Really, I'm all for symmetry with stuff like this if that is what it takes to get these giants to at least attempt to comply with the law.
What would symmetry look like from the US side if the EU starts demanding Google be broken up? Unfortunately the EU has no massive, powerful technology businesses to demand be broken up.
So?
If it had then most likely there would be a similarly strong push to break up such a company if it misbehaved. At least, I would hope so.
Microsoft got very lucky with the change of party in charge, they were about to be broken up in the US into 'apps' and 'os'.
And that's a good punishment for companies that use the fact that they have their fingers in completely different pies to stifle the competition.
Breaking up VW would not accomplish much in that sense.
Maybe because the EU has working competition laws, so EU companies rarely tend to hold a monopoly in dozens of independent markets?
I mean, that’s the basic issue here, isn’t it? The US hasn’t had effective antitrust regulation for decades, which is why Google ever could grow to this size in the first place.
Honestly, this sort of thing is often thrown around as a trope and I don’t think it holds much water.
If you create a startup in SV, you can easily sell to the whole US.
In the EU, you’ll need to obey 28 different laws, 28 different standards, and file 28 different tax forms. This is currently the single biggest hurdle for startups in the EU.
The second, of course, is that people seem less willing to throw billions at risky concepts just so one maybe gets big enough.
Different social attitudes to risk, and a language barrier, are no doubt much more pressing concerns.
All these can be potential roadblocks that make it harder.
The real difference is that the EU and it's member nations actually enforce their regulations and don't let situations happen like Uber/ISPS/AirBnB just ignoring laws until they had enough money/influence to force changes to the regulations
I mentioned this in a sibling comment – a good example is the EU enforcing VAT laws actually, vs. in the US many online stores simply being located in a state without sales tax and not paying any in the state where the customer lives either.
In the EU, VAT compliance can definitely become an issue, especially with small projects.
Not so much an issue for VC startups, but definitely one for bootstrapped ones. The only way to get a large enough market to survive is to sell to the entire EU, but that means much more work with VAT compliance, and translations.