?
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by mobilefriendly on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:51PM (#17257636)
It is a business whereby politicians buy votes.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by hexane360 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:17PM (#17258594)
Then they've been doing a very shitty job at it, compared to their deals with corporations.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by ams6110 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @03:26PM (#17259319)
They don't have to, because they get the votes anyway. Promises and sympathy seem to be all that's required.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by SketchySeaBeast on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:22PM (#17257288)
Robin Hood LLC.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by bsamuels on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:27PM (#17257356)
giving average joe the opportunity to lose all his money in cryptocurrency/day trading doesnt strike me as redistribution of wealth
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by JBReefer on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:08PM (#17258508)
No, it's a redistributive system alright, just not the way people hope.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by frockington on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:39PM (#17257506)
Don't forget, you can pay for Robinhood Gold and get access to margin!
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by Carlton87 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:13PM (#17257177)
The only way you will ever achieve wealth redistribution is with violence. Look at the great leap forward. It will not happen in America, at least I pray not in my lifetime.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by chrisbennet on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:25PM (#17257336)
We've had great inequality in the U.S. before (beginning of 20th century) and it somehow resolved itself. Perhaps there is a historical lesson in there somewhere.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by eloff on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:30PM (#17257404)
It was resolved in part thanks to World War II which was a massive all-in undertaking for the US (which it never really backed down from, they've maintained a massive standing force ever since then.) That was a huge redirection of capital that created many jobs while simultaneously removing millions from the work force. That is basically a perfect storm for raising wages across the board, and thus decreasing inequality.

Historically wars and unrest seem to be critical for redistribution of wealth once inequality increased to unsustainable levels. I wonder what will happen now in this era of unprecedented peace.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by Carlton87 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:35PM (#17257461)
You make my point. I don't believe there has ever been a redistribution from wealthy to poor without war and violence.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by opportune on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:40PM (#17257524)
Social democracy is the least painful solution within the current societal organization. That or mass labor movements. Otherwise unfettered capitalism will simply exacerbate inequality until things reach a tipping point - if billionaires and people that control the media don’t begin to shill for more redistributionist policies in the next couple decades they will have indirectly killed themselves
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lovich on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:22PM (#17257284)
It's happening in America right now, just not in the way you think. Everytime a company pays their employees so little they need welfare to live, that's redistributing wealth from society to shareholders

It's also been happening for years with social security redistributing wealth from younger workers to older retirees

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by dnautics on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:35PM (#17257463)
It also happens whenever we do QE or lowering discount window interest rates - that's wealth distribution from everybody (that happens to disproportionately hurt those with lower earning power) to banks and those privileged enough to obtain government grants, and indirectly, away from everyone saving for retirement to publically traded corporations.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by Consultant32452 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:35PM (#17257459)
>Everytime a company pays their employees so little they need welfare to live, that's redistributing wealth from society to shareholders

I'm curious what you believe would happen if we could magically remove all welfare programs. Do you believe those employers would be forced to raise wages? Or do you believe the lives of the poor would just be that much worse?

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lovich on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:53PM (#17257661)
I think everyone would be worse off unless companies are forced to pay. I am pro UBI, I just thought the guy was being crazy by hoping for something to never happen in his lifetime that is happening every day and has been for a while
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by Consultant32452 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:58PM (#17257721)
>I think everyone would be worse off

I agree with this, which is why I disagree with your first sentiment:

>Everytime a company pays their employees so little they need welfare to live, that's redistributing wealth from society to shareholders

Since we agree that employers would not pay more if welfare is removed, then the value of those welfare programs must not be subsidizing shareholders.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lovich on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:08PM (#17257833)
I don't agree with that conclusion at all. If they didn't subsidize those employees through welfare people would stop working there, either through leaving to other jobs or just dieing. At some point people have to eat and have a place to sleep.

Society is providing a workforce to employers at a wage that is not sustainable without the welfare

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by Consultant32452 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:14PM (#17257912)
>If they didn't subsidize those employees through welfare people would stop working there, either through leaving to other jobs or just dieing.

So then you believe if we eliminate welfare that employers would be forced to raise wages, because employees would be unable or unwilling to work there for their current wages. That is the opposite of what you said before.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lovich on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:34PM (#17258134)
I am struggling to understand your train of thought.

I claimed that there is redistributing wealth from society to business owners via welfare for low paid employees. In my understanding of the world the wages that are necessary to sustain the work force are $X and employers are paying $X -$Y. That $Y is the amount covered by welfare and what I am considering to be the wealth redistribution from society to the business owners.

That seems consistent with the idea that if the $Y subsidy is removed, then employers would be forced to raise wages or lose their workforce.

For example: if I have a nice car that my parents cover the lease and they stop covering the lease,I will either have to increase the amount of money I spend on the lease or lose the car. Just because I can respond to the change doesnt mean wealth wasn't being redistributed from my parents to me

Edit: it also appears that we are triggering hn's anti flame war measures as I have to wait some time to reply to you now. This has been a unheated discussion to me, but there will be delays in any responses now

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by Consultant32452 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:01PM (#17258448)
In your first response you seemed to be indicating that the lives of the poor would just be worse if we removed welfare. If that were the case, then welfare is not subsidizing shareholders.

Now you're saying that if welfare is removed employers would be forced to raise wages or go out of business. If that's true, then yes, welfare is subsidizing shareholders. Given that belief, do you support removing welfare programs so that we (society) can stop subsidizing shareholders?

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lovich on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:34PM (#17258771)
You are making a connection I am not making. If welfare is removed you are assuming that people's lives would not be worse because _eventually_ companies would be forced to raise their wages. In the short, medium, and even long term if the companies we're done headed enough, people's lives would be worse off because they would lack the welfare _and_ employers would not have adapted wages to the new equilibrium.

As to what I support. I would be for a UBI system so that every company would no longer have to worry about supporting their employees basic needs. It would allow for better competition as employees would be in a better negotiating position since no one would need a particular job. It would be still be a wealth transfer but I think the improvements to economy would pay off and it would give every citizen a benefit directly by not making them tied to employment. Road repair from damage from trucks is another situation where it looks like a wealth transfer from society to businesses, but the payoff in terms of the improvements to citizens lives are worth it.

As it stands currently the benefits from this current setup only go to owners of companies with low paid employees and I don't believe that the benefit of lower prices on some goods outweighs the harm that is caused by increasing the inequality between business owners and employees without giving employees a way to improve their lives

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by Consultant32452 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:57PM (#17259004)
>If welfare is removed you are assuming that people's lives would not be worse because _eventually_ companies would be forced to raise their wages. In the short, medium, and even long term if the companies we're done headed enough, people's lives would be worse off because they would lack the welfare _and_ employers would not have adapted wages to the new equilibrium.

This concern could be alleviated by phasing out welfare over time rather than instantaneously removing it. I feel like you dodged the spirit of the question, so I'll ask it again. Ignoring UBI as a possibility, given the world as you understand it today where welfare is a subsidy for shareholders, do you support removing welfare so that we can stop subsidizing the wealthy?

UBI vs welfare doesn't really change the situation here. UBI may be more economically efficient than our current form of welfare, but that's a different discussion altogether. I'm only interested in the question of whether you really believe that welfare as it stands today is a subsidy for shareholders. Because if you believe that, then it seems the rational proposal would be to get rid of welfare.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lovich on Thursday June 07, 2018 @03:25PM (#17259302)
Gotcha now

Short answer: I do not support removing welfare even though it subsidizes the wealthy

Long answer: I don't believe that wealth redistribution is a bad thing inherently and I would not be for removing welfare to replace it with nothing. I think UBI is economically and socially Superior to our current welfare system but our current welfare system is better than nothing.

The cons to our current system are that it's increasing inequality and benefiting a fee people massively at the expense of society, but I'd rather shoulder that expense than let people die by exposing them to unfiltered capitalism which I believe would lead many people to bring entirely jobless and destitute

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by Consultant32452 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @07:07PM (#17261165)
>but our current welfare system is better than nothing.

I feel like you're trying to have it both ways. On one hand you say that our current welfare system simply subsidizes shareholders. You seem to believe that if we phased out welfare that the poor would wind up in the same place they are today because they would demand higher wages. In other words, it provides no benefit to the well-being of the poor. And yet you say it's better than nothing. How can that be?

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lovich on Thursday June 07, 2018 @09:52PM (#17261941)
You're making jumps again. Shareholders and the poor are two subsets of society. Its possible for wealth to be moved from society as a whole to the shareholders and still benefit the poor, without taking money from the poor to do so.

I don't think the poor as a group would end up in the same place. I believe the wages would end up rising but less people overall would be employed. If you remove welfare then the people who end up without a job are going to be without anything and homeless/starve to death. The amount of time it would take for the new equilibrium to be met would also cause a lot of pain and suffering in the interim.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by Consultant32452 on Friday June 08, 2018 @02:53AM (#17263201)
>I believe the wages would end up rising but less people overall would be employed.

Interesting, what are your thoughts on the minimum wage?

>If you remove welfare then the people who end up without a job are going to be without anything and homeless/starve to death.

I feel like if your options are working or death, there will be many more people working, not less as you suggested above. But I also think the imagery of people starving to death is unrealistic. Over 70% of the world's population lives on less than $10/day. The American poor is very wealthy by global standards and they have a loooong way down to go before they start starving to death. The worst case scenario of the American poor losing welfare while simultaneously somehow not being able to demand higher wages looks more like the American poor inching ever so slightly closer to the global average lifestyle than starving to death. I don't want that situation any more than you do, but let's not be overly colorful in our language.

I understand why UBI is more economically efficient than our current welfare systems. Anything that moves towards giving the poor money they can spend on whatever they want is a bonus in my opinion. I'd start with Medicare and Medicaid. Instead of paying directly for healthcare we should just cut a check to the elderly/poor and let them spend those funds on whatever they wish. However, I don't understand why you feel it would behave differently than welfare with respect to its "subsidizing the shareholder class." Unless you expect UBI to be high enough so that nobody would have to work, and then I'm not sure how the economy doesn't collapse on itself with so few people doing work and so few taxpayers.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by ChrisLomont on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:53PM (#17257675)
It's not the purpose of a company to pay enough to completely cover an employees life costs. It is the role of governments to help those in need. Companies pay taxes (profits, part of social security, wages which support taxes, property taxes, and on and on) which helps fund this role of government.

If you require companies to pay enough to support the lifestyles of employees, than any person unable to generate enough value for a company will not get a job, will not have the opportunity to gather job skills to maybe get to that point, and will require full support from the government. And mandated higher wages leads to inflation, which puts the most vulnerable even further behind.

It's fairly reasonable for the least skilled to get a job that pays accordingly, with society picking up the slack. If that person ever increases in skills to move out of this, then they too will pay more in taxes to support the new group in need or least skilled.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lovich on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:59PM (#17257739)
I'm pro UBI and think we'd all be better off if everyone got enough to live and then companies could offer a penny a week if they wanted, since employment would not longer be tied to your ability to live.

Regardless of any of those arguments, I was responding to someone who said they hoped wealth redistribution didn't happen in his lifetime, and gave examples of it happening right now

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by ChrisLomont on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:00PM (#17258430)
I'd be pro UBI, but I've never seen the math where it works without violating one of: 1) insane tax rates that traditionally kill economies, 2) lower benefits for those most in need, or 3) simply wanting richer to hand money to poorer so they can not work much.

As such, I'm much more in favor of targeted assistance to make the most use out of limited resources.

And every one I've looked into will suffer from terrible inflation, probably defeating any gains. For example, if a person is willing to work a crap job to pay rent, this will not change no matter the money scaling. Give enough free money, then rents will simply rise (along with all other things for the same reason), to absorb the excess, and the same people will still end having to do the same work to keep their standard of living.

Free money is almost always inflated away by markets.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lovich on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:37PM (#17258810)
I don't know that our economy and technology is actually advanced enough to handle full UBI but there are places we could start. A food allowance for everyone would be good for instance and possible. Just no checks, here's x amount of money which will buy you enough food whether or not you use it on food.

Housing is another example. We don't have more empty house than homeless people in America. We don't necessarily have more house in downtown SF or NY but if we could set up a system where you could accept a house, with no real control over where, it would relieve some pressure off of people as a number of the population would accept that offer

I agree on the free markets inflating away free money. University costs are a perfect example where demand was artificially inflated with federal student loans, but the supply was not equally increased so the price just went up. If we started providing basics I'd believe they'd have to be controlled more like a utility. We try not to let market forces control water because weve decided that basic for everyone. So we give a company some garunteed profits in exchange for them not being able to wrong every last dollar out of the economic niche. We lose some efficiency, but gain stability

Targeted assistance might help better, but it's extremely difficult for the government as a single entity to try and provide help on the demand side without constraining the actions on the supply side. The increase in beuracratic costs also eats up much of the benefit

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by ChrisLomont on Thursday June 07, 2018 @08:06PM (#17261480)
>A food allowance for everyone would be good for instance and possible.

This would likely just be absorbed into inflation. It's hard to simply give people free money without prices increasing to make the time/work tradeoff for the good simply remain constant.

> you could accept a house,

If you've ever been a landlord, you'd realize people would likely destroy the properties. Many homeless are not homeless because they don't have a dwelling; they're homeless because that have fundamental other issues that make them owning and maintaining any property impossible.

>If we started providing basics I'd believe they'd have to be controlled more like a utility

Any country in history that tried to centrally plan such a large chunk of their economy failed. It's a sure way to get massive shortages and corruption and cronyism.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lovich on Thursday June 07, 2018 @09:58PM (#17261964)
The houses wouldn't just be for homeless who do have a high incidence of mental illness, it would be for everyone. As for the food money being destroyed by inflation, it might but giving general funds are a lot more likely to stimulate consumption than a targeted stimulus like college loans.

>Any country in history that tried to centrally plan such a large chunk of their economy failed.

There's problems and it wont go perfectly but we should still try to improve everyone's lives. I also disagree that anyone who tried to centrally plan such a large chunk of the economy has failed. Look at water and electricity, those are massive industries that are centrally planned. Central planning is not as efficient as a market based economy and is not the way to grow an industry or develop new technologies. It does work better than a market based economy when it comes to uninterrupted coverage which is why it's used in the utility model

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by ChrisLomont on Friday June 08, 2018 @07:47AM (#17264396)
> it might but giving general funds are a lot more likely to stimulate consumption than a targeted stimulus like college loans.

And vastly lower on total return. Investing in education will likely increase output overall. Investing in food and alcohol and TV will not.

And consumption will not even be increased if inflation eats the money, which it likely (and historically) will. It will simply rescale the dollar to make no one better off.

>There's problems and it wont go perfectly

Ignoring that it has spectacularly failed and destroyed lives and countries is not simply "problems." Repeating things that have been demonstrated to be terrible ideas is again a terrible idea.

>but we should still try to improve everyone's lives

Then let's use targeted use of scarce resources instead of wishful thinking and ignoring history. Otherwise we repeat ideas that sound good but fail such as rent control. The things you present are not new ideas. They have been tried and failed. Ham-handed allocation of scarce resources is almost always worse than targeted allocation. This is simple economics.

>I also disagree that anyone who tried to centrally plan such a large chunk of the economy has failed.

List a country that has succeeded at planning as large a piece as you're suggesting.

>Look at water and electricity, those are massive industries that are centrally planned.

No, they are not. They are locally planned, compete with each other, trade resources, and have plenty of free-market features to trade futures, trade stocks, and compete. They are absolutely not centrally planned.

Venezuela is an example of what happened when the central government takes over such markets.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lovich on Friday June 08, 2018 @09:02AM (#17264829)
How often do utilities compete? I don't have a choice on water hookup and electricity has only been a choice in generators recently. Also no one has actually done UBI long term and on a large scale. At this point I feel like you are being disenguous.

If you don't like the idea of UBI and think market only solutions are better, that's fine, but this is different than the government telling everyone they're making A widgets this year instead of B widgets

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by ChrisLomont on Friday June 08, 2018 @01:26PM (#17267710)
>How often do utilities compete?

They don't often compete directly for you; the government gives them local monopoly. They compete to sell excess product on the open markets, which is why energy trading is a massive industry. By competing on that market, they indirectly compete for you, since your utilities can often buy capability from other markets. In short your pipes are limited, but the product you get from them is created in open markets, with your utility company being the last middleman in the chain to deliver goods locally. It's also why you can sell capability back into electrical grids in many places. There's a market for it.

So in that sense, probably every one of them competes.

This trading directly happens because there is no central planning. Central planning, as usual, is inferior to letting pricing determine how goods move. Your claim was this industry was an example of central planning, but it is not. Capability is not centrally planned - markets react to move goods where they are best prices by local merchants, like any other free market good. If you've never seen how this works here's an intro[1]

>Also no one has actually done UBI long term and on a large scale

If there is evidence that it fails on short term and small scale do we really need to make it bigger and longer to hurt more people before we address the reasons it fails? There have been several places that have tried portions of it, and they have matched what economic theory said would happen. At some point it needs a new idea or method before more people are subjected to historically damaging ideas.

UBI is simply welfare for more people. Those paying for it necessarily get less than with no UBI, and those getting it will receive more welfare. No UBI proposal I have seen is anything more than this - tax some people more to give others more.

There is ample evidence among countries that more welfare correlates with more people working less, and less overall productivity. Even the Canadian UBI experiments found this to be true.

When people work less, less is produced, and as a result society has less.

>At this point I feel like you are being disenguous.

About utilities? You think they're centrally planned and don't compete in markets. Both are wrong. So I don't think I'm being disingenuous - you're simply uninformed how things work. It's disingenuous to claim you understand something that you have not simply googled to see where your understanding fails, then not admitting it.

[1] https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/042115/under...

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by DoreenMichele on Thursday June 07, 2018 @08:12PM (#17261504)
I'm pro UBI and think we'd all be better off if everyone got enough to live and then companies could offer a penny a week if they wanted, since employment would not longer be tied to your ability to live.

This will never work.

First, it is a myth that X amount of money provides adequately for everyone, in part because there is no standard issue normal person.

Second, money reduces friction in trade, thereby providing valuable efficiencies. But if income is entirely unrelated to creating or husbanding some kind of value, the entire system can rapidly come unraveled.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by frockington on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:34PM (#17257441)
You should get out and meet real people in America. It will probably change the first half of your post
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lovich on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:56PM (#17257694)
Not quite sure how. I ended up working at Walmart after college and had to steal food since I couldn't afford rent,student loans, and medicine. Pretty much everyone of my coworkers was in the same boat with student loans being the only difference.

If you think it's not happening I suggest you put all your assets in an account you won't access and then try and live for a few years off a retail job

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by Carlton87 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:30PM (#17258080)
Life Pro Tip: Have better skills and be a better employee.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by hexane360 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:20PM (#17258629)
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lovich on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:40PM (#17258190)
Life Pro Tip: have some empathy

Additionally: No shit, I taught myself programming and I'm an engineer now. Not everyone is capable of doing this, and the fact that I managed was down to just as much luck as it was skill and effort.

It also doesn't change the fact that we are taking money from society and giving it to companies

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by frockington on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:44PM (#17258243)
What did you major in? Was it poorly thought out from the beginning or did college admissions lie to you about job prospects?
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lovich on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:57PM (#17258400)
I took an easy major to get a high gpa as I was trying to get into the military through ROTC and they care about your grade not your major. Then Obama got voted in on a platform of winding down the war, the ROTC detachments were told they could contract half as many people as they expected before the new president was even sworn in, and I got cut to graduate right after the recession with no real skills.

With the benefit of hindsight I could have done much better for myself,but I would not expect someone at that age to have the foresight to prepare for just how fucked your life plans can get

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by frockington on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:42PM (#17258213)
Don't go to college and then work at Walmart...
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by lovich on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:57PM (#17258408)
Not a lot of choices after the recession. There were people with Masters working there for a few months