News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by bryanh on Friday April 27, 2018 @08:37PM (#16945497)
Disclaimer: said CTO.

Happy to answer any questions — though we definitely don’t presume we have all the answers, we’re constantly learning!

We are also hiring remote engineers — https://zapier.com/jobs/. Would lov to talk to anyone in the JS, k8s, and Python community!

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by hitekker on Friday April 27, 2018 @08:56PM (#16945555)
I recently heard from friends of friends that Zapier conducts reference checks on its candidates without the candidates' permission. By that I mean: finding previous coworkers on LinkedIn, contacting them out-of-the-blue and asking for an appraisal of the person they may-or-may-not have once worked with.

Is there any truth to this rumor?

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by bryanh on Friday April 27, 2018 @10:21PM (#16945770)
We use a service called SkillSurvey for reference checks. It asks the candidate for references in an automated fashion and then the feedback is collected fairly anonymously.

We try to be respectful of people’s situations — EG: it’s never appropriate to contact a current employer without permission. We don’t do that.

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by freedomben on Saturday April 28, 2018 @12:51AM (#16946117)
So to be clear, you only contact references that the candidate provided to you and not others such as connections on LinkedIn? Your answer doesn't seem to specifically deny that you contact people not specifically provided, other than employers.

By the way I read a little on your job site and Zapier sounds like a great place to work :-)

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by bryanh on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:04PM (#16948546)
That is correct. It is our policy to use the tool I mentioned elsewhere in the thread which only contacts the references provided by the candidate -- I'll check internally to make sure no one is deviating from that process.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by swat535 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @07:20PM (#16949951)
I really appreciate this kind of direct transparency
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by paxys on Saturday April 28, 2018 @02:42AM (#16946394)
It would be weird if they randomly found and messaged people from LinkedIn etc. I have, however, seen interviewers and recruiters at a lot of companies reach out to mutual contacts if they find any, and because the SV network is so tight this happens a lot.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by bryanh on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:34PM (#16948669)
> randomly found and messaged people from LinkedIn

We definitely do not do that. As mentioned elsewhere in the thread, I'll double check internally and make it super clear that isn't acceptable.

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by rajacombinator on Saturday April 28, 2018 @07:34AM (#16947183)
In situations like this, lack of explicit denial is generally confirmation.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by pbreit on Saturday April 28, 2018 @02:30AM (#16946357)
“Indirect” references are common in SV.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by hitekker on Friday April 27, 2018 @10:29PM (#16945791)
Cool, makes sense to me.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by justus87 on Friday April 27, 2018 @09:30PM (#16945664)
I interviewed there in August 2017 and they used a service for reference checks that I provided several contacts to.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by clay_the_ripper on Friday April 27, 2018 @09:16PM (#16945615)
Is there something wrong with doing this?
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by trevelyan on Friday April 27, 2018 @09:24PM (#16945646)
Yes. They may not want people to know they are considering leaving their current job. And they may not keep their job if people find out they aren't fully committed.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by godzillabrennus on Friday April 27, 2018 @09:45PM (#16945706)
It’s immoral behavior on the employers part to not ask for permission. IMHO it shows how they will be to work for if you take a job.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by eloff on Friday April 27, 2018 @11:15PM (#16945893)
I don't get why people downvoted you. It is definitely expected that potential employers ask permission. People may apply while having a current job, and not wanting their boss to find out.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by wsinks on Saturday April 28, 2018 @12:01PM (#16948236)
Wow, I didn't realize my expectation was so different. I've always assumed people wouldn't contact my current employer, but why not my previous employers? You're right that it's better to ask permission, then you gain more information about the relationship too. Hm.. good food for thought.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by scaryclam on Sunday April 29, 2018 @08:35AM (#16951746)
Not everything on linkedin is up-to-date or correct. Then there's the issue of some people personally knowing others but the information not being on linkedin. It's pretty easy to accidentally cold call someone for references who will talk to the candidates current employer, and this may even be the reason the candidate left them off of the reference list in the first place.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by SnootyMonkey on Sunday April 29, 2018 @08:15AM (#16951706)
This is something I've never really thought about, the ethics of reference checks. Is anyone aware of a good guide or thoughtful article on the subject?
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by cookiecaper on Saturday April 28, 2018 @02:13AM (#16946312)
Experienced remote engineer here with a good deal of experience in k8s, Python, Linux, application architecture and design, the works. Applied to Zapier Infrastructure Engineer position a little over a year ago, if memory serves. Twice, actually; one time my application was closed out almost immediately. Waited several months and the same gig had been reposted and/or reactivated, so I applied again. This time I got a message once a week for about six weeks that said they were reviewing my application, and then I got a message that said they weren't interested. My only contact was an internal recruiter, and I never spoke to or received any information from anyone technical.

It was a disappointment because I expected better from a YC company's process. Of course, I can't really blame Zapier for passing, as I'm sure there are a great deal of applicants and, since I never talked to anyone, I can't know whether we'd be a good match, technically or culturally. For example, many remote companies, especially those that are primarily staffed with offshore employees, are just trying to pinch pennies and paper over it by talking about the hipness and uniqueness of their remote workforce.

Zapier is a custom Q&A intake application [or, at least the applications I filled out were], so it's irksome to write real answers to those Qs and get nothing back. I'd much rather write an HN post where I can wear my rightly-deserved downvotes and critiques with pride -- then I at least get something for the effort! ;)

So, note well, potential applicants: "would love to talk" seems to mean "would love to have you languish in our HR system after you've taken the time to fill out our bespoke long-form questionnaire". Like I said above, usually it's hard to fault companies too heavily for this, but when the CTO is making a personal appeal on HN, I feel like a counterpoint is warranted.

Hiring in general seems to go very slowly these days. I don't know if everyone is flooded with fake resumes from "bootcamp grads" or what now, but 5 years ago or so, you could normally expect to hear back within a few days if someone was interested. It's a different ball game now. In the last couple weeks I've gotten two replies to applications I sent in around Christmas time -- one "an invitation to interview" from a well-known company (which I ignored), and one a message from another company that they'd closed out my application in their HR platform.

Disclaimer: my experience from memory. Intervals and dates may be fuzzy. Not going to dig up the correspondence.

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by EastSmith on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:25AM (#16946992)
Applied ~2 years ago for a frontend job there, spend half a day answering the initial questions, never got ANY response from them. I mean - a short "Thank you, but no thank you" note would have been just fine. Landed the perfect remote job shortly after.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by bryanh on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:24PM (#16948628)
Yeah, that was unacceptable of us. No excuses. We've gotten better with our https://zapier.com/jobs/our-commitment-to-applicants/.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by ddorian43 on Sunday April 29, 2018 @08:12AM (#16951694)
The same for me. I even rewrote the questions as answers and didn't even get an acknowledgement.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by sah2ed on Saturday April 28, 2018 @10:10AM (#16947708)
> ... spend half a day answering the initial questions

Half a day??? Talk about dedication :)!

Anyway, Zapier's process appears to have improved from 2 years ago -- they commit to and usually succeed in responding to your application within a week now.

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by bogomipz on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:44AM (#16947599)
>"Hiring in general seems to go very slowly these days. I don't know if everyone is flooded with fake resumes from "bootcamp grads" or what now, but 5 years ago or so, you could normally expect to hear back within a few days if someone was interested."

This has been my experience and observation as well. I have regularly gotten responses from recruiters months after I applied for roles and have already taken something something elsewhere.

And curiously the recruiters don't ever bother to even acknowledge that months have passed since I applied. Or bother to ask if I am even still looking.

I am curious if anyone knows what the cause of this is. Is this simply the proliferation of incompetent recruiters? Is it just companies advertisings roles that aren't "actually" hiring for at the moment in order source CVs? Something else?

But as you mentioned this was not always the case. This seems to be recent-ish phenomenon in my observation(last ~3 years.) Not even large fortune 500s move as this glacial pace. What's more baffling is that this phenomenon exists at all in a tight labor market.

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by bryanh on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:22PM (#16948622)
I appreciate you sharing your experience -- our commitment to candidates includes regular correspondence so candidates don't go into a black hole of no response -- we know that is extremely frustrating.

We definitely do get a lot of candidates, but that doesn't excuse poor experiences and we truly try to do our best. Hiring truly is an flawed and messy process on both sides.

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by cerebrum on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:47AM (#16946718)
Cookiecaper, I understand where you are coming from but complaining only makes you look like a sore loser. You are not helping your position by this post. Consider taking constructive action.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by barry-cotter on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:34AM (#16947024)
He’s telling people about his experience of applying to Zapier in the comments to a post about Zapier. It’s relevant and no more gives the impression of being sour grapes than the people who don’t interview at Google after two rounds of apply again next year when Google recruiters email them.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by bryanh on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:42PM (#16948702)
I'm glad he shared, it helps provide lots of context around candidates' viewpoints and experiences.

Generally, we've found it best not to look away from the mistakes we make, and we make our fair share of them! By doing that we hope to not repeat them, or at least repeat them less often.

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by cookiecaper on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:05PM (#16950245)
I appreciate your POV. I tried to communicate that this wasn't a case of sour grapes. I don't have any ill will toward Zapier. I will try to be more explicit about that next time I leave a similar comment.

There are many valid and plausible reasons that they could've chosen not to move forward in the interview process: maybe they got to another hireable candidate before they even seriously considered my application, maybe there is some specific technical need that I clearly don't meet and which I'm not picking up on from the job description, maybe something else.

And I can't see anyone else in the candidate pool either; while I'm good at things, undoubtedly there is a non-trivial quantity of people who are better. Candidates are compared and contrasted against the pool of other applicants; if there is someone else whose qualifications blow mine out of the water, or who is technically comparable but much cheaper, then who can blame Zapier for taking the obviously-superior option? I can't see the other applicants, so I can't know whether or not there was a slam-dunk applicant who made the merely "great" applicants pale in comparison.

Even if I'm highly qualified and there isn't anyone clearly superior in a comparable price range, people often can't quantify a firm rational basis for their specific preferences between candidates (and this becomes even more apparent once you're on the other side of the table).

This is when the infamous "culture fit" is broken out. I was once told that I had been passed over because I "wasn't assertive enough" after I spent most of an interview blasting the use of MySQL in a specific industrial application. There's no way that note wasn't intended as passive-aggressive retaliation. :P

Recently I was dismissed from a candidate pool because my answer to "Tell me about a time you resolved a problem with a colleague" hadn't been rehearsed to the satisfaction of the interviewer, who was one of those "I'm technical because I read WIRED and like being nerdy" types. That is just a different preference in technical depth as far as I'm concerned. Technically strong people are going to worry about technical interview content and focus on that rather than their answers to tired cliches.

Sometimes even things that seem trivial or silly can be a bigger impediment in context. For example, my first name is Jeff. I know of at least a couple of gigs that I've lost solely because there were already 3 or more Jeffs involved in the work on a daily basis and they didn't want to make the situation worse! "Jeff" is a somewhat common name but it's not super common -- sometimes I wonder how frequently this happens to Johns or Steves.

tl;dr it's just impossible to know whether a hiring decision is justified or not without having the insider dialogue and insight, and even then, don't expect stellar rationale. As bryanh said elsewhere upthread, hiring is a messy process.

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by roberttod on Friday April 27, 2018 @09:46PM (#16945712)
I've worked as a remote tech lead for a couple of years and I often find myself at 6pm New York time asking an important question to someone in London, 11pm their time. Slack is bad for this, I wonder what people make of me DMing them that late, also I rarely get a response the next day. How does the "Async" blog you mentioned solve these sort of issues? Is it just a regular blog or does it have special features?
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by bryanh on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:13PM (#16948574)
Async is for the area between "Slack" and "Documentation" -- it covers things like project statuses, requests for comment, new feature discussions, company announcements, Friday updates and lots more. You can think of it like a cross between a blog and Twitter feed. We're starting to add more Reddit-like features for customizing the experience and sub-groups but that is pretty early still.

I don't think Async solves the problem you mention -- that is more of a cultural thing. We expect folks to message each-other frequently (preferably in a public room with an @ mention) but set the expectation that you don't need to respond immediately. The public aspect is important as you will often get "drive-by help" from someone else on the team!

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by samastur on Saturday April 28, 2018 @03:42AM (#16946575)
Have experience working in teams up to 9 time zones apart, but not working at Zapier.

I have phone set up to not disturb me with notifications between 10pm and 7am so I wouldn't mind as long as nobody expects a response before next working day morning. Before I could do that I simply did not have company's chat/email on my phone.

My day starts with reviewing any received messages (no matter what channel -- email, chat...) and responding to them. I would find it unprofessional if someone did not. If this wasn't just an occasional oversight, then I would take it up with them.

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by viraptor on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:12AM (#16946782)
Not from zapier. I think it's up to them to disconnect from work chat on their private phones, or silence it out of hours. I worked in TZ 11h away from the rest of the team and unless I was on call, I wouldn't see any messages until morning/Monday. If you don't want it to look like you expect an immediate response, you can always add something like "..., when you start your day."
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by mseebach on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:49AM (#16947064)
Slack has a scheduled do not disturb feature, you can set a period every day when you don't want to be disturbed by notifications. If someone DMs you, Slackbot tells them that you're in do not disturb (and gives them the option to "poke through" and notify you anyway). I work for a company with offices in both Europe and US (and people travelling frequently between them, so you don't always know where they are), and this feature is broadly used.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by scaryclam on Saturday April 28, 2018 @03:40PM (#16949121)
"and gives them the option to "poke through" and notify you anyway"

Yeah...this is why I close down slack when I don't want disruptions. There's no point in a DND if others can do it anyway. It shouldn't be an option. If someone at work has an emergency and needs to get hold of me, they can give me a phone call. Non-verbal communications have a tendency to be abused, but the reality of actually having to have a conversation with the person you're disturbing means only serious calls seem to get made.

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by paxys on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:30PM (#16949764)
Sounds like more of a culture problem, and no software can help with that.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by matthewheath on Saturday April 28, 2018 @12:26PM (#16948343)
Speaking solely from personal experience, I find that Async helps keep everyone on the same page. Rather than needing to scroll back through Slack or keep tabs on multiple channels, all I need to do is log in to Async and read the various posts folks have put up that mention me (if you're mentioned, it's important and you should probably read it) as well as other posts that might cover areas outside of my team that interest me.

It's a much more scalable approach than trying to read the backscroll in Slack, IMO.

It has a few special features, but on the whole it's basically like a company-wide journal.

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by scruple on Saturday April 28, 2018 @12:34PM (#16948378)
I am a full-time remote employee, and I also work with folks in South America over to Belarus. I am curious, what is Async? Searching for it on Google is not fruitful.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by matthewheath on Saturday April 28, 2018 @12:40PM (#16948407)
Sorry for not clarifying in my earlier comment: Async is an internal Zapier tool (custom built) used to communicate across the company. Think of it like an internal blog system.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by scruple on Saturday April 28, 2018 @02:27PM (#16948883)
Ah-ha! That's awesome, thanks for the clarification. That does sound very useful, in fact.
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by SnootyMonkey on Sunday April 29, 2018 @08:35AM (#16951747)
We happened to have built an OSS / SaaS version of Asynch if you're interested: https://github.com/open-company / https://carrot.io
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by scruple on Sunday April 29, 2018 @09:46PM (#16955124)
I am! I'll check this out, thanks!
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by otakucode on Saturday April 28, 2018 @03:37AM (#16946561)
Given that you're not handicapped by having your talent pool reduced to those physically close to you by happenstance or willing to uproot their life to get physically near an office, does each opening result in a flood of applicants? Do you find this to be a boon, or a hindrance? You might not be able to compare, but do you think that it makes hiring easier or harder?
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by bryanh on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:29PM (#16948650)
We definitely get a lot of applicants and of course that makes it very difficult to manage at times, but we're also very lucky that so many people want to work for Zapier. We try to be good stewards of that privilege -- which means being prompt and clear in our communication and giving everyone a fair shot.

It does make it harder to hire, but it would be even harder at the other extreme -- if no one applied!

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by cerebrum on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:42AM (#16946711)
Hello Bryan,

you started the company having already a pool of people you knew and trusted.

What if you don't have that? I'm worried about security aspects, hacking, etc...

How is it possible to start a company with remote hires and still have trust that they won't run away with your code, etc... Especially if the remote hires are in another jurisdiction where legal recourse might be hard or impossible?

Thanks

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by eloff on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:33PM (#16948665)
I don't know what you're so worried about. What's to stop anyone in the office from running away with your code? I mean you could have some problems if you're hiring in China or Russia - but even then most of the time people just want an honest, steady job. Your source code is not usually something that anybody else wants, it would be almost impossible to find a buyer.

If you're really worried, just stick to people in developed countries with a sane legal system. But honestly finding people with great communication and technical skills should be a much more important criteria to the success of your company. You're company is much more likely to die from self inflicted wounds than because someone sold your source code to a competitor.

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by bryanh on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:09PM (#16948561)
That is a hard question -- unfortunately it is something you can never be 100% safe on. In the end, you have to trust people to do anything interesting. Generally, we're very careful in hiring, we have basic internal controls, and luckily -- people are generally good. :-)
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by googamooga on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:31AM (#16946210)
What is HyperNews mentioned in your interview?
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by bryanh on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:16PM (#16948584)
That should be "Hacker News", perhaps a typo or garbled phrasing on my part!
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by lasersox on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:20AM (#16946182)
Thank you very much for your openness! I am curious if you are you still using Slack or you rely entirely on Async at this point?

Thanks!

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by matthewheath on Saturday April 28, 2018 @12:24PM (#16948336)
We still use Slack for internal every-day communications. Personally, I treat Async as a summary of things that have gone on around the company this week so I can keep up to date with different departments (Slack is not ideal for doing this.)
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by lasersox on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:39PM (#16949306)
It could be a full-time job just keeping track of everything. Do you have a dedicated person for this?

Are most of your people in the Western hemisphere? I find that with Slack I need to pay close attention to the stream which can be a major distraction. Also it can be kind of a pain going through scrollback if I was asleep for a few hours while others are working.

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by matthewheath on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:46PM (#16949337)
1. Not really? (In regards to having a dedicated person handling this.) We have a weekly hangout where our CEO raises important issues in the week, and most folks are pretty communicative of major issues (e.g. product will tell support what's changed this week so we can be aware when supporting customers, etc.)

I never feel like I'm overwhelmed keeping track of things, since everything is so accessible thanks to Async. It frees me up to let Slack kind of drift past when I'm not working.

2. We're globally distributed. I'm in the UK, for instance, but we have folks in the Eastern Hemisphere too. I will admit that most folks are in the US so right now, we do skew towards the Western Hemisphere, but that might not always be the case.

Also, in support, we have a summary channel in Slack where we post the most important things that someone coming online would need to know about. For example, outages, recent issues, policy changes, important messages, etc. all get posted to a specific channel in Slack so you can read them _without_ the noise of chat involved.

Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by bryanh on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:29PM (#16948655)
This is how I view it as well!
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by zengid on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:06PM (#16949203)
What is your opinion on hiring Juniors for remote work?
Re:Interview with CTO and Co-founder of Zapier on Working wi... by bryanh on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:52PM (#16949363)
We haven’t done it that much before — but might try to do that more now! You really need a strong foundation of senior engineers to help mentor and support junior engineers so most smaller organizations will generally tend to not hire junior engineers until later.