News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by yabatopia on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:22AM (#17064798)
You can see a similar simplification between good and bad in popular movies, like all the superhero movies. It's always the good versus the bad, and the bad can't be helped, they must be punished or -better yet - destroyed.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by aurbano on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:33AM (#17064854)
I would love a popular movie (maybe even one for kids) where at some point through the movie we get to see things from the "bad guy"'s point of view and discover that it actually makes sense, leaving the viewer undecided on whether they support the good or the bad guy.

It would be interesting to see children struggle with the moral dilemma, is there any movie like this already that I'm not realising?

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by funkjunky on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:44AM (#17065429)
I don't know why so many people here are suggesting "The Wire", unless they don't understand what the concept of a child is.

For incredible kids TV shows that emphasize empathy for "the bad guys", demonstrate the flaws and weaknesses of the "the good guys", and does so in a way that encourages personal growth, integrity, and compassion over moral nihilism as a response, then you can't do better than

* Steven universe

* Avatar: the last Airbender

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by grzm on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:54AM (#17065503)
> "I don't know why so many people here are suggesting "The Wire", unless they don't understand what the concept of a child is."

Your parent isn't making the "for kids" a requirement, which explains many of the suggestions here, including "The Wire".

> *"I would love a popular movie (maybe even one for kids)"

Kids is also relative: you need to take the kids themselves into account to know what may be appropriate for them.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by caf on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:44AM (#17065947)
The sequel to Avatar, the Legend of Korra also continues in the same vein, with more of a flawed hero and some villains whose motivations are very relatable.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by danShumway on Monday May 14, 2018 @11:10AM (#17066175)
> and does so in a way that encourages personal growth, integrity, and compassion over moral nihilism as a response

I appreciate you including that. When media does trend towards "reality is complicated" very often it feels like to me its ending with the lesson 'everybody hurts everyone so just get used to it and stop classifying anything as wrong or right.'

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by aleeds on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:43AM (#17064913)
Both Captain America: Civil War and Infinity War are like that.

I remember hearing shouting matches as I left Civil War about who was right, who was on the side of good.

And Infinity War leaves a lot of people with a sense that maybe Thanos wasn't so bad.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by mirceal on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:15AM (#17065176)
Yeah. Thanos had a vision and executed on it. Depending on who tells the story one could easily see him as the hero.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by Jach on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:58AM (#17066089)
Even if you agree with him that population control is needed, I don't see how you wouldn't criticize him harshly on his method both on the technical grounds of being ineffective and on various moral grounds. His comic-book motivation of trying to impress a certain lady is much more relateable for the particular action he took.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by phaedrus on Monday May 14, 2018 @11:21AM (#17066248)
I saw a fan theory suggested on Reddit that it would make more sense if population control was also a means to an end for Thanos, and that Thanos's ultimate reason for doing what he does was to stave off the arrival of Galactus.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by Jach on Monday May 14, 2018 @11:29AM (#17066309)
Still makes no sense -- universal replacement rate is probably > 2, almost certainly now with so many deaths + resources freed up, the overall population will be back to its pre-snap number in a few solar years tops (ed: ok maybe longer, on earth it took ~200 years for Europeans to recover from the plague, but that's just earth and just Europeans). Would have been better to target fertility rates, or kill more females than males and more asexually reproducing sentients than non.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by gambiting on Monday May 14, 2018 @11:37AM (#17066382)
Or you know....if we're arguing about potential solutions to unhappiness in the universe when the infinity gauntlet literally allows the wearer to do anything they desire, then why not just give everyone limitless resources, or just make everyone permanently happy, or eliminate greed or fear or violence.

I still like the idea of wiping half of life in the entire universe though, it works well from the narrative perspective.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by mirceal on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:20PM (#17071141)
I said he had a vision, not that the vision made sense
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by acjohnson55 on Monday May 14, 2018 @11:22AM (#17066251)
Especially within the discourse of black folks, there is a lively debate on the extent to which Killmonger is a villain in Black Panther. My biggest criticism of the movie is that they could have written it to make it even more ambiguous, by making Killmonger less openly ruthless.

Same goes for the much maligned Marvel's Inhumans, where it's not clear exactly why the Royal Family is deserving of any sympathy.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by Can_Not on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:22AM (#17065236)
I felt like Batman vs Superman had at least a little bit of that.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by RobertRoberts on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:48AM (#17065454)
>I would love a popular movie (maybe even one for kids) where at some point through the movie we get to see things from the "bad guy"'s point of view...

Has society gotten so corrupt that we can't see that almost all the "good guys" are total villains compared to the moral and ethical norms from even as recent as 30 years ago?

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by dpark on Monday May 14, 2018 @11:07AM (#17066155)
Apparently, because I don’t know what you’re talking about. 30 years ago we were celebrating a vigilante who threw a criminal off a building in revenge for the death of his parents. [1]

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batman_(1989_film)

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by RobertRoberts on Monday May 14, 2018 @05:19PM (#17069557)
Yes, there has been and always will be anti-heroes. The difference is that instead of that being the exception, it's now the rule.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by dpark on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:36PM (#17071193)
I don’t agree that everyone is an anti hero now, but regardless the complexity is a sign of the medium maturing.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by Spare_account on Monday May 14, 2018 @11:29AM (#17066310)
This sounds like rose-tinted glasses. Can you expand upon it with some examples of who you had in mind when you wrote the comment?
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by RobertRoberts on Monday May 14, 2018 @05:30PM (#17069622)
Being good is evidently boring...

I added a few examples in another comment. Even Rambo sacrificed his own safety and freedom to help rescue POWs.

Modern day heroes are all a bunch of whining self-centered children. Just go watch any super hero movie today for a good example of that.

It's almost a badge of honor to be morally ambiguous. Compare a list of protaganists, how many are anti-heros? Do we even have any real good guys in movies and tv these days? Even Superman has been turned into a murderer for this generation.

A few examples from popular TV:

Walking Dead: everyone is a murderer. Murder is justified consistently.

Billions: It's hard to know who to root for, they are all rotten. The righteous people are the "bad guys"

Scrubs: All the characters are morally bankrupt (compared to 30 years before it's time)

Ironman: A selfish rich asshole.

Batman: (ok, he was always an anti-hero from day 1)

Deadpool: Do I need to explain this one?

Wicked: A play about how the evil witch is misunderstood.

The Shield, The Wire, modern Star Trek vs old Star Trek, the list is too long...

There has always been corruptions, lack of morals. That's not my issue, it's that today, there simply isn't even close to a minority of actual real main protagonists that are selfless.

I think people find good people trying to do what is right just boring these days.

/rant

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by dpark on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:46PM (#17071240)
I think what you’re seeing is characters not being so one-dimensional. You harken back to simplistic characters who have no depth (A-Team, G I Joe, Rocky) and dismiss more complex characters (many of which are not actually new) for not portraying simplistic morality. But this isn’t moral bankruptcy. Real people are complex and portraying hero’s so idealistically makes them less relatable and frankly, yes, boring.

You call Iron Man a selfish, rich asshole. But this is the character who shut down his defense contracts worth billions because he found out that his weapons weren’t being used the way he thought. He also sided with the UN (or whatever equivalent) against his team, in deference to traditional hierarchical authority. If anything, his morals are simpler than many other modern characters. He’s just not as flat as the Superman written for Reeves.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by elboru on Monday May 14, 2018 @11:08AM (#17066158)
Would you mind sharing an example?
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by RobertRoberts on Monday May 14, 2018 @05:19PM (#17069551)
A-Team, GI-Joe, Rocky, heck, even Terminator 2 (the machine) from the early 90s tried really hard not to kill people.

Go back further, and the good guy "sacrificed" himself or his own interests for the benefit of others.

Edit: Rocky isn't a great example, but leaving it in because at least it was inspiring to try and rise above his place in life honestly.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by 13years on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:33AM (#17065330)
The modern Battlestar Galactica series was excellent in this regard. Although, target audience is not children.

Started with a black and white view of good vs bad, but started pulling that apart as by mid way through there was no appropriate label for any side. You began to question what was good and what was bad and why.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by jjaredsimpson on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:17AM (#17065718)
I dunno. I think the Cylons are clearly bad. Genocide, pursuit, enslavement. Sure they have a grievance. But the response was quite disproportionate.

If you restrict the scope to just human interaction on ships then you retrieve the good-bad spectrum. A caste system, a military dictatorship, black markets, etc.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by dpark on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:59AM (#17066094)
Battlestar Gallactica had mostly clear good/evil lines. What they didn’t do is paint all humans as good and all Cylons as evil. There were good Cylons and evil humans throughout along with plenty on each side who were not clearly good or evil but some mix.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by iamben on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:46AM (#17064944)
TV (albeit adult TV) is much better at this. Many of the most popular shows feature antiheroes/flawed characters. You know what they're doing is bad/wrong and yet you're rooting for them anyway.

Ironically I'm not sure it makes a difference. I think in a kind of perverse voyeuristic way people like to live through them, but stay safe in the knowledge that they "could never do that". Like the kind of excitement you got from being around the naughty kid at school, without actually risking getting in trouble.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by sykh on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:48AM (#17064954)
The TV series “The Wire” does this in an extraordinary way.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by krisroadruck on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:59AM (#17065564)
If you have Youtube Red, there is a show they just did called Cobra Kai where they look at the Karate kids nemesis 30 years later. In one episode the guy is recounting some event to one of his students from the opposite perspective as we were fed in the original movie and it fills this idea you describe above really nicely. Check it out if you get a chance.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by oldcynic on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:45AM (#17065964)
V for Vendetta springs to mind, depending on how young the kids are. Although it's too clear early on that it's the regime that's bad not our bad guy hero.

Grendel, Grendel, Grendel[0] Superb children's animation from the 80s. Though you might be very hard pressed to find it. A retelling of Beowulf from the monster's point of view whilst paying homage to Monty Python. He's big, bad, misunderstood and ultimately dies when our human hero Beowulf ambushes him. Never full of Disney shmaltz and cute, deep enough to give you plenty of talking points.

[0] https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0082478/

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by derivagral on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:38AM (#17064883)
Despicable Me & Megamind remind me of that.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by FranzFerdiNaN on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:24AM (#17065247)
You should watch The Wire, which is exactly what you describe. In fact, everyone should watch it, as it is one of the best shows ever made (despite the wonky final season).
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by jpindar on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:38AM (#17065900)
Not a movie, and certainly not for kids, but that's part of the appeal of Game of Thrones.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by dragonwriter on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:30AM (#17065299)
> I would love a popular movie (maybe even one for kids) where at some point through the movie we get to see things from the "bad guy"'s point of view and discover that it actually makes sense

Lots of movies with bad guys and good guys do that, but mostly just without...

> leaving the viewer undecided on whether they support the good or the bad guy.

(Or, if they do that for a while, they resolve it, for most viewers, by the end.) In fact, any movie with a well defined “good guy” and “bad guy” does so specifically because it either doesn't do that or resolved it before the end. Otherwise you have at best a winner and a loser.

OTOH, lots of movies that aren't action movies are driven by character conflict where there isn't a well-defined bad guy and good guy, and where the protagonist is differentiated from other characters by focus and arc, not by superior virtue, and where it's quite possible to disagree on whether the protagonist or someone with which they had a conflict was more right, because “good guy defeats threat of bad guy” isn't the story model.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by RHSeeger on Monday May 14, 2018 @11:48AM (#17066474)
There's a quote that they use frequently in Marvel: Agents of Shield... everyone is a good guy in their own story. Even the people they are trying to stop, much of the time, are viewing the world in a way that makes their (sometimes horrific) actions seem the right thing to do.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by furgooswft13 on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:34AM (#17065335)
Not movies but...

Avatar: The Last Airbender the cartoon tv show is a perfect example of this. For kids and adults alike.

Also Star Trek DS9 did an excellent job of getting into the villains heads, spending time with them and showing their perspectives and motives.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by LambdaComplex on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:27AM (#17065803)
> Star Trek DS9

And even the "good guys" did some questionable stuff, e.g. in In the Pale Moonlight. But that's my favorite Trek episode ever out of all the shows, so I'm not complaining

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by nickspacek on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:31AM (#17065852)
I completely missed Avatar: TLA when I was younger (it was a bit after my time) but have been watching it now as an adult and love this about it. My kids also got really into the conflicted nature of the "bad guys". They did a great job delving into the moral conflicts on both sides.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by lossolo on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:03AM (#17065097)
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by pvaldes on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:59AM (#17065561)
Watchmen for children... hem, probably not.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by cmiles74 on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:25AM (#17065262)
"Star Butterfly vs. The Forces of Evil" has several episodes like this: the first half will be from one character's point of view and the second half from the opposing side.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_vs._the_Forces_of_Evil

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by letsgetphysITal on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:45AM (#17064935)
The Watchmen did this well.

Spoliers

Spoliers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Ozymandias did unify the world, after all.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by michaelscott on Monday May 14, 2018 @11:02AM (#17066112)
I always found the ending to that personally unsettling, because I actually agreed with him and he does end up accomplishing a greater good.

It's great because it divides the present heroes as well, with Rorschach the absolutist morality on one side, Dr Manhattan as the complete pragmatist on the other, and everyone else somewhere in between.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by Sacho on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:38AM (#17064885)
There's probably many movies like this, but I'm not a movie buff so I can't give an example right off the bat. I know of the video game Quantum Break, which included short live-action episodes between gameplay chapters from the villain's POV. They served to explain the villains' actions and humanize them.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by mbrumlow on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:16AM (#17065188)
Every once in a while there is a episode of Criminal Minds that does this. Well sort of. Like I don't think anybody could ever get behind what the "bad" guy is doing, but you can at last understand and then feel sorry for the "bad" guy.

This is also one of the few shows where they try not to kill the bad guy every time.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by dragonwriter on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:33AM (#17065325)
> This is also one of the few shows where they try not to kill the bad guy every time.

That's actually fairly common in TV shows. Police procedurals, for one example, where they try to kill the bad guy every time are kind of exceptional.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by dfxm12 on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:44AM (#17064925)
This is why I hope Marvel somehow gets the rights to DR. DOOM and adapts Triumph and Torment for the big screen.

Most comic book villains lack any redeeming quality (largely on purpose, to remove any chance for empathy and justify the heroes' wanton destruction), but DOOM is refreshingly multi-dimensional for a villain.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by michaelscott on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:55AM (#17066049)
Magneto has always been that type of character for me. Considering his back story and how you happen to view the world yourself, you can very easily see him as being the good guy against the hateful and prejudiced humans (and Xavier as being too pacifist and unable to enact any "real" change).
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by nyxtom on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:38AM (#17064881)
Some of the greatest villains are built on this concept of deep sympathy with the character. At least I think so.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by smileysteve on Monday May 14, 2018 @12:37PM (#17066895)
After reading through this thread; I think of Shrek

The big scary Ogre comes to the rescue instead of Prince Charming. Something about government plans for land and evil fairy God mothers.

--- And then there is Frozen,

A Girl is taught to conceal, not feel, and turns the whole place into an icicle and is in many ways considered the wicked person.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by dudul on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:22AM (#17065763)
There are plenty of examples.

This is one of the reasons why I actually like the X-Men movies a lot (at least the 1st ones), while I hate most superhero movies. I find the character of Magneto, with his backstory and his relationship with Xavier really interesting.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by kaybe on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:53AM (#17065496)
In this vein, I can recommend this review of 7 Samurai:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jZSRxp-dJ-Q

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by modzu on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:47AM (#17065449)
King of New York (1990) is a good one

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0099939/

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by wiseleo on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:27AM (#17065805)
Not a movie, but there is an anime about that.

It's called Magica Madoca. It completely flips the roles by the end.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by amelius on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:42AM (#17064908)
Any movie where the bad guy's motive is not "greed", probably.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by icebraining on Monday May 14, 2018 @11:56AM (#17066556)
No Country for Old Men, Death Proof, Cape Fear, Dead Calm...
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by KaoruAoiShiho on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:49AM (#17065463)
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by ljm on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:56AM (#17066059)
It sometimes goes well beyond that too, where the ‘bad guy’ isn’t human enough to deserve any kind of compassion and so becomes an object for any kind of abuse or revenge the ‘good guys’ care to throw at them, and not all of this is just in the realm of TV fantasy because it’s clearly catering to a certain audience mindset.

- torture is okay if someone is a suspect

- jokes about being raped in prison

- all of the shitty treatment suspects get in police procedurals and detective shows, at the hands of the ‘heroes’

Even if they turn out to be innocent, it’s still like they’re guilty of not being innocent enough which justifies the abuse, while the apparent good guys are celebrated for being utterly sociopathic.

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by V-2 on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:08AM (#17065124)
Only that's not the case at all. Popular cinema and TV are bursting at the seams with antiheroes. From Clockwork Orange through Hannibal Lecter to Sopranos, Dexter, Breaking Bad...
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by Can_Not on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:39AM (#17065376)
For some people's tastes, it's not the same thing. Those are about making bad guys relatable and struggle against the good guys. OP more likely meant if neither side of the conflict were good or bad.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by eeZah7Ux on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:42AM (#17064907)
For millennia, traditional myths and stories have been going against the just-world fallacy [1]

Painting a good VS bad worldview has been heavily used for mass propaganda and it became very effective starting from WW2 due to television and movies.

[1] https://youarenotsosmart.com/2010/06/07/the-just-world-falla...

Related: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yO0v_JqxFmQ

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by Jach on Monday May 14, 2018 @10:51AM (#17066020)
It didn't always seem to be this way though: https://aeon.co/essays/why-is-pop-culture-obsessed-with-batt...

And it's not necessarily just because of the shape of post-WW2 society either: http://www.overcomingbias.com/2018/03/beware-covert-war-mora...

Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by CompelTechnic on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:33AM (#17064852)
I feel like more recent kid-targeted movies have had a lot more moral nuance than the classics and fairy tales do. There are often sympathetic antagonists, flawed heroes, etc.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by awat on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:38AM (#17064882)
I’d have to agree with this. The first charector that comes to mind for me is Magneto I think he reacts how a lot of people would even though that makes him an antagonist. I had a history teacher use him vs Professor X in Jr. High as a way to better convey the nuance of opposition styles.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by qwerty456127 on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:05AM (#17065104)
There are some that show the villain background, musings and/or rehabilitation. There also are some that show a hero becoming a villain. In fact many movies show and emphasize the reality is far from black-and-white. Unfortunately many people still don't get it and keep judging the characters just as good or bad.
Re:Jails are replacing visits with video calls–inmates and f... by rgrieselhuber on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:37AM (#17064872)
Expand this out further and it's clear that manufactured dialectics are a very useful tool in controlling large amount of the population.