News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @01:44PM (#16832203)
This will get canned on the appeal, guaranteed. The article is a bit misleading because they're not going after him because he's doing aftermarket repairs. They're going after him because he's claiming that the repaired devices are using genuine parts from Apple, which even have the Apple logo on them, yet they weren't purchased from Apple.

This is my biggest complaint with the "Right to Repair" movement. They're constantly conflating what Apple is fighting against (counterfeit parts and being compelled to provide documentation and manuals without oversight) with the valid complaint of users not being legally allowed to repair their own devices. Apple has never been against that and isn't fighting that. They're fighting the fact that these bills, every single one of them, wants to force Apple to provide instructions and parts for repair shops that aren't Apple authorized for which they can't verify or guarantee the quality fo the repair. That's a completely understandable position and yet people keep falsely claiming that it's simply about Apple wanting to keep people from repairing their own stuff. That's not it at all and it's doing a disservice to the "Right to Repair" movement to continue to do so.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by atonse on Friday April 13, 2018 @01:50PM (#16832264)
It's not that simple. Until literally 3 days ago I held exactly your same view "why don't they just become Apple authorized repair shops?"

Well, apparently Apple actually restricts the repairs you can do. For example, if you have water damage, you aren't allowed to just fix the actual components (capacitors, etc) that blew, you have to replace the whole board, resulting in much higher costs and eWaste for customers. (This is from Louis Rossmann, a well known YouTuber who fixes MacBooks). You are basically restricted to mostly replacing boards and things like that, not fixing individual chips.

For a company that toots their horn about being Green, their policies sure generate a ton more waste than necessary.

And I say this as someone who almost exclusively owns Apple stuff. I am holding out with my 2015 MBP dearly for the next iteration of their laptop keyboards that don't require a $500 repair because of a spec of dust.

All this has made me a STRONG proponent of the right-to-repair movement. If Apple actually cared more about less flashy and sexy parts about being green, they'd make these parts readily available.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by zaroth on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:45PM (#16832806)
It would be like when the capacitor blew on my A/C condenser if I would be forced to replace the whole unit instead of the $10 part.

It’s important that people know if they are getting 3rd party or refurbished parts, but it’s equally important for people to have the right to use 3rd party and refurbished parts if they so choose — with the only restriction of having the necessary safety/compliance markings.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @04:49PM (#16833787)
That's not analogous at all. Apple is not stopping people from repairing their devices with 3rd party or refurbished parts. The parts in the OP article were branded as Apple parts (logo and everything) but were not actual Apple parts. That's why Apple is asking for receipts and purchase orders. They want the guy to prove that he's buying the parts from them if he's telling customers that they're genuine Apple parts.

The amount of misinformation around here is staggering...

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by zaroth on Friday April 13, 2018 @06:17PM (#16834373)
That wasn't my understanding from reading the article... I read it to mean that they were refurbished Apple parts, but not refurbished by Apple. A screen assembled by a third party consisting of some parts made by Apple with the Apple logo, but the assembly of the completed part was not done by Apple. But TFA is really not clear at all on this point.

My capacitor analogy was more to the point of Apple being against microsoldering repairs where individual components are replaced instead of the entire board.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @09:54PM (#16835372)
Yeah... I understood the analogy but I just think it's inaccurate because Apple doesn't have that policy out of some kind of nefarious reasons. They do it that way because micro soldering repairs in-store would take far long and are probably not worth the effort. A customer would much rather get their phone or computer swapped out or repaired in 20 minutes than have to leave it for days on end while it's re-soldered and individual components are on order. Since Apple can do that all off-site, there's not really a benefit. The comment about waste isn't correct either since Apple recycles most of that stuff.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by amluto on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:07PM (#16832434)
I have another not-very-green issue: my iPhone lightning port is wearing out. Apple will not repair it in their own shops. At least they don’t seem to try to prevent third parties from doing it.

This is especially surprising given the unusual design of the Lightning port. Most ports (e.g. all USB variants) put the parts that are likely to wear out in the cable. Lightning has them in the jack, which is why the cable is so pretty. But for some reason Apple thinks it’s reasonable for the jack to be officially non-replaceable.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by DanHulton on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:18PM (#16832541)
So, I thought my port was wearing out as well, and got very upset. What I found, however, was just that pocket lint had gotten jammed in there and compacted down over and over through the years, such that the cable didn't fit snugly any more.

I fixed this just by using a plastic flosser to pick the lint out (you could use a paper clip, but I opted for the somewhat-softer plastic), then some canned air to get rid of the remaining bits.

Went from "oh god, I gotta go to the Apple store" to connecting with a SNAP again, with a seal tight enough to support the phone's entire weight.

I hope that this is just your issue, because it's very easy to fix, even if diagnosing it is a bit tricky.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by gervase on Friday April 13, 2018 @03:15PM (#16833090)
This only works for a couple of years; eventually, the pocket lint permanently reduces the springiness of the contacts, such that the cable is "loose" in the socket, and the connection can therefore be lost by shifting the position of the phone.

Fortunately, it's a simple (if tedious) fix with a $15 part.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by amluto on Friday April 13, 2018 @03:56PM (#16833396)
Yep. The Apple store even kindly cleaned my port for me, and it helped a bit. But they still flat-out refuse to do the repair.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by digi_owl on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:12PM (#16832488)
Actually the mini-USB put the parts that were likely to wear in the plug...
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by mikeash on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:15PM (#16832515)
That’s why mini USB is now almost extinct, replaced with micro USB (and now Type C?) which doesn’t make that mistake.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by amluto on Friday April 13, 2018 @03:59PM (#16833421)
IIRC type C is even rated for 10k cycles. Other than some serious charging screwups and a generally overcomplicated design, it’s quite well engineered.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by wuliwong on Friday April 13, 2018 @05:22PM (#16834005)
I think you are misrepresenting dpkonofa's position. I believe his position is that Apple shouldn't be forced to assist with your repairs by producing manuals and parts. That isn't the same as "why don't they just become Apple authorized repair shops?"
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @10:05PM (#16835421)
Thank you. I'm being downvoted left and right here because people are arguing a straw man of what I'm actually saying.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @04:45PM (#16833761)
>resulting in much higher costs and eWaste for customers.

This isn't true or accurate. The costs of this service are lower, overall because the rate of repairs are faster which means more customers can have working devices faster which means that Apple can (and does) take time on the backend to remanufacture and certify parts. They don't throw out these components. They're taken apart, tested, and, if they pass, they're used to remanufacture devices for warranty and insurance purposes that are then sold to phone insurance carriers and given to warranty customers.

The idea that they are restricting repairs for any reason other than the fact that it's a better experience for the end-user is complete FUD.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by throwahey on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:04PM (#16832406)
I would take anything Rossman says with a grain of salt, he clearly has a personal vendetta against Apple. Further, Apple products are almost entirely recyclable, up to and including the packaging. As long as they are properly disposed of, you wouldn't be producing additional waste.

And you are assuming that "flash" and "sexy" serve a single, vapid purpose. The designs of their products are as compact and space efficient as possible because weight, battery size, and thermals all play a factor in the quality of a product.

You can shit on them all you want but no company comes close to Apple in quality, and I don't see anyone complaining about the right to repair ultrabooks, or pixelbooks.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by atonse on Friday April 13, 2018 @03:00PM (#16832958)
Louis Rossmann, Jessa Jones, these are all people I'm aware of at least on YouTube that are people who truly care about teaching the public how to do a lot of their own repairs.

I can tell you, I'm a software guy. And I was absolutely intimidated by circuit boards, until I found the world of electronics repairs on Youtube (EEVBlog too). Now I have fixed two power supplies and a pair of headphones. In all those cases, I was able to get parts easily from third parties (and for my headphones, I got cheap replacement parts from AudioTechnica themselves).

I am delighted to have rediscovered this part of my skills that I lost in my teens when I fell in love with software development.

Yet I still can't get a genuine apple battery to replace on my phone. I've successfully replaced batteries on about 5 iPhones now, but they were all shady battery replacements on Amazon. Frankly I'm just annoyed that Apple doesn't make these parts available.

Look at the backlog for battery replacements now. If you get it from Apple, there is now a monthslong wait-list at the genius bar because they've created their own bottleneck.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @04:54PM (#16833826)
>are people who truly care about teaching the public how to do a lot of their own repairs

Rossmann makes money off of his businesses that repair computer products, Apple or otherwise. He stands to gain a lot based on the popularity of his channel whether he's telling people the truth or not. He's not in it to help people, he's in it to drum up business. If he helps people along the way, then that's great.

Case in point - he made a whole video about how shitty the new MacBooks are and claimed that plugging a USB device into the USB-C port disabled WiFi. He pushed that point and tweeted about it and posted it everywhere. When it was discovered that it wasn't the computer but the cheap $5 USB-C to USB-A converter that he was using that was unshielded (which is required by the USB spec), he never issued a retraction or an apology. All he wanted was to get in on the fervor surrounding the newly released laptops. He doesn't give 2 shits about whether or not he's teaching people factual information. What really sucks about it, much like the whole "Right to Repair" movement, is that it takes away substantially from the issues and points he brings up that are completely valid.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by endemic on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:12PM (#16832480)
>As long as they are properly disposed of, you wouldn't be producing additional waste.

I'm not sure that's entirely accurate. You'd have to take into account the cost of sourcing raw materials for a replacement machine, right? I've heard anecdotes about how buying a used gas-burning car is actually less detrimental to the environment than buying a new EV; this strikes me as a similar situation.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by Johnny555 on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:47PM (#16832832)
buying a used gas-burning car is actually less detrimental to the environment than buying a new EV

I think that's only true if that gas burning car was going to be destroyed if you didn't buy it. Someone will buy it, maybe someone that's replacing their older less efficient car. And by buying the more expensive EV, your demand is helping to increase volume and lower costs of EV's.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by nugi on Friday April 13, 2018 @03:07PM (#16833018)
No, even driving 200miles a day, for 15 years in a 1978 suburban with bad rings is less poluting than producing a single eCar.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by Johnny555 on Friday April 13, 2018 @04:13PM (#16833523)
Source?

https://www.ucsusa.org/clean-vehicles/electric-vehicles/life...

Manufacturing a mid-sized EV with an 84-mile range results in about 15 percent more emissions than manufacturing an equivalent gasoline vehicle. For larger, longer-range EVs that travel more than 250 miles per charge, the manufacturing emissions can be as much as 68 percent higher.

These differences change as soon as the cars are driven. EVs are powered by electricity, which is generally a cleaner energy source than gasoline. Battery electric cars make up for their higher manufacturing emissions within eighteen months of driving—shorter range models can offset the extra emissions within 6 months—and continue to outperform gasoline cars until the end of their lives.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by jschwartzi on Friday April 13, 2018 @03:42PM (#16833286)
The air quality in the 70s would disagree with you. Sunsets are not supposed to be orange, and the sky is not supposed to be brown.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by urda on Friday April 13, 2018 @01:56PM (#16832323)
Louis Rossmann, who openly admitted to using illegally obtained schematics and internal documents from Apple? I wouldn't be throwing that name around as a talking point at all in this discussion.

The reason why Apple doesn't want any Joe-schmoe just yanking and replacing caps and other components is simple: quality control. I can barely count on two hands people I would be comfortable working on the innards of a PC, let alone my phone and even then let alone desoldering and soldering new components onboard.

Apple isn't doing this because they don't want people to repair their stuff, but because for most consumers it isn't feasible without ruining the rest of the product. These are small, compact, and complicated devices. It's not like swapping out some RAM or a GPU on a desktop rig at all.

So yes, replace the whole board and recycle the old (as Apple does with most of their parts).

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by Someone1234 on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:09PM (#16832447)
> Louis Rossmann, who openly admitted to using illegally obtained schematics and internal documents from Apple? I wouldn't be throwing that name around as a talking point at all in this discussion.

So you're discounting someone's opinion because they were forced to use unauthorized repair manuals since the manufacturer stopped producing repair manuals for devices customers have paid for? That's the whole crux of the issue, that people have lost the "right to repair" their own devices due to suppressing information, suppressing reverse engineering efforts, and suppressing compatible replacement components (and software).

Effectively you're saying that if someone supports and tries to uphold the "right to repair" their opinions should be ignored because they did something a large corporation told them not to.

> Apple isn't doing this because they don't want people to repair their stuff

See, I thought it was financially motivated.

> but because for most consumers it isn't feasible without ruining the rest of the product.

Someone has a broken device, they shouldn't be allowed to try and repair it themselves because they could make it worse? In either case they have a broken device. And Apple is well within their rights to refuse a repair after someone has tried a DIY repair, but often that isn't a financial possibility which is why a DIY repair was tried to begin with.

You don't have to go far to find an anecdote of someone who took an older Macbook into an Apple store and the repair cost was nearly as high as a replacement cost.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @04:57PM (#16833848)
>manufacturer stopped producing repair manuals for devices customers have paid for

Why is a manufacturer in any way obligated to provide this information for customers (and for free, no less)? Apple is not stopping him from taking apart these devices and figuring out how to repair them but I don't see why they should shoulder any obligation to provide that information to people that refuse to become an authorized repair center (which is exactly what that authorization and certification gets them).

>Someone has a broken device, they shouldn't be allowed to try and repair it themselves

This is not at all the point of contention nor in any way what Apple is doing here. Stop spreading FUD.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by urda on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:10PM (#16832460)
> So you're discounting someone's opinion because they were forced to use unauthorized repair manuals because the manufacturer stopped producing repair manuals for devices customers have paid for?

Yes, because it's a legal case we are discussing here and that's called "breaking the law". Failing to understand that means I cannot discuss this article with you at all since a really important common understanding has been missed on your part.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dang on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:40PM (#16832767)
Please don't cross into personal swipes. If you can't discuss something, it suffices not to discuss it.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by Someone1234 on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:20PM (#16832557)
> Yes, because it's a legal case we are discussing here and that's called "breaking the law".

It is an issue for society at large, fair use should include repair materials, and if you look at judgements from vehicles and farm equipment cases you'll see that the legal side isn't clear cut anyway.

Not least of all because you're conflating OWNING stolen materials and REDISTRIBUTING them. Copyright largely covers the latter and not the former. In this case they're simply owning a "stolen" document and using the knowledge from it, which isn't within itself a copyright infringement or illegal.

Unless you can explain how simply owning a stolen document is "breaking the law." Which law?

> Failing to understand that means I cannot discuss this article with you at all since a really important common understanding has been missed on your part.

You don't wish to discuss it because it challenges your whole viewpoint. Which is in essence that Apple's rights extend into a device they sold to a user, and that a user shouldn't be legally allowed to "tamper" with their own property.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by smallnamespace on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:16PM (#16832523)
> that's called "breaking the law"

Right, which is why people are advocating getting the law changed, because they believe the practical outcome of law as it current exists is not just (nor economically efficient, for that matter).

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by landryraccoon on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:23PM (#16832593)
> Yes, because it's a legal case we are discussing here and that's called "breaking the law".

Even if this is true, the law isn’t some divine fiat. Some laws are dumb and it is proper and patriotic to point it out and criticize. Just because something might be against the law doesn’t make it wrong. Your argument is the shallowest sort of moral argument, that things should be done a certain way just because that’s how they’re done.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by PhasmaFelis on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:52PM (#16832874)
If his facts are correct, it's irrelevant that he also broke the law. Facts are facts.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by nightcracker on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:05PM (#16832417)
> Louis Rossmann, who openly admitted to using illegally obtained schematics and internal documents from Apple?

Are you seriously trying to discredit a man for doing exactly what he's fighting for?

It's like trying to discredit a politician that's pushing for the abolition of jaywalking by saying that he jay walks himself. No shit - that's the whole point.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by urda on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:11PM (#16832471)
I'll repost the same thing here, since apparently this is confusing to some HN users this morning:

> So you're discounting someone's opinion because they were forced to use unauthorized repair manuals because the manufacturer stopped producing repair manuals for devices customers have paid for?

Yes, because it's a legal case we are discussing here and that's called "breaking the law". Failing to understand that means I cannot discuss this article with you at all since a really important common understanding has been missed on your part.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by pixl97 on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:30PM (#16832647)
"I'm sorry, I can't discuss this case with you because you won't sit at the back of the bus, like the law says" --You 60 years ago
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by ksk on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:07PM (#16832428)
>The reason why Apple doesn't want any Joe-schmoe just yanking and replacing caps and other components is simple: quality control. I can barely count on two hands people I would be comfortable working on the innards of a PC, let alone my phone and even then let alone desoldering and soldering new components onboard.

And yet people are perfectly OK with a greasy mechanic fixing their metal cage hurtling down the freeway at 65 miles per hour. Your attempt to demean skilled repair workers is rather telling of your own bias.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by logfromblammo on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:38PM (#16832746)
Quality control only happens on premises you control. Once the product reaches the point-of-sale terminal, the consumer own it, and the QC job is done. You send your product out onto the free market and have to hope you raised it well enough to uphold your brand.

It isn't about QC; it's about money. It's the same reason every car dealership has an in-house repair department. Branded repairs mean that people can still buy the brand after they already own the product. Counterfeits cut into that revenue stream.

[dead]
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by ksk on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:23PM (#16832590)
>Woah I didn't know you could read my mind!

Oh, but you certainly are able to determine the skill level of people you don't know. Nice.

Quoting you:

>The reason why Apple doesn't want any Joe-schmoe just yanking and replacing caps and other components is simple: quality control.

You called them joe-schmoe, and questioned the quality of their work. Yeah, maybe in your alternate universe that considered praise. Normal people read that as an insult.

Let me suggest some alternate wording "a competent technician will use their extensive knowledge, and repair your device"

>Drop the attacks and focus on the article, this is HN not reddit.

I would invite you to take your own advice first.

>I didn't mention anything about skilled repair workers, nor is that demeaning to point out the abilities to repair small electronic devices like phones is not just a "walk in the park".

Please point to the text arguing that repairing devices is a "walk in the park".

[dead]
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dang on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:42PM (#16832785)
Please don't engage in petty spats here, regardless of how wrong or annoying you find other comments.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by Someone1234 on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:59PM (#16832953)
Sorry. I lost my head there for a sec, most of my posts are more constructive/on-topic than that (I'd like to think). I'll try to be better going to forward.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by smallnamespace on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:15PM (#16832511)
> The reason why Apple doesn't want any Joe-schmoe just yanking and replacing caps and other components is simple: quality control

Right, and the entire discussion is that Apple's right to quality control has overreached to the point that it is now impinging upon the common sense right of someone to be able try to fix something that they own when it breaks.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @10:07PM (#16835428)
How so? Apple isn't stopping anyone from being able to try and fix something that they own. The only action they've taken is against companies claiming that they're an Apple authorized repair center when they're not.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by crististm on Friday April 13, 2018 @03:11PM (#16833054)
About counting people thing: your frame of reference is probably too narrow?

Come to thing of it, I personally don't know ten people capable of doing state of the art SMD repairs but I'm sure there are many more than that in _my town_.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by opencl on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:02PM (#16832381)
Where do you see any indication that this man was claiming to use genuine Apple components? I see nothing of the sort on his website[1]. The article specifically says that he made no claims of being authorized by Apple or using genuine Apple components and the court agreed with him. There was an Apple logo, on an internal component, which was covered up, because (at least according to the seller) they actually are Apple parts that had been refurbished. Now maybe they actually are counterfeit parts and the seller was lying, but there is zero evidence of this and the repairman certainly wasn't intentionally selling counterfeits or lying about anything.

[1] https://www.pckompaniet.no/reparasjon-iphone/

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by ryguytilidie on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:14PM (#16832505)
I feel like I see this on the internet more and more lately. Paragraph one starts with some shoddy, made up evidence where they mock some idea and then you look for the start of paragraph 2 to figure out what they're really getting themselves upset about:

"This is my biggest complaint with the "Right to Repair" movement."

So yeah, have a problem with some group, reorganize information to make that group look bad and pretend like this thing you made up is a great illustration of the grudge you had against some people.

But my question is, why?

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by ericabiz on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:58PM (#16832943)
> Why?

Because he’s a former Apple employee: https://www.linkedin.com/in/dpkonofa

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @05:00PM (#16833874)
Why does that have any affect on my point? The article has been changed since it was originally posted. The original article had the guy claiming he was using genuine Apple parts which was stated right on the company's website (they've changed it since the case went to court):

https://web.archive.org/web/20160327050030/http://www.pckomp...

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @04:59PM (#16833867)
I appreciate you trying to discredit me instead of the argument I was making but the article has been modified since its posting. The original had a claim where the guy said he was using original, authorized Apple parts:

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20160327050030/http://www.pckomp...

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by ryguytilidie on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:10AM (#16858428)
"I appreciate you trying to discredit me instead of the argument I was making"

I'll just go ahead and roll my eyes at this trash.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @05:14PM (#16833959)
You don't see that on his website because he's changed it since the case went to court: https://web.archive.org/web/20160327050030/http://www.pckomp...
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by hhw on Friday April 13, 2018 @01:56PM (#16832330)
But the article states quite clearly that he is NOT claiming to use genuine parts.

“PCKompaniet has never removed the coverup of the Apple logo on the screens that have been imported and has no interest in doing so. PCKompaniet does not pretend or market itself as Apple authorized and does not give any indication that the repair comes with an Apple warranty.”

Unless you have evidence of the contrary, your argument is not applicable to this case.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by woobar on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:52PM (#16832870)
> But the article states quite clearly that he is NOT claiming to use genuine parts.

Not trying to pick side in this argument, but a quick search on webarchive[1] shows that this page (https://www.pckompaniet.no/reparasjon-iphone/) used to have this blurb:

'Kun orginale deler blir brukt her hos oss!'

That google translates as 'Only original parts are used here!'

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20160327050030/http://www.pckomp...

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by bluGill on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:53PM (#16832890)
The problem for Apple is if you sell badly repaired phone, the buyer has no way of knowing it was badly repaired and will blame Apple for any failures.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @05:35PM (#16834085)
This is exactly it. Note that Apple has yet to go after or sue someone simply for repairing an Apple device. That's never been the case yet. They've only sued people who claim to use genuine parts that don't, people who have used stolen service manuals, or companies that claim to do authorized repairs but don't.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by eagsalazar2 on Friday April 13, 2018 @01:48PM (#16832253)
How can you or other 3rd parties repair devices if Apple won't sell parts or provide manuals and it sues people who claim to be able to do such things on your behalf? I think it is fair that apple withhold an "apple certified" designation but everything else beyond that is them trying to squash 3rd party repairs so that they can maintain a monopoly on that work, prevent you from upgrading memory, etc and ultimately keep you on the upgrade treadmill. You really don't think that is the case?
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @05:04PM (#16833899)
>Apple won't sell parts or provide manuals and it sues people who claim to be able to do such things on your behalf

This is objectively not true. Apple is not against selling parts or manuals. That's the entire point of an Apple Authorized Repair center. Anyone can get certified by Apple if they can demonstrate that the repairs are done to the level that Apple specifies. What the "Right to Repair" bills are asking for is that Apple provides the manuals for free. Why is that justifiable, fair, or right in any sense if doing so could (and materially would) harm their business?

As for the second claim, Apple has never, ever sued someone simply for repairing their devices as a third-party. They've only sued people who claimed to use genuine Apple parts that weren't or people who stole manuals and schematics that are reserved for authorized repair centers.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by bambax on Friday April 13, 2018 @01:56PM (#16832317)
> the valid complaint of users not being legally allowed to repair their own devices. Apple has never been against that and isn't fighting that.

Hmm, what? Apple is actively fighting that by making devices incredibly difficult to tear appart, not selling replacement parts, and, yes, suing every mom-and-pop repair shop.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by zaroth on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:55PM (#16832903)
The “difficult to tear apart” thing I would give incredible leeway to. It’s very hard to demand a device is physically constructed a certain way without unintentionally harming innovation.

Besides, people have differing opinions on what constitutes “ difficult to tear apart”. I’ve replaced batteries on all my iPhones and while it’s a delicate procedure it’s not particularly difficult, takes just a few minutes, and I’ve never damaged a phone in the process. I remember how much vitriol there was against Apple for not having hot swappable batteries, but I’m sure glad they went that route, and that they were able to lead the market in that choice.

But for the rest of it, they should definitely have to provide parts, manuals, and attacking the independent repair shops is wrong unless the shop is actually misleading their customers.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @10:08PM (#16835434)
>suing every mom-and-pop repair shop.

This is blatantly false. Please link 1 instance where Apple sued a mom-and-pop repair shop for anything other than they were claiming they were an authorized repair center or used genuine parts and didn't.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by ksk on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:04PM (#16832397)
Well, heres hoping it doesn't get canned.

>This is my biggest complaint with the "Right to Repair" movement. They're constantly conflating what Apple is fighting against (counterfeit parts and being compelled to provide documentation and manuals without oversight) with the valid complaint of users not being legally allowed to repair their own devices

Your complaint seems rather imagined to me. Where are they "constantly conflating"? I don't see that here.

https://repair.org/

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @05:09PM (#16833932)
>Your complaint seems rather imagined to me.

Please show me a source where Apple sued someone (either an individual or a third-party repair center) simply for repairing their own device or a user's device on behalf of that user. You won't find it because that's not what Apple's complaint is here. People are conflating Apple's refusal to provide manuals and replacement parts without cost (and outside of their certification program) with the idea that Apple is trying to prevent people from repairing their own devices. That's not true in the slightest and it's straight-up misinformation.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by ksk on Friday April 13, 2018 @06:43PM (#16834545)
>Please show me a source where Apple sued someone (either an individual or a third-party repair center) simply for repairing their own device or a user's device on behalf of that user. You won't find it because that's not what Apple's complaint is here.

That would be inefficient and a waste of their money in most cases.

>People are conflating Apple's refusal to provide manuals and replacement parts without cost (and outside of their certification program) with the idea that Apple is trying to prevent people from repairing their own devices.

Apple uses various methods - Updates that brick repaired phones, and copyright/patent law to block others from supplying parts. Here they can choke the repair shops much more easily. I don't want to be forced to go to Subaru to repair my car either. I prefer to have an option of which tires to buy, which oil to use, which stereo I use, etc. I also don't want the car to be welded together to the point where nobody can repair it. YMMV.

Sometimes the good guys win.

https://9to5mac.com/2017/02/25/iphone-warranty-third-party-s...

http://money.cnn.com/2017/04/06/technology/apple-australia-l...

>the idea that Apple is trying to prevent people from repairing their own devices.

People don't want to repair the phones themselves. They want to use services available in almost every other consumer industry to service their phones. Apple insists that they should be the sole arbiter of who is and isn't allowed to do that. People are trying to fight Apple on that. And thats what its all about.

Apple does produce some very high quality products and I have enjoyed many of them over the years. That doesn't make them a saint on all fronts. Fairs fair, Praise where praise is due, and criticism when they do something purely out of greed/control.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by ubernostrum on Friday April 13, 2018 @09:09PM (#16835239)
Your problem is that Apple is not Microsoft.

Microsoft effectively has to support literally any combination of things someone might try to do to their Windows PC, because they know nobody will blame the author of the crappy driver or the manufacturer of the peripheral. They'll blame Microsoft.

Apple, by tightly controlling its hardware ecosystem, avoids a lot of that. But also gets to build software that's tested for far fewer configurations, meaning that if you do step outside that configuration, you have to accept that they're not testing for it and aren't guaranteeing the next version of their software will continue to work for you.

But rather than understand this, you attribute it to Tim Cook twirling his mustache and cackling over how he's going to deliberately brick all those phones that people repaired themselves! Soon, he will rule the world! BWAHAHAHA!

Except you know as soon as you think about it that you have no evidence of this and that the kind of "Apple bricks your phone to punish you for repairing it" narrative you're pushing here is completely false. Apple might not like losing out on some more of your money, but figuring out ways to push updates that will break your phone while not breaking someone else's is just not worth the time and money for them. So the simplest explanation -- that they don't have staff thoroughly test every type of repair you might do to your phone with every update they push -- is the likeliest, and you know that too.

This, for the record, is my problem with the "right to repair" people. You ignore real problems to peddle conspiracies.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by ksk on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:14AM (#16836010)
What in the world are you on about? Sorry dude, I can make no sense of anything in your rambling comment.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by ubernostrum on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:36AM (#16836062)
You appear to be claiming that Apple deliberately develops software updates to break user- or third-party-repaired devices.

This requires Apple to have a team studying how third parties repair their devices, and working on ways to modify their software to break such devices while leaving all others unaffected. That's a not-insignificant challenge.

The likelier explanation is that Apple does not invest in developing updates that will deliberately break your phone as retaliation for you repairing it in ways they don't like. The likelier explanation is that Apple simply doesn't test the interaction between their updates and your repairs, and doesn't much care if your phone breaks as a result. They test for the interaction with their stock devices, and devices repaired through their advocated channels, and don't seem to want the "absolutely everything everybody might do must be supported" approach Microsoft historically took (with good reason -- one of the advantages of tight ecosystem control is getting to avoid Microsoft's nightmare).

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by ksk on Saturday April 14, 2018 @01:51AM (#16836102)
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by ubernostrum on Saturday April 14, 2018 @02:59AM (#16836258)
If you mean "can I provide you the exact reason why it happened", no. But I still think it's much more likely that Apple just doesn't test for third-party repairs than that they deliberately work to come up with ways to break a third-party repair without breaking their own repairs.

I believe this because I've worked on software teams that developed things that would only be used in-house in controlled ways, and I've seen how fragile those usually end up being and how poorly tested they usually are.

But I also see that there's no possible evidence someone could present, or argument someone could make, that would change your mind, because as the quote says: you can't reason someone out of a position they didn't reason their way into.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by ksk on Saturday April 14, 2018 @03:39AM (#16836348)
We're clearly operating on seperate planes here. Your reasoning as far as I can tell, is your own belief, and not based on evidence that anyone can verify. My reasoning is based on Apples actions, their own comments, experiences of third party repair shops who are being threatened by Apple, and my own experience with third party repair shops.

I can never understand why people want to stop others from choosing where they repair their products. If you (not you specifically) think third party repairs are shady, well great ! you already have a choice and you can get yours serviced at Apple. We should be free to make decisions about things we own. Apple fighting to block our right is disspointing.

>But I still think it's much more likely that Apple just doesn't test for third-party repairs than that they deliberately work to come up with ways to break a third-party repair without breaking their own repairs.

There is no "testing for repair". When you replace a component on a logic board, it either works or if its sabotaged (like inkjet cartriges, kurig kcups, iphone screens), it doesn't. And thats if you're doing a component level repair. For parts replacement, it should be way easier. I get the feeling you're not very familiar with how electronics repair works. It is really nothing like software.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Saturday April 14, 2018 @03:19PM (#16838927)
>My reasoning is based on Apples actions, their own comments, experiences of third party repair shops who are being threatened by Apple, and my own experience with third party repair shops

No... your reasoning is based on your interpretation of all parties' intentions of which you have no basis for combined with flat-out misinformation about what the third-party repair shops are doing/claiming. Apple is not stopping anyone from choosing where they repair their products nor are they stopping third-party repair shops from repairing their products. The fact that you continue to spread this objectively false information is all anyone needs to know to validate that your position is unfounded. If it was, you wouldn't have to lie and rely on already discredited information to make your point. Your point would stand on its own. As it is, though, it falls apart immediately under any kind of basic scrutiny.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by ubernostrum on Saturday April 14, 2018 @03:14PM (#16838905)
I can never understand why people want to stop others from choosing where they repair their products.

The fact that you keep saying things like this, when I've said nothing indicating that I believe such a thing, is a clear indicator of willful dishonesty on your part. You get no more of my time.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @09:58PM (#16835394)
>Apple insists that they should be the sole arbiter of who is and isn't allowed to do that

This is entirely inaccurate. They just want there to be a clear distinction between Apple service and third-party service.

To use your Subaru analogy, it would be like Subaru making parts for your car and no other third-party manufacturer making them. You wouldn't have a choice but to buy from Subaru. Subaru isn't stopping anyone from reverse-engineering those parts or simply making their own parts that are compatible but it doesn't make sense that Subaru would have to be forced to provide instructions on how to do it. Anyone that's ever taken their car to a mechanic and gotten screwed should be able to relate to what Apple's goals are here. They're not preventing anyone from doing anything but there sure as hell do want to know that the people they've authorized for repairs are doing them to their standards. If someone's iPhone is all fucked up, other people don't know that they got it repaired at some janky kiosk. They just see an iPhone having issues. That devalues and severely harms a brand and company.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by ksk on Saturday April 14, 2018 @12:27AM (#16835867)
>This is entirely inaccurate. They just want there to be a clear distinction between Apple service and third-party service.

False. This is getting tiring.

https://www.notebookcheck.net/Consumer-watchdog-accuses-Appl...

https://boingboing.net/2015/10/01/apple-removes-ifixits-repa...

https://9to5mac.com/2017/02/25/iphone-warranty-third-party-s...

Apple is using or was using (for above links) various ways to make it seem like third party services are illegitmate. Its one of the several tactics to maintain a monopoly. Consumers are getting wiser. Thousands of people have gotten a screen fixed or a battery replaced without paying Apple's tax. Apple sure as hell doesn't like that. But tough cookies. Its no different than the inkjet situation where they blocked third party cartriges and made it nearly impossible for you to refill ink.

>To use your Subaru analogy, it would be like Subaru making parts for your car and no other third-party manufacturer making them. You wouldn't have a choice but to buy from Subaru. Subaru isn't stopping anyone from reverse-engineering those parts or simply making their own parts that are compatible but it doesn't make sense that Subaru would have to be forced to provide instructions on how to do it. A

Subaru doesn't brick my car if I put in a non-subaru stereo.

>Anyone that's ever taken their car to a mechanic and gotten screwed should be able to relate to what Apple's goals are here.

And anyone who has gotten gouged by Apple knows that a monopoly of service and parts is never going to bring about competition.

>If someone's iPhone is all fucked up, other people don't know that they got it repaired at some janky kiosk. They just see an iPhone having issues. That devalues and severely harms a brand and company.

So your argument, as best as I can unpack it, since it was very confusing to me, is - Its justified because someone somewhere at somepoint in time in some cases might face some issues with their third party repair and some people might possibly sometimes mistake that as an Apple problem. Wow.

Anyway, we're going around in circles. There is no point in arguing you have your opinion and I have mine. I am happy to support a positive movement that promotes less e-waste and more local jobs.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Saturday April 14, 2018 @02:46AM (#16836221)
>Subaru doesn't brick my car if I put in a non-subaru stereo.

If Subaru offered an alarm system in your vehicle that disabled the ignition if the system was tampered with, you'd be saying that the system worked exactly as intended. Apple didn't brick people's devices to prevent third-party repairs. The devices were bricked because the chain of trust between Touch ID and the secure enclave was broken. Users had Touch ID enabled and their phones were bricked because Touch ID couldn't verify and there's no way around Touch ID. It's exactly why the update that "fixed" the issue was an update that simply turned off Touch ID for devices that didn't pass verification.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by cptskippy on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:39PM (#16832750)
> They're constantly conflating what Apple is fighting against (counterfeit parts and being compelled to provide documentation and manuals without oversight) with the valid complaint of users not being legally allowed to repair their own devices. Apple has never been against that and isn't fighting that.

Apple is setting up an environment where counterfeiting is practically necessary by hindering legitimate repairs using non counterfeit non genuine parts.

Apple doesn't allow those who aren't Authorized Repair Centers to purchase genuine replacement parts or to have access to service manuals. I'm not aware of another OEM that does this. I can go to HP, Dell, Samsung, MSI, Acer, or LG and purchase genuine parts or download service manuals. Apple posts service manuals online but they go out of their way to lock them behind a login so that only Authorized users can see them.

Apple has bricked iPhones during iOS upgrades if those devices weren't using genuine Apple displays.

Apple has bricked iPhones during iOS upgrades if you replaced the touch ID, regardless of whether it was a genuine part or not.

The iPhone X camera module is a separate part form the display yet if you replace the display genuine or not while keeping the original camera module, it stops working for facial authentication.

Apple disabled the ability to adjust the brightness of your Macbook's display if it wasn't genuine. Hey maybe it doesn't want to damage non genuine displays... so what's the difference between a genuine and non genuine part? The EEID that Apple programs into them. A counterfeit display in this case is simply one that was purchase from Apple's supplier, LG, and programmed with Apple's EEID not by Apple.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @10:13PM (#16835457)
>Apple has bricked iPhones during iOS upgrades if those devices weren't using genuine Apple displays. >Apple has bricked iPhones during iOS upgrades if you replaced the touch ID, regardless of whether it was a genuine part or not. >The iPhone X camera module is a separate part form the display yet if you replace the display genuine or not while keeping the original camera module, it stops working for facial authentication.

This is incorrect and a complete oversimplification of what actually happened. In every single one of the cases you mention, the device was bricked because having the part displayed broke the chain of encryption from the secure enclave to the device in question - Touch ID or Face ID. If you can't verify the chain of trust, there's no way for the device to accurately tell that the security measures that are in place are working correctly with any kind of certainty.

In fact, Apple reversed the Touch ID issue by simply notifying the user that a third-party display had disabled Touch ID (because the Touch ID module key no longer matched the key in the secure enclave). The software simply wasn't designed to allow insecure use of the device and it was fixed within less than a week.

You're either simply ignorant of how these situations came to be or you're being disingenuous because the inaccurate click-bait headline is easy to use to confirm and support your suspicions.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by cptskippy on Friday April 13, 2018 @11:30PM (#16835716)
> This is incorrect and a complete oversimplification of what actually happened. In every single one of the cases you mention, the device was bricked because having the part displayed broke the chain of encryption from the secure enclave to the device in question - Touch ID or Face ID. If you can't verify the chain of trust, there's no way for the device to accurately tell that the security measures that are in place are working correctly with any kind of certainty.

It's not incorrect just incomplete because even genuine parts would fail validation and result in a bricked device.

> In fact, Apple reversed the Touch ID issue by simply notifying the user that a third-party display had disabled Touch ID

> You're either simply ignorant of how these situations came to be or you're being disingenuous

Now who is being disingenuous and/or ignorant?

Only Apple could replace or repair your screen/button and have Touch ID work. When users had their screens repaired using non genuine parts they were fulled aware that Touch ID wasn't going to work.

The devices didn't brick themselves on first boot. They disabled Touch ID and access to the secure enclave but continued to work. Then Apple released an iOS update that bricked their phones for their safety. Then they back pedaled and released a patch so that instead of bricking devices it just notified the user of what they already knew.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Saturday April 14, 2018 @02:50AM (#16836233)
>It's not incorrect just incomplete because even genuine parts would fail validation and result in a bricked device.

Genuine parts would only fail if they were installed without rekeying Touch ID. It didn't matter that the parts were genuine Apple parts or not. It mattered that Touch ID and the secure enclave were no longer paired after the hardware keys no longer matched between the 2.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by cptskippy on Saturday April 14, 2018 @09:14AM (#16837194)
Right, why does that warrant bricking the phone?

Or in the case of the iPhone 7, disabling the home button?

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by Karunamon on Saturday April 14, 2018 @10:37AM (#16837469)
“Bricking the phone” was a bug and was fixed.

Disabling Touch ID is necessary to support the security of the phone. I don’t want a state actor installing a crocked module and use it to break the phone’s security.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by cptskippy on Saturday April 14, 2018 @08:24PM (#16840373)
> "Bricking the phone” was a bug and was fixed.

It wasn't a bug according to Apple. First they said it was deliberate then after the story blew up they said it was a test feature never intended to leave the factory.

They never said it was a bug, the behavior was intentional.

> Disabling Touch ID is necessary to support the security of the phone. I don’t want a state actor installing a crocked module and use it to break the phone’s security.

No one is disputing that, why do you keep bringing it up?

Are you trying to downplay the fact that they are intentionally screwing over people who don't get repairs through them?

Why does swapping the Touch ID module necessitate disabling the home button as well as Touch ID in the iPhone 7?

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @05:06PM (#16833909)
>Apple doesn't allow those who aren't Authorized Repair Centers to purchase genuine replacement parts or to have access to service manuals

And why shouldn't they be allowed to do that? They're not stopping anyone from reverse engineering the parts. They're not stopping anyone from doing the repairs and documenting them otherwise. I don't understand why anyone thinks that Apple should be compelled to willfully aid people that could harm their business model and their brand and to do it for free, no less.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by cptskippy on Friday April 13, 2018 @07:06PM (#16834694)
> And why shouldn't they be allowed to do that?

They are perfectly in their right to do that, it's just shitty.

> They're not stopping anyone from doing the repairs

Actually they are by bricking devices later for having non genuine parts or unauthorized repairs.

> I don't understand why anyone thinks that Apple should be compelled...

Who said anything about compelling them to do anything? I just said they were dicks.

And how would allowing people to service their own machine hurt Apple's brand anymore than people currently making unauthorized repairs?

Giving them access to genuine parts would just increase the likelihood that the repairs work.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @10:00PM (#16835407)
>Actually they are by bricking devices later for having non genuine parts or unauthorized repairs.

The only time devices have ever been bricked for unauthorized repairs is for screen repairs where the chain of trust for Touch ID couldn't be verified. It wasn't intentional and they reverted with a patch within weeks.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by cptskippy on Friday April 13, 2018 @11:19PM (#16835691)
> It wasn't intentional

Actually when it first came out Apple said it was intentional enhanced security checks that disabled the phone for the user's safety.[1] Why brick the phone? The enclave is secure and the Touch ID doesn't work, it hasn't worked since it was repaired. Why suddenly decide the phone needs to stop working during an update? Why not just wipe the secure enclave?

When user's contact Apple for support, they were turned away and Apple recommended they replace the phones.

Apple later changed their story and said that it was intended for validation at the factory and mistakenly affected customers.[2] Bricking a device at the factory seems like an odd way to validate it. Wouldn't a JTAG or SPI bus be a better way to query the phone to perform validations?

> they reverted with a patch within weeks.

Weeks. Turn your phone off and don't use it for weeks then come back here and tell me how it was no big deal.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/money/2016/feb/05/error-53-apple... [2] https://techcrunch.com/2016/02/18/apple-apologizes-and-updat...

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by wuliwong on Friday April 13, 2018 @05:18PM (#16833986)
> the court decision states. “PCKompaniet has never removed the coverup of the Apple logo on the screens that have been imported and has no interest in doing so. PCKompaniet does not pretend or market itself as Apple authorized and does not give any indication that the repair comes with an Apple warranty.”

You are incorrect. The Apple logos were covered up and the court findings state that they were never uncovered. I didn't see anywhere in this article where they say the owner was making claims about using genuine Apple parts.

But I do agree, it seems the right to repair stuff is not great. Repair whatever you want but don't force Apple to help you.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by crististm on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:58PM (#16832950)
Where do you get the idea that Apple or anyone else for that matter can dictate the after market service level?

The appropriate move is that everybody on the market to deliver the schematics of the device to the purchaser, not to the service shops. And while we're at it (since as you said, Apple is not fighting the right to repair) provide also the complete source code with all the private keys they use to brick repaired devices into oblivion.

You might want to reconsider your position on defending idiotic corporate behavior against individuals.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @05:10PM (#16833938)
>The appropriate move is that everybody on the market to deliver the schematics of the device to the purchaser

Why? Why is that appropriate when that's not the case for any other product or service that you can own?

There's nothing to reconsider if I don't find their behavior idiotic.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by crististm on Friday April 13, 2018 @08:01PM (#16834961)
That's a simple one: because they already deliver manuals to the service shops of their choice.

With regard to your circular reasoning: it goes nowhere. You should know that all devices used to come with service manuals and some still do today.

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @10:03PM (#16835412)
They used to come with service manuals because they were a collection of simple mechanical parts. Devices nowadays are far more complicated and intricate than the types of things you're referring to.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by crististm on Saturday April 14, 2018 @02:21AM (#16836169)
There is the part where service manuals exist today. Apple just don't give them to you.

I sense a fairy tale infinite complexity in todays devices from your post. You know that people built them

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by barrkel on Friday April 13, 2018 @02:08PM (#16832439)
The article flatly contradicts your claims.
Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @05:12PM (#16833948)
The website of the company that the article is about does not. They state (and it's archived since they've changed it since the court case) that they use genuine Apple parts for their repairs.

Edit - https://web.archive.org/web/20160327050030/http://www.pckomp...

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by jkoebler on Friday April 13, 2018 @03:18PM (#16833107)
From the article (which I wrote, happy to answer questions) ... this is quoted in the court decision i.e., was written by a judge not by the defendant:

"PCKompaniet does not pretend or market itself as Apple authorized and does not give any indication that the repair comes with an Apple warranty.”"

Re:Apple Sued an iPhone Repair Shop Owner in Norway and Lost by dpkonofa on Friday April 13, 2018 @05:11PM (#16833946)
The PCKompaniet web site states that they use genuine Apple parts.

Edit: https://web.archive.org/web/20160327050030/http://www.pckomp...