However, having worked at other parts of Google (not on Maps or location stuff), I'd guess at a much more prosaic explanation than that kind of conspiracy: the product managers / engineers / tech writers / UI designers don't want to maintain the complexity of both code paths and UX flows indefinitely if most users are happy to share their location server-side in exchange for the conveniences and features that enables.
You and I aren't happy to do that, but we on Hacker News aren't representative of most consumer-product Google users.
Huh? Google Maps works fine for me despite having disabled location services. It nags me nearly everytime I open the app to "enable location services to proceed", making it sound as though it is required, but I just click "No" and get on with it. Haven't noticed any missing features.
Google search has been awesome for me when logged in, Maps is irreplaceable; as well as Inbox :/
As for Google Mail - There are many great E-Mail hosters like ProtonMail, coupled with your favorite E-Mail client it has no downsides, unless you miss tight Google Products integration.
- navigation
- address search (not the first time I hear it is awful in OSM)
- pictures of places
- live traffic data, both streets and public transportation
- great search (like gyms near me)
- colored points of interest on the map. Kind of an hidden feature but that's immensely useful when you know it is there and you don't know the city you are in.
- reviews
It might take 5 or 6 apps to replace it entirely.
As for inbox, their spam filter is top notch and I like the automatic tagging system.
edit : just started trying OSMAnd, wow it is extremely laggy on my high end phone.
But if performance of osmand bothers you, this is the place to go.
>non-free (as in freedom) map data service
As in, it's all OSM data but not directly from their servers? Or is maps.me adding extra some extra info to the displayed map?
I wonder if OSMand could make use of maps.me code to speed up their rendering - or perhaps it's not possible without cutting out information/features.
In my mind it's mostly a creepy and half-assed webmail provider with crappy imap support. But I've never really used Gmail all that much (because: creepy evil ad company and email is an obvious bad combination).
I bring it up because it feels like that's a primary reason why people might be trapped on gmail is just that all the websites they are signed up on are linked to it.
I do wish we had was better controls. For example, if you disable location tracking, Google Maps won't remember any address you visit. Why can't it be cached locally? If I regularly visit an address on my phone, it should be included in my autocomplete. I don't need cross-device history or tracking, I just want my damn phone to remember places I've visited previously without uploading it to the cloud. Taking an all-or-nothing approach seriously harms the user experience.
Despite it taking years, I've gradually been migrating away from my hard dependency on Google services. With that being said, if I were locked out of my gmail account I'd be seriously fucked. Maybe some day I'll reach the point where that's not the case.