The perception problem is the same as air flight. If self driving cars can't be essentially accident free passengers will be filled with the anxiety of lack of control. Even if the self driving car is 99% safer than human operated cars it's a hard sell to the buyer when you face that 1% risk that the consumer doesn't perceive as being a mitigation toward their own driving safety skills.
Apologies for the incomprehensible last sentence, hope you get the gist though.
I sort of suspect Waymo would have been selling driverless cars a year ago if it weren't for this, actually.
Note, I include in self driving cases where there is a human seemingly in control, but the computer will override bad input and even take over all driving as needed..
Edit: originally this implied that it would be illegal to posses a manually driven car. Governments will not remove all the existing cars from the road that quick.
Take trains for example. No need to steer, have priority over anything else and basically can't brake.
Yet, a limited (and mostly subway) trains are self driving.
We have hardly any self 'driving' robots in day to day life. Those would be a lot slower and lighter.
Given that we have no industry standards for those kinds of things, it would be surprising if even one is considered safe enough in 10 years. Let alone that they would be mandated.
What makes them work at the moment is that they formally have to have a human in control. Same thing as an autopilot in a plane.
But a few more deadly mistakes and the whole concept may get scrapped.
Regulations are driven a lot by feelings and emotions.
In practice though if that happens there will be less people getting payed fat salaries to work on it, and then progress will probably slow, so the effect will be the same.
What the safety reality of self driving will be is of course an open question. The risk that someone else gets there and proves they are safer is too high for the big auto companies to ignore. Regulators already insist that all companies have any useful safety device when the device proves itself.
Note that the car companies are interconnected. The ones that are not investing in this technology have cross agreements with those that are.
I would watch for signs that one of the big companies deprioritizes internal research. I think it will be a lagging indicator that the self driving startup scene has cooled and they think that outside startup challengers will be underfunded and easy to buy or compete with. Right now it is accelerating in the opposite direction, but I don’t see why it has to if we don’t see progress in the next couple of years.
Of course they could have secret agreements that the governments don't know about, but cartels like this are a dangerous game that tend to backfire on the members. Each one that agrees has to play along, but if any one decides to work in secret they are first and get to scoop the competition and win. Since the agreement is already illegal under most national laws there is nothing that the others can do about the cheater.
In terms of politics, I see just deterioration in my region. We get technology we want (smartphones), but not what we need (carbon sequestration, better food sources). Our current tech is ruining the planet.
And as a developer, I see a lot of new and different, but little better. But that might be also connected to my world view already.
Based on what? Telsa hasn't even gotten driving on the highway correct. Uber is running down people in the streets.
Waymo's the only one claiming they think they can successfully test a completely driverless car. But we haven't seen any test results.
I'm not holding my breath. I grew up hearing people talk about how we would have Mars colonies by now. Imagine my surprise a couple of decades later when the shuttle program ended and the U.S. lost the ability to send people into space for a time.
The way I see it, the clock is ticking. If self-driving cars don't reach a certain level of capability soon, I suspect they simply won't; the technology will have plateaued at a point where it will not be viable in the foreseeable future. It'll be like supersonic flight: full of promise in the 1960s and 1970s, but mothballed for decades after that waiting for some engineering breakthrough to make it commercially viable.