News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You will be surprised to see how much Google tracks about... by ssahoo on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @01:43AM (#16685598)
I think the Google Maps annoyance after activity tracking is disabled is designed intensionally. To force users to give up the control with easy to click buttons.
Re:You will be surprised to see how much Google tracks about... by jkaplowitz on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @03:03AM (#16685986)
I too dislike how many of Google's consumer services are being increasingly gated on the location history permission, which I too have disabled and which therefore means I can't use those services.

However, having worked at other parts of Google (not on Maps or location stuff), I'd guess at a much more prosaic explanation than that kind of conspiracy: the product managers / engineers / tech writers / UI designers don't want to maintain the complexity of both code paths and UX flows indefinitely if most users are happy to share their location server-side in exchange for the conveniences and features that enables.

You and I aren't happy to do that, but we on Hacker News aren't representative of most consumer-product Google users.

Re:You will be surprised to see how much Google tracks about... by majewsky on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @04:54AM (#16696381)
> I too dislike how many of Google's consumer services are being increasingly gated on the location history permission, which I too have disabled and which therefore means I can't use those services.

Huh? Google Maps works fine for me despite having disabled location services. It nags me nearly everytime I open the app to "enable location services to proceed", making it sound as though it is required, but I just click "No" and get on with it. Haven't noticed any missing features.

Re:You will be surprised to see how much Google tracks about... by jkaplowitz on Friday March 30, 2018 @05:53PM (#16720093)
One example of a Google consumer service that needs location history is the Google Assistant. on my Google Pixel phone, that has fully replaced the older non-Assistant OK Google system which didn't require location history.
Re:You will be surprised to see how much Google tracks about... by solarkraft on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @05:54AM (#16686813)
I find it interesting that the engineers' laziness may just happen to translate to an "evil" win for the company.