Re:How vulture capitalists ate Toys 'R' Us
by JumpCrisscross on Monday April 23, 2018 @03:50PM
(#16906781)
> But after collecting fees from Toys R Us, Bain and KKR each took home at least $15 million
With all due respect to you, the author of that article doesn't understand how PE funds work. (Most people don't. But one shouldn't write an article if that badly misinformed.)
Private equity funds are structured assuming portfolio companies won't vanish. They may lose some money. But between 1998 and 2010 only 4.9% of PE-backed companies defaulted, and of those, 72% did a Chapter 11 or pre-packaged bankruptcy [1]. As a result, when funds get fees or interests, the general partners are allowed to pay themselves a little something up front. If it turns out they overpaid themselves in year 1, they can make up for it by underpaying themselves in year 7.
Which makes a liquidation, like this one, nasty for the managers. First, their high water mark is toast. Second, most of that $15 million will find its way to the fund's limited partners. If the fund paid out its managers, clawback terms could be triggered. That means fuck year 7, you return the overpayment now.
Private equity managers are smart. But their limited partners aren't dunces. We've gone through cycles, up and down, with PE. The terms have "learned". Liquidations of PE-backed companies are rare. Nobody is walking away from this happy or whole.
With all due respect to you, the author of that article doesn't understand how PE funds work. (Most people don't. But one shouldn't write an article if that badly misinformed.)
Private equity funds are structured assuming portfolio companies won't vanish. They may lose some money. But between 1998 and 2010 only 4.9% of PE-backed companies defaulted, and of those, 72% did a Chapter 11 or pre-packaged bankruptcy [1]. As a result, when funds get fees or interests, the general partners are allowed to pay themselves a little something up front. If it turns out they overpaid themselves in year 1, they can make up for it by underpaying themselves in year 7.
Which makes a liquidation, like this one, nasty for the managers. First, their high water mark is toast. Second, most of that $15 million will find its way to the fund's limited partners. If the fund paid out its managers, clawback terms could be triggered. That means fuck year 7, you return the overpayment now.
Private equity managers are smart. But their limited partners aren't dunces. We've gone through cycles, up and down, with PE. The terms have "learned". Liquidations of PE-backed companies are rare. Nobody is walking away from this happy or whole.
[1] http://portal.idc.ac.il/en/schools/economics/about/documents...