News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by mattsfrey on Thursday April 12, 2018 @11:54AM (#16822194)
This needs to be rejected whole sale. One nation does NOT have the authority to dictate what a company can do outside of it's borders and concerns. The censorship issues that have been cropping up lately in these regards are appalling. The "hate speech" legislature of many EU nations comes to mind. If that insanity were to be enforced "world wide" it's seriously time for new service providers to step up that aren't so money hungry for those markets to capitulate.
Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by hunter23 on Thursday April 12, 2018 @01:05PM (#16822868)
I think it's actually quite common for a country to dictate what it's citizens and companies can do outside of its borders.

For example,

* A US company can be prosecuted on corruption charges if it bribes an official out of its borders. This is even if what they do is not considered bribery in the country itself; you are bound to the US law even when you are doing business outside of it. The US has used this approach to clamp down corruption cases of companies in developing countries.

* Trade embargos work this way. We have an embargo on Iran and ban US based companies from doing business with them, even if its through a subsidiary that operates outside our borders

* US citizens are required to pay taxes when they live in another country (we are the only country to tax globally)

* As a US traveler, you have to follow some US laws even when you are in other countries. The US has used this to combat sex tourism. So while it may be easy to go around the country's age of consent laws while you are visting, you can still be prosecuted in the US. This is to prevent child sex trafficking etc.

Nomentatus has listed other examples in this thread.

Enforcement, on the other hand is pretty difficult. I don't see how Canada force Google to do things outside of it's borders - the worst they can do is kick Youtube out their country.

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by endangered on Thursday April 12, 2018 @01:19PM (#16823003)
* That is a US company

* The ban affects US companies

* The taxes affect US citizens

* The laws affect US citizens

This has nothing to do with this decision.

What Canada is aiming to do is to force a non-Canadian company to follow Canadian law even if it does not operate at all in Canada.

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by lovich on Thursday April 12, 2018 @02:05PM (#16823384)
It's interacting with Canadian citizenship and being paid by Canadian companies for advertising.

If it's literally doing no operations inside of Canada then they have nothing to worry about because Canada couldn't do anything to them.

Its pretty hypocritical of companies to rely on local laws to protect them but then act like all their customers on the internet don't exist in any real space and aren't under a nation states juridisction.

I'd prefer a completely free internet, but you don't get to have it both ways

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by hunter23 on Thursday April 12, 2018 @03:24PM (#16824096)
Just to be clear I was responding to the OP's statement "One nation does NOT have the authority to dictate what a company can do outside of it's borders and concerns". This is incorrect - a nation regularly forms laws on what its companies and citizens can do outside of its borders and concerns.

Now what you are staying is something completely different from the OPs argument - you are stating "Google is not a Canadian entity so neither Op's or my arguments matter". I am not a legal expert so I have no idea but the statement that Google "does not operate at all in Canada" seems misleading as I know that Google has offices based in Canada. They have Canadian citizens working in Canadian offices under a registered entity so I am not sure why you are saying that Google "does not operate at all in Canada".

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by 8note on Thursday April 12, 2018 @11:41PM (#16826982)
Google makes money advertising to Canadians. that sounds a lot like operating in canada
Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by kahnpro on Friday April 13, 2018 @08:15AM (#16829226)
Then Google needs to close its Canadian offices, and stop providing services to Canadians.
Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by izacus on Thursday April 12, 2018 @12:29PM (#16822514)
So does that mean that we should punish Google when it pulls our YouTube video due to trademark concerns valid only inside US and videos with pro-Russian, pro-Chinese, pro-ISIS political slant?

Or does this your idea only work for US cultural norms? Should we then start processes of getting Google out of EU, Asia? After all, a media service who distributes illegal content inside your borders, spreads US propaganda, bans your propaganda ... is dangerous right?

How do we reconcile the fact that those are global services?

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by kodablah on Thursday April 12, 2018 @01:06PM (#16822883)
> Or does this your idea only work for US cultural norms?

Always these false equivalences, every time. I can count on it. In this case, I'm sure GP thinks as I do, that no US court should be able to tell a company what to take down elsewhere in the world. That Google chooses to is another matter. Please please, can we stop trying to deflect the real issue with these whataboutisms?

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by tgragnato on Thursday April 12, 2018 @02:06PM (#16823392)
In this particular case, the whole thing is probably more complicated than what it seems: it's not entirely clear that Google chooses to is another matter.

As a reference: "The Digital Disruption - Connectivity and the Diffusion of Power" by Eric Schmidt & Jared Cohen [http://archive.is/R13l2]

In the past people interpreted the article as "US companies control a large proportion of the internet infrastructure, the government can use this as a foreign policy tool". If you're a foreigner this may not sound cool..

It is natural for a company that maintains complex and entrenched relationships with a government, to influence and being influenced, at home and abroad.

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by kodablah on Thursday April 12, 2018 @02:59PM (#16823879)
Sure. But that doesn't change the common moral stance that one has of "X government should not be able to force a company to do things outside of X's jurisdiction" for any values of X, even if that is at odds with what currently happens today. And some people's morals may extend the quote to "if company is not headquartered in X" or "if company does not do business in X" or whatever they may think. But the conversation on the morals themselves cannot be had if all we do is replace values of X for three reasons: 1) it assumes people have inconsistent morals, and 2) no two situations are the same and 3) the conversation is diluted.

To your broader point about US internet hegemony and government influence, I think it doesn't sound cool to many regardless of where they reside. If we must draw equivalence for history's sake here, one could look at the dissemination of culture over and over again and protectionist measures by the encroached upon in order to retain power, often against the will of the citizens. Over time, people will do what they want, in the meantime all most want is those with power to limit themselves. It also has value to recognize the environments that foster these cultural innovations and fight fire with fire instead of power.

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by tgragnato on Thursday April 12, 2018 @03:29PM (#16824132)
I agree on the ideal of extra jurisdictional non-interference, but I consider it an ideal. Realistically, a global intercommunication network involves risks. Risks that people should have the chance to manage.

When companies and governments take away the freedom of self-determination from people, then the question becomes more complex.

This is why, despite agreeing with the moral stance, I believe that Google has been put in a difficult position, and do not need a priori defence.

Freedom of information is an important issue, but I prefer to turn my attention to less controversial actors.

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by John_KZ on Thursday April 12, 2018 @12:12PM (#16822358)
Exactly. Google should have subsidiaries in each nation it operates and obey the local law - nothing more and nothing less. Canadia courts should not have an effect on Mexico, and Iranian courts should not have an effect on the US.

Google can sell/offer it's services anywhere as long as it's legal.

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by tw04 on Thursday April 12, 2018 @12:20PM (#16822420)
So if Google operates a subsidiary in China, they should be completely immune from a lawsuit in the US, if say, they sell your private personal info to the highest bidder in that nation?

I don't see how that could be abused...

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by jerf on Thursday April 12, 2018 @12:25PM (#16822469)
Your question at the moment is ill-defined. Carefully expand out the nationalities of the "you" who is buying the info, the nationalities of the person whom the info is about, the nationality of the subsidiary from which the information is being purchased, and the nationality under which you believe they should be suable. ("Jurisdiction", if you prefer, may replace "nationality".)

There's a lot of combinations in there, and I don't think conversation can be profitable had without being clear. It's fine to fill it in with variables, too, I'm not asking for a concrete binding, but at the very least your question as I read it now is missing whose information is being sold.

(Also note the ONLY thing I'm saying here is that you need to be more clear. I am not making any claims of my own at this time, because before I can have an opinion about an answer to a question, there needs to be a question.)

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by tw04 on Thursday April 12, 2018 @12:30PM (#16822520)
Chinese subsidiary, Chinese buyer, US citizen.
Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by lowbloodsugar on Thursday April 12, 2018 @01:03PM (#16822854)
Logically, for China Google to sell your data to Chinese Buyer, then US Google must have sold your data to China Google. If it is illegal for US Google to sell data to third parties, then US Google could be sued for selling that data to China Google. However, since the USA is all about "Freedom meaning we can do what the fuck we like with your data", and not "Freedom from persecution", there's no reason that US Google couldn't do what you describe. If you were a European citizen, and it was German Google selling your data to China Google (or US Google), then that'd be a very different story.

It seems odd that you're worried about China, when you live in a nation that has been proven to wiretap you by the government, and where private transactions are authorized based on information which three credit score companies store completely insecurely.

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by sp332 on Thursday April 12, 2018 @01:03PM (#16822851)
How would the Chinese subsidiary get the info about the US citizen?
Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by jacksmith21006 on Thursday April 12, 2018 @12:30PM (#16822521)
Google does not sell your personal data. They do use to Target ads but does not leave Google.
Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by sp332 on Thursday April 12, 2018 @01:05PM (#16822867)
Google might not sell data wholesale, but they do sell it retail, so to speak. If I make an ad targeting gay dog owners in NYC, and someone clicks that ad, I know that Google knows they're a gay dog owner in NYC. Google sold me that person's data.
Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by Spivak on Friday April 13, 2018 @12:29AM (#16827134)
Or more succinctly, a lot of people don't really find a meaningful difference between selling data and selling access to or use of that data.
Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by ksk on Thursday April 12, 2018 @12:14PM (#16822377)
Google doesn't want that because not every subsidiary would be profitable, and they would have to pay local taxes in every country they have an office/employ people/generate revenue.
Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by flukus on Thursday April 12, 2018 @11:50PM (#16827007)
> One nation does NOT have the authority to dictate what a company can do outside of it's borders and concerns.

We crossed this bridge quite a while ago, it's only the direction that's changing. If I hacked a server in the US from the UK guess where I'm being charged? If I send drugs from Canada to the US guess where I'm being charged? These aren't hypotheticals, they've happened before.

I agree it needs to be changed, but this was foreseeable a long time ago and nobody cared.

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by 8note on Thursday April 12, 2018 @11:39PM (#16826975)
Nothing requires Google to do business in Canada, and it's not like this is the first Canadian law to extend to things that happen internationally.
Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by GCU-Empiricist on Thursday April 12, 2018 @01:03PM (#16822849)
So this is lawfare between a company that makes something and a company purported to have stolen their design. I guess the question that really would make it interesting is what country is the purported design thief in?
Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by dragonwriter on Thursday April 12, 2018 @12:31PM (#16822534)
> One nation does NOT have the authority to dictate what a company can do outside of it's borders and concerns.

The actually do, that's inherent in the nature of sovereignty. You can eliminate the practical effect of that by adopting a single shared global sovereign regime, but that idea is controversial even in the abstract, and in concrete detail even moreso, as those who agree that such a thing is desirable disagree violently on the character that such a regime should have, and mostly view not having one as better than having the wrong one, so we are stuck in a system of multiple sovereigns.

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by dsacco on Thursday April 12, 2018 @12:36PM (#16822572)
Do you mean that sovereignty grants that authority in principle, or in actuality? If the United States doesn't enforce the demands of another country with respect to a company in its borders, the company can freely ignore those demands. That various countries choose to have treaties enforcing the demands of others seems to be less about sovereignty and more about good relations.

For example, Germany ordered Project Gutenberg to remove certain books from its servers or to make them unavailable to Germans. I maintain a full mirror of Project Gutenberg and I make the banned books available to Germans. If Germany sent me a personal letter demanding I cease and desist, I'd ignore it. If the United States demanded I cease and desist on Germany's behalf, I wouldn't ignore it. But the latter doesn't seem like "Germany's sovereignty" to me.

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by dragonwriter on Thursday April 12, 2018 @12:46PM (#16822673)
> Do you mean that sovereignty grants that authority in principle, or in actuality?

Yes, both.

> If the United States doesn't enforce the demands of another country with respect to a company in its borders, the company can freely ignore those demands.

The authority to legislate and the ability to impose consequences are two different things. It is, for instance, indisputable that the US has authority to criinalize tax fraud by it's citizens occuring within the US, but if a tax fraudster escapes to a foreign country with all their possessions before the US catches them, and that country is uninterested in assisting the US, the US may well find it practically impossible to enforce sanctions without engaging in interstate conflict.

The only difference with the situation at hand is that an act committee overseas by a foreign entity is more likely to be difficult to sanction since flight for the purpose of evasion is less likely to be necessary (OTOH, if the offender has any contact with the offended jurisdiction, they are still at risk, and being g ofrced to avoid the jurisdiction to avoid sanctions may itself be a kind of sanction.)

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by s2g on Thursday April 12, 2018 @01:03PM (#16822859)
The US has strongarmed other countries into helping enforce US tax law.

It's crazy to see American's pretend the US isn't a massive offender when it comes to pushing their laws well outside their borders.

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by patmcc on Thursday April 12, 2018 @01:00PM (#16822819)
>>>the company can freely ignore those demands

>>>If Germany sent me a personal letter demanding I cease and desist, I'd ignore it.

You (presumably) don't do any business in Germany, or really care about their government being unhappy with you, which is pretty reasonable. Google wants to keep doing business in Canada, so they have to play ball. Can Canada send people into the US offices of google to enforce any of this? Of course not. But can they shut down google in Canada if it refuses to abide by court orders? You bet. (I doubt it'll come to that though)

Re:Google can be forced to pull results globally, Canada sup... by mcguire on Thursday April 12, 2018 @04:49PM (#16824821)
You have the actual solution, in fact. How long does anyone think a Canadian supreme court decision could stand if Google ceases operations in Canada?

I suppose they could stand up a Baidu-like Canadian Google replacement, but it would take a while.