News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by DmenshunlAnlsis on Monday May 21, 2018 @12:50PM (#17119780)
The Tesla’s stopping distance of 152 feet from 60 mph was far worse than any contemporary car we’ve tested and about 7 feet longer than the stopping distance of a Ford F-150 full-sized pickup.

That’s worrying, and almost as worrying is that Tesla says their braking is much faster. I’m sure plenty of fans will make comments about shorting stock, but this is Consumer Reports, and they have a very good reputation to protect.

I’m not thrilled by this tidbit either.

The Model 3’s stiff ride, unsupportive rear seat and excessive wind noise at highway speeds also hurt its road-test score. In the compact luxury sedan class, most competitors deliver a more comfortable ride and rear seat.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by tshannon on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:25PM (#17120062)
This part really intrigued me about the stopping distance:

The Tesla spokeswoman says the company has the ability to update its vehicles over the air. “Unlike other vehicles, Tesla is uniquely positioned to address more corner cases over time through over-the-air software updates, and it continually does so to improve factors such as stopping distance,” she says.

I'm curious the mechanism that makes that possible, or if it's just BS.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by ensignavenger on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:35PM (#17120144)
To me, it is disturbing. I get used to the way my vehicle handles, for it to suddenly change because of a software update could potentially be dangerous- but would almost certainly result in a trip to the mechanic for a checkup.

Maybe they have a system for warning owners about these sorts of updates?

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by audionemesis on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:43PM (#17120214)
Well, yes. You get prompted to update your car (you can choose not to). And then after the update is complete, you get a Whats Changed prompt the next time you're in your car. Essentially a patch notes for your vehicle
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by whatok on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:48PM (#17120239)
For something as major as changing the way a car breaks, do you think "patch notes" (if read at all) are able to properly convey the magnitude of the change?
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by audionemesis on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:56PM (#17120287)
Yes? My 75D had an entire second shaved off of its 0 - 60 time. I was aware of the change and was able to deal with it just fine...

I'm also not sure what the alternative you're imagining here is. Take it in to a shop just to have them install the update for you? I also don't see how this is any different than changing worn out brakes on an old ICE car. I had the brakes changed in my old '97 Accord, and the difference was noticeable when I pulled it out of the driveway. I think you need to give people a little more credit...

Also, the Whats Changed prompt literally takes up the entire 17in touch screen. It's sort of hard to miss.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by whatok on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:08PM (#17120892)
I'm talking about the general populace not only actually reading a prompt but understanding it. Based on how people interact with computers/phones, I do not have a lot of faith in their abilities on this end.

I didn't propose an alternative but there's a huge difference in awareness between a physical in-person "update" vs an OTA update.

For something as serious as changing brake handling, I'm sure they would have some sort of prominent display/cannot continue until you agree prompt but there's always going to be people who do not read things in their entirety. For something that can be destructive as a car, I don't find that acceptable.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by greglindahl on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:55PM (#17120276)
How do you know that the change is driver-visible? The change might only be for braking hard enough that the anti-lock feature kicks in... which most drivers don't do very often.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by ensignavenger on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @10:09AM (#17126009)
Good, that makes sense! It would be preferable if they gave you the notes before you installed the update (maybe they do provide a link for it?) Thanks for confirming that, anyway.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by bdcravens on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:46PM (#17120706)
Is there an option to revert?
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by vvanders on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:50PM (#17120254)
They've already been doing this, back when dual-motor cars first rolled out they had an update that cut the 0-60 from 4.6s to 3.9s.

Def changed the way the car drove, can't say that I minded in that case though.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by saynay on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:54PM (#17120274)
I can see that for many other areas of handling, but breaking has always seemed the most variable to me. Different road conditions, tire conditions, if the breaks themselves are wet, etc.

I suspect you would get used to it fairly quickly.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by ensignavenger on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @10:12AM (#17126028)
Right, but I like to at least pretend to know what the road conditions/ tire conditions/ brake conditions are. Maybe I'm not as clever as I think I am, though :) I try to be a very conscientious and careful driver.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by Cthulhu_ on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:33PM (#17120128)
Why would you think it's BS? The Model S gets over-the-air updates all the time; if I recall correctly, they increased the ride height a while ago through an update after a car drove over a metal wotsit, causing a puncture in the battery compartiment and a fire.

They can probably update the settings for the brakes as well, as long as the underlying mechanicals support it.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by blacksmith_tb on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:39PM (#17120177)
I think the implicit question is "can an OTA somehow improve braking performance - why isn't it optimal already?" not "do Tesla OTAs change other aspects of the car?"
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by Nasrudith on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:54PM (#17120275)
Electric motors and generators are essentially the same thing run in different directions. Run electricity through a motor and it generates motion while putting load on the power. Move a generator and it creates resistance as it extracts electricity. This also answers both how they can change it and why it is not already optimal. Actively using the motors to break causes it to use energy instead of recovering it. Hybrid drivers have long known to break gradually when possible to maximize battery recharge. It is possible they had an electric neophyte as a test driver. Fair enough if they were supposed to test from the perspective of someone new to hybrids and electric cars trying a Tesla as their first.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by mshook on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:01PM (#17120347)
Not sure if you read the article but what they were testing is pretty much emergency braking from 60mph to full stop.

So the goal is not regenerate the battery (and it doesn't matter if the driver was "an electric neophyte"), it's to brake hard and to repeat the process a couple of times to see if you get brake fade.

From the article: Our testers get a car up to 60 mph, then slam on the brakes until the car comes to a stop. They repeat this multiple times to ensure consistent results. Between each test, the vehicle is driven approximately a mile to cool the brakes and make sure they don’t overheat.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by Nasrudith on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:17PM (#17120464)
Whoops. My mistake for giving into the temptation to segue after my explanation of what I did know.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by detaro on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:03PM (#17120368)
What does "gradually braking to optimize battery recharge" have to do with an emergency stop?
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by tw04 on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:36PM (#17120157)
There are plenty of reasons why you would default to a lower ride height. What would be the purpose of intentionally making your brakes worse than an f150?
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by gnode on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:41PM (#17120200)
I don't think anyone's suggesting it was intentional. Parameters for managing the brakes may just have been set badly, or the anti-locking algorithm written poorly. A possible explanation is they may have optimised it to improve handling while braking.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by tshannon on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:39PM (#17120179)
I never said I thought it was BS. I was curious what the physical mechanism to change the braking characteristics was. If there was no physical mechanism that I assume it's BS.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by onesun on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:17PM (#17120461)
The car most definitely has software controlled anti-lock braking equipment, and likely has software controlled electric brake cylinders. Both of those things could plausibly be updated via an OTA update.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by kbd on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:35PM (#17120141)
They improved acceleration via a software update[1] so it's plausible at least.

[1] https://www.engadget.com/2016/11/16/tesla-p100d-software-per...

Edit: why downvotes?

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by gnode on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:38PM (#17120168)
My understanding is that car brakes can generally exert more braking force than the tire's grip on the road. A long stopping distance may represent a problem with the anti-lock braking system (which is likely software controlled, and can be updated over the air).
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by Animats on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:49PM (#17120249)
Interestingly, Waymo's self-driving car cannot be updated remotely.[1] As a security measure, Waymo deliberately did not install a data connection to allow that. Probably a good decision.

[1] http://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4458000-Waymo-Driverl...

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by gnode on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:57PM (#17120304)
That's probably also to do with Waymo's cars being developed primarily for ride hailing fleets. With a private ownership model, requiring owners of variable technological faculty to manually apply updates would be less practical.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by londons_explore on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:37PM (#17121146)
That was more a PR move than a real security measure.

Signing updates and checking signatures is established technology to certify that updates come from the right place and are not tampered with.

That and the updates are likely >10 GB, so you wouldn't want to download them over mobile data anyway.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by dragontamer on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:35PM (#17120613)
But braking is a solved problem. Apply the maximum force to the tires, until right before the tires begin to slip. Then, reduce the force to prevent slipping. Stay within the "static coefficient of friction", which is higher than "dynamic coefficient of friction".

Alternatively, there's also "let the human do it". (Aka: threshold braking), but most people prefer to have the computer do this task during an emergency.

This algorithm has been used in anti-lock brakes for decades at this point. I'm not sure why it would need an OTA update to improve. Once this algorithm is properly implemented, then the only thing left is to buy better tires and use better rubber to get better grip.

This CR report suggests that Tesla's braking behavior is suboptimal. There's no reason for a smaller, lighter Model 3 to have a worse braking distance than the freaking F-150 truck.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by gnode on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:01PM (#17120827)
> But braking is a solved problem.

That's not to say Tesla haven't decided to re-solve it / implement it themselves anew. The rest of the auto industry has been doing ABS much longer than Tesla has existed.

It's also not a prescriptive algorithm. ABS systems don't stay within the static coefficient of friction; they repeatedly retest the boundary between static and dynamic friction (hence the judder). It's a bit like optimising TCP window size for those familiar with it. There are a bunch of parameters you can tune.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by londons_explore on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:41PM (#17121171)
It also depends what your goal is.

Typical ABS systems typically perform far worse on gravel or sand than non-abs systems for example. It turns out on gravel locking the wheels is usually a better solution because then you start to plough deep into the gravel.

No ABS system could determine that beforehand, since it isn't to know if the gravel is deep (allowing ploughing deep into it) or shallow (where staying on the boundary of static/dynamic friction works better).

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by magduf on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:22PM (#17120502)
It could, but it could also be a function of the car's weight (batteries are heavy) and the tires it comes equipped with from the factory. Poor tires will yield poor braking performance due to lack of grip.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by dragontamer on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:39PM (#17120650)
But it can't be poor tires, because the Model 3's brakes were proper in the first test (~130 feet stopping distance). The same car with the same tires then had different braking behavior in every test after the first test.

That's just odd.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by cc439 on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:52PM (#17121271)
I can almost guarantee the problem is caused by the brake pads glazing over. The working surface of a brake pad will become work hardened, which drastically lowers their friction coefficient, once pushed past their designed temperature limit.

The Model 3 (3,800lbs for the long range model) is a fat pig of a car compared to other, conventionally powered cars in its class (3,300lbs for a BMW 3 Series) but this is countered by Tesla fitting them with relatively enormous brakes (14" rotors up front, 13.5" in the rear, larger rotors have more heat absorbing capacity for the pads).

If I had to guess the root cause for this problem, I'd say it is likely down to Tesla's focus on minimizing aerodynamic drag causing a lack of airflow within the wheelwell and across the brakes out the wheel itself. Either that or they chose an absolutely terrible brake pad compound but that just doesn't seem likely in this modern era. Either way, the brakes are getting so hot after a single stop that CR's cooling procedure (a reasonable one I might add) is inadequate to keep the brake pads from drastically overheating. This also explains why braking performance was still compromosed after letting the car cool overnight. The work hardened surface will perform poorly until it is literally ground off from further heavy use of the brakes.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by justin66 on Monday May 21, 2018 @10:11PM (#17123303)
Can't brake pad material also adhere to the surface of the rotor as well, requiring that they be turned to remove the material? I think that's what people mean when they talk about the rotor being "glazed," a related problem to what you're talking about. This is all a potentially expensive repair.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by magduf on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @10:18AM (#17126061)
Usually, when pad material adheres to the rotor, people call that "warped rotors" because it feels like the rotor is warped when braking. It's not usually uniform, I think.

As for expense, brakes are simple and the parts generally cheap, at least for mass-market cars. You can get a full set of pads and rotors for less than $100 from Autozone.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by justin66 on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @10:38AM (#17126179)
"Warped" rotors, yes, I've heard that term. Not something that comes up in conversation as much as it used to.

They are a lot cheaper today but the cost of rotors varies tremendously depending on the manufacturer and their volume. I gather they turn rotors a lot less than they used to because they're so darn inexpensive to replace, but I'm pretty sure it's still economical for some of the higher-end stuff.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by dragontamer on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:28PM (#17121561)
> I can almost guarantee the problem is caused by the brake pads glazing over.

That's actually a very reasonable explanation. I can't say I'm a car expert, but your logic at least sounds correct.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by londons_explore on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:49PM (#17121248)
Most vehicles detect a sharp press to the brakes, and add extra assistive braking force. Thats from the observation that most humans do not apply enough braking force in an accident (potentially because they have never applied that much force before, and don't know how much is 'enough').

It's possible that the tesla software either isn't applying the extra assistive force, either due to incorrect tuning or a bug.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by gnode on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:10PM (#17120901)
I'm not sure how true this is. As the car's weight increases so too does the grip, as it's a function of down-force multiplied by the roughly constant coefficient of friction of the tires.

Conceivably, the car's weight may mean that aerodynamic down-force produces a relatively smaller impact on grip, and air resistance a relatively smaller deceleration. But I'm not sure that's enough to account for the difference.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by dragontamer on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:31PM (#17121089)
Excellent racing tires have coefficient of friction > 1. That is, a 2-ton car can have more than 2-tons of force applied from the tires.

But most consumer tires have coefficient of friction of less than 1. ~.9 for higher end stuff, but it could be as low as ~.5 or so. Which mean 2-tons of car will lead to LESS than 2-tons of acceleration / deceleration / turning force.

In effect, "more weight is more advantage" is only true if you have a coefficient of friction greater than 1.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by londons_explore on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:46PM (#17121219)
The last line of your post isn't clear.

Since F=MA, A=F/M. Assuming the braking force (F) is μ (coefficient of friction) * Mass * Gravity, thats F=μMG.

Combining those equations you get:

A = μMG / M

And the M's cancel, giving:

A = μG

Therefore the braking distance due to road friction alone (and ignoring aerodynamic downforce effects) is independent of the mass of the vehicle.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by magduf on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:29PM (#17121566)
Isn't this neglecting the forward velocity and momentum?

According to theory, the width of a tire has zero effect on tire grip. Race cars and high-performance cars prove this is incorrect: there's a reason they have wide tires (which also cause poorer fuel economy through extra friction). Tires and their interaction with the road are a lot more complex than some simple physics equations.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by dragontamer on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:30PM (#17121571)
Hmm, that makes sense.

Its like the whole "area" doesn't matter as well. I can't help but think that maybe the Newtonian friction model is overly simple sometimes. Surely weight and surface area would have an effect?

But perhaps not really. Or at least, not in a way that's very measurable.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by magduf on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:59PM (#17121781)
I think it's definitely overly simple. If it were correct, high-performance cars wouldn't have wide tires. According to Newtonian friction, the contact patch is the same size regardless of the size of the tire. Obviously that's silly; a Lamborghini is not going to get sufficient grip out of economy-car tires, nor would an 18-wheeler. That model completely neglects the complexities of the construction of the tires; they're not like balloons, they're actually semi-rigid.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by JKCalhoun on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:24PM (#17120516)
I understand Teslas are fairly heavy cars. That explains most of the problem I think.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by audionemesis on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:36PM (#17120624)
The Model S is in fact about as heavy as a Ford F150.

However, if this braking result is consistent across all Model 3 vehicles, that's a bit worrisome. I'm also a little concerned with the other issues they had (ergonomics, wind noise, etc). From everyone I know that drives or has driven a Model 3, they've had amazing experiences as far as actual driving

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by abritinthebay on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:53PM (#17120269)
"this is Consumer Reports, and they have a very good reputation to protect"

CR doesn't have a very good reputation though? I mean... they used to. But their reputation is middling at best now.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Falls Short of a CR Recommendation by brianwawok on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:44PM (#17120688)
Who has better reviews for consumer goods?