That's not true.
Of the 15 most popular light aircraft models built in 2015, only one was introduced in the 1950s: the Cessna 172. And even that one underwent a pretty substantial overhaul in 1998. The most popular light plane sold in 2015 was the Cirrus SR22 with 270 units sold. The SR22 debuted in 2001.
It's disingenuous to say that and not talk about numbers. There were over 44 thousand of them built, and they are literally the most produced aircraft ever. Cirrus is a blip on the radar compared to Cessna.
At 300 planes/year they will not catch up with Cessna in a century even if Cessna ceased to exist today!
In fact, the top six most produced civilian aircraft ever that are still in production are[1]:
Cessna 172 (1950's)
Piper PA-28 (1960's)
Cessna 182 (1950's)
Cessna 152 (1950's)
Antonov AN-2 (1950's)
Beechcraft Bonanza (1950's)
Do you have the statistics on the market share of the "slide-rule" planes today? Not as a percentage of planes being built or sold, but of the ones in service. I'd bet on them being the majority.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most-produced_aircraft
Obviously if you look at production through all of aviation history you are going end up overweight in older models. But that is just a reflection of the fact that planes are generally designed and built to last. It has nothing to do with the current state of the art, which is what the OP was lamenting.
The point we were discussing is that excessive regulation on light aircraft prevents innovation by driving the cost prohibitively up and thus leading to a decrease in sales of new designs.
It is not clear to me that the argument that the industry overall is less safer is invalid if most of the planes flown are old, and if over-regulation of light aircraft is the cause of that.
We do need the statistics on the numbers of old-design planes in the air, together with the pricing data, statistics on sales which include old planes, etc.
Cessna 172 cost under $9000 in 1956 when it was introduced, which is about $80K today when accounted for inflation.
Do you know of any similar new aircraft in the same ballpark? Last time I checked, $50K still gets a Cessna 172 built in the 70's. A new Cessna 172 seems to be north of $250K, depending on configuration.
Cirrus SR22 is north of $550K.
Civil aviation has definitely become a richer man's game over the past 5 decades; the question is why this happened.
To be clear: a middle-class enthusiast really can't afford to buy the best-selling plane of the year new today, while that was a realistic option in the 1950's.
1. Do you not think this is bad?
2. What do you think are the causes of that?
As to your second question, liability concerns and government regulations certainly add a lot to the cost of an airplane. But the flip side of that is that modern airplanes tend to be pretty darn safe. As a pilot, I think that's a good thing too.
Meet the most popular aircraft in history: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cessna_172
The only updates are new engines, the aircraft's control is not just analog, it's literally "planks moved by pulling on wires".
It seems to me that the problem here is that new airplanes are cost prohibitive. Your solution to light aircraft safety is to make the majority of light aviation illegal or too expensive to function, like solving the problem of unstylish watches by outlawing anything cheaper than a Rolex.
People seem to have the impression that GA has to be safer than driving, or safer than some other benchmark, before the safety level is acceptable. I am perfectly willing to accept some risk (the raw rate of fatality per ground mile is about 20x higher for GA vs. driving) even as a passenger, and I don't see why the FAA should be in the business of determining what risk is acceptable to passengers. I think the FAA's primary responsibility should be to the broader public, who experience the same risks on the ground regardless of how much or little GA they buy, rely on, or associate with.
Some of the FARs make a lot of sense in this regard, for example the rules for single-occupant ultralight aircraft (including powered paragliders), and ideally a similarly pragmatic approach can be applied to other questions in aviation regulation.
Oh wait ...
Anyone that's ever looked to buy private planes knows that, except very small instructional aircraft, most are 40+ years old. My father-in-law just put an offer on an 8-seater built in the 1960s. And that's pretty much just the way it is for buying airplanes. It requires old tech and frequent maintenance, but it's still cheaper than the alternative.
Genuine question: is the 172 really considered unsafe, googling "cessna 172 safety record" brings up a lot of articles suggesting it is as safe or safer than comparable aircraft - or are you saying that light private aircraft aren't very safe in general?
I assume you have nothing to do with aviation. The Cessna 172 is extremely safe. In fact I'd argue that they're safer than commercial flights, because accidents are much more survivable. Safety depends purely on the pilot and the extremely well-documented maintenance routines. All accidents I've ever heard of Cessnas are caused by pilot error with minor exceptions.
Uber clearly doesn't follow this trend. Neither does Volvo, apparently https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_47utWAoupo
>Pipers have parachutes
Only because they're prone to a certain unrecoverable spin in some configurations. You can get a ballistic chute on a Cessna too if you like.
>The Cessna 172 is a very old design
That's because it's a great design, and one that has been tested for 50 years. I'd take it over modern ones.
>Surviving an accident due to going too slow to die isn't "safe".
It is if you don't die.
Is there any independent research that supports this? I've often heard the argument that regulations are too expensive as an excuse for lowering standards.
Vehicles are already regulated with regards to safety features; seat-belts, airbags, anti-lock braking systems etc. These have and do prevent many deaths and serious injuries.
But holding cars to the same mechanical rigors as airplanes would make them neigh unaffordable for most, to say nothing of yearly inspections many states have which is often considered nothing more than a government subsidy to mechanic shops. It is also entirely unnecessary, as when a car has a mechanical failure, it can just roll to a stop.
As for preventing accidents in the first place, car crashes, as with plane crashes, are caused overwhelmingly by operator error.
For engines, yes, but it's scary how many people don't maintain their brakes properly. Or otherwise drive vehicles that are unsafe to be on the road.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Justrolledintotheshop/
There's a reason why many states, particularly northern and road salt states, have mandatory inspections.
There's also very good reasons why state patrols and the DOT do mandatory inspections of larger cargo trucks.
Obviously a car does not need to be maintained to the same standard and expense as a light aircraft. If you fuck up your own clutch it's nobody's problem but your own wallet.
At least in my experience, it seems every single year the shop states they won't pass the car unless some of the brakes are replaced. I suspect in this case they are just bald-face lying, as recently I balked at yet another ~$600 maintenance charge to pass a routine inspection, took the car to a friends shop out of town, and was able to conclude that the original shop never even checked the brakes, as the wheels took _a lot_ of force to remove once the lug nuts were off.
Similarly with emissions checks. It often turns into nothing more than a yearly tax on your vehicle and does nothing to improve anyone's safety.
That's why most states have an emissions test (to address the negative externality that individual drivers don't feel a cost to emit pollutants, but society does pay that cost) and a safety test. Most states do not have a general mechanical test. (The definition of what part of 'mechanical' is also 'safety' is not a bright line, so if you're arguing the safety tests sometimes go too far, maybe that's right -- we could ask an actuary who has the data I suppose.)
Also don't install a 5 point harness without a proper roll cage you will be asking for trouble.
The FAA seems to be relatively OK with the current annual fatality rate for light-sport aircraft, homebuilt experimental licensed aircraft, and light aircraft in the size range of the Cessna 172. For pilots with less than 1000 hours, flying a light single engine aircraft is a relatively dangerous activity on a per-hour basis.
If human spaceflight had the same number of annual fatalities as the current number deaths in the US 48 states while flying homebuilt/kit/light sport aircraft, both NASA and the news media would be freaking out.
NASA is requiring spacex to put the Falcon9 and Dragon2 through a very expensive and rigorous period of qualification before it can carry humans on commercial launch contracts. The likelihood that there will be a totally catastrophic disaster that the launch escape system can't recover from is low, but the standard of safety (in terms of flight-hours per human per year) seems to be much, much higher than the FAA's.
Space flight is spectacularly dangerous, and US launch vehicles have a particularly gnarly safety record. Some paranoia is probably warranted.
Challenger and Columbia were lost due to institutional ineptitude. The engineers that were the manufacturer of the SRBs on Challenger specifically warned against the cold temperatures and were overruled. People noticed the foam shedding issue with the space shuttle many years before the Columbia incident. The space shuttle was a catastrophic clusterfuck of a pork barrel political design. There was actually no launch escape system or possibility of recovery from early launch phase anomaly once the SRBs were lit, until they burned out (unlike the launch escape system on Soyuz, Apollo, Dragon2, etc).
The space shuttle had a ridiculous number of moving parts and degree of complexity compared to a Dragon2 on a Falcon9 (or a Soyuz on top of its booster)
The soviet union and russia have had zero fatalities since Soyuz 11 in 1971. I would actually venture that at this point it might be statistically safer to fly along as a passenger in a modern Soyuz mission than to fly as a second passenger in some sub-500-hour pilot's kitbuilt piper cub clone.
But Wikipedia tells me that the next Soyuz to go up will be #142, counting from Gagarin. In the hypothetical world where (say) the Mir crisis had been fatal, Soyuz would have a lifetime success rate almost exactly the same as the Shuttle's.
Even if the new ones are much better, we don't have the statistical power to say. Gimme the kitbuilt Piper any day.
The Soyuz-success/failure manned rate is about the same as the space shuttle, though a bit higher but with successful escapes and launch aborts. If you start comparing casualties the space shuttle loses massively as only 4 cosmonauts have died, all in the decent stage (either crashed or died on entry) with the R7 and derivatives as launch vehicles and Suyuz or Voskhod as name.
To be fair, the total of the R7 family (which is skewed since there are way more failures in the early days than after the 1990's for all kinds of rockets) is 137 vs 1755 or about 7 % vs the 1.5% of the space shuttle.
I ride motorcycles, and am personally fully aware of the fact that this mode of transport makes me to a first approximation 10 times as likely to die on the road compared to driving a car, and I'm happy to accept that risk for myself.
(Probably because I have enough hubris to believe I can make a significant difference there by being more skillful and less reckless than all those _other_ motorcycle riders - which I believe psychologists refer to as "illusory superiority"...)
What a nonsensical statement. If light sport aircraft had as many fatalities as the current number of deaths in the US 48 states while driving/walking/biking, both the FAA and the news media would be freaking out.
And, as pointed out, spaceflight is actually significantly more dangerous than light sport aircraft, so I'm not so sure that the "standard of safety [...] seems to be much, much higher than the FAA's."
These are not remarked upon outside of local news. Three people die in an experimental category airplane crash, makes the local news. If three people were to die in a spacecraft accident, national media would freak the fuck out.
I disagree; there are ongoing, successful efforts to make driving, walking down the street (see Vision Zero for example), and many more activities safer. We haven't accepted the risk levels at all.
But the existence of awareness campaigns proves the point: Someone has to connect the dots on the statistics and then advocate to get people to care. Nobody needs to advocate for more coverage of spacefaring fatalities.
These aren't campaigns to build awareness, but to change laws, training, etc.
> Someone has to connect the dots on the statistics and then advocate to get people to care
People need to know about something in order to care about it. I'm not sure what that means.
> Nobody needs to advocate for more coverage of spacefaring fatalities.
Right; those are sensational and get lots of coverage.
I don't disagree with your sentiment about the FAA. I don't believe autonomous cars are being held to a higher standard needlessly.
But, it's good to step back and recognize every now and then that every Federal Aviation Regulation (FAR, 14 CFR) is written in blood. The FAA can be a pain to deal with sometimes but every pilot I know is very, very glad that they do what they do.
* https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/ViewPublication/...
The human should watch out. On the other hand, the pothole should be fixed.
It is probably typical to have multiple factors, making it easy to bend the numbers to one's liking.
But at what cost? Ground transportation wouldn't be very useful if we couldn't afford it
Sure, "human life is sacred" and all that but that's kind of a first world problem you don't get to care about except when you already have infrastructure that's good enough for most use cases.
>Ironically self-driving is held to a much higher standard than regular driving; which is appreciated but further makes one question why regular "dumb" vehicles are so under-regulated
Design and construction of new vehicles is subject to a large and ever increasing amount of regulation. It just doesn't make the news when a FMVSS gets updated to require that brake hoses meet a later revision of some SAE spec which specifies a more rigorous QC procedure.
Regarding maintenance, some negligible fraction (I've heard 6%, "less than 1%" and 0.5%) is caused by mechanical failure. If mechanical failure caused a meaningful portion of crashes you'd see insurance companies harping on about it and offering elective inspection programs in non-inspection states.
Either drunk, speeding, not paying attention, deliberately being a bellend, etc?
If anything that just means the licensing process should be stricter - not specifically a change in the cars themselves.
With self-driving cars the car is the driver so of course it has to be more strictly controlled - it has to make decisions.
If driving/vehicles/roads were held to the same or a similar standards to aircraft there might be fewer accidents and deaths today.
Ironically self-driving is held to a much higher standard than regular driving; which is appreciated but further makes one question why regular "dumb" vehicles are so under-regulated (the analogy that springs to my mind is when HTTPS with a self-signed certificate used to be treated much worse than regular HTTP, it took years to treat HTTP as the insecure connection it is, manual vehicles are the same way, something that has been around so long we ignore its safety issues).