Re:Boeing's folding wingtips get the FAA green light
by John_KZ on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @11:15AM
(#17126478)
Ok, I'm done using up my energy and time, since you obviously don't know shit about aviation, and don't care to learn, just to pretend-win an argument. Did you even read your articles? A small portion of aluminum skin on the upper part of the wing does not constitute aerodynamic failure, neither does a small portion of ripped-off aileron gliding parallel to wind flow.
The only significant accident was the 707, which was on a 4-engine plane, in the 60s, and was dubbed a miracle. If this happened on a 2-engine plane they'd all be dead.
So please stop wasting my time and go play-pretend to be a presudoacademic specialist on reddit. You'll fit right in.
Yes, and an entire wing going missing is not the same as 10% of your wingspan (less in terms of area) coming unhinged.
> please substantiate on the "Part of wings missing all time"
You made up the "all the time" part and then put it in quotes as if it were a direct quote. Please don't do that.
Here's an incident with a commercial plane:
"Plane grounded after part of wing falls off mid-flight
More than 60 passengers had to be flown back to London City Airport after part of the plane's wing fell off shortly after it took off"
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/transport/1...
Anyway, I am not saying it's a slam-dunk, or that it is a trivial occurrence. I am saying that these things have happened and therefore it is not an obviously and categorically non-survivable event, as you claim without any supporting evidence other than that it's obvious to you.
UPDATE: Here's another one
"Delta Plane Loses Part of Its Wing"
https://abcnews.go.com/US/delta-plane-loses-part-of-wing-mid...
And then there's this quora answer (it's about 50% the wing, not <10%):
https://www.quora.com/Can-a-passenger-plane-fly-if-it-loses-...
Includes a reference to a 707 that lost 25 feet of wing and landed safely:
http://www.airplanemart.com/Aircraft-Accident-and-Incident-R...
And another of an Airbus surviving a missile strike on its wing over Bagdad:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2003_Baghdad_DHL_attempted_sho...