Re:You will be surprised to see how much Google tracks about...
by majewsky on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @04:54AM
(#16696381)
> I too dislike how many of Google's consumer services are being increasingly gated on the location history permission, which I too have disabled and which therefore means I can't use those services.
Huh? Google Maps works fine for me despite having disabled location services. It nags me nearly everytime I open the app to "enable location services to proceed", making it sound as though it is required, but I just click "No" and get on with it. Haven't noticed any missing features.
Re:You will be surprised to see how much Google tracks about...
by jkaplowitz on Friday March 30, 2018 @05:53PM
(#16720093)
One example of a Google consumer service that needs location history is the Google Assistant. on my Google Pixel phone, that has fully replaced the older non-Assistant OK Google system which didn't require location history.
Re:You will be surprised to see how much Google tracks about...
by solarkraft on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @05:54AM
(#16686813)
I find it interesting that the engineers' laziness may just happen to translate to an "evil" win for the company.
However, having worked at other parts of Google (not on Maps or location stuff), I'd guess at a much more prosaic explanation than that kind of conspiracy: the product managers / engineers / tech writers / UI designers don't want to maintain the complexity of both code paths and UX flows indefinitely if most users are happy to share their location server-side in exchange for the conveniences and features that enables.
You and I aren't happy to do that, but we on Hacker News aren't representative of most consumer-product Google users.