News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by _eht on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:59AM (#16771203)
It was reworded enough times to make their promise vague and not well defined.
Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by eastdakota on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:21AM (#16771294)
I’m Cloudflare’s CEO. What questions do you have?

I’ll start: do we ever store 1.1.1.1’s users’ IPs? No. They’re never written to disk. And APNIC never has access to them.

What data do you provide to APNIC? We give APNIC reports on non-DNS data that’s hitting 1.1.1.1. It includes information like: what protocols are sending data to the IP, what’s the volume, where it it coming from?

For DNS users of 1.1.1.1, we never provide APNIC any identifying information. We don’t upload any data to them. While they can query for questions like: “How many queries came from India in the last 24 hours?” they can’t query anything on a specific user.

If you have concerns, ask them here. I’ll answer.

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by nextgens on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:44AM (#16771627)
Are you aware that your public resolvers are actively breaking DNS-based GeoIP (striping EDNS0-ECN and not using source IPs geo-localized as the requester would be)? and if so, what is the rationale for it?
Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by lathiat on Friday April 06, 2018 @04:42AM (#16771850)
Yeah I tested it out and switched back, it made performance to Twitch in particular quite bad for me. I don't get that issue with Google DNS though.
Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by nextgens on Friday April 06, 2018 @05:29AM (#16772000)
Google's take good care of it... and they explain precisely what they do on the topic...

https://developers.google.com/speed/public-dns/docs/ecs

https://developers.google.com/speed/public-dns/faq#locations (when EDNS0/ECS isn't supported)

The tin foil hat brigade might suggest that this is deliberate to ensure that only what's served by cloudflare gets to be fast...

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by acct1771 on Friday April 06, 2018 @10:20AM (#16773399)
Why is healthy speculation now considered "tin foil hat brigade"?

Conspiracy theory isn't a dirty word.

Speculation keeps people informed and alive.

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by zuzun on Friday April 06, 2018 @04:11AM (#16771743)
I think everyone's concern should be that Cloudflare or Google might just replace each IP in their 24h logs with a random UUID and call it anonymized. Both companies can potentially store enough information to correlate DNS requests with regular traffic logs.

It doesn't take much guessing to know who sent an anonymous DNS request for example.com to one of your countless PoPs if your CDN logs a HTTP GET request to www.example.com at the same location a few milliseconds later.

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by jgrahamc on Friday April 06, 2018 @04:16AM (#16771765)
We're not storing the source IP addresses in any form. Not raw, not "transformed", not anonymized, not hashed. They are not being stored.

Our business is not about tracking people; it's about selling our service to businesses to make their web sites/APIs/applications faster and more secure.

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by chinathrow on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:18AM (#16771532)
From https://developers.cloudflare.com/1.1.1.1/commitment-to-priv...:

"Specifically, APNIC will be permitted to access query names, query types, resolver location and other metadata via a Cloudflare API, that will allow APNIC to study topics like the volume of DDoS attacks launched on the Internet and adoption of IPv6."

I interpret "query names" as some values obtained from DNS queries hitting 1.1.1.1, e.g. "foo.example.com".

Is your answer to "What data do you provide to APNIC?" complete in the statement above?

Thanks for clarifying.

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by eastdakota on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:50AM (#16771656)
No querying IPs, ever. Nothing personally identifiable. APNIC can query things like: how many DNS queries come from the UK? How many query for google.com?
Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by thinkloop on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:05AM (#16771476)
Hello,

Are the gigabytes of junk billions of tiny requests or are there large requests as well?

Are you finding it more difficult than expected to manage the data?

I'm a 1.1.1.1 customer since you launched, thanks a lot for it.

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by eastdakota on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:51AM (#16771666)
Nope. We have a lot of excess capacity. Doesn’t increase our costs. But, that’s a longer conversation…
Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by walrus01 on Friday April 06, 2018 @04:19AM (#16771775)
Neteng here: without seeing the traffic charts for individual interfaces and aggregations, I would bet cloudflare has a shitload of excess inbound capacity. They are a content pushing CDN. I would bet that at a major IX where they have one 100Gbps port that their out:in ratio is 90:10 or greater. So if they only have 6-9 Gbps of traffic inbound on a 100GbE port to a fabric consisting of 80+ bgp peers, they have a lot of extra capacity to absorb unwanted inbound traffic before it becomes an operational concern.

Have seen edge traffic charts for major porn hosting companies and the out:in traffic ratio is like 97:3

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by lulmerchant on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:36AM (#16771365)
How do you know where the requests came from without IP addresses? Do you log ASN or something?
Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by eastdakota on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:48AM (#16771403)
We keep IPs in memory to help stop abuse and debugging ng other issue, but we promise to purge all logs within 24 hours or less.
Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by decisiveness on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:14AM (#16771512)
>they can’t query anything on a specific user.

What exactly do you mean by "user"? Can they query DNS traffic by IP address / subnet? Exactly what are all of the restrictions there?

EDIT: Is there a whitelist of things they can query by or do you simply trust them to be good citizens, have a binding legal agreement, all of the above?

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by eastdakota on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:46AM (#16771641)
No. We have a legally binding agreement. And, more importantly, we don’t store or give them access to IPs or anything else that may be associated with any individual. Look at a DNS query, look at what could be identifying — let us know where concerns are. My hunch is we’ve thought of it. If not, we will fix. We don’t want personally identifiably info. It creates a legal risk for us. We purge it as quickly as we can.
Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by davrosthedalek on Friday April 06, 2018 @07:15AM (#16772355)
We don’t want personally identifiably info. It creates a legal risk for us. We purge it as quickly as we can.

Ding ding ding, we have a winner. If more people would realize this, we would have less data breaches. To get there, a data breach must become more costly for the companies.

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by JackC on Friday April 06, 2018 @08:41AM (#16772728)
Is there personal data in the domain names queried, as opposed to the IP addresses querying? I think there probably is. For example, consider the bug in iTerm2 that ran a dns query for any text cmd-clicked on.

To protect against that, could you commit not to log to disk any queries that come from fewer than N ips in 24 hours, and not to expose rare queries to APNIC or internally? (Not a demand, just brainstorming mitigation.)

It might also be fun to give an internal team access to the data you consider safe, and challenge them to dig up personal data from it.

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by dx034 on Friday April 06, 2018 @10:04AM (#16773289)
Do you plan to publish usage statistics over the coming weeks? I'd be keen to know what kind of (valid DNS) volumes you've seen since the announcement. And if there are any obvious patterns of ASNs or countries using it a lot (unless you don't want to disclose that to avoid being blocked there).
Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by GunlogAlm on Friday April 06, 2018 @05:59AM (#16772115)
> I’ll start: do we ever store 1.1.1.1’s users’ IPs? No. They’re never written to disk.

Is there a guarantee that this will always be the case? Might there, in theory, be a point in the future where users' IPs are collected and stored?

Loving 1.1.1.1, btw.

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by cesarb on Friday April 06, 2018 @07:01AM (#16772300)
Does APNIC get a sample of the raw packets of non-DNS and non-HTTP/HTTPS/QUIC protocols, so they can figure out what they actually are and why they're being sent towards that network?
Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by kuschku on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:41AM (#16771378)
I expect that no human from APNIC or Cloudflare will ever look at raw data from 1.1.1.1, nor will any of it be recorded, or used in aggregated data that retains any personal information.

As personal information count full IP addresses, the content of requests, or any set of data that can be used to recover these.

That is what "we respect your privacy" means.

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by eastdakota on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:52AM (#16771420)
Neither we nor APNIC can query “what” or “how many” requests from any IP have been made.

We can query things like:

1. How much query traffic is from Africa? 2. What’s the peak time of query traffic? 3. What are the most popular DNS authoritative servers?

If you have specific concerns, please raise them here.

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by tannercollin on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:16AM (#16771520)
What's in it for you guys? How do you make money off of 1.1.1.1? Thanks!
Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by eastdakota on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:58AM (#16771698)
Brand. How much would you pay if you were us to associate your brand with privacy/security and speed?

Performance. Our core business is making our customers fast and safe. More people using 1.1.1.1 means our Authoritative DNS service inherently faster for anyone who uses it.

Recruiting. Our mission is to help build a better Internet. Lots of places the people on our team can work. That they work for us is often because employees believe in our mission. 1.1.1.1 helps with that.

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by kabacha on Friday April 06, 2018 @07:29AM (#16772403)
> Our mission is to help build a better Internet.

I've been working a lot with open data and I have huge problem with Cloudflare ruining open internet with bot protection and such. The issue I have is that public data is public, be it bot or human.

I'm having real issue with you guys saying that your mission is to better the internet when you break shitton of floss apps that are essentially harmless and people who want to do harm, crawl at huge rates for commercial purposes break your systems like it's made of twigs. I'm saying this as a person who works on both sides and can't help but call you out.

So sorry unless you turn to non-profit I'm really not buying your "helping the internet" song.

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by kuschku on Friday April 06, 2018 @09:40AM (#16773103)
I agree. Part of what makes the web the web is that anyone has to be able to crawl its data, and build new technology on top.

As long as Cloudflare blocks that, it's hostile.

Maybe a way to register as spider with Cloudflare, and get a token that one passes in the header, with strict rate limits would be much better than the current solution of just showing captchas.

Re:Cloudflare's new DNS attracting 'gigabits per second' of ... by celticninja on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:53AM (#16771674)
I guess they don't, they just make a better internet, which helps their customers of their other services, and the rest of us. Seems like so good old fashioned altruism to me.