News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by sithadmin on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @01:57PM (#16969514)
I paid my rent and living expenses when pursuing my Masters degree by writing papers for services that helped undergrads cheat on class/term papers.

I don't regret it at all. It helped me become a faster, more efficient author, and in my experience, the sort of student that would pay someone else to buy a paper will end up failing out one way or another regardless. I knew people that paid for papers in undergrand, and most either flunked out, or barely graduated and ended up worse off than our other classmates in terms of job/grad school prospects.

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by badlucklottery on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @02:05PM (#16969620)
>or barely graduated and ended up worse off than our other classmates in terms of job/grad school prospects.

And also devalues the degree their peers actually worked for, even if only a little. I've been in a lot of interviews where I'm wondering, "How the hell did this person graduate from ${school}?" and the obvious answer is "a non-zero amount of cheating".

I don't think you should beat yourself up over it but I also think but it's also important not to rationalize it away either.

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by sithadmin on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @02:08PM (#16969652)
Personally, I don't really see meaningful value in degrees anyway, so I don't really buy that line of argumentation. My only reason for pursuing graduate studies was to pass the barrier to entry for an academic position, but I gave up on that and went into consulting.
Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by badlucklottery on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @02:23PM (#16969824)
>I don't really see meaningful value in degrees anyway

Do you see how that's a rationalization strategy? Maybe you honestly don't but discounting the value of the degree to zero makes your actions victimless. But, if the value is non-zero, damage has been done.

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by sithadmin on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @02:56PM (#16970209)
Rationalization? No. There's no rationalization going on in my head. I just don't care.

But if people are going to argue about it? Sure, I'll raise a counterpoint.

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by ThoAppelsin on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @04:04AM (#16974973)
You should care. It is your responsibility to care from the point on when you've decided to take a part in these events. You shouldn't have initiated with them if you wanted to be so careless.
Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by andai on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @01:22AM (#16974267)
There's no nice way to say this, but you might be a sociopath.
Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by ttoinou on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @02:36PM (#16969978)
He acted morally right to me. Lowering value of shitty diplomas you can cheat easily is useful to society, and brings future competition to this industry
Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by openasocket on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @02:44PM (#16970082)
Is stealing from stores that don't have good security also useful to society, by bringing future competition to the industry? And if so, does that make stealing moral?
Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by Franciscouzo on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @06:34PM (#16972361)
The difference is that diplomas are not fungible but most products bought from a store are.
Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by openasocket on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @07:08PM (#16972579)
I don't understand how that changes the reasoning. If something is immoral, I argue that it is still immoral even if everyone is doing it. Why would that change if that something immoral involved a non-fungible good?
Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by ttoinou on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @02:52PM (#16970160)
My second sentence was not a justification to the first one, just one of the intended consequences on society of what he did.

How did his action compares to stealing ?

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by openasocket on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @03:03PM (#16970298)
I thought your second sentence was meant to be a justification of the first. So what is your justification for why what he did is morally right?
Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by ttoinou on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @03:06PM (#16970317)
The students lied to their professor, he just sold them the text so I don't see any wrong doing on his part.

Can you justify why it would be bad to ghostwrite ?

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by openasocket on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @03:28PM (#16970544)
Cheating is immoral. Helping someone do something immoral is also immoral. Therefore, what he is doing is wrong.

Do you disagree with the first sentence or the second?

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @03:29PM (#16970561)
There can be shades of everything of course. If a cheater uses a legitimate ghostwriting service, maybe doesn't rise to the level of 'immoral'.

But that might not be the case here?

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by ttoinou on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @04:40PM (#16971333)
I'm not sure what cheating means here, it is about lying to professors.

   Helping someone do something immoral is also immoral. 
Depends on the circumstances
Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by openasocket on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @07:14PM (#16972634)
Cheating means to use dishonesty to receive something you do not deserve. Like stealing the answer key to a test and just copying the answers blindly instead of learning the material. Having someone else write as essay you were assigned is a clear example of cheating. It is also an example of lying to professors, but cheating is a more clear term. This isn't like telling a professor you like their shirt when you think it is ugly, this is fraud. If you are caught cheating in college the penalty is at least failing the class and can often lead to being expelled from the school. People caught cheating in law school can be rejected from the Bar (meaning they can't practice law) even if they pass their exams. This is a very serious thing, and I don't want to conflate it with a simple lie.

Can you explain under what circumstances you don't think my reasoning that "Helping someone do something immoral is also immoral" would not hold? And how those circumstances apply to this case?

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by ttoinou on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @08:03PM (#16972914)
It would hold or not hold depending on the specifics, what "helping" mean in that case. I could take an extreme case and ask you if the engineers designing the computer that "helped" them cheat are also morally responsible ?

And I don't care about the consequences for the cheater, as long as it doesn't fallback on someone innocent or who did not voluntarily agreed to be part of the scheme

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by openasocket on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @08:39PM (#16973127)
> It would hold or not hold depending on the specifics, what "helping" mean in that case. I could take an extreme case and ask you if the engineers designing the computer that "helped" them cheat are also morally responsible ?

The case we are talking about is the OP, who knowingly helped people cheat. Students asked him to write their essays for them and he did so. This isn't like making a computer that someone could potentially later use to do something immoral, the OP knew in advance what would happen.

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by borkt on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @03:02PM (#16970280)
I agree. I got fairly close to finishing but was disillusioned by a few teachers and students who clearly weren't there for the right reason. I had a graduate professor that specifically forbid us to work in groups on problem sets. When I would only make it half way after days of work, my professor would ask what is wrong with me and why im not completing work. When I mention I saw the rest of the class working together he said if you can't solve it thats what I should have done. So break the rules he set to do better? It just made no sense.

That and people splitting assignments up and then bringing together each persons contribution and copying it. It was done far more often than not, and in the open right down the hall from a teachers office hours. I decided it really wasn't an environment I wanted to be in and just moved on.

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by sithadmin on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @04:21PM (#16971115)
Sounds par for the course to me.

I was working towards a degree in the social sciences at a top 5 (for my field) university/top 10 in general. I was mostly disillusioned by the professors that put little to no effort into leading engaging seminars (some of which were the top living 'experts' in their fields), and the fact that so many other postdocs from other top 5 schools were adjuncting at my university and just sitting in on my classes, with no hope for actually obtaining a tenure track position anywhere.

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by nfoz on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @02:22PM (#16969806)
I think that lying is wrong (immoral), even if your assessment of the externalities of it aren't that bad. Here you're not the one lying, you're selling the mechanism of another's dishonesty. It's interesting to think about where that fits, but I can't see it in a favourable light.

When you're profiting from it, it makes it hard to fairly assess those externalities. The rationalizing in your post is pretty apparent.

I think there are a lot of legitimate concerns about the idea of class grading and hiring metrics etc., but "I might as well profit from others' dishonesty" is maybe not the right way to respond to that.

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by candiodari on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @11:41PM (#16973871)
On the other hand, even a little bit off attention of the professors or assistants would expose every last cheater. Cheaters don't even read the assignments they hand in (I've seen people expelled for handing in a paper where the name of the author on the 2nd page onward was different, seen different people hand in the same paper, ...)

A few questions would trivially expose them.

Clearly universities simply don't check. And frankly, we all know that this isn't an individual oversight, but a policy.

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by nfoz on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @02:56AM (#16974728)
But see, I don't think that's "the other hand". It seems unrelated, at best, to the moral question of whether you should profit from helping other people to cheat.

Maybe the schools should put more effort into catching and punishing cheaters. But they shouldn't have to -- if the students were being honest.

The easier and cheaper it is to cheat, the more tempted the students will be. You can lubricate that market by providing the cheating-materials, maybe even by marketing them. Cheating numbers will go up, thus increasing the cost to detect and catch and appropriately deal with cheaters. The last bit is probably the expensive part.

And the more the schools crack down on easily-detectible cheating, the more sophisticated it will get. Sure that means increasing the cost of cheating, but that's an arms race that can only be won by a culture that values honesty. You reinforce that culture by not selling cheating-materials.

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by candiodari on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @09:46PM (#16982723)
This is just the university demanding others do their work for them. Catching cheaters is a part of the service universities provide, and they want to push that cost onto others.

You talk as if cheaters haven't existed before. As if this is new. You cannot prevent this market from existing, the university simply needs to check.

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by pitt1980 on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @02:06PM (#16969623)
"ended up worse off than our other classmates in terms of job/grad school prospects"

you sure about that?

Just because the jobs they wound up in didn't impress you, doesn't mean that they didn't beat out other honest competitors on the margin for those jobs

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by sithadmin on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @02:08PM (#16969658)
You're not wrong. I can only speak for their outcomes relative to my peers at the university I attended.
Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by Paul-ish on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @09:51PM (#16973458)
Rather than abstaining from or attempting to reform an institution you find flawed, you exploit it for personal gain. If you ever come to find that exploits in your code are used for someone else's personal gain I hope you can be equally equanimous.
Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by logfromblammo on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @03:53PM (#16970831)
That makes sense.

It is probably in the interests of someone with a Master degree to devalue all Bachelor degrees.

But it is also perfectly understandable that those with Bachelor degrees who actually earned them would be super pissed at you for helping a bunch of useless idiots achieve exactly the same institutional recognition, but without the same level of actual mastery, thereby ensuring that they would all have to pass a stupid bozo filter in every job interview for the rest of their lives.

Please try to regret what you have done, just a little bit.

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by carapace on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @07:47PM (#16972811)
> I don't regret it at all.

I don't believe you. I think you do regret it and that's why you're spending so much time here today talking to people about it.

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by shifter on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @02:05PM (#16969614)
That shifts the "cost" to employers... and you profited from it. Does that make it theft? :-)
Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by sithadmin on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @02:09PM (#16969666)
I don't really feel sympathy for employers that don't adequately screen candidates.

And who knows: maybe the cheaters are completely capable of meeting the requirements of whatever job they end up in.

Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by ambicapter on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @02:13PM (#16969698)
inb4 the next HN article decrying hilarious overwrought interviewing practices...
Re:YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating by soperj on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @02:16PM (#16969741)
This is a cost they should be bearing.