We want housing to be more affordable in LA, [a different but still local] we also want Amazon to come to town and bring in a bunch of new workers from out of town. Those two goals seems hard to reconcile.
We want affordable housing = existing residents who want to rent their affordable apartments or continue to own their single family house without additional traffic/school overcrowding and their network of friends to have that opportunity too, politicians who want to represent these folks
We want tech jobs, more office space, more apartments = real estate developers, young tech professionals who want job options, incoming residents who aren't aware of how uncrowded these neighborhoods used to be, politicians who want to represent these folks
Cities that can grow outwards, like Houston or Dallas, can punt on this problem for a lot longer than LA or SF or NY can, but I'm very interested in seeing what that looks like long-term. Maybe Dallas hits a continuing density-vs-sprawl equilibrium that results in mostly-reasonable prices w/ mostly-reasonable commute lengths (people seem pretty tolerant up to 45-min one direction, IME) just over a wider and wider footprint without ever needing to densify - not many natural barriers for a while. But maybe it doesn't.
SF/SV -> Sacramento
NYC -> Newark
LA -> San Diego
High level management can day trip it via 1-2 hour train/car/shuttle ride to the secondary headquarters without the expense/complexity of plane rides and overbite hotels, or conversely the employees can day trip it to primary headquarters. Plus there is no timezone difference for conference calls. And most importantly the employees can still be within driving distance of their social network and have a very similar quality of life (climate, outdoor recreation, etc.) but not all of their paycheck is spent on housing.
We already tried that. Google, Apple, etc. located themselves in the small orchard towns of Mountain View and Cupertino instead of the big San Francisco. San Jose responded by building up its downtown, anchored by Adobe, and investing in light rail. A similar story played out in L.A., with media companies moving to Burbank.
This didn't solve the problem. There's really no way around building housing.
At least, this is my own particular experience. It took me years to learn how to ask good questions. Before, I would either:
1) When I ran into something that seemed frustrating or inefficient, I would assume that the task was just difficult and I needed to put my head down and slog through it.
2) Ask broad questions to try and build a mental model that would let me work more efficiently and know what to focus on, hear the feedback "you're trying to understand the universe", and think that meant I should stop asking questions and just keep punching. It was only at my current employer (where everyone is in the same office and my tech lead and I could have in-person 1-on-1s) that I got feedback on how to be more specific and contextual in my questions.
Do you think it matters that they were in-person? The fact that you called them 1-on-1s implies dedicated chunks of time for direct communication. Would they not have worked just as well over VoIP? Did you have to schedule time for 1-on-1s in the office, or was it more spontaneous?
FWIW, I'm visually impaired, and I spent most of my career so far on a distributed team where the same was true of my boss and most of my coworkers. So maybe there's some aspect of in-person communication that we're just used to doing without. Edit: Then again, remote work _is_ on the rise in the wider software industry.
yes.
I wish I had an explicit enough understanding that I could give you a solid explanation of why I believe this, but I don't.
Its not on any of the main line's into London and not that well placed for anyone living in London let alone commuting in from more affordable places.
San Diego is already a nightmare for commuters with the growth of tech in north county. I think major mass transit would have to go in first before additional growth would be feasible.
The difference between Texas and California is not geographical but political. Texas is pro housing. California is anti housing.
Also, wouldn't you want your kids to be able to afford living in their hometown?
Many interests paint this as an all- or nothing- problem: "the developers just want to pave over Golden Gate Park!" "The NIMBYs just want their property values to increase!"
In reality, nobody credibly advocates this. Building high-density apartments in previously single-family home tracts is one solution. Paris is an excellent example of housing that is both beautiful and functional. Apartments are limited to six stories, and have good public transit available, so congestion isn't like Jakarta.
> At the meeting, one woman fretted that the tall building would violate the privacy of a nearby public school.
> When Tillman said he saw his project as necessary so people like his daughter could afford to come back and live in the city, one particularly motivated activist said she wished his daughter was killed in a terrorist attack.
> Parroting many of the Mission activists' concerns, Commissioner Rich Hillis complained that the design was "bulky, and a bit out of character" with the neighborhood, while Commissioner Kathrin Moore said that erecting an 84-foot tall building would be like "plopping a foreign object into this area and not thinking about the consequences." Commissioner Dennis Richards said, "I think a project absolutely belongs here. The question is what kind of project."
https://reason.com/blog/2018/02/21/san-francisco-man-has-spe...
Historically, cities responded to this by building more housing, thus reducing the tension. In the 1970s, in certain locales like the West Coast, they stopped doing that. Forty to fifty years later, a massive housing crisis resulted.
We could start by acknowledging our mistakes and working to correct them.
So why people are not trying to buy land and build something on it instead? Buying a house will cost magnitude more than buying land and building your own house. Building will take time and resources, but... paying for a loan for 30 years? I think i can spend two years building my own home for the fraction of a cost of buying existing one.
Why no one is doing this?
B. It can be much harder (higher down payment/harder to qualify) to get a land loan and a construction loan, Vs. a mortgage + more expensive as you need to pay for all of that for the time the house is being constructed and also pay for a place to live...
C. Often times lot values imply the highest density development e.g. in order for the purchase price of a lot to make sense you can’t just build a single family home but need to build 3 town homes for the economics to workout
The paperwork alone would be a nightmare!
Housing has come a long way since the days of the mail-order Sears & Roebuck assemble it yourself house.
Even in SF there are a lot of land for housing! For example, there are hundreds of body repair/tyre shops in SF. Why city ever need them in the city where Uber wins over owning your own car? But you can't just buy them and build more housing - in most cases you need to wait several years to "clean up" the soil.
Yeah, well...those places are already in use. And if you want to change that use, you first have to buy the land from the people who are already using it. And that's expensive, because people know what the land is worth. In other words: those auto repair shops are there for a reason. You can't just ignore the reason(s) and pretend that the land is vacant.
It's not as if every SF landowner is behaving in an economically suboptimal way because they're all stupid.
This is exactly what i am saying - it is economically suboptimal. They will be there until they are profitable.
But problem not in the land price itself, but also waiting for 3 years until you will be able to start new construction, this delay will increase actual price of this piece of land up to 30%.
There are many ways to reduce this delay.
No, you believe they're economically suboptimal, and you're making up excuses why reality disagrees with your theory.
"But problem not in the land price itself, but also waiting for 3 years until you will be able to start new construction, this delay will increase actual price of this piece of land up to 30%."
Proof of work required. You're going to have to prove that three years is a typical delay; that this results in the stated 30% price increases; and that this is the actual reason that your hypothetical auto-repair shops aren't all apartment complexes.
There's a simpler explanation: just as commercial rents are higher than residential rents, commercial uses of land are typically far more valuable than apartment buildings. If a redevelopment doesn't pay landowners a significant multiple of their current (commercial) revenue, they're not going to do it. Most apartment projects can't come close.
Sorry, i am not native speaker, but isn't it the same as "economically suboptional"?
> There's a simpler explanation
This neighbourhoods are mostly commercial districts that requires the first story to be commercial and other stories to be residential. Building up doesn't change commercial use of this buildings but just add more housing.
> No, you believe they're economically suboptimal, and you're making up excuses why reality disagrees with your theory.
I am not "believing", this is just a one hypothesis. I could be wrong, of course.
I'm saying that on average, whatever you observe in the world is already "economically optimal". You may believe that there's a better way to use land, but if reality doesn't agree with your beliefs, there's usually a good reason.
"This neighbourhoods are mostly commercial districts that requires the first story to be commercial and other stories to be residential. Building up doesn't change commercial use of this buildings but just add more housing."
It doesn't matter. If the trade doesn't benefit the current owner, it won't happen. Someone has to pay for the redevelopment, and I'd wager that in most cases, owners have to take on debt in order to finance redevelopment. So they go from having an annuity (fixed cash flow), to payments on debt, for a (possible) future gain. Maybe this is attractive for some owners. For many others, probably not.
So what about selling? Couldn't an enterprising developer buy the land and re-develop it for them?
Sure! Except: the current owner is making significant income from the business right now. That will go away, and they're going to want to be compensated for the loss. They're also not stupid, and know that the buyer is going to redevelop the land and charge more for it. Thus, they will (logically) ask for the buyer to pay them now for many years of future cashflow under the new use of the land.
In other words: owners know what the land is worth, and they're going to ask for it. The buyer is going to be paying not just for years of lost business income, but also, a significant percentage of her future revenue. And she's going to pay for redevelopment. And maybe that pays off, but it certainly doesn't pay off quickly -- and it isn't necessarily obvious that an apartment building is worth more than an auto repair shop. It depends on the health of the business!
This is why you can't just look at an auto-repair shop and say that it "should be" an apartment complex. It has nothing to do with regulation.
I got it, this is just misunderstanding. I meant that upbuilding is "econimically suboptimal", but current situation is optimal.
> In other words: owners know what the land is worth Actually, no. Some of developers told us that the problem with market is that most of the land is not for sale because owners just don't know that they can sell on a good price, they are not thinking about this at all. Developers are willing to buy land up to x10 more that they are currently buying.
> It has nothing to do with regulation.
In regions where there are a huge crisis in housing local government can introduce a new type of a Tax - Underdevelopment Tax. This will reduce margins of the owners that hold their land for "investing" opportunity and force them to sell their land to developers. Even if this tax will be low, they will start to think about selling their land right now and this help to the market a lot.
I remember driving through the Bronx with my dad in the 80s when he worked there. It looked like a war zone. Bubbles tend to pop, and bankrupt buildings get boarded up, not cheaper.
This discussion reminds me of people who dare not go to the gym because they're afraid of getting unsightly muscles. We're so very far from what you fear!
Have you looked at what it takes to make housing pencil out in the city? Developers are not "printing money". Construction costs are incredibly high, especially with inclusionary zoning.
I don’t live in SFO, but real estate and local politics are like white on rice. Developers are just one variant of real estate industry player. It’s often an old money game.
There are certainly hot spots in places like NY and SF, but it's not just one area. Lots of cities are growing. And it's not all due to evil corporations running amok, at a certain level it's just capitalism itself that requires growth - the GDP has to keep growing year over year, and the population probably has to grow slightly to provide for that growth. Immigrants move in, and children grow up and need somewhere to live. Add in the generational effect of baby boomers, i.e. that older people retiring and staying in their homes mean that we need more housing for the same number of jobs.
Specific booms like tech in SF may exacerbate the problem even more, but fundamentally our way of life just requires continual growth. This is at odds with the NIMBY attitude that I have a right for not just my home, but every building in my neighborhood, to stay exactly the same as the day I moved in. It's not at odds with affordable market rate housing, that just requires supply keeping up with demand.
So fighting residential development locally to try to push companies to other areas may be a rational strategy for some.
I'm not convinced that perpetual population growth will always be required for economic growth.
No there isn't. All the places with viable logistics and water supply are pretty much full up. Urban areas need barge transport, good rail grades, aqueducts, and rivers to carry away waste. You can't plop a city down in the middle of nowhere. The energy economics mean it will never work. All the sites worth building on have been built on. A lot of the places supplied mostly by truck are of questionable viability in coming years.
Probably the only area of the country that could long term sustain a much higher population density is the great lakes region.
If Oklahoma had the population density of the Netherlands it would have an additional 72 million people living in it...and oh by the way it’s got huge oil and gas reserves and some pretty enormous inland ports...
The Netherlands is, too, in the long run. But for now it's economically sustainable.
There are a few interesting studies in this area, California's agricultural section's tug-of-war with its residents for water is the biggest one that comes to mind, and the lesson you get is that industry uses up the lion's share of the water out of greed and sloth, but enough pressure will force them to curtail usage.
I wouldn’t want to live there, but seems like a lot of bulk commodities, and products come in and out of Oklahoma and there is still plenty of room...
None of the other developed countries have vast interior deserts. The east and west coasts and some parts of the Mississippi and Great Lakes watersheds are plenty overpopulated.
How much do tenants actually value a guaranteed right to live in a given community? When we look at anywhere in the U.S. that isn't rent controlled, we figure out, it's not much at all.
There is nothing illegal about signing a very long lease with a landlord. Commercial real estate contracts routinely include a a clause which allows tenants to extend a lease at a very similar price for many years in the future.
Landlord would absolutely love to do leases like this. But the reason this doesn't exist in the non-commercial settings is because no one cares enough about living in a place long enough to actually pay for that option.
Rent control only exists because its a a popular transfer of wealth, and is emotionally appealing, not because it actually makes people better off.
Tenants with kids value continuity of school districts. It’s a major reason why buying a house is so important. Tenants don’t seem to care because most tenants are high-income-no kids, old, or poor.
Usually bigger developments require no-negotiation, ironclad leases to make sales and financing easier. Smaller landlords and public housing are sometimes more flexible.
It's because of zoning. Allow more high rise to be built and allow more expansion and demand can be met.
It's not some mystery. It's local laws that prevent people increasing height of buildings and prevent expanding the area.
It's a problem that can be seen around the world due to similar planning laws in many places. See the Demographia report below:
http://www.harriscountytx.gov/CmpDocuments/74/Budget/FY18%20...
It's grown by 67% since 1990. Far greater than NYC or LA or SF in percentage terms.
The other thing that should be mentioned is that Texas has fairly high property taxes. They also help.
1) There's a major time delay here. Most rent-controlled apartments have rent increases tied to inflation. Had zoning and land development policy over the last 50 years kept up, maybe in aggregate affordability within communities could have been preserved. As it stands, we are so far behind what would have been needed to keep things affordable that it's basically unworkable in the short to medium term (10-20 years) to expect changing zoning laws to solve our problems now. NYC would need an insane capital infusion, and any economic downturn would make the building market freeze up (as we saw in 2008).
2) New development in price-controlled neighborhoods doesn't solve the issue for people paying significantly under market. That's exactly what happens now, in fact: new development once a neighborhood is rezoned allows developers to buy up old properties and build luxury high rises. There is SO much demand for luxury (i.e. Manhattan yuppie) housing that, again, in the short-medium term, long-time residents are still necessarily displaced without protection.
3) To what degree should a community be able to resist change? Other than the fear of being displaced, renters also fear their communities being torn apart by gentrification, slowly dissolved by a changing demographic and rising prices. Now, I lean more on the side that communities don't necessarily have a right to exist (i.e. NIMBYism in CA), but there's definitely some leeway here, especially when those communities are classically disadvantaged (socioeconomically, racially, etc.). Rezoning a neighborhood that is fragile can have majorly negative impacts on the communities, and make things even more dire for the most vulnerable segments of the population.
4) It's unclear how much remaining demand is unsatisfied because of housing prices in NYC. Think of the surplus of people commuting in on major rail lines each day. Surely some fraction of them live in the suburbs for lifestyle reasons, but I'm sure a large fraction of them are simply priced out of the city. So demand for housing may increase if prices are lowered substantially. Depending on this unknown demand, rezoning could have little to no effect on the populations we're discussing here.
Rezoning is an extremely important part of the solution here, and the city should DEFINITELY be making aggressive moves to rezone in various places. But it's not a silver bullet, and in the short-medium term doesn't solve most of the problems that rent control have attempted to solve.
I suppose there are other problems like lengthy process of permitting (basically at least 1 year for issuing building permit) and entitlement (unpredictable). This huge delays reduces margins of a projects and in some cases they became unprofitable.
That is the entire problem. The entire problem of building more dense housing - even 3-4 stories in SF is negotiating every single thing besides the literal physical feasibility of construction.
If your startup doesn't think this is the key problem to solve, I'm not sure you have a complete grasp of what you're trying to do here.
Also frequently it’s property taxes that force people out of neighborhoods (eg their families own a place for years, and then the property values go up making it too expensive for them to live in). If property taxes were eliminated, this would displace fewer people. Naturally you don’t see any politicians talking about this since they don’t want to eliminate a source of revenue for the state — they’d rather blame Airbnb!
Prop 13 wouldn't be so damaging if it were easier to build. Unfortunately Prop 13 incentives and/or minimizes the consequences of communities restricting development, so it had this weird feedback effect. Regulations have unintended consequences and so we should be rightly wary of them. But that reality shouldn't be dispositive on whether we should attempt them.
Market dynamics are like gravity: you can't ignore gravity but gravity doesn't make human flight impossible, it just constrains the solution space. Arguing that we shouldn't attempt market interventions is like arguing that we shouldn't have attempted human flight because God didn't equip us with wings or that we should've waited around until we evolved wings.
If you eliminate property tax, or prevent it from rising, you make the absentee owner who only cares about a payoff 20 years from now leaving perfectly livable homes empty many magnitudes worse. (as evidenced by california)
eliminating property tax only incentives blocking all new development to drive up property values and encourage rent seeking
I'm quite interested to see your reasoning behind that statement. Don't people still want their property values to go up even with property taxes? Except in a no property tax scenario, people who own their homes outright would still be able to stay if they wanted to. Perhaps no property taxes would more highly encourage local owners to restrict newcomers. Isn't the government also interested in increasing property values so they can receive more revenue? In that case I suppose they would in a sense be "earning" the taxes they levy.
- Edited for clarity
Bingo. Rampant NIMBYism. Also growing the local economy should be the priority for local governments not creating a housing bubble
There is an argument that can be made that people who cannot afford to live in prime real estate in an economic powerhouse should sell their house and move somewhere else to enable growth or allow more housing to be built. But picking neither is not a productive outcome
I was just trying to point at that local governments are also encouraged to have high property values for tax revenue. They also tend to have a bit more power to be able to affect large areas property values by force. If people cannot/don't utilize the government to enact policies to force people out, it seems to me that it would be pretty difficult for people to enact those policies without governmental power.
What we see in places like San Francisco are property owners and governments teaming up to drive property values up in a mutually beneficial relationship.
Edit - It could be said that the government itself is rent-seeking in such an arrangement.
I find measures to limit the amount that property tax can increase on a property you own and occupy much easier to stomach than measures like rent control.
This city is full of landlords who got rich with the existing rent control system. It’s just preventing some of them from getting mega buck wild rich. So sad.
Philosophically, I don't like placing two sympathetic groups on opposite sides of a scale and weighing them, because that's usually a false choice and there is some external factors unaccounted for that make the choice less normative. In the case of rent control, this externality is clearly that it depresses new unit construction, exacerbating the problem. So I oppose rent control.
Yes, rent control exacerbates an already existing problem, but it doesn't create it. The same landlords who profit from the high prices of housing in our urban cores actively oppose new development because of that same reason.
We can't solve this problem by banning rent control. The only way to solve a capacity problem: adjust supply or demand. I don't see demand changing anytime soon.
The law generally -- and correctly -- recognizes that making someone homeless is a very serious thing, and should not be done on a mere whim, no matter how much someone might want to argue that as a property owner their whims are sacred.
In such a situation, there'd be no real real-estate speculation, and levels of rent-extraction above cost would be controlled by municipal bylaw (as they'd effectively be a tax.) Property development companies would all either be nationalized, or would be private government-exclusive subcontractors.
Basically: imagine China, but instead of privatizing every industry all at once, they had kept construction and property management state-run. How would that look?
I don't know how well this works (I only have a superficial knowledge of the property market from my travels and relations) but I imagine it becomes a problem when you have major improvements. For example, imagine a condominium. As a political matter the government isn't going to kick out 100 tenants just because the leasehold on the land terminated. So I suspect that in terms of revenue the governments are no better off than relying on property taxes. In the few cases I'm personally familiar with the typical scenario seems to be that the government offers renewal terms at a highly discounted rate a couple of decades before the lease expires. It seems like a pointless contrivance.
Certainly freeholds are nicer from the perspective of efficient markets because you don't have arbitrary dates to contend with. Imagine trying to sell land with only 10 years remaining on the leasehold. The seller can expect very little, which is to be expected and not per se problematic. But more importantly 10 years limits the types of things you can use the land for, especially if you're risk averse. In general buyers will find it difficult to find land with a remaining term long enough to recapture the value of improvements, so liquidity would suffer significantly. Seems to me property taxes are a much simpler, more consistent, and theoretically fairer way for governments to capture the value of land. And that's ignoring Henry George-style land-value taxes.
I suppose leaseholds may make it easier for governments to actually kick people off land if they're committed to doing so. The end of the lease is a nice, neutral date to implement some difficult policy objective.
Here's a short, interesting article a quick Google search found: https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/housing/understanding...
What caught my eye was
"And when the flat reaches 69 years, CPF savings cannot be used to finance the mortgages."
CPF is the mandatory savings program, sort of like Social Security and Medicare, except you can borrow against it. So basically if there's only 30 years left on a leasehold you can't borrow against your CPF account. My guess is that as the leasehold nears expiry your ability to securitize simply goes down to nothing, probably long before termination. And even before then you probably start paying a premium because if you default the bank is stuck with a rapidly depreciating asset.From what little I've gleaned from my travels and from the academic literature, I think Americans enjoy an exceptionally liquid property market and efficient financing market, particularly for residential property.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/sarahsu/2017/03/21/good-news-fo...
"Last Wednesday, Premier Li Keqiang said a real estate protection provision that would ensure individual’s access to property under a 70-year lease would be renewed unconditionally is being drafted.
This will help to quell ongoing fears that wealth garnered from one generation will be removed after the 70-year lease ends by the government. And while this does not address the fate of 20-year leases, the precedent set in Wenzhou may be replicated in other areas."
Lots of important land uses like airports, factories, train stations require huge investment with returns spread over decades or centuries, it would be harder to get people to make these investments on leased land.
It seems you have no idea what unintended consequences you're preserving by staying beholden to an ancient status quo.
I think UBI would significantly help relieve housing pressure in large metro areas and perhaps help revitalize some currently-dying small towns and rural areas, which after all will need more services with increased population.
Even places that are economically barren see people just go onto Social Security disability (perhaps a form of UBI) instead of moving to regions with jobs.
There are also people who move when they retire, or when they have kids. This could facilitate that happening earlier which would also reduce the pressure on housing in cities.
The problem is, many cities like NYC and San Francisco are trying to have their cake and eat it to. Liberal residents want to keep their suburban-style single family neighborhoods while simultaneously appearing to care about skyrocketing rents. You simply cannot have it both ways. The ONLY viable solution is to relax the rules blocking the construction of new housing. SB827 in California, which would have overridden local zoning to legalize the construction of higher density buildings within walking distance of transit stops, was a valiant effort to do the right thing, but it failed because of a strong anti-development sentiment from anti-capitalist tenants rights groups and pro-housing-appreciation single family home owners (in a particularly absurd moment, the mayor of ultra-tony Beverly Hills, which has built almost no new housing in the last few years, claimed to be against the bill because he was concerned about all of the "luxury housing" it would build in his town).
Those two cites are not the same at all. NYC has few suburban style neighborhoods and the ones we do have aren't that relevant to these discussions.
New York is at least somewhat functional as a large city, and can and does permit the building of massive amounts of high rise residential development. From where I stand in downtown Brooklyn, the skyline has become nearly unrecognizable in recent years. And predictably, rents are starting to fall noticeably.
San Francisco doesn't operate this way at all.
I've been wondering this for a while, but haven't come up with a satisfying answer: to what extent do people have the right to live in a given community? Does this depend on if people have lived in a community for some time? Does it only depend on whether they can afford to live there? I feel like these questions aren't black and white, but there's also no clear middle part I feel comfortable committing to.