https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-03-09/toys-r-us...
These are charged to the fund (i.e. the investors), not the company. PE firms charge companies transaction fees. "Toys 'R' Us does say in its SEC filings that $47 million in transaction fees that it owed KKR, Bain and Vornado, have been waived. The advisory fees were also voluntarily reduced by the investment firms in recent years" [1].
Private equity isn't VC. When a holding goes bust, the fund loses a lot of money. That, in turn, sharply limits what fund managers can do and how much they can pay themselves, including from other better-performing investments.
[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/nathanvardi/2017/09/19/the-big-...
This isn't equivocally true. It all depends on how levered the investment is and how much debt they pulled off the books to pay back the banks (or their fund). The stereotypical PE fund looks like this: buy company for $100M with 50% debt and 50% equity. Meaning, investment banks give them $50M to buy the company at market rates and the PE firm spends the other $50M from their fund. Load the company up with debt and then pay off the senior credit facilities with the profits while the business slowly dies. In other words, it's very possible that PE firms and their lenders earn profits even if their portfolio companies go bankrupt.
In the case of Toys R Us specifically, it appears they did a 17%/63% levered split...which frankly is exorbitant. Most market norms are more around 50/50:
sank $1.3 billion of equity into the takeover of the Wayne, New Jersey-based toy company, financing the rest with debt, according to company filings.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-09-19/bain-kkr-...
> That, in turn, sharply limits what fund managers can do and how much they can pay themselves
What are you referring to when you say "fund managers"? The LPs? The LPs are super diversified, so that's irrelevant. The GPs make their base salary from management fees and their bonus from carry on the return of the fund. The idea that a fund "loses" money isn't that black and white...their are intricacies into how this plays it out.
Source: Wife is a PE firm founder and I advise PE firms.
Losing a dollar is losing a dollar, diversified or not. The investors in these PE funds lost money. Where they net out against other investments is irrelevant.
> GPs make their base salary from management fees and their bonus from carry on the return of the fund
Salary, yes. But good luck earning any carry on this fund. (They'll be lucky if DPI crosses 1x with a hole this big.) Agree that PE accounting is complicated.
Again, depends on who's left with the debt...the typical large cap PE playbook is to hand the debt off to the company, while the PE firm and the senior debt have been paid off by the time the company gets liquidated. I haven't reviewed all of the financials and the SEC filings, but normally if you're levered at 63%, then it's likely they were able to pay off the equity in short order.
See case study here: https://d1ge0kk1l5kms0.cloudfront.net/images/G/01/books/stec...
Another trend that was gaining popularity in the private equity industry involved rapidly accessing the capital markets after closing a deal to raise cash to pay a large dividend to the private equity owners. Firms typically used the debt markets to finance these dividends, creating more highly levered, riskier companies. In some cases, dividends paid to private equity firms within one year of their original investment equaled the original equity commitment. In the Hertz LBO transaction, Clayton, Dubilier & Rice, Carlyle Group, and Merrill Lynch collected $1 billion in bank-funded dividends six months after buying rental car company Hertz for $15 billion.6 About four months later, Hertz issued an IPO to pay off the debt and to fund an additional dividend, resulting in total dividends paid to the owners that equaled 54 percent of their original investment of $2.3 billion (still leaving them with 71 percent ownership). Private equity funds also took cash out of their portfolio companies to pay large “advisory” fees to themselves. These fees exceeded $50 million on large transactions during the buyout phase and annual fees often continued throughout their ownership.
In that same article they mention Toyr R Us had ~$600M in EBITDA in 2005 in which they could have easily paid off at the initial $1.3B that the PE firms put up in equity financing. They also paid 9x (!!!!) EBITDA for a Retailer....that's a ridiculous multiple with highly unlikely outcomes for multiple expansion. So you only have three options (1) debt pump and dump (2) consolidate the back-office (3) buy add-ons.
This is all leads me to believe that the real suckers in this whole thing are the current debtors. Pure speculation on my side, but I really believe that Toys R Us was already on it's way out (e.g. Amazon). Bain/KKR trying to find deal flow where none could be found, figured they had two viable intertwined paths (1) try to sell it to Amazon (2) load it up with so much debt that if they couldn't sell it to Amazon, they wouldn't lose money if they paid themselves back before it went into bankruptcy.
Capitalists place bets in things that go down too.
PS - 1x DPI ain't terrible in a seller's market (which it has been for large cap in the last 10 years). I'm not sure what KKR or Bain fund this deal came out of, but the real truth will be in there.
Yes, we do. It's disclosed in SEC and bankruptcy filings; they lost money [1].
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-09-19/bain-kkr-...
Marketplace says that Bain and KKR made money off of the deal.
https://www.marketplace.org/2018/03/06/business/toys-r-us-an...
"The private equity firms’ investors haven’t made money off this deal. But the firms themselves have. It’s unclear where Vornado ended up. But after collecting fees from Toys R Us, Bain and KKR each took home at least $15 million."
With all due respect to you, the author of that article doesn't understand how PE funds work. (Most people don't. But one shouldn't write an article if that badly misinformed.)
Private equity funds are structured assuming portfolio companies won't vanish. They may lose some money. But between 1998 and 2010 only 4.9% of PE-backed companies defaulted, and of those, 72% did a Chapter 11 or pre-packaged bankruptcy [1]. As a result, when funds get fees or interests, the general partners are allowed to pay themselves a little something up front. If it turns out they overpaid themselves in year 1, they can make up for it by underpaying themselves in year 7.
Which makes a liquidation, like this one, nasty for the managers. First, their high water mark is toast. Second, most of that $15 million will find its way to the fund's limited partners. If the fund paid out its managers, clawback terms could be triggered. That means fuck year 7, you return the overpayment now.
Private equity managers are smart. But their limited partners aren't dunces. We've gone through cycles, up and down, with PE. The terms have "learned". Liquidations of PE-backed companies are rare. Nobody is walking away from this happy or whole.
[1] http://portal.idc.ac.il/en/schools/economics/about/documents...
+ YouTube + Amazon: Lets kids see what a toy looks like in HD, whereas previously you'd need to go to a store to see the big images on the box, or to press the "try me" buttons. As you said, the brand drives most of the sales, so the store experience adds little.
+ Advanced Supply Chains/McDonalds: The toys in Happy Meals are insanely nice, I wouldn't be surprised to see them retail for $5-10 at a toy store. High-quality toys are throw-ins for a lot of stores now, obviating the need for a special purpose store, save for Christmas/Birthdays.
+ YouTube + Grocery Store: The rise of Surprise Eggs over the last few years has been astounding, to the point that a decent amount of our toy budget is spent at the checkout line at the grocer, where these eggs are increasingly on offer.
+ YouTube + DIY: The explosion in popularity of DIY slime is another development where tactile time is invested in a project rather than a packaged toy.
+ Apps: The YouTube Kids app and the many thousands of quality games on offer in the app store are great substitutes for plastic junk.
No doubt debt played a role, but I think almost every story has underplayed massive changes in the toy market that are an additional headwind to the industry.
I avoid certain stores in order to avoid the whole "I want this, I want, I want, whine whine" in the store and then at the checkout. I understand Toys R Us playing to this, going in you know it's going to happen...
but rather than really trying to increase it with impulse things at the entrance and then at the checkout, especially with things like candy, they could innovate.
Giving the kids a scanner like some of the walmarts have available and letting them zap all their wants, like some stores have with wedding registries, then letting them print a list or send to an app and then be able to sort by most wanted, etc - easy sharing.. could increase sales, and take care of the whining problem for example.
I'd also support a non candy aisle by spending more money if it had fresh fruit / veggy snacks for example, and I think others would as well.
The wall street greed that pushes some of these methods of selling is backfiring in some ways that are uncountable - if your app could detect the times I need something, yet drive by your store because kids and your impulse check out aisles..
Why waste money on things that get an initial "wow!" - only to be tossed into a pile and never used, when there are tons of privacy stealing ad supported free things that take all the time and attention.
Last holiday I looked through the TUS online and offline catalogues for 10-12 age range, found 2 things that may be interesting to the youngin' here; one was a watch.
Strangely card based games like pokemon yugio mtg can actually get groups of kids involved without the need for electronics, but I don't think those alone would keep a large warehouse in business. I am also not driving across town when target has the card packs a mile from here, and specialized card shops are all over town.
I did see TUS expand it's electronics section, but the ad supported freemium models don't sell many games, just hardware once every so often.
Sad to see TUS go, unlike GP commenter, I don't think the author is crazy, I believe that shareholders often influence places to make decisions that may raise profits in the short term yet lose the war after a couple of years. It may not be the only reason, but I'd wager it's one of the main ones out of the top 10 perhaps.
Additionally, walking out of a store with something is a nice experience, maybe reading the manual on the way home, instead of waiting a week to get something unless you have prime or pay for faster shipping.
Amazon is definitely convenient, but it's sad to see Toys R Us go. Stores like that provide a real added value in my opinion.
Couldn't see what the value add was. I'll take my local toy shop, thanks.
Toys R Us is a pretty basic economic transaction. They sold toys, and the people buying them get the value. We're not dealing with public goods or externalities or any other type of market failure where this type of value might be tricky to pick up.
On the other hand, a toy store is stocked only with management's recommendations. They're not fools, either, they only stock what they expect to sell well - mainstream, right down the center products.
You only think it's better reading the manual on the way home and not waiting a few days because you're still riding that emotional high.
I much prefer the Amazon approach where feasible, because that detachment helps you keep a more level head while purchasing, which reduces the expenditures on frivolities and you'll have more savings for more meaningful things later.
There's enormous effort expended on this by stores - because it works.
I kind of doubt that this is really the case in practice. There is detachment from the walk by impulse buys. But there is also detachment from the part where you spend your money. One click purchases are just too easy.
And Amazon suggestions are getting better all the time at convincing you to buy more and more. Not to mention the discounts on auto delivered products.
The store can only entice me when I decide to get in a car and drive there and walk in. Amazon is just a click or tap away from absolutely anywhere.
I feel this era is going way too much into sound/engineered decision making for mundane human life, and I say it's detrimental.
I don't see the big deal with a few impulse purchases as long as it's not hurting the family budget.
Our local Target has some choice of baby stuff but nothing like babies r us has. And with the problems of fakes I've ran into on Amazon, I would NEVER trust them with something like a carseat.
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-09-19/bain-kkr-... [2] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-tax-privateequity/u-s... [3] https://www.thedailybeast.com/republicans-love-welfarefor-th...
They invested $1.3 billion. The interest payments were deductible to Toys 'R' Us, which would have been useful if it survived long enough to pay dividends to its equity holders. KKR et al lost money on this.
I think it's hard to say conclusively without being their tax accountants/lawyers:
> > all the debt payments are tax deductible
After declaration of bankruptcy, they probably get tax credits they can use in the coming years... Excuse my inexact terminology, I'm not an Accountant.
Because it is fashionable to assume everyone on Wall Street just makes tons of money at the expense of Main Street, which is a gross oversimplification of what is occurring in today's society.
Although I was initially inclined to agree with the tone of the article, just the numbers in the article itself disproved it's main thesis.
Near the end: > "Bain, KKR, and Vornado will have to write off their investment, of course. But they did suck around $200 million in fees out of Toys 'R' Us over the course of their ownership."
Near the beginning: >"The trio put up $6.6 billion to pay off Toys 'R' Us' shareholders. But it was a leveraged buyout: Only 20 percent came out out of the buyers' pockets."
Net, using these numbers, is that the buyers put in $1320 million and took out $200 million, a net loss of $1.12 billion dollars. This doesn't mention the $5Billion lost by the other investors (minus whatever interim payments were made).
The board and shareholders did well to get out when they did, and I'd hypothesize that the employees, while still losing jobs, had the jobs with the buyout for years longer than they otherwise would have.
So, you are claiming that the author somehow didn't find over a billion dollars in fees for them to break even over 15 years? If so, he's a pretty incompetent journalist. And, even if there are a billion in 'hidden' fees, they still lost money.
For them to have made even a modest 5% interest for 15 years, which is a very modest/baseline profit goal for finance pros, you'd need to find almost $2billion in missing fees.
So, where's the money?
Well, they earn huge payouts because of the risk involved, which is plainly clear in this case.
Did Bain use its own money to buy Toys R Us? No, it was a leveraged buyout. They already made a profit on the transaction. The losers were Toys R Us employees and customers and the banks who provided the loans.
Bain et al lost over a billion dollars. Not only did they invest the equity, they also loaned some of the debt out of their own funds.
The firms got $470 million in fees and interest against their $1.3 billion investment [1]. Bain et al lost money. These numbers were disclosed in SEC and bankruptcy filings.
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-09-19/bain-kkr-...
As in where did the proceeds go? To the previous investors. From whom KKR et al bought Toys 'R' Us. There's a "B" in LBO.
Anyone who despises private equity should be celebrating this story, in this case, KKR/Bain/Vornado were the suckers in the deal, they bought the rotten apple and suffered massive losses because of it.
https://www.nytimes.com/2004/08/12/business/toys-r-us-says-i... https://www.nytimes.com/2005/03/18/business/company-news-toy...