News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Andre_Wanglin on Thursday May 31, 2018 @02:44AM (#17194416)
The kids were in school twice as long, received free dental, medical, and mental health services as well as free meals and transportation for their parents. That is quite a bit more than high-quality schooling. And does the touted "closing" of the black-white achievement gap persist if white students receive the same treatment?
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by JepZ on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:18AM (#17194558)
Well, it might be more than just 'high-quality' schools, but maybe that is necessary. That way you release the kids from their uneducated parents in some respect.

The problem with uneducated parents is that they are still very valuable for the children in terms of emotional development. The problem however is, that they tend to make critical mistakes which sometimes affect the children's development.

And to bridge those two aspects, this 'high-quality' school model might be a very good answer.

Just to be clear: Not all uneducated parents are the same and some of them might be very good parents, its just that the probability of finding problematic behavior is much higher for uneducated parents.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Iv on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:52AM (#17194699)
This is a think I wish more people understood: There is no equality of chances. Unless you give every kid the same standardized education and childhood experience, which implies a society no one wants.

The only alternative is to recognize the people who start at a disadvantage and offer them compensation for that.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by gameswithgo on Thursday May 31, 2018 @09:15AM (#17196014)
>The only alternative is to recognize the people who start at a disadvantage and offer them compensation for that.

I don't know exactly what you mean there. Do you mean - let the kid develop sub-optimally and then when they grow up, give them a job even though they are less qualified?

Because that is an idiotic alternative. Much better to do our best to get kids as close to equality of chance as possible by providing everyone with a high quality education and health care.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Iv on Friday June 01, 2018 @12:56AM (#17202707)
No I mean that kids will be advantaged or disadvantaged because of the environment they grow in. We should identify people who are having a big handicap because of their environment and give them tools that others don't necessarily have to get over it.

If you are born out of two drug-addict parents, even if you are given the same education tools as some from middle-class parents, you will likely perform less well. It is not a breach of equality to offer special classes to such kids.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by professorgerm on Thursday May 31, 2018 @02:01PM (#17198534)
Likely they mean good ole original Marxism.

"From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs" is a slogan popularised by Karl Marx.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by didibus on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:15AM (#17194787)
> Unless you give every kid the same standardized education and childhood experience, which implies a society no one wants.

I've always personally been open to this idea. I find families to be tribal and often problematic. I think it be nice to start seeing all children as your own, the children belong to society, and maybe we should all pay for them.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by mamon on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:50AM (#17194942)
>> the children belong to society

That's the dangerous way of thinking that we should avoid. Children belong to their parents, until they come out of age when they start "belonging" only to themselves. Seeing children as belonging to society is typical for totalitarian regimes (see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hitler_Youth)

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by croon on Thursday May 31, 2018 @05:12AM (#17195008)
No, it's typical for any society. There's social services in most if not all industrialized societies, that can take children away from their parents for the sake of the child if the parent(s) are ill-equipped to raise them. That's not a bad thing.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by bzbarsky on Thursday May 31, 2018 @10:29AM (#17196556)
The problems start when "ill-equipped" is defined as expansively as possible. See the various cases of CPS getting involved when parents try to teach their kids basic independence by letting them walk to the playground on the corner and play there.

I think the way CPS is currently done in the US is actually causing a great deal of harm to current kids whose parents are totally reasonable parents...

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by waterhouse on Thursday May 31, 2018 @05:54AM (#17195150)
> That's not a bad thing.

For the record, I don't consider this obviously true. If you search "cps horror stories", some of the results are about horrible family situations that Child Protective Services has encountered, and others are about family situations that CPS has horribly mishandled. A couple of links focusing on the latter:

https://parentalrights.org/child_protective_services/

https://lfb.org/confessions-of-an-ex-cps-agent/

I'm not sure if anyone has tried very hard to make a case that the good of CPS outweighs the bad.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by DomreiRoam on Thursday May 31, 2018 @05:40AM (#17195102)
I just checked the definition of "belong" I didn't like the idea that parents own children . I did find to meanings: "be the property of" and "be a member of". So I really prefer to say that children are part of a society than children are owned by their parents.

Could we say that children are part of our society and that parents are their guardians and primary educators? I would like to convey that we have shifted from the "pater familias" model to something different were we recognize that children are no more properties.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday May 31, 2018 @06:44AM (#17195336)
Belong doesn't always imply ownership, it is more nuanced. "We belong together" doesn't mean that there's a contract of sale putting one of us in the others ownership.

Children belong with their parents. Parents belong with their children. It's mutual.

That aside:

High levels of intellectual learning are not the be-all-and-end-all; ie should not be the ultimate goal. Fulfillment of the person, and in turn of those around them, is a better outcome IMO.

Schools often focus on intellectual outcomes to set kids up for their future; but parents should watch that the kids have a measure of fulfillment now -- this is why the huge focus on attendance as the primary statistic in UK schools is so damaging IMO. Kids need an education (not necessarily in a school) but a family holiday can be a part of that education and provide a measure of enjoyment to life.

"What is this life if full of care we have no time to stand and stare, ..." (W H Davies)

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by DomreiRoam on Thursday May 31, 2018 @07:40AM (#17195563)
As a non native speaker i just reacted to "belong to" and I think "belong with" is really better in the context of parent-children relation.

I 100% agree that intellectual outcomes (and even more fitness to the job market) shouldn't be the ultimate goal. We should look back to a well rounded education. And you re quite right that education is provided in a lot of way. "It takes a village to raise a child"

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Andre_Wanglin on Thursday May 31, 2018 @05:00AM (#17194971)
"Society" is just another tribe, one that may wish to eradicate your culture. In a multicultural society, whose tribe is deemed "problematic" and whose is "normal?"
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Iv on Thursday May 31, 2018 @05:59AM (#17195171)
Even by being open to the idea, it is easy to see that such a project will garner so much opposition as to be politically non viable.

It is also very hard to achieve, as even if you break up the family structure, there will be a disparity of compétences accross the education institution and will also magnify genetic advantages and handicap, things that as a society we do not feel legitimate to attribute merit.

I am open to the idea of banning inheritance though, which seems to me the most unfair family advantage out there.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Andre_Wanglin on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:27AM (#17194845)
Your alternatives are bounded by a lack of imagination.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Iv on Thursday May 31, 2018 @07:26AM (#17195505)
Pray tell which ones I missed.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by your-nanny on Thursday May 31, 2018 @08:23AM (#17195745)
Probably the ones that involve been cruelly indifferent to their fates.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Andre_Wanglin on Thursday May 31, 2018 @09:02PM (#17201727)
Most people would welcome a government that is merely indifferent to them.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by MaysonL on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:16AM (#17194792)
Note that one of the services that Harlem Children's Zone provides is teaching parents what they can do to help their kids succeed. See their "Baby College" for example.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Iv on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:49AM (#17194691)
"That is quite a bit more than high-quality schooling." Yeah, it sounds almost like European-level. Seriously, nothing mentioned there should strike as exceptional in a rich country.

"And does the touted "closing" of the black-white achievement gap persist if white students receive the same treatment?"

That would be surprising, seeing how many other biased factors there are to handicap these kids. Even pre-natal conditions are a factor there! (Uneducated and poor women are more likely to smoke while pregnant)

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by stuaxo on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:13AM (#17194782)
OT: I'm really annoyed, in the UK things like free school meals to the neediest are being taken away, along with cuts to transport, we're heading towards the US.

Now I have a child it's tempting to leave the country.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by kingkongjaffa on Thursday May 31, 2018 @05:56AM (#17195157)
The barrier to a decent quality of life in the UK is getting higher and higher.

Anecdotally - growing up a single parent on <£20k a year was enough for me to have a good childhood.

Today my household will have a combined earning of nearly 3x that and the quality of life isn't 3x better. Probably only 1.5x-2x (I can now go on 2-3 holidays a year instead of 0 in my first 20 years)

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by gnarbarian on Thursday May 31, 2018 @02:53AM (#17194452)
Also, it would be good to know if the children were randomly selected for this program from all the children in Harlem or if ambitious parents who cared more about their children's education could jockey for position and placement.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by dagw on Thursday May 31, 2018 @02:58AM (#17194468)
Enrollment to the program is apparently done by lottery among everybody that applies and the study compared kids that applied and got selected to kids that applied but didn't get in. So that should at least go some way to account for the parent factor.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by burfog on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:25AM (#17194589)
It fails.

In the special school, 100% of the kids/parents actively took an interest in education. In the alternatives, less than 100% did.

School quality is largely determined by the students in the school. This doesn't just mean that the performance of student X is determined by student X caring about school. The performance of student X is also determined by the fact that student Y cares or doesn't care about school.

So in all the non-special schools, there exist the sort of uncaring disruptive students who will drag down everybody. It isn't that the special school is itself somehow wonderful, but that the bad influences are excluded.

Simply put, one can not scale this solution. Providing the supposed quality school to everybody is not possible because the quality of a school is largely determined by the students.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by dnomad on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:38AM (#17194642)
You're asserting without any evidence that every student Y who "doesn't care about school" would not respond to the protocols described in this paper? This is an extraordinary claim and probably wrong. It needs to verified with data. The paper does provide the basis for a logical next step: imposing these protocols on all students in a region and measuring the impact.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by sheepmullet on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:47AM (#17194679)
> You're asserting without any evidence that every student Y who "doesn't care about school" would not respond to the protocols described in this paper?

No. They are simply stating the truth that there is no evidence it will work.

It is basic selection bias.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by burfog on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:10AM (#17194766)
I don't know a proper name for the problem, but I don't think "selection bias" is really it. The problem is that the control is getting damaged by the experiment. The control is intended to be similarly-selected students (the lottery losers) in non-special schools, but there are also other students (never applied to the lottery) in those non-special schools who interfere with the experiment. The control students don't get to have those non-special schools to themselves.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by dagw on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:35AM (#17194877)
I don't know a proper name for the problem

I think "confounding variable" would the describe the problem. Basically there are two variables that seem to affect the outcome, but since they only controlled for one of them, they can't tell if the second variable is affecting the experiment or not.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by malcolmgreaves on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:26AM (#17194593)
White kids already receive this kind of treatment signficantly more often than children of color. This underlies the aforementioned achievement gap.

Curious -- is this something that you're not aware of? I find it odd that you end your post with "of white students receive the same treatment?"

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by sheepmullet on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:43AM (#17194665)
You haven't answered his question.

What exactly is the gap that has been closed?

Is there still an achievement gap between these kids and white kids at similar high-involvement charter schools?

[dead]
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by croon on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:52AM (#17194698)
Either you are misunderstanding, or you are being intentionally obtuse. On aggregate, the students receiving those perks are generally wealthy, and generally white.

Of course there are wealthy black students, and poor white students, but the achievement gap isn't based in particulars, but in aggregates and statistics.

Side note: I do realize that your alias is a play on Andrew Anglin, creator of neo-nazi website Daily Stormer. Very clever. You could do with being more subtle in your framing of these posts though.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by sheepmullet on Thursday May 31, 2018 @07:38AM (#17195555)
> Either you are misunderstanding, or you are being intentionally obtuse.

Are you sure you aren't the one misunderstanding or being intentionally obtuse?

It's called the black-white achievement gap.

It is deliberately and for good reason not called the rich-poor achievement gap.

There is a significant gap after adjusting for wealth and parents education levels.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Andre_Wanglin on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:19AM (#17194805)
I am to understand that white students, in aggregate, receive twice as much schooling as black students? And thus the black-white achievement gap?
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by lern_too_spel on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:41AM (#17194900)
No, you are to understand that white students in aggregate are the beneficiaries of privileges that in sum are equal to double schooling. A combination of (in aggregate) better educated parents, more at home supervision and guidance, more extracurricular educational enrichment, better nutrition, an environment of children improved with the previous privileges, etc.

What's the alternative? That the black children are inherently less smart? The same used to be said of Asian kids, and that achievement gap persists for Asian kids who grow up in neighborhoods of other poor uneducated Asians. Meanwhile, Shanghai and Korea have shown that these kids can learn.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Andre_Wanglin on Thursday May 31, 2018 @05:24AM (#17195049)
Why do you characterize normal parental investment as privilege? Is it to exculpate parents who neglect their children? Again, as the students in The Promise School not only enjoyed these "privileges" but also twice as much schooling, what would happen if all students received twice as much schooling? Does it stand to reason that the claimed success in closing the achievement gap would persist? In terms of resource allocation, why should some populations be excluded from receiving this additional benefit?

I have never heard anyone express any prejudice toward "Asians" regarding a lack of intelligence. In fact, the usual stereotype is precisely the opposite.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by bildung on Thursday May 31, 2018 @07:23AM (#17195495)
> Why do you characterize normal parental investment as privilege? Is it to exculpate parents who neglect their children?

Children usually can't choose their parents. The point of public school services like those described in the study is to lower the burden on disadvantaged children.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by lern_too_spel on Thursday May 31, 2018 @05:42AM (#17195113)
> Why do you characterize normal parental investment as privilege?

Privilege: a special right, advantage, or immunity granted or available only to a particular person or group of people.

The children of educated parents have many advantages, some of which I have enumerated. Black children are born disproportionately to uneducated parents due to generations of denying blacks education followed by generations of denying them good education in an environment that is conducive to education (where there are multiple parents at home who can help, for example).

> Again, as the students in The Promise School not only enjoyed these "privileges" but also twice as much schooling, what would happen if all students received twice as much schooling?

As I already stated, white students in aggregate are already receiving more extracurricular educational enrichment. Adding more schooling would be substitutive with that additional education.

> In terms of resource allocation, why should some populations be excluded from receiving this additional benefit?

Excluded from what? This should be an option to anybody. White students in Harlem had the same access to these programs.

> I have never heard anyone express any prejudice toward "Asians" regarding a lack of intelligence.

The literacy rate in Korea was 22% at the conclusion of WW2, but Korea now performs near the top in international exams. Descendants of Chinese who arrived in the 19th century continue to perform poorly on intelligence tests, yet we see Hong Kong and Shanghai perform very well on those same tests.

The 19th century stereotype of Chinese was of opium-addled superstitious barbarians.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by sheepmullet on Thursday May 31, 2018 @07:49AM (#17195606)
> Black children are born disproportionately to uneducated parents due to generations of denying blacks education

Not long ago the average white American had only a basic formal education.

My father left school when he was 12 and over half his class left at that age.

My grandfather left school when he was 10.

If that was a key reason then we would only have to have waited a generation.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by lern_too_spel on Thursday May 31, 2018 @10:00AM (#17196338)
You had the advantage of good schooling in a decent (though not great) environment, just as the Koreans and Shanghai kids did or are an outlier. You take one advantage and claim that's the only one. Blacks have for generations lived in an environment where they did not have access to jobs that require an education, even if they were able to obtain one by sheer force of will, leaving entire communities without a drive for attainment.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by CPLX on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:23AM (#17194821)
Perhaps you will be unsurprised to learn that this poster's first contribution to HN was, in fact, a multi-paragraph impassioned defense of said Nazi hate site: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16731182
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by zingmars on Thursday May 31, 2018 @06:30AM (#17195286)
These shaming tactics are not helpful, and to be quite honest it's kind of creepy that you actually went through his post history just to find some 'dirt' on this person.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by DanBC on Thursday May 31, 2018 @08:48AM (#17195865)
They are helpful.

HN is being trolled by a polite racist. It's important that people know this, so they can avoid being trolled.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by CPLX on Thursday May 31, 2018 @09:04AM (#17195941)
Indeed. I'm quite certain I'm under no obligation to engage with disingenuous neo-Nazi's on the internet, and I see little good that could possibly result from trying.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by opportune on Thursday May 31, 2018 @09:11AM (#17195984)
They absolutely are helpful. This website doesn’t need racists to try to recruit new people here by attempting to engage in “debate.” Look up Stormfront, what they believe, and how they try to “recruit”
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday May 31, 2018 @06:52AM (#17195372)
I read some of Mein Kampf once imagining that on every page I'd find the vilest, most abhorrent statements, ill-informed and manifestly damaging to society.

Surprisingly some elements of what Hitler said on education made sense.

Someone can be a racist bigot and still have a good idea in another field.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by gizmo686 on Thursday May 31, 2018 @09:48AM (#17196248)
A lot of people were taking the Daily Stormer's side on that that issue. Heck, I grew up idolazing the ACLU because they would defend Nazis.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by lern_too_spel on Thursday May 31, 2018 @10:22AM (#17196498)
I feel lucky as a non-Jew non-black that I won't have to live in terror of the people radicalized by the Daily Stormer's conspiracy theories and hate speech. Maybe you do too. That doesn't mean it's right for a company to give the Daily Stormer a platform for radicalization, which the company is under no legal obligation to do.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by gizmo686 on Thursday May 31, 2018 @10:41AM (#17196645)
I feel lucky as a Jewish American that I live in a country where the rights of Nazi's are respected.

I do not want to get into a legal argument of if CloudFlare is allowed to discriminate (they likely are). But I do want to live in a world where they are not allowed to.

First they came for the Nazis, and I did not speak out because I hate Nazis.

Then, they came for me, and there were no institutional protections, because they would have protected those damn Nazis.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday May 31, 2018 @10:42AM (#17196656)
Nice ivory tower. But Nazis almost destroyed the world; they killed 50 million people. I'm making an exception for them.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by gizmo686 on Thursday May 31, 2018 @11:01AM (#17196796)
And how do you plan on making that exception?

In the case under discussion, Cloudflare established the president that they could terminate service to customers based on what they say. We have already decided as a society that we do not want the government to have that sort of power. Why are we now insisting that private companies must have and use that power?

Freedom is not defended by defending people that we like. It is defended at the periphery; by defending people that most of us do not like.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by krapp on Thursday May 31, 2018 @01:02PM (#17197979)
>In the case under discussion, Cloudflare established the president that they could terminate service to customers based on what they say.

Cloudflare didn't establish a precedent. It's standard boilerplate for any web service to reserve the right to terminate any account any time for any reason, as well as to alter their terms of service in any way at any time, for any reason, without notice.

Reasonable people can disagree about whether or not Cloudflare should have exercised their rights in this case, but they didn't upset the applecart of free speech by doing so.

>We have already decided as a society that we do not want the government to have that sort of power. Why are we now insisting that private companies must have and use that power?

As a society, we believe that government should be limited in scope to only those powers explicitly granted to it by the people. The people meanwhile enjoy the full scope of rights not granted to government, and those rights are considered inalienable and irrevocable.

Private entities like Cloudflare have and have always had greater power than governments to choose what to publish, and what not to publish, with whom to associate and not, merely by virtue of being private entities.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by gizmo686 on Thursday May 31, 2018 @02:14PM (#17198653)
>Cloudflare didn't establish a precedent.

Cloudflare did reserve the right to do so in their ToS; but they had a precedent of not using that right to police speach (and activly argued that it was not their place to do so). While they did not establish any legal precedent here, they still established a social precedent.

>They didn't upset applecart of free speech by doing so.

Yes they did. Just because private companies are not subject to the first amendment does not mean that they are not arbiters of free speech.

>As a society, we believe that government should be limited in scope to only those powers explicitly granted to it by the people.

And we have already decided that one of those powers is to prevent private companies from discriminating. See the Civil Rights, which defined the notion of public accommodations. Despite being (potentially) privately owned, these public accommodations are not allowed to discriminate based on protected classes.

I would also like to point out that, in the course of this thread, we have gone from 'Andre_Wanglin should not be listened to because his defense of Cloudflare demonstrates that he is an impassioned Nazi sympathizer' to 'reasonable people can disagree, but Cloudflare's behavior did not violate the constitution or break any law'.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by lern_too_spel on Thursday May 31, 2018 @11:02AM (#17196809)
> First they came for the Nazis, and I did not speak out because I hate Nazis.

By your reductionist logic, we shouldn't jail pedophiles who have abused children. Those pedophiles, like the Nazi radicalizers are harming other people through their actions.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by gizmo686 on Thursday May 31, 2018 @11:21AM (#17196962)
We shouldn't (and don't) jail people who advocate for the right to have sex with pre-pubescent children. Simmilarly, we shouldn't (and don't) jail people who advocate for the killing of all Jews [0]

When the Nazis escalate to actual violence, I have no problem with taking legal action against them. (Although I do still have a problem with private companies bowing to public pressure to act against them in a vigilante manner. ) If you want to propose a specific rule/law you would like to see applied, you can do so and we can debate the merrits of that rule/law.

You should not get to decide on a specific group that the rules/laws should or should not get applied to.

[0] We do make illegal specific incitements to violence. But not the mere advocacy of violence.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by lern_too_spel on Thursday May 31, 2018 @11:36AM (#17197096)
> We shouldn't (and don't) jail people who advocate for the right to have sex with pre-pubescent children. Simmilarly, we shouldn't (and don't) jail people who advocate for the killing of all Jews [0]

But we should (and do) applaud when companies remove a platform for people who incite others to pedophilic abuses, and we should (and do) applaud when companies remove platforms for people inciting others to violent acts against groups.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Andre_Wanglin on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:28AM (#17194851)
Please dispute a single fact.

In fact, your comment is a lie as my first "contribution" was a simple one-line assertion based on information I happened to be aware of.[0] It was only after being prodded for substantiation that I bothered to type a whopping 3+ paragraphs of facts relating to the matter under discussion.

[0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16728884

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by michaelt on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:27AM (#17194843)
malcolmgreaves didn't say anything about _poor_ white students.

And it's well established that parents income and education level has a strong correlation with children's education and outcomes [1].

Of course, it's confusing to bring that into a discussion of this article, as the article says "Even accounting for a host of background factors, the achievement gap [between white and black students] remains large and statistically significant"

[1] http://educationnext.org/how-family-background-influences-st...

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Andre_Wanglin on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:34AM (#17194869)
Yes, poor white students contribute to the black-white achievement gap despite being poor. That is precisely why I brought up that population.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by bo0tzz on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:53AM (#17194703)
They might not receive it for free, but they do receive it. Thus in the end there's still a gap.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Andre_Wanglin on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:42AM (#17194903)
Please substantiate your claim that poor white students receive these benefits, to include "twice as much" schooling.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by WillPostForFood on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:04AM (#17194744)
There is more to it than that, they try to isolate the effect of the school from social programs.

There are two pieces of evidence that, taken together, suggest that high quality schools are enough to significantly increase the achievement of poor minority students (see also Atila Abdulkadiroglu et al. (2009) and Angrist et al. (2010)). First, students who live outside the Zone garner the same benefit from attending the Promise Academy as the students inside the Zone, suggesting that proximity to the community programs is not important. Second, siblings of Promise Academy students who have access to the same community programs but were ineligible for the Promise Academy because of their age show no detectable gains in achievement.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by your-nanny on Thursday May 31, 2018 @08:36AM (#17195801)
Nazis and white supremacists are not welcome here.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by your-nanny on Thursday May 31, 2018 @05:57PM (#17200673)
I was wrong. HN is totally open to posts by neoNazis and white supremacists
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by your-nanny on Saturday June 02, 2018 @11:40AM (#17215008)
As long as they're civil, HN makes it very clear that they welcome participation by people who historically have advocated mass genocide if Jews and the enslavement of bkacks
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by detaro on Saturday June 02, 2018 @11:43AM (#17215023)
Um, you have noticed that the account you're complaining about got banned?
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by your-nanny on Thursday May 31, 2018 @11:37AM (#17197102)
Andrew Anglin. Look him up. Nazis and white supremacists are not welcome here!
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by lopmotr on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:40AM (#17194896)
It doesn't make sense to me that all kids get the same education at the same pace even though they have different abilities. If someone learns slower, maybe they need more hours at school to learn the same material as someone who learns faster. And maybe they even need to skip some unimportant subjects to find that time. It would be great if every individual student somehow got a tailored program (impractical with conventional teaching, I know) so they could all reach a sufficient standard of education. Some geniuses might not even have to go to school if they can just flip through the book and ace the test on their own, while the labor saved teaching them could be spent on those who need more.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday May 31, 2018 @07:06AM (#17195434)
If you can flip through the book and learn to a particular level on your own then you don't need less schooling, you need schooling at a more appropriate level (in order to fulfill your intellectual drive/curiosity/etc.).
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Andre_Wanglin on Thursday May 31, 2018 @05:43AM (#17195117)
What does someone who has spent his academic career with a tailored education program that provides extra time to complete tasks and take tests do upon entering the workforce? Will employers go the extra mile to cater to his needs? Will the market do likewise for his business or product? If I could have taken as long as I wanted on the SAT, I probably would have been able to get a perfect score. But then I wouldn't have been taking the same test as everyone else, would I?
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by lopmotr on Thursday May 31, 2018 @09:39PM (#17201931)
If the goal of school is to get kids to learn the content of the curriculum, then that's not relevant. If you want to use it to assess how fast they learn or how intelligent they are, then that would have to be explicitly included as a goal before you designed the system. Perhaps employers and universities use school grades as a proxy for intelligence because it's convenient, but it's a little indirect. It would give falsely high scores to students who have good teachers or who hire private tutors.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by dnomad on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:30AM (#17194609)
> That is quite a bit more than high-quality schooling.

I'm not familiar with any legal or otherwise definition that constrains what services a school can and cannot provide. There are in fact high-quality boarding schools in Europe that provide all these services and more. (In fact they provide free housing to some of their students!)

> And does the touted "closing" of the black-white achievement gap persist if white students receive the same treatment?

Why be a coward, Andrew Anglin? Why don't you just come out and say what you mean?

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by sheepmullet on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:38AM (#17194644)
> I'm not familiar with any legal or otherwise definition that constrains what services a school can and cannot provide.

It is important to note in a study where the abstract suggests a community focused approach is not necessary.

They should put in the abstract: Community approach not necessary if you get the school to provide the most critical community offerings.

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Andre_Wanglin on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:37AM (#17194637)
You do realize that addressing the achievement gap is the point of both the school and the article, correct? It then makes sense to question if the gap might re-emerge if similar methods were applied to all students, does it not? I have no problem saying precisely what I mean to say.
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by dnomad on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:45AM (#17194674)
> It then makes sense to question if the gap might re-emerge if similar methods were applied to all students, does it not?

No, it doesn't make any sense. What do you think actually causes the gap? Is it some magical force inherent in white children?

They've shown they can eliminate the gap by addressing environmental issues like nutrition and providing more school time. That would indicate to a logical person that the gap is caused or at least correlated with precisely these deficiencies that were corrected. If other kids don't experience these deficiencies what would make you think more nutrition or more school time could increase their performance?

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by swebs on Thursday May 31, 2018 @07:31AM (#17195526)
>No, it doesn't make any sense. What do you think actually causes the gap? Is it some magical force inherent in white children?

You mean genetics?

Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by Andre_Wanglin on Thursday May 31, 2018 @04:01AM (#17194728)
How is spending twice as long at school correcting a deficiency? Are you sure you understand what a deficiency is? If spending twice as long at school can improve the results of the poor black students in this study, why shouldn't it do the same for white students? If it does, what happens to the achievement gap? How is this not a reasonable question? And do you really think being provided free medical care, dental care, mental health care, etc. is not qualitatively different than receiving the same from the fruit of the parents' labor?
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by lg on Thursday May 31, 2018 @09:19AM (#17196043)
i don’t think taxpayer provided medical etc care is any different than getting it from parents’ employer-provided (tax-code-subsidized) insurance or from inherited wealth from generations ago. in all cases it’s manna from heaven as far as young kids know. is there some problem with european or canadian children who get these things from a single-payer government scheme?
Re:High-quality schools can increase academic achievement am... by sheepmullet on Thursday May 31, 2018 @03:53AM (#17194702)
> What do you think actually causes the gap? Is it some magical force inherent in white children?

Why do you go straight to the absurd?

Can you not think of any other factors?

As an example what if poor early childhood nutrition maxes you out at a lower peak?

It is a fair question.