In the industry there is always a high safety factor when it comes to designing systems with human lives at risk. The same applies to something like elevators. Multiple suspension cables can snap and the power can go out and the elevator can still run.
Did you just assume that? Because I'm pretty sure that a folded wingtip in flight would result in a nearly unstoppable spiral of death.
Here's the story of the F-15 that was landed with an entire wing missing:
https://theaviationist.com/2014/09/15/f-15-lands-with-one-wi...
Parts of wings missing, engines falling off etc. happen. What wasn't survivable was the thrust reversers deploying in-flight:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lauda_Air_Flight_004
Oh, I stand corrected: "As evidence started to point towards the thrust reversers as the cause of the accident, simulator flights were made at Gatwick Airport which appeared to show that deployment of a thrust reverser was a survivable incident. Lauda said that the thrust reverser could not be the sole cause of the crash"
The Lauda incident was "survivable" in the sense that they had a 3-second window to realize that the reverse thruster was deployed and take action. Without having any indication of what was happening, and with no training on what to do. So as you understand the statement was made purely to try and defend the manufacturer and airliner. Blaming pilots is a very economical way out.
>Parts of wings missing, engines falling off etc. happen.
There's only a handful of recorded engine losses (as in "ripped off the plane") of which not all were survivable. Also losing the engine is much better than damaging the wingtip. It's much closer to the body.
And please substantiate on the "Part of wings missing all time" statement, like it's a casual thing that happens all the time. Do you have any cases where a large part of the wing was ripped off? Near the end? Because I'm not aware of a single one. Wing damage happens, but aerodynamically significant wing damage is rare and lethal.
Yes, and an entire wing going missing is not the same as 10% of your wingspan (less in terms of area) coming unhinged.
> please substantiate on the "Part of wings missing all time"
You made up the "all the time" part and then put it in quotes as if it were a direct quote. Please don't do that.
Here's an incident with a commercial plane:
"Plane grounded after part of wing falls off mid-flight
More than 60 passengers had to be flown back to London City Airport after part of the plane's wing fell off shortly after it took off"
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/transport/1...
Anyway, I am not saying it's a slam-dunk, or that it is a trivial occurrence. I am saying that these things have happened and therefore it is not an obviously and categorically non-survivable event, as you claim without any supporting evidence other than that it's obvious to you.
UPDATE: Here's another one
"Delta Plane Loses Part of Its Wing"
https://abcnews.go.com/US/delta-plane-loses-part-of-wing-mid...
And then there's this quora answer (it's about 50% the wing, not <10%):
https://www.quora.com/Can-a-passenger-plane-fly-if-it-loses-...
Includes a reference to a 707 that lost 25 feet of wing and landed safely:
http://www.airplanemart.com/Aircraft-Accident-and-Incident-R...
And another of an Airbus surviving a missile strike on its wing over Bagdad:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2003_Baghdad_DHL_attempted_sho...
The only significant accident was the 707, which was on a 4-engine plane, in the 60s, and was dubbed a miracle. If this happened on a 2-engine plane they'd all be dead.
So please stop wasting my time and go play-pretend to be a presudoacademic specialist on reddit. You'll fit right in.
"Winglets, as the name applies, are miniature wings, and as such they generate their own tip vortices that degrade their performance.
Winglets reduce drag, but they also generate lift at the tip, increasing the bending moment at the wing root and requiring the structure to be beefed up, adding weight."
Folded wingtips don't produce a smooth surface so my intuition would be that it would increase drag.
We just had that southwest flight land with a missing engine and a hole in the side, and back in the 80s we had that hawaiian flight land safely with the roof ripped off (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aloha_Airlines_Flight_243). Modern airliners are built to fly in some pretty insane conditions.
I wouldn't want to be on the plane to find out, but my gut says you'd be fine.
> What happens?
In the large, I'm sure the teams of engineers at Boeing have it covered.
So one in a billion confluence of errors makes the pins disengage in the middle of a flight. What happens?
For comparison, see these stories of aircraft flying safely with a much larger wing area unintentionally folded: https://theaviationist.com/2014/02/19/us-navy-fighters-folde...
(devices such as winglets excepted; I don't think that applies here)
You answered your own question and didn't know it.
If the additional width added here has no net lift benefit but served as winglets do to reduce induced drag from the 'mixing boundary' but even more effectively – since the outward moving airmass doesn't have to accelerate (read: change direction) when it hits the base of the winglet, but instead gets to continue smoothly migrating to the tip – I can absolutely see how that would pay off in efficiency gains.
Wings can be designed to have nearly arbitrary amounts of lift: reducing drag for a given amount of lift is the secret sauce, which could very well be what this design achieves.
(me: FAA Licensed Dispatcher)
Finally, it's meaningless to say that wings "can be designed to have...arbitrary amounts of lift," and plainly incorrect to say that drag is the "secret sauce." (Aeroelastic flutter? Wing mass? Control moments? Moment coefficients?) Reducing induced drag is done in exactly two ways. You either increase the span or put a winglet on so you can effectively increase the span while still being able to park the plane.
Nobody thinks they can do brain surgery, but everybody is a fluid dynamicist.
It would have been enough to say that wing extensions in general (winglets and the 777x ones included) serve to improve the overall efficiency/performance of the wing (so they might not be generating any lift at all, if it's even possible to analyze them in isolation).
It's fine to make the point that we're all unqualified to discuss this because we aren't fluid dynamicists. But dumping a load of technical language on us that you don't expect us to understand is a rude, non-productive, and self-aggrandizing way to do that.
I would address the GPs nit-picky points, but the tone is so snarky it's not worth my effort. I may not be a fluid dynamicist, but neither am I a pedantic putz. (subtext: chill out, dude.)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_T._Whitcomb
He was such an intuitionist that AFAICS he apparently spent some of his last years on perpetual motion machines (i.e. some kind of quantum zero-point energy device.)
The idea that it's not OK to have spirited discussions about this, that the science should dictate who is right and who is wrong, is just inadequate to the problem. The design space for aircraft is huge, and almost any conceivable practical technique or configuration is going to be conventional, based on experience.
The answer being that these things are tested to destruction and procedures and failsafes put in place when necessary.
Edit: For the wingtips specifically I'd imagine not a lot of difference at all control-wise, just a loss of efficiency.
Consider a Boeing 777X going along at its cruising speed and the locking mechanism for the wing tips just disappears; primary and secondary. The wingtip is effectively unsecured. What happens?