Prop 13 wouldn't be so damaging if it were easier to build. Unfortunately Prop 13 incentives and/or minimizes the consequences of communities restricting development, so it had this weird feedback effect. Regulations have unintended consequences and so we should be rightly wary of them. But that reality shouldn't be dispositive on whether we should attempt them.
Market dynamics are like gravity: you can't ignore gravity but gravity doesn't make human flight impossible, it just constrains the solution space. Arguing that we shouldn't attempt market interventions is like arguing that we shouldn't have attempted human flight because God didn't equip us with wings or that we should've waited around until we evolved wings.
If you eliminate property tax, or prevent it from rising, you make the absentee owner who only cares about a payoff 20 years from now leaving perfectly livable homes empty many magnitudes worse. (as evidenced by california)
eliminating property tax only incentives blocking all new development to drive up property values and encourage rent seeking
I'm quite interested to see your reasoning behind that statement. Don't people still want their property values to go up even with property taxes? Except in a no property tax scenario, people who own their homes outright would still be able to stay if they wanted to. Perhaps no property taxes would more highly encourage local owners to restrict newcomers. Isn't the government also interested in increasing property values so they can receive more revenue? In that case I suppose they would in a sense be "earning" the taxes they levy.
- Edited for clarity
Bingo. Rampant NIMBYism. Also growing the local economy should be the priority for local governments not creating a housing bubble
There is an argument that can be made that people who cannot afford to live in prime real estate in an economic powerhouse should sell their house and move somewhere else to enable growth or allow more housing to be built. But picking neither is not a productive outcome
I was just trying to point at that local governments are also encouraged to have high property values for tax revenue. They also tend to have a bit more power to be able to affect large areas property values by force. If people cannot/don't utilize the government to enact policies to force people out, it seems to me that it would be pretty difficult for people to enact those policies without governmental power.
What we see in places like San Francisco are property owners and governments teaming up to drive property values up in a mutually beneficial relationship.
Edit - It could be said that the government itself is rent-seeking in such an arrangement.
Also frequently it’s property taxes that force people out of neighborhoods (eg their families own a place for years, and then the property values go up making it too expensive for them to live in). If property taxes were eliminated, this would displace fewer people. Naturally you don’t see any politicians talking about this since they don’t want to eliminate a source of revenue for the state — they’d rather blame Airbnb!