News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by ckastner on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:51AM (#17152654)
> "The GDPR explicitly allows any data processing that is strictly necessary for the service - but using the data additionally for advertisement or to sell it on needs the users' free opt-in consent"

This is the key point. As the saying goes, on Facebook, you aren't the customer, you are the product.

The GDPR just changed this -- rightfully, in my opinion.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by dmortin on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:27AM (#17152909)
Somebody has to pay for it in the end, so Facebook could simply say "agree to targeted advertising and use the site for free or do not agree and pay a monthly fee for the site".
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by henrikschroder on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:38AM (#17153006)
Sign me up!

The sad truth though is that the users who are most likely to pay to get rid of ads, are also the users that are most valuable to advertisers, because that's a signal they have more money to spend than the rest.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by mortehu on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:50AM (#17153141)
You can disable Google's ad targeting at any time: https://adssettings.google.com/ You don't have to pay anything. What you get instead is untargeted ads, like ads for cars, potato chips, and shampoo, just like on TV. Personally I find those to be a lot more annoying.

Facebook's ad targeting can be similarly disabled under https://www.facebook.com/ads/preferences/?entry_product=ad_s...

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by blub on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:08AM (#17153826)
So... I have to be logged in or have a Google cookie in order to not be tracked by Google. This is complete bullshit and worthless for anyone using private browsing.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by kinsomo on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:05AM (#17153811)
> What you get instead is untargeted ads, like ads for cars, potato chips, and shampoo, just like on TV. Personally I find those to be a lot more annoying.

I'm genuinely curious: what's so much more annoying to you about untargeted ads? I've never found targeting to be effective at showing me ads that were genuinely better or less annoying.

I feel more comfortable with untargeted ads, since I can be much more confident nothing truly sneaky is going on, especially technology ever gets good enough to reliably manipulate me to buy more now.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by drusepth on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:30PM (#17155317)
>I've never found targeting to be effective at showing me ads that were genuinely better or less annoying.

I'm not the guy you're responding to, but I think the key difference is this statement. I had untargeted ads on for about a year and they were always irrelevant. Since returning to targeted ads, I now see things all the time that I'm at least mildly interested in (mostly startups and new services, and/or tools/software I want to try out).

I don't care if I'm being coaxed into buying more: the things they're tempting me with are legitimately interesting and I have the ultimate say on whether I buy it or not.

Untargeted ads don't give that choice: they're just always irrelevant to my interests.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by kinsomo on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:32PM (#17156032)
I consider most advertising-delivered information to be suspect. I find about things I'm interested in organically, through interest-based websites and the like.

In any case, except for a few specific circumstances, I've rigorously used ad-blocker so I haven't had to deal with any ads at all. The last ads that I have seen were on Facebook, but even it couldn't seem do a good job, even though it's purportedly the master of targeting

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by Reason077 on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:16AM (#17153902)
"What you get instead is untargeted ads, like ads for cars, potato chips, and shampoo, just like on TV. Personally I find those to be a lot more annoying."

Really? I kind of despise the targeted Ads. They're typically poor quality, and often it's some website I visited months ago to look at one product constantly dangling that product in my face in a desperate attempt for me to come back and buy it.

Show me the cars and potato chips, please!

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by birdmanjeremy on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:46AM (#17154805)
This is retargeting, and is pretty much the least sophisticated ad targeting out there.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by telchar on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:46PM (#17155470)
For me I don't really care whether ads are targeted or untargeted. It's the data collection they use to target the ads that's the real concern. I suspect that's true for most people but for some reason these discussions are typically framed as targeted vs untargeted, which IMO misses the point.

That said, I also really don't like seeing ads at all.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by CaptainZapp on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:11AM (#17153860)
Does this disable Facebook's data hoovering about you?

I wouldn't think so.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by sanxiyn on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:15AM (#17153341)
You can also disable Google's ads on some sites, https://contributor.google.com/

Sadly, Google Contributor is not available outside US. I am eagerly waiting for it.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by delecti on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:09AM (#17153285)
It also puts users in the mindset of starting to consider if their time on Facebook is worth $X/mo.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by dmortin on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:41AM (#17153034)
What if they say it's $20 a month? And it's just facebook. Google also asks for $20, Reddit too, etc.

It won't be cheap.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by letsgetphysITal on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:47AM (#17153104)
Google services with guaranteed no tracking and profiling?

$20 is cheap.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by ccozan on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:14AM (#17154460)
Huh? A Google Suite account is 4 euros a month. No tracking and profiling.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by xxs on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:48AM (#17153119)
So you are stipulating an account worth is 240USD a year at facebook? Instead of 20, why won't you say 100, make it round.

Seriously though, behemoths do fall and if facebook ceases to exist there will be no harm but good in my book.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by jhall1468 on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:38AM (#17153539)
I've seen this so many times, but if this future comes I think there will be a lot of angry ass people complaining about the $100s of dollars it costs to make the internet useful.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by adventured on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:24AM (#17153983)
Every recipe site runs on ads as one example. Now five million recipes across 1,000 prominent sites are to be locked behind paywalls, and you must pay $5 per month for access to each site due to the extreme drop in traffic they suffer (nobody is signing up to pay except at the largest sites, smaller sites have to charge more to make up for that, they implode accordingly).

The result: 973 of those sites disappear. Diversity of choice just collapsed. Starting a new recipe site or blog just got 100x more difficult. But hey, in Communist Internet, who needs lots of recipe sites.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by mynewtb on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:47AM (#17154203)
What do you think the creative work is for running a recipe site? And what about the technical work/costs?

I guess you mean the kind where either there are users providing those for free or it uses a huge number of compiled one, not some person inventing new ones.

I would wager that 970 of those sites can be run for virtually no cost, either maintained by loyal community or the wide internet.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by fiter on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:26AM (#17154600)
Many recipe sites are basically blogs, so yes, there is a lot of cost associated with each of them. I do not know if they tend to make money their money on ads or on books or on other methods.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by gkya on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:30AM (#17154637)
First of all, ethical ads are possible, and more so on a website already very targeted like a recipes website. I can easily guess what sorts of ads would be useful.

Furthermore, I agree the sibling commenter in that these sorts of websites usually just publish what community submits anyways, so we can have a bunch of wikis instead.

P.S.: Everybody should know the difference between trying to overcome the status quo which is selling yourself to companies and hoping that they do not abuse you, and things like communism or government overreach. And if businesses will lose money or get closed if they stop bad, malevolent practices of theirs, good riddance. Let the sanity get the better of them.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by dhimes on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:24AM (#17153430)
The number that's been kicked around for he value of North American user is about $50/year. So $5/month will cover it.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by CaptainZapp on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:13AM (#17153880)
The problem is that even if I pay Facebook this company is so utterly untrustworthy that I don't believe for one second that they wouldn't run their data sucking shenanigans on paid accounts.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by gkya on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:32AM (#17154661)
And that's why you want to have regulations. In the case you suggest, you could ask e.g. EFF if you suspected that they are abusing the contract, to sue FB in behalf of the users. Or even kick-start a big court case yourself.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by iainmerrick on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:01AM (#17154349)
I agree, but at least if the ad market is much smaller, the data will have that much less value.

Various companies will probably still gather and sell data for even more nefarious purposes, like manipulating elections, but that’s a different battle.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by adventured on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:30AM (#17154040)
That's not the number that is being kicked around.

Facebook will yield more than $100 per active user in the US and Canada for fiscal 2018. That's going to $200 from here over the next six or seven years (it doubled from 2015 to 2017). No meaningful number of users are paying $15 per month out of pocket for Facebook.

Google search is similarly worth a lot per user in the US. People would be irate if they had to pay $10 or $20 per month to use search engines after commonly enjoying the free utility of that for the last two decades.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by dhimes on Sunday May 27, 2018 @08:34AM (#17166656)
Last time someone claimed they knew the numbers I asked them to explain how. They disappeared without replying. So I'll ask you the same thing.

If you divide revenue by users you get between $1-$2 USD. I need to know how NA are 50-100 times that.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by maxerickson on Sunday May 27, 2018 @08:48AM (#17166689)
Facebook publishes revenue per MAU on page 37 of their 2017 annual report:

https://investor.fb.com/financials/default.aspx

Note that it is reported quarterly (I had some numbers but took them out when I realized I was using 1 quarter instead of the year).

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by dhimes on Sunday May 27, 2018 @03:31PM (#17168674)
OK thanks. Indeed, $100 isn't a bad number to use.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by lukeschlather on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:26PM (#17155272)
Per daily active user or monthly active user?

I also think it's conceivable in a more equitable arrangement with paid subscriptions that you could easily have a sizable number of paying users not being active in a given month.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by pjc50 on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:07AM (#17153264)
Are you saying the free market doesn't apply to pricing for these services?
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by sanxiyn on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:17AM (#17153359)
I am more than willing to pay $20 a month for both Google and Facebook. Do you hear me? Take my money!
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by wstrange on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:46AM (#17154194)
Google gsuite pricing is $5 / month for the basic version.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by burger_moon on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:06AM (#17153247)
I would actually pay a small amount to have a read-only account for facebook that doesn't track me at all. I don't want to post anything, but I would like to view stuff more easily on the platform. Especially since so many events are organized through fb.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by em3rgent0rdr on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:31PM (#17156013)
Have you tried the mobile site with JavaScript disabled. Or have to tried Facebook command line where you can simply query for posts in the terminal?
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by iainmerrick on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:52AM (#17154247)
That model already works for streaming TV! At least it’s working pretty well for Netflix, Amazon, HBO... (It’s definitely not ideal for viewers, but at least now it’s easy to get TV without ads.)
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by akerro on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:44AM (#17153074)
We already donate to reddit.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by p49k on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:12AM (#17153307)
I’m pretty sure Facebook can’t do that. The point of the GDPR, as I understand it, is to make control of your data a right which can’t be bargained away, much like employers can’t try to bargain away your right to sick leave.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by zerostar07 on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:20AM (#17153391)
depends really, the law says you can't deny service, but doesnt say you get to get the exact same service. I would expect the same for people who deny ad cookies - they 'll get more ads shown.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by moopling on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:53AM (#17154262)
I didn't think that was possible. Otherwise it would make determination of a fair price very messy -> In the extreme facebook could set an arbitraily high price if they didn't want to change their business model.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by RugnirViking on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:04PM (#17159950)
That would be a violation of the current policy. I don't wish to be rude, but it doesn't seem that hard to understand, and i'm a little surprised by the number of people making mistakes like this.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by Doxin on Monday May 28, 2018 @06:03AM (#17171595)
It's important to note that the GDPR doesn't ban ads without consent. It bans tracking users without consent.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by taysic on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:48PM (#17158776)
That's not possible with GDPR. You have to be able to access the same service 'without detriment' even if you do not want targeted advertising.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by belorn on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:38AM (#17153011)
Yes, but when that point hits hard enough maybe people will stop saying "Why do you not use Facebook/Gmail, it is free".

Now someone can actually try and compete with a free service. It might not work but its a step closer to happening. For example we have had open source federated social networks, and non-profits that ran email services.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by dmortin on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:42AM (#17153047)
That other free service also encounters the same dilemma. They have to pay for the site, so either they take your data or make you pay.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by simias on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:50AM (#17153134)
You can have ads without tracking. But frankly I'm 100% happy if you actually have a choice of "give your data or pay". It's a massive improvement over "give your data or don't use the service" or "give your data and pay" which is what we have today.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by dmortin on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:54AM (#17153164)
If people force the issue then I expect big sites will give you this option. But it won't be necessarily cheap, so most people will opt to use the free version instead.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by nothis on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:39AM (#17153014)
I’d happily pay.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by zerostar07 on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:01AM (#17152720)
yeah but now the product is not free.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by tazjin on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:06AM (#17152744)
It'd be great if companies offered a "buy back your privacy" subscription model. For the services I really don't want to stop using (Twitter ...) I'd definitely be using that.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by scrollaway on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:47AM (#17153112)
https://gsuite.google.com/

A lot of people don't seem to know that GSuite is both usable (useful, even) and affordable (cheap!) even if you are a solo user.

Here's a quick howto:

1. Go buy your own domain name (~$10/yr, https://www.gandi.net/). Make it something you like, something professional. This is for your personal email address. firstname@lastname is the most common pattern. I recommend everybody do this. Even if you want to stay on gmail, yahoo, aol or whatever you can set up redirects. This becomes an email address you truly own, and your email provider cannot hold you hostage anymore.

2. Create a new GSuite account ($5/mo, https://gsuite.google.com) - The entire setup is guided and completely painless if you're even slightly technically-aware.

3. Migrating from a previous Google account: You can use Google Takeout to get a lot of your data (https://takeout.google.com/). Unfortunately, migrating the data automatically is hard. For email you can set up IMAP from gmail, for Drive there's migration scripts. But you also don't have to migrate immediately, Google is good at multiple accounts.

I know I'm sounding like a Google shill right now, but GSuite really is what people tend to ask for when they talk about Google's handling of data and say they'd pay $5/month to "regain their privacy". Well, here's your occasion to do so.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by Macha on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:53AM (#17153151)
Is GSuite better from a privacy perspective? It doesn't show ads in gmail, but I'm pretty sure they're still tracking you and feeding that into ads on youtube etc.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by beberlei on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:02AM (#17153224)
from the DPA that you can sign with Google with regard to GSuite:

> 5.2 Scope of Processing. > 5.2.1 Customer’s Instructions. By entering into this Data Processing Amendment, > Customer instructs Google to process Customer Personal Data only in accordance > with applicable law: (a) to provide the Services and related technical support; (b) as > further specified via Customer’s use of the Services (including the Admin Console > and other functionality of the Services) and related technical support; (c) as > documented in the form of the applicable Agreement, including this Data Processing > Amendment; and (d) as further documented in any other written instructions given > by Customer and acknowledged by Google as constituting instructions for purposes > of this Data Processing Amendment.

So no, they probably can't track and feed that into youtube ads, because it is not a cause that provides the service or support.

Afaik Google announced last year that they stopped processing GSuite account emails to a large degree.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by dvfjsdhgfv on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:08AM (#17153277)
> Afaik Google announced last year that they stopped processing GSuite account emails to a large degree.

Well, that's surely reassuring.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by heartbreak on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:20AM (#17153386)
> This becomes an email address you truly own, and your email provider cannot hold you hostage anymore.

It's hardly yours. Using a custom domain for anything sensitive like banking is not a good idea. Your registrar is almost certainly a lot easier to phish/social engineer/whatever than Google.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by scrollaway on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:13AM (#17154444)
> Your registrar is almost certainly a lot easier to phish/social engineer/whatever than Google.

Please don't spread unsourced FUD. I'm not saying registrars are perfect (although Gandi, which I linked, has an impeccable track record), but everyone uses registrars for their domain name, even the biggest businesses out there.

If you have a problem with a particular registrar, I invite you to source it and share it. But the general idea that the potential for a point of attack makes the email "not yours" is nonsensical.

What matters is the email address you give out to people. Where that email is stored and ends up doesn't matter. Which registrar owns the domain doesn't matter.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by heartbreak on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:25PM (#17155267)
I'm not spreading FUD. I'm spreading Maciej Ceglowski's information: https://techsolidarity.org/resources/congressional_howto.htm...

@pinboard has explained on Twitter that registrars can get tricked into letting an attacker into your domain account (of course they can). And from there they can update your zone file to send your mail wherever they want.

This isn't about the storage of your email.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by scrollaway on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:03PM (#17156885)
Even if such an attack were to take place, that doesn't mean you don't "own" your email. You own it far more than an @gmail.com address...
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by buzer on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:58AM (#17154959)
> but everyone uses registrars for their domain name, even the biggest businesses out there.

Everyone uses registrars, but in some cases you can be your own registrar. Like in Finland, when .fi domain registrations were moved to exclusively to registrars (initially you would register domains with Finnish FCC equivalent, later option was added to let registrar handle that for you and finally it was moved to just registrars), quite a few companies and individuals registered to become registrar for .fi domain.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by mynewtb on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:50AM (#17154227)
a) 2FA for your bank account

b) Who is going through all the trouble to target me specifically with a phishing attempt.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by stubish on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:01AM (#17153207)
Where does it say that paying for GSuite means that Google stops invading your privacy? I can't find it, and can only assume the only difference is you don't see the ads.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by Anderkent on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:37AM (#17152997)
The users that can afford and would buy this service are exactly the ones that advertisers want to reach. If you stop showing them ads or only share data for people not willing to pay, the data becomes useless.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by anonymouz on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:07AM (#17153267)
Tough luck.

There is no fundamental right allowing tracking or advertising.

There is a fundamental right to privacy.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by Anderkent on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:09PM (#17155731)
Right, but what this means is a business often can't support itself via a mix of subscription and ads - if you offer both for the same content the value of your adds will likely crash, so it's mostly equivalent to just being subscription based
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by gaius on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:09AM (#17152758)
They would take your money and track you anyway, and everyone knows it
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by tazjin on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:12AM (#17152790)
And be fined into oblivion.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by amelius on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:43AM (#17153054)
How would anyone find out, and provide proof for this?

Can we expect a EU government agency to validate companies on a regular basis? And if not, would they even cooperate with white-hat hackers to find offenders?

Also, from what I read, data protection agencies have been understaffed and overworked for years now.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by pjc50 on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:10AM (#17153292)
Tracking which doesn't result in any visible effect to the users is fairly harmless. The more concerning stuff involves handing the data to third parties like direct marketers and political campaigns. Those commercial relationships are a lot harder to hide and generate a paper trail.

"Why did this company pay you $x million?"

".. stuff?"

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by tomatotomato37 on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:23AM (#17153417)
When in doubt, make it a consulting fee
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by Aunche on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:45AM (#17154183)
You can choose to be paranoid about everything if you want to. Maybe your dentist is drilling fake cavities or your lawyer is giving you bad advice so you spend more money.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by rinze on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:20AM (#17152851)
It wasn't before either. You were just paying with a different currency.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by dangerface on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:08AM (#17152751)
Good now they have to make it worth paying for.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by VMG on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:33AM (#17152958)
The GDPR ensures that only Facebook will be able to comply, and prospective competitors shouldn't even bother.

The regulation counts 58 000 words.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by michaelbuckbee on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:54AM (#17153165)
The regulation's big but it's probably not larger than a sprawling API documentation, etc. and you approach it the same way: just read what you need.

IIRC almost _half_ of the actual regulation is about what and how the member countries should set up their internal supervisory authorities and the rest is similarly specific.

There are innumerable checklists, summaries and guides on how to deal with GDPR as well.

The two I like are:

https://blog.varonis.com/gdpr-requirements-list-in-plain-eng...

and

https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-da...

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by SmellyGeekBoy on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:38AM (#17153008)
I see so many people parroting this but I just don't get it. Surely it won't be a problem at all for a new startup handling data correctly from day 1? Facebook has a mountain of historical data that was collected using non-GDRP-compliant methods that now falls foul of EU law.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by VMG on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:45AM (#17153079)
You need somebody that knows the regulations and developers that are capable of auditing the whole system. That's added fixed costs, which is an advantage for incumbents.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by dvfjsdhgfv on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:07AM (#17153261)
But these regulations are not that complicated! Heck, in the EU we've been observing most of them in the last years already. Most things are really straightforward. Things get complicated when your core business is making users' data available to third parties. But it's not different from any other business: if you want to make money in catering for example, you need to read and adhere to relevant laws, too.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by VMG on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:31AM (#17153485)
Is an IP address PII or not? I have read multiple different interpretations today.

Is a hash of an IP address PII?

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by dvfjsdhgfv on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:48AM (#17153639)
Is this really that complex? If it can be linked to the individual, then it is. https://www.whitecase.com/publications/alert/court-confirms-...
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by kodablah on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:58AM (#17153737)
So IP + timestamp of my ticket system logs is invalid because I also have a timestamp of ticket updates by a user. Actually, just IP because I have a timestamp on the log file. So the latest line has an IP, so I can take the file timestamp and see the latest ticket comment and now I've linked it to an individual. You're right, this is easy. Even easier now that I can't think of a way of storing an IP without the ability to at least correlate the latest one.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by dvfjsdhgfv on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:20AM (#17153949)
> So IP + timestamp of my ticket system logs is invalid

What makes it "invalid"? If you can identify a person by their IP, then the IP becomes a part of their personal data. For most websites it's irrelevant, because people just visit and leave. But if someone signs in with their real name, you just need to update the ToS saying that apart from their other data you also store their IP. How complicated is that?

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by kodablah on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:33AM (#17154063)
Ok, just update the ToS. No ability needed to provide opt out of that IP collection? No ability needed to go, upon request, and delete all these IP+timestamp logs that I could use to correlate with their name? Handwaving all of this stuff away as clear and easy is at the least ignorant to real people's concerns and at most willfully dishonest.
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by dvfjsdhgfv on Saturday May 26, 2018 @05:02AM (#17160995)
How can anyone "opt out of that IP collection"? It's not the way the Internet works: logging is an essential part of of its infrastructure (and in certain jurisdictions it's required by law). The only problem is if the IP is associated with personal data. If the user really wants to remove it, they can remove their personal data, and in this way the problem disappears.

On the other hand, if you plan to sell the IPs associated with some other data to a third party that can easily link it to people (Google and Facebook can), you may want to consult a lawyer.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by DanBC on Saturday May 26, 2018 @05:04AM (#17161005)
Can you point to the bit of the law that requires website owners to delete data upon request? Or the bit of the law that requires website owners to ask for consent to gather IP addresses?
Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by VMG on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:44AM (#17154167)
Writing style can be linked to individuals.

Can I still have a forum where users submit text?

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by forgottenpass on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:23AM (#17153419)
I love all these posts that assume because they've never been on a software that team that makes compliance part of their job, that it's completely outside the grasp of a small team.

Those of us in fields regulated prior to GDPR are laughing at you.

Re:Google and Facebook accused of breaking GDPR laws by turtle4 on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:11AM (#17153854)
Is that what they are saying though? I'm not reading it as 'small teams can't comply'. I'm reading it as if you comply, you will make less money advertising, and that affects the dynamics in a social app.

If you have to charge money, your chance to overcome the network effect of FB or an established site is difficult, because en masse migration of users to a new service typically goes hand in hand with that new service being offered freely.

Conversely if you don't charge money, your ability to fund the development of a competitor is based on reduced ad income since you can't offer targeted ads, which is going to shorten your runway by a significant amount.

These two things seem to indicate that the likelihood of building something that replaces one of the existing social services goes down. I don't think it makes it impossible, but the law seems to make it less likely that the social app incumbents get replaced (if that was at all possible).

As far as those in other regulated fields having done this for some time, I can't think of many regulated fields where the network effect is so high as social apps, so it is probably a bit apples to oranges. Presumably it is not as large a deal in those markets where social network dynamic is not as strong.