News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by ixtli on Friday March 23, 2018 @09:48AM (#16658044)
I realize that this is tangential to what you're talking about but your comment reminded me of it strongly: As much as it's clear that there was some funny business with trump's people and russia, the way liberals are salivating over mueller's investigation makes me uncomfortable. they need the legal system to pronounce in some way that trump and his people broke the rules, in order to avoid acknowledging that the general thrust of all of this is the system working as it was designed.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by WallWextra on Friday March 23, 2018 @09:49AM (#16658059)
It's like how the 2008 election didn't count, because Obama is actually a Kenyan. People can't just lose an election anymore.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by ixtli on Friday March 23, 2018 @09:55AM (#16658126)
I like to talk about social issues and politics and stuff but the more I do it in public the more I run into what feels like "politics-as-basketball." It's really begun to feel like team sports as opposed to a critical analysis of conditions and power analysis.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by mieseratte on Friday March 23, 2018 @10:26AM (#16658467)
As someone in their mid-twenties, I have to ask the older HNers: has it always been this "stupid," so vitriolic and hateful? If not, when did it become this way?
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by ams6110 on Friday March 23, 2018 @10:35AM (#16658563)
It has, but it's never been so easy to spout off to the world before, or be instantly informed about what other people are thinking.

In the 1980s the media hated Reagan about as much as they hated Bush or Trump. Before that it was Nixon. But you really only heard about it if you watched the evening news, and that was 30 minutes of the day. It wasn't being fed to you continuously like an intravenous drip on your phone.

It's the speed and pervasiveness that have increased, not so much the partisanship.

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by tim333 on Friday March 23, 2018 @10:51AM (#16658726)
I'd disagree and say through the Bush Clinton Bush Obama period it wasn't as bad. I guess the levels of stupid vitriolic and hateful come and go. The world has definitely gone through worse phases as well, see the 1930s for example.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by creaghpatr on Friday March 23, 2018 @12:02PM (#16659441)
They probably would have been worse to Bush up front had 9/11 not happened. Blasting the President in the year(s) after 9/11 would have probably been in poor taste through the eyes of the public.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by Slansitartop on Friday March 23, 2018 @11:03AM (#16658842)
> In the 1980s the media hated Reagan about as much as they hated Bush or Trump. Before that it was Nixon. But you really only heard about it if you watched the evening news, and that was 30 minutes of the day. It wasn't being fed to you continuously like an intravenous drip on your phone.

While I wasn't mature enough then to form my own opinion about it, I'm under the impression that the media was also more restrained and professional back then. Now it seems a lot more tabloid, generally. There also seems to be a burring between "opinion/editorial" and reporting, especially online, which fuels the polarization.

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by adventured on Friday March 23, 2018 @10:33AM (#16658549)
The Revolutionary War era was as bad or worse than it is today. [1] They spit about as much venom at each other as you possibly could. They said arguably far worse things about each other than have been said about Trump or Obama.

There was a bit of comparative calm that settled in, from the immediate time after the Civil War, until the late 1960s. The level of ugliness of ideological attacks that Franklin Roosevelt saw, for example, were nowhere near what Obama & Trump have seen. That century was a far calmer era for political vitriol, than the 1780-1860 time frame, or since the late 1960s.

A not amusing Civil War era example:

"In 1856, U.S. Sen. Charles Sumner of Massachusetts gave a speech criticizing pro-slavery southerners. Three days later, he was beaten so badly - on the Senate floor - by U.S. Rep. Preston Brooks of South Carolina that he didn’t return to the Senate for three years."

[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2011/09/the-ori...

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by zeveb on Friday March 23, 2018 @10:48AM (#16658688)
I think maybe it has, and each of us doesn't notice it when we're younger and we think that we're really arguing about principles. Before Trump Derangement Syndrome (Russia!) there was Obama Derangement Syndrome (Kenya!); before that there was Bush Derangement Syndrome; before that there was Clinton Derangement Syndrome; before that Reagan Derangement Syndrome (Oliver Sacks even included a bit in his book The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat which alleged that there are people with a neurological condition which causes them to detect lies, who couldn't watch Mr. Reagan speak because everything he said was a lie; if true this would have been quite an amazing discovery …), and so on & so forth.

And of course a lot of this wasn't entirely unfounded. Mr. Obama really was the first anti-American president; Mr. Bush really was incompetent; Mr. Clinton really was a perjurer, philanderer, power-abuser & possible rapist; Mr. Reagan really did lie a lot (e.g. Iran-Contra); Mr. Carter really was incompetent; Mr. Nixon really was a crook; Mr. Johnson really was a crook &c. &c. &c.

The fact that we keep on electing compromised, power-hungry people to a position of extreme power is no doubt part of the problem, but even back when the presidency was far weaker you had the partisans of Jefferson & Adams maligning one another with language we would be shocked at today.

The only recent American president I can think of who was mostly decent was probably Gerald Ford, who never ran for the position. Maybe that's the secret.

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by jessaustin on Friday March 23, 2018 @11:00AM (#16658809)
It goes in cycles, but anyone who imagines that e.g. the Civil War wasn't preceded by strong feelings has no sense of history. Keep in mind that decorum and conduct are different things. Since the 1950s, USA has done some awful things, with inconsistent discussion, heated or otherwise. As someone who regrets that history and takes Orwell seriously, I'm glad there are now some cracks in the consensus.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by paulsutter on Friday March 23, 2018 @10:50AM (#16658722)
No it was never this vitriolic or hateful
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by mmjaa on Monday March 26, 2018 @06:50AM (#16677948)
Dialectic Materialism has been Weaponised.

People think that because they are capable of pitching an anti-synthesis against a synthesis, they are intelligent - whereas nothing could be further from the truth. If you can't get out of the pro-vs-con mindset you are stuck in a trap designed to ensure you don't think beyond the curve, outside the event horizon of 'generally approved thought-process' society.

People need to be given uncomfortable positions to evaluate. Just maybe, its important to not discount the conspiracies and realise that in fact truth is stranger than fiction ..

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by ixtli on Monday March 26, 2018 @12:59PM (#16680399)
This is interesting. Right now I'm of the mind that the best I can do is to continue to press on the inherent contradictions.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by adventured on Friday March 23, 2018 @10:28AM (#16658498)
As I've gotten older and have seen enough side switches, I've found it increasingly astounding to watch how predictably the partisans memory wipe themselves about XYZ terrible thing that their side did. Now that the bad side - the side they're not on - is in power, they must protest that same XYZ thing.

It's said that Trump is terrible with journalists (he is). And there's Obama's quiet, terrifying war on journalists with the Espionage Act, that the partisans on that side almost entirely ignored.

Assisting in the destruction of Syria and Libya is a fine thing to ignore (one should perhaps get a nobel peace prize for it). Destroying Iraq is genocide and a war crime. Or vice versa, depending on which side you're on.

The sides just flip flop, memory wipe past misdeeds, and then resume the perpetual partisan war. I think it works to assist them in staying in power, maintaining the always conflict. Oceania is always at war with Eastasia.

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by germinalphrase on Friday March 23, 2018 @12:32PM (#16659812)
This is not a defense of the behavior - but it's been strongly asserted that Obama's crackdown on whistleblowers and journalists has more to do with improved abilities to track document access and sharing than it does the explicit desire to confront whistleblowers and journalists. All presidents have wanted to minimize whistleblowing and critical journalism, we just have better tools to understand just who, exactly, accessed that version of the 'secret prison memo' on Feb. 23.

The investigations are more successful so more leakers and whistleblowers get caught.

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by jessaustin on Friday March 23, 2018 @01:45PM (#16660670)
Yeah that sounds like everything else we've heard from NSA: "We can, so we will."
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by the-dude on Friday March 23, 2018 @11:08AM (#16658903)
> Assisting in the destruction of Syria and Libya is a fine thing to ignore

Will the US agression ever end? It is sickening.

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by apotheothesomai on Friday March 23, 2018 @10:34AM (#16658555)
Sure, it's just like that, because all that hacking of Democratic databases didn't happen.

I think the assumption that the wrongdoing was a conspiracy to get Trump elected gets far too much attention and is a secondary issue, but unlike the birther issue, there was quite a bit of funny business in general. The birther issue was just made up a priori.

The funny business, regardless of whether it benefited anyone, needs to be investigated. Once we understand what happened, then we can worry about whether it was an effort to swing the election or just a tactic for creating chaos.

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by rdiddly on Friday March 23, 2018 @10:27AM (#16658487)
...which is ironic, since due to that same polarization, Presidents in general seem to have less ability (or maybe it's inclination) than ever, to effect any meaningful change about anything that matters.

It doesn't matter who's President.

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by humanrebar on Friday March 23, 2018 @10:33AM (#16658543)
Arguably that's how the U.S. government was designed to function. The new (well, the recurring thing) is that Congress, White House, and even the judiciary get more political capital from inaction and blame than they get from cooperation.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by macintux on Friday March 23, 2018 @10:48AM (#16658687)
> It doesn't matter who's President.

It absolutely matters when something goes wrong outside our borders.

If, hypothetically speaking, a small NATO country on Russia's border devolves into chaos thanks to, say, a massive power grid failure combined with agitation from Russian nationalists, and Russia then intervenes to "stabilize" the situation, the temperament of the president and coherence of the White House as a whole would make a great deal of difference in how the crisis evolves.

Purely hypothetical, of course.

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by equalunique on Friday March 23, 2018 @11:53AM (#16659319)
Why does this sound like Ukraine
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by macintux on Friday March 23, 2018 @11:57AM (#16659366)
Ukraine is neither small nor NATO, but...yeah.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by jessaustin on Friday March 23, 2018 @01:51PM (#16660746)
Estonia are cool, but they know they need to stay on good terms with their neighbors. John McCain doesn't run things anymore.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by KirinDave on Friday March 23, 2018 @11:43AM (#16659219)
Maybe this was a reasonable stance if you were a hardliner skeptic.

But it's March 2018. 5 of Trump's senior campaign staff are indicted. Multiple Russian actors are indicted. The Russian government doesn't even deny it, Putin literally blamed Jewish people. CA's c staff was just on video talking about using human trafficking to compromise politicians and their CEO just disclosed that some state governments were cooperating with the Trump campaign.

All this is astride the long understood fact that American election security is so bad that there aren't reliable records to disprove a machine that's been tampered with. What's more, the we've also seen corroborated evidence that the machines election officials in some swing States we're compromised by sophisticated actors. These machines aren't just where emails happen, they're the machines where the software that configures the voting machines runs (for some models).

None of what I've said is even an uncharitable reading of the facts. The final statement might be surprising but it's well supported in security literature.

But sure, you be skeptical as a well-measured and coldly logical citizen.

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by jessaustin on Friday March 23, 2018 @11:48AM (#16659274)
All this is astride the long understood fact that American election security is so bad that there aren't reliable records to disprove a machine that's been tampered with.

In this context, is it curious that no one has signed on to co-sponsor the following bill?

https://congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/5147/tex...

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by dragonwriter on Friday March 23, 2018 @12:33PM (#16659827)
> In this context, is it curious that no one has signed on to co-sponsor the following bill?

No one has signed on to HR 5147 because everyone (84 members, all Democrats) who cares enough about election security to cosponsor a bill on it has instead signed on to cosponsor HR 5011 [0], which is a much broader election security bill; to the extent the specific requirements in HR 5147 are desirable and not address by HR 5011, they probably make more sense as an amendment to HR 5011.

[0] https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/5011...

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by jessaustin on Friday March 23, 2018 @01:06PM (#16660255)
Terms that don't appear in everyone's favorite bill: "voter-verified", "open-source" (not sure why Gabbard has that hyphen), "preservation". On the other hand, it does begin with "It is the sense of Congress that, in light of the lessons learned from Russian interference in the 2016 Presidential election..." so it ought to play well with the military-intelligence-enforcement-industrial-media complex. If Gabbard somehow got all those important things amended into this most favored bill, it would lose all its co-sponsors. Democrats and Republicans are like Coke and Pepsi. If we had actual democracy we might end up with something palatable.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by dragonwriter on Friday March 23, 2018 @01:16PM (#16660375)
> Terms that don't appear in everyone's favorite bill: "voter-verified", "open-source" (not sure why Gabbard has that hyphen), "preservation".

HR 5011, rather than trying to cobble together a bandaid over hackable electronic voting systems, has its central mitigation the voting system problem (it addresses more election infrastructure than just ballot-casting) incentives and grants to get rid of electronic voting altogether in favor of the proven system of voter-marked paper ballots. Voter-marked ballots that are the thing that is counted in the normal case is much better than voter-verified receipts that are selectively or conditionally used to audit counts, and open source is irrelevant when there is no software, and the idea that open source is somehow equivalent to secure has been refuted time and again.

Now, sure, it arguably [0] wouldn't be bad to add something like HR 5147s requirements for hold-outs that aren't going to abandon electronic voting into HR 5011, and that would be a very good debate to have when HR 5011 (or, more realistically, the similar bill introduced in the next Congress) is heard in committee.

[0] Arguably not, though, because that could encourage people to see electronic voting as safer than it is; maybe better would be to amend in a hard deadline requirement for abandoning electronic voting in favor of voter-marked paper ballots, a stick to go along with the grant-money carrot.

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by jessaustin on Friday March 23, 2018 @01:42PM (#16660647)
Gabbard's bill is also about paper ballots, only it says "shall require" rather than "here are some grants if you want them". Also, the popular bill says nothing about voter verification or ballot preservation, so it brings us back to Florida 2000 all over again. Love those hangin' chads!
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by KirinDave on Friday March 23, 2018 @11:52AM (#16659317)
People could kick up a big stink about it, but the reason it won't go anywhere is that Ryan can hold it in committee in perpetutity. , isn't it?

The voting machine observations aren't new. They're old, some dating back to Bush-era elections.

I think technological illiteracy and States refusing to replace costly machines represent the bulk of the opposition.

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by jessaustin on Friday March 23, 2018 @11:58AM (#16659390)
I thought they were trying to win back the House? One couldn't imagine a more evocative campaign issue, for independents suspicious of both parties like me. "We care about democracy and Paul Ryan doesn't! Tell Paul Ryan to restore trust to democracy!" OK, tell me that and I'll vote Democrat. Crickets.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by dragonwriter on Friday March 23, 2018 @12:37PM (#16659879)
> I thought they were trying to win back the House? One couldn't imagine a more evocative campaign issue, for independents suspicious of both parties like me. "We care about democracy and Paul Ryan doesn't! Tell Paul Ryan to restore trust to democracy!"

And that’s the electoral (as opposed to policy) side of why 84 of them are cosponsoring a much broader election security bill than Gabbard’s HR 5147 (and, to be clear, one that was introduced before Gabbard’s “me too” bill.)

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by KirinDave on Friday March 23, 2018 @12:03PM (#16659456)
You probably won't, but I'm not going to engage an obvious troll any further.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by jessaustin on Friday March 23, 2018 @12:20PM (#16659643)
Is it the fact that I like Gabbard, or the fact that I voted for Bernie, which earns me such a commendation from such a valiant defender of the status quo (war) machine?
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by tw04 on Friday March 23, 2018 @09:55AM (#16658128)
As evidenced by the gerrymandered districts intended to do things like sway presidential elections. Clearly the system is working as designed and not being cheated...
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by strictnein on Friday March 23, 2018 @10:01AM (#16658213)
How does one use gerrymandering to sway a presidential election?
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by macintux on Friday March 23, 2018 @10:51AM (#16658724)
Nothing in the short run, but I think an argument could be made that gerrymandering in the age when digital technology has enabled very precise calculations to be made has engendered a completely dysfunctional political system.

And that completely dysfunctional political system certainly played a role in the last election.

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by ixtli on Friday March 23, 2018 @09:57AM (#16658156)
That's kinda what I'm getting at: gerrymandering is the implementation. Our legislatures need to specify and clarify rules to stop those kind of abuses, but I don't think anyone is going to jail for gerrymandering a district. My point was simply that these are the rules of the game but people seem to believe someone is cheating.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by maxerickson on Friday March 23, 2018 @10:17AM (#16658373)
It's generally the legislators that are drawing the districts.

In Michigan there is a constitutional referendum coming up that will take that power away from them if it passes.

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by neuronexmachina on Friday March 23, 2018 @10:25AM (#16658456)
Gerrymandering sways House and state-level elections. It doesn't have a direct impact on Senate and Presidential elections.
Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by davvolun on Friday March 23, 2018 @12:24PM (#16659696)
NE-02 sent an electoral vote to Obama in 2008, whereas the other 4 NE votes went to McCain. In 2010, NE-02 was gerrymandered (arguably) and all 5 votes have gone to Romney (2012) and Trump (2016) since then.

Admittedly, that's sort of an exception that proves the rule. Only NE and ME don't operate under a winner-takes-all, they've so far only split their votes once each (2008 in NE and 2016 in ME), and their votes -- certainly splitting their votes -- has never impacted the result of a Presidential election.

Re:Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour by ordinaryradical on Friday March 23, 2018 @11:31AM (#16659122)
I find it strange you’re made uncomfortable by this as opposed to a president privately profiting off the White House, actively courting a foreign power for his own gain in the election, empowering his own family like banana republic dictator, wantonly obstructing the investigation like a petty child, and being surrounded by incompetents and shady characters who keep dropping like flies for actually breaking the law and getting caught for it.

If this were Nixon, wouldn’t it be an appropriate response to hope that all involved were caught?

If wanting to see this kind of criminality be ended is “salivating” call me Mr. Drooly.