News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by sunflowerfly on Monday May 21, 2018 @10:38PM (#17123377)
Bringing the same rules to light aircraft as airliners has actually made them less safe. Bringing a new four place plane to market has been cost prohibitive. The majority of new planes built today were designed in the 50’s on slide rules. Imagine if we were all still driving 50’s era automobiles. Luckily, the FAA loosened these rules this week.
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by lisper on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:43AM (#17124129)
> The majority of new planes built today were designed in the 50’s on slide rules.

That's not true.

Of the 15 most popular light aircraft models built in 2015, only one was introduced in the 1950s: the Cessna 172. And even that one underwent a pretty substantial overhaul in 1998. The most popular light plane sold in 2015 was the Cirrus SR22 with 270 units sold. The SR22 debuted in 2001.

Source: http://www.fi-aeroweb.com/General-Aviation.html

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by hansthehorse on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @03:21AM (#17124254)
And costs upwards of 600 thousand new.
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by romwell on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @05:57PM (#17129748)
>Of the 15 most popular light aircraft models built in 2015, only one was introduced in the 1950s: the Cessna 172.

It's disingenuous to say that and not talk about numbers. There were over 44 thousand of them built, and they are literally the most produced aircraft ever. Cirrus is a blip on the radar compared to Cessna.

At 300 planes/year they will not catch up with Cessna in a century even if Cessna ceased to exist today!

In fact, the top six most produced civilian aircraft ever that are still in production are[1]:

Cessna 172 (1950's)

Piper PA-28 (1960's)

Cessna 182 (1950's)

Cessna 152 (1950's)

Antonov AN-2 (1950's)

Beechcraft Bonanza (1950's)

Do you have the statistics on the market share of the "slide-rule" planes today? Not as a percentage of planes being built or sold, but of the ones in service. I'd bet on them being the majority.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most-produced_aircraft

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by lisper on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @06:10PM (#17129823)
No, it is not disingenuous because the topic at hand is "the majority of new planes built today."

Obviously if you look at production through all of aviation history you are going end up overweight in older models. But that is just a reflection of the fact that planes are generally designed and built to last. It has nothing to do with the current state of the art, which is what the OP was lamenting.

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by romwell on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @12:43AM (#17131533)
OK. You are correct, you have refuted the point that the majority of planes built today are of older designs.

The point we were discussing is that excessive regulation on light aircraft prevents innovation by driving the cost prohibitively up and thus leading to a decrease in sales of new designs.

It is not clear to me that the argument that the industry overall is less safer is invalid if most of the planes flown are old, and if over-regulation of light aircraft is the cause of that.

We do need the statistics on the numbers of old-design planes in the air, together with the pricing data, statistics on sales which include old planes, etc.

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by lisper on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @03:42AM (#17132071)
Wow, new planes cost more than old planes. Who knew?
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by romwell on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @04:54PM (#17138174)
New planes today cost more than new planes used to cost back in the day (accounting for inflation), which creates more demand for older planes.

Cessna 172 cost under $9000 in 1956 when it was introduced, which is about $80K today when accounted for inflation.

Do you know of any similar new aircraft in the same ballpark? Last time I checked, $50K still gets a Cessna 172 built in the 70's. A new Cessna 172 seems to be north of $250K, depending on configuration.

Cirrus SR22 is north of $550K.

Civil aviation has definitely become a richer man's game over the past 5 decades; the question is why this happened.

To be clear: a middle-class enthusiast really can't afford to buy the best-selling plane of the year new today, while that was a realistic option in the 1950's.

1. Do you not think this is bad?

2. What do you think are the causes of that?

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by lisper on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @05:33PM (#17138531)
These are very different topics from the original one under discussion, and much more complex. I don't know why it should matter to you what I think about this, but since you asked, no, I don't think the increased cost of aircraft is bad. Aviation is a very environmentally destructive pastime, so high barriers to entry are a good thing.

As to your second question, liability concerns and government regulations certainly add a lot to the cost of an airplane. But the flip side of that is that modern airplanes tend to be pretty darn safe. As a pilot, I think that's a good thing too.

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by claudius on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:16AM (#17123879)
But the problem with that is not so much that it creates a market for old airplanes but rather that airplane certifications don’t expire – if the 50’s planes you allude to had to obey the same standards as new planes (after some grace interval of e.g. 10 years), the problem could be solved?
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @08:29AM (#17125405)
You say that, but the same can be said about cars - you can still drive a car from the 50's, even if it no longer meets current-day safety standards (notably, rollover protection and environmental standards). Older vehicles, be it cars or planes, will retire naturally because maintenance eventually becomes prohibitively expensive.
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by candiodari on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @10:02AM (#17125972)
This ignores that, unlike cars, 1950s planes are built from scratch today.

Meet the most popular aircraft in history: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cessna_172

The only updates are new engines, the aircraft's control is not just analog, it's literally "planks moved by pulling on wires".

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by microcolonel on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:24AM (#17124070)
> But the problem with that is not so much that it creates a market for old airplanes but rather that airplane certifications don’t expire

It seems to me that the problem here is that new airplanes are cost prohibitive. Your solution to light aircraft safety is to make the majority of light aviation illegal or too expensive to function, like solving the problem of unstylish watches by outlawing anything cheaper than a Rolex.

People seem to have the impression that GA has to be safer than driving, or safer than some other benchmark, before the safety level is acceptable. I am perfectly willing to accept some risk (the raw rate of fatality per ground mile is about 20x higher for GA vs. driving) even as a passenger, and I don't see why the FAA should be in the business of determining what risk is acceptable to passengers. I think the FAA's primary responsibility should be to the broader public, who experience the same risks on the ground regardless of how much or little GA they buy, rely on, or associate with.

Some of the FARs make a lot of sense in this regard, for example the rules for single-occupant ultralight aircraft (including powered paragliders), and ideally a similarly pragmatic approach can be applied to other questions in aviation regulation.

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by adrianN on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @04:00AM (#17124362)
When planes crash they might fall on houses. That seems like a good reason to me to make them a lot safer than cars.
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by candiodari on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @10:03AM (#17125975)
Luckily, when cars crash (or just dride) they never hit anything like houses or people.

Oh wait ...

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by microcolonel on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @08:16AM (#17125346)
Well, also consider that you don't make GA safer than driving by regulating it. A lot of GA can be compared with the kind of unconventional driving done on remote or logging roads. GA is pretty safe where driving is also safe.
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by 8note on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:21PM (#17123488)
That's assuming that over those years, the market would select for safer flights and not cheaper ones at the expense of safety.
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by paulddraper on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:52AM (#17123804)
No. It's assuming that modern tech is safer and more reliable. (A debatable assumption, but also a pretty fair one.)

Anyone that's ever looked to buy private planes knows that, except very small instructional aircraft, most are 40+ years old. My father-in-law just put an offer on an 8-seater built in the 1960s. And that's pretty much just the way it is for buying airplanes. It requires old tech and frequent maintenance, but it's still cheaper than the alternative.

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by selectodude on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:03AM (#17123643)
The issue is that non-commercial aircraft are being held to the same standard as a 777, not that the 777 is held to an extremely high standard. There's nothing safe about a Cessna 172, period, and it's far too expensive for them to redesign it. So it's going to continue to be a 60 year old plane with updated avionics.
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by tdubhro1 on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:26AM (#17123909)
> There's nothing safe about a Cessna 172

Genuine question: is the 172 really considered unsafe, googling "cessna 172 safety record" brings up a lot of articles suggesting it is as safe or safer than comparable aircraft - or are you saying that light private aircraft aren't very safe in general?

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by cjrp on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:16AM (#17124050)
Not specific to the 172, but a sizeable part of the training when getting your license is about what do when the engine stops (gliding, finding a suitable field/road/etc.) - and if you fly long enough there's a fairly good chance you'll have to put what you learned into practise.
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by anfilt on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:41AM (#17124122)
You do realize most airplane crashes are small planes.
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by paulddraper on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @09:37AM (#17125799)
And most automotive crashes are non-commercial vehicles as well.
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by John_KZ on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @07:02AM (#17125047)
>There's nothing safe about a Cessna 172

I assume you have nothing to do with aviation. The Cessna 172 is extremely safe. In fact I'd argue that they're safer than commercial flights, because accidents are much more survivable. Safety depends purely on the pilot and the extremely well-documented maintenance routines. All accidents I've ever heard of Cessnas are caused by pilot error with minor exceptions.

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by selectodude on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @10:43AM (#17126213)
Planes crashing due to pilot error is unsafe. Cars brake themselves now, Pipers have parachutes, B777s have redundancy on redundancy. The Cessna 172 is a very old design. Surviving an accident due to going too slow to die isn't "safe".
Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by John_KZ on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @11:22AM (#17126554)
>Cars brake themselves now

Uber clearly doesn't follow this trend. Neither does Volvo, apparently https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_47utWAoupo

>Pipers have parachutes

Only because they're prone to a certain unrecoverable spin in some configurations. You can get a ballistic chute on a Cessna too if you like.

>The Cessna 172 is a very old design

That's because it's a great design, and one that has been tested for 50 years. I'd take it over modern ones.

>Surviving an accident due to going too slow to die isn't "safe".

It is if you don't die.

Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light by forapurpose on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:28AM (#17123916)
> Bringing a new four place plane to market has been cost prohibitive. ... the FAA loosened these rules this week

Is there any independent research that supports this? I've often heard the argument that regulations are too expensive as an excuse for lowering standards.