News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by kennydude on Friday April 20, 2018 @11:57AM (#16885855)
The GDPR states you can only offer opt in and NOT opt out. This is not an opt in method, no matter how Facebook spins it. I hope the EU pulls them on this :)

Going by http://techblog.bozho.net/gdpr-practical-guide-developers/ anyway

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by 734786710934 on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:02PM (#16885899)
GDPR doesn't go into effect until May 25. The article states that this is a test that will become opt-in at that time.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by gboudrias on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:03PM (#16886506)
Jesus christ how evil can Facebook get? "We'll just sneak in this test to identify everyone before we have to make them opt into it."

What's even the point of opting out after that? That's some evil genius machinations.

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by dhimes on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:42PM (#16887408)
Brings up a question about the GDPR: do you have to delete any data on someone, or just data they entered? If they get the facial recognition working so they can recognize people in instagram photos and whatnot, then they'll be able to have data on you even if you're not a user. It's part of why I never liked people "tagging" me in photos.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by eksemplar on Friday April 20, 2018 @03:14PM (#16887680)
There is another big problem with the GDPR for international companies. I mean, how do we know you comply?

I work in the public sector in Denmark mind you, we have quarterly audits and despite having had a law that was pretty much GDPR levelalready, we’ve passed all audits. I don’t think we should have, I won’t go into details on this, but how do you audit 300+ systems, some of which the central IT department doesn’t even know exist because some rogue manager bought them? I have no idea, and I have even less of an idea on how you’d audit the cloud.

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by zjaffee on Friday April 20, 2018 @08:46PM (#16889391)
GDPR doesn't actually require that you delete date about anyone, it requires that you be able to dereference a user from their data after a defined period of time when you specifically request that your data is deleted.

This can include you having to directly contact the company in a way that isn't clearly visible within the app itself.

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by e12e on Friday April 20, 2018 @07:29PM (#16889134)
You're responsible for the data you store and have access to that can be linked to an individual.

The GDPR is quite clear on this.

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by rhizome on Friday April 20, 2018 @05:44PM (#16888672)
do you have to delete any data on someone, or just data they entered?

A discussion of derivative data and models was sadly and sorely missing from Zuck's recent Congressional testimony.

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by Privvy on Friday April 20, 2018 @04:12PM (#16888116)
GDPR is red herring. Current laws already require opt-in when collecting biometric data. From 2011:

> The Hamburg data protection authority on Tuesday ruled that Facebook’s facial recognition feature, which attempts to identify people in photos uploaded to the site, violates German privacy laws.

> Johannes Caspar, the head of the authority, said Facebook should not be collecting users’ biometric data – such as their face shape and the distance between their eyes – without getting their explicit consent. He has demanded that the social networking site change or disable the feature. All data collected so far should be deleted.

> Mr Caspar has given Facebook two weeks to respond. If the company is unable to make changes, Mr Caspar said the Hamburg authority would consider bringing legal action against it.

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by PunchTornado on Friday April 20, 2018 @04:32PM (#16888252)
???? nobody and nothing has made fb or google move about this like GDPR. Local laws are made to be broken. If a court in Hamburg tells fb to do something then they can easily play it along.

GDPR enforces fines of 4% of their global revenue so that's the only reason for them to respect it.

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by Privvy on Friday April 20, 2018 @04:49PM (#16888336)
Of course penalties for non-compliance have gone up. But collecting biometric data without explicit and informed opt-in, is already against the laws of many EU member states, and has been for nearly a decade. Facebook is walking on thin ice.

It seems they ask for permission, so the title that users are auto-enrolled may be misleading. But if they do auto-enroll: It is against the privacy laws already, no need to wait for GDPR.

About respecting local laws, I find this a difficult issue. What to do with draconian local laws that forbid ridiculing a president? But if it has to be a yes-no: I'd say, yes, obey local laws when you serve users there. Remove comments from Turkish IPs that slander their president, but keep comments from German IPs that ridicule Turkey's leader.

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by fredley on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:14PM (#16886002)
Protip: wait until 25th May to delete your Facebook account (if you're in the EU).
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by recursive on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:28PM (#16886164)
I doubt that will magically cause any laws to become retroactively applicable. Why would it matter?
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by lmkg on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:28PM (#16886708)
GDPR includes the "Right to Erasure"/"Right to be Forgotten." After May 25, they are actually required to delete your data, not just a "soft delete."
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by Matticus_Rex on Friday April 20, 2018 @05:13PM (#16888479)
They'll be required to do this after May 25th regardless of when you deleted the account. All personal information is in scope of the law, not just personal information of people who were customers after the enforcement date.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by toephu2 on Friday April 20, 2018 @04:02PM (#16888059)
Who will be auditing Facebook to do this though?

Is the EU going to hire the Big4 in the U.S. to do this? Who is going to pay for that?

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by netsharc on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:54PM (#16886937)
FWIW, Zuckerbot said before congress that if you request deletion, your data will actually be deleted, and I doubt he would dare lie to congress.

Then again, it's American congress, and what's the stat, how many of those congresspeople has he "donated" to?

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by lostlogin on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:18PM (#16887174)
Google ‘Zuckerberg lie to congress’.

You’ll find that there were plenty of statements that were on the line, crossed it or omitted key detail. Saying ‘I don’t know’ is also a lie if you do know, and there was a lot of that.

https://theintercept.com/2018/04/11/mark-zuckerberg-is-eithe...

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by npizzolato on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:14PM (#16887134)
Eh, you can choose to believe Zuckerberg here. I personally have no faith Facebook will voluntarily permanently delete someone's data when they close an account. They have shown very little prior behavior that would lead me to find his statements on this to be trustworthy.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by bergoid on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:29PM (#16887294)
> I doubt he would dare lie to congress

He wasn't under oath so the stakes for lying aren't too bad.

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by reaperducer on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:28PM (#16887286)
May 25 at 12:01am - Facebook violates GDPR, and the EU has no way of knowing it or enforcing it.

The more I hear about this, the more the "GDPR" seems like mere "PR."

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by kenning on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:55PM (#16887528)
What's more likely, that the EU wants good PR and hopes that nobody will notice they're not accomplishing anything, or that they're representing their constituents by making widely popular policies and putting the onus on violators to supply them with evidence of compliance?
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by CalRobert on Thursday May 03, 2018 @03:49PM (#16989259)
One whistleblower could do the trick. Plenty of FB staff in Europe.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by reaperducer on Friday April 20, 2018 @03:02PM (#16887594)
Why not both?
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by wereHamster on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:26PM (#16886130)
Why? Does the GDPR mandate that Facebook treat the deletion request differently?
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by SahAssar on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:32PM (#16886208)
Yes, currently there is nothing forcing them to delete all the data, after GDPR takes effect if you send them a deletion request under the GDPR they are forced to do so within a month (or 90 days if there are special circumstances).
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by andy_ppp on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:36PM (#16886256)
Does GDPR consider data in training sets and trained deep learning models as your data? It's kind of a small snapshot of your expected responses to some stimulus right, it's arguably more your data than anything...
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by SahAssar on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:45PM (#16886354)
If it's personally identifiable, yes. You also need opt-in (not opt-out or buried deep in a TOS) permission to use personal data in that way before feeding it to your learning model (since that use-case is basically never the primary purpose that the data was given for).

If you use any sort of automated system to make decisions about a EU customer that impacts their life in a significant way (like whether to ban them or not) you will also need to have some sort of appeals system where they can appeal to have the decision looked at by a human and potentially have it reversed.

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by annabellish on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:21PM (#16886644)
>You also need opt-in (not opt-out or buried deep in a TOS) permission to use personal data in that way before feeding it to your learning model (since that use-case is basically never the primary purpose that the data was given for).

Huh, now _that's_ interesting. Do you have a source for that? I know some guys at work that'll be upset if I can prove that to them, given that their pet project is a MI personalisation system making heavy use of just watching everything everyone does in an identifiable manner.

(I'll be honest, part of the draw is being able to say 'I told you so'~)

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by lmkg on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:44PM (#16886847)
A general point of the GDPR is that when you collect data, consent is given for a business purpose. The user has the ability to opt-in to different business use-cases if they so choose. Data collected cannot be used for a business case that was not consented to by the user.

This area is one that gets more legal-y than other parts of the GDPR, because in some cases you can use data without consent if it's legitimately required to provide the service the user asked for, and as far as I can tell there's not a lot of guidance on what counts as being a different business use. But yeah, personalization is usually not a strictly necessary feature of most platforms, so you're gonna need the user to opt-in to using their data that way.

This guidance is kinda spread out over the GPDR, but one area of relevance:

https://gdpr-info.eu/art-13-gdpr/

Pay attention specifically to (3), but also (1)(c) and (2). Part (3) quoted below:

  Where the controller intends to further process the
  personal data for a purpose other than that for which 
  the personal data were collected, the controller shall 
  provide the data subject prior to that further 
  processing with information on that other purpose and 
  with any relevant further information as referred to in 
  paragraph 2.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by SahAssar on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:38PM (#16886785)
I think these are the relevant parts:

> When assessing whether consent is freely given, utmost account shall be taken of whether, inter alia, the performance of a contract, including the provision of a service, is conditional on consent to the processing of personal data that is not necessary for the performance of that contract.

From https://gdpr-info.eu/art-7-gdpr/ paragraph 4

And the definition of consent is here:

> ‘consent’ of the data subject means any freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous indication of the data subject’s wishes by which he or she, by a statement or by a clear affirmative action, signifies agreement to the processing of personal data relating to him or her;

From https://gdpr-info.eu/art-4-gdpr/ paragraph 11

---

'specific' and 'unambiguous' in combination seem to disallow the "bury it in the TOS" cop-out.

'informed' and 'specific' in combination seem to disallow the opt-out cop-out (since a opt-out permission is never specific, and basically never informed).

Article 7 paragraph 4 (the first quote) seems to disallow the usage of data unless it is necessary for the service.

Of course this is still all pretty untested in the courts, and IANAL but to me it seems pretty clear. If your primary service is not building a machine learning model based on your own users data you will need to get your users to opt-in for that specific use-case.

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by Angostura on Friday April 20, 2018 @04:44PM (#16888319)
The data subject also has the right to know what the basis of the automated decision was, too.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by lmkg on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:33PM (#16886746)
Relevant GDPR text available at: https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-162/

In short, aggregated data or statistical summaries is not constrained in the same way. I think you still need consent into to perform the aggregation/summarization, and said processing needs to ensure "statistical confidentiality," but such results are not PI.

(IANAL, and I'm still trying to understand this myself.)

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by SahAssar on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:43PM (#16886839)
So basically, the training set is under the GDPR if it includes PI, but the resulting model is not (unless you can extract PI from it), and you need user permission to use PI for training in most cases, right?

(Also IANAL, and also trying to understand)

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by smueller1234 on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:48PM (#16886377)
A lot of this type of thing isn't clear yet and will be worked out when GDPR is enforced.

At my previous employer, we took a pretty comprehensive view and tried to play it safe, so at the very least any non-anonymous data in training sets would qualify. That does, however, already beg the question of why on Earth you'd need to train a model with non-anonymized data in the first place!

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by hinkley on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:43PM (#16886329)
Trust me, Facebook will claim that they are special.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by SahAssar on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:48PM (#16886383)
Even if they do, I can live with them having it for 90 more days after the 25:th. If enough people complain about them saying they're "special" to their countries data protection agencies I'm guessing it will lead to some inquiries as to how special they really are.

I think facebook, google and all the other big tech companies have already "war-gamed" this out and I think that they will comply without saying that there are special circumstances as much as possible, so that they can save that card for when they really want to use it.

Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by dnzm on Friday April 20, 2018 @03:22PM (#16887742)
I wonder how much of a difference that would make - after the gdpr is effective, if I ask them to, they'll have to delete their data on me, regardless of whether I have or had an active account in the then-past.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by TomMarius on Saturday April 21, 2018 @11:40AM (#16891804)
If you delete your account now, you will have to ask them directly after that. How do you directly contact Facebook (reliably)? It'll certainly be possible, but I imagine it will take a lot of time and effort
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by Navarr on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:40PM (#16886288)
I'm confused, didn't you opt in when you clicked the checkbox to agree to Facebook's T&C?
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by smueller1234 on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:45PM (#16886343)
A big thing in GDPR is that consent must be sufficiently specific and explicit. Long and generic T&C might no longer pass. Ultimately, I imagine the regulation will make a lot of lawyers richer as this kind of stuff gets hammered out in practice.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by brylie on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:46PM (#16886357)
With GDPR, blanket "opt-ins", I.e. clickwrap, won't suffice. People need to give informed consent, meaning key uses of personal data must be explained in plain language. Hopefully this will lead to a lot less abuse of I Agree to Everything and any Future Changes type of TOS.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by downandout on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:01PM (#16886491)
Yes, you did. This is just another clickbait headline. GDPR - when it becomes active - will outlaw the opt-out strategy. But there is nothing legally wrong with it today.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by PeterisP on Friday April 20, 2018 @07:16PM (#16889077)
No, the existing privacy legislation already requires opt-in for processing of biometric data; GDPR makes many things stricter, but much of it is already a legal requirement.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by downandout on Friday April 20, 2018 @11:26PM (#16889841)
Apparently Facebook's well-trained legal team disagrees with your assessment of European law. Facebook isn't stupid; they wouldn't have done this if it weren't legal.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by pimmen on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:01PM (#16886496)
You have to give consent to every use of your personal data. You can't agree to them using your data for 47 different purposes at the same time.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by a_imho on Friday April 20, 2018 @01:24PM (#16886674)
What if they claim people opted in? How can anyone prove or disprove that without a signed piece of paper really?
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by r00fus on Saturday April 21, 2018 @12:20AM (#16889963)
This will be forced with a challenge. With clickwrap super-generic consent being disallowed under GDPR, it's only going to take a single challenge where FB doesn't have the explicit consent for gov to start levying fines.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by a_imho on Saturday April 21, 2018 @05:44AM (#16890725)
Anyone can pull up a piece of data to claim they have consent, you need something like a signature otherwise it is words against each other. There is no way to verify consent with some click through, anyone can click a link in someone else's name or create a record in a db that says so.
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by reaperducer on Friday April 20, 2018 @02:32PM (#16887319)
Makes sense. Think of all of the spam e-mail messages you get with tiny text at the bottom reading something like "You are receiving this e-mail because you signed up for {$web_site_you_never_heard_of_before}."
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by fibers on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:01PM (#16885891)
you can always opt out by moving out of europe /s
Re:Facebook has auto-enrolled users into a facial recognitio... by Analemma_ on Friday April 20, 2018 @12:03PM (#16885903)
Yeah, let's see one of those "4% of global revenue" fines they were talking about. Would be about $1.6 billion based on Facebook's 2017 financials.