One would hope that the courts interpret this to mean that the defendant knew that a specific act (e.g., accepting a specific ad) would facilitate a violation but still performed this act. (Or maybe the courts could simply declare the amendment void for vagueness.) Unfortunately it will probably take expensive lawsuits to resolve this.
>Because its guaranteed that services like gmail are used to facilitate sex trafficking.
Since 18 USC 1591(e) isn't limited to online services, one can even go further and show that a "knowledge in the abstract" standard would catch even electricity providers.
That's exactly what it means: the explicit intent of the change (as many of the people pushing it have stated) is to compel online providers to police content. (And there has been noise made that if they don't adequately step up active policing in other areas, this approach will be extended to other kinds of content.)
It is very clearly a move for safe harbor for user-submitted, not-actively-moderated content to a safe harbor only for user-submitted content where the host is actually completely ignorant.
Or is that explicitly disallowed by some other text in this statute or by some other law? For instance if Google made it absolutely impossible (e.g. w/ strong crypto) for them to "know" what's inside their users' emails, is there some law that could force Google to undo that (ostensibly in the name of national security or something like that)?
I feel like data platforms got themselves involved, the platform immunity excuse stopped holding, when they started doing their own content moderation to begin with. Once they decided to remove content they didn't like, were they not implicitly endorsing the content they left alone?
Historically this has been rather clear.
Take the Silk Road. Arguably just an eBay clone on the dark web, right? Except the proprietor specifically marketed it for the trade of drugs. There was no question about what its intended purpose was; he created it to sell drugs, internal documents show he knew drug trade was going on; by all accounts, he knowingly participated in the venture.
There was a small ISP somewhere in NY. Authorities notified them that they were hosting child porn provided by a customer. No biggie, right? Section 230 and all. Except they didn't take action to remove it, which put them in the camp of...knowingly participating in its possession/distribution. They got fined.
Backpage is in the same camp. They know what's going on, even contributing to it. They knowingly participate in the venture.
In this context, I can only speculate the language was added wrt the editing of specific ads. They weren't assisting in their publication, they weren't supporting their publication, but they did know what they were and made changes to...facilitate...those ads staying published and under the radar of authorities.
But I do see your point, and agree that it will likely be used for some unforeseen interpretation.
You just have to be a knowing “facilitator.” Toyota can’t deny that it “knows” that it’s cars are used to “facilitate” drug deals. It’s not a “participant” in those drug deals, but the whole point of this law is to get rid of the “participation” requirement.
What? When did that happen? Please, could you share some link?
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/10/corrupt-silk-roa...
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/06/secret-service-a...
https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/vv7dgj/great-mome...
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/nov/8/shaun-bridge...
[EDIT:] Scroll to the bottom of the Motherboard article, click on this exemplar of LEOs' name, and read more. Apparently there may have been another LEO ridin' dirty on this investigation, only we don't know who. All we know is that she or he modified all the digital evidence that was later used to convict Ulbricht. This is law enforcement, people.
I could posit a law that says all brown-haired people should be summarily executed. You could then correctly note that the law would have caught the Green River Killer, John Wayne Gacy, and Ted Bundy. That doesn't make it a good law.
I think that quote from the GP directly addresses your question.
I think that’s excessive, I don’t think services should have to moderate or police user generated content.
In law it is not about what you know, but about what you can prove. A person's belief system or fantastic truths are not evidence of a crime.
In your GMail example you have a reasonable faith that people may use the service to engage in communications in facilitation of a criminal enterprise. Your faith is irrelevant. You must have the email communications in hand along with a valid search warrant.
That isn't what most people are losing their minds over. People are losing their damn minds, according to wonderfully mature comments on the earlier news article at ArsTechnica, on two points:
1. This law is hostile to any legally valid sex business.
2. This law holds web site owners responsible for the content that appears on their site.
My opinion on those two:
1. Sex businesses whether legal or not are generally considered a social vice much like alcohol and tobacco. There are all manners of legal restrictions upon commercial communications generally, and particularly for services and products that are considered vices. They are heavily restricted in where they can advertise and any media that violates such laws can be held responsible. This has been a thing for decades, so it is only fitting that it should apply to sex businesses which are slowly creeping towards wider legalization.
2. Web publishers get all kinds of legal passes that publishers in other mediums don't get under the guise of third-party attribution. Web site owners should be liable for the content that appears on their site. This has been true somewhat from a civil perspective ever since Viacom slapped the shit out of YouTube in a multi-billion dollar law suit[1], but it hasn't been criminally true. This law cracks open the door for potential criminal violations, is panic for businesses that publish user contributions in order to monetize third-party advertising.
Speaking about web-site owners being held liable for the content on their site this reminds me of SOPA[2]. I know this made a lot of people cry (with really big tears), but is far more upsetting to social media companies. It isn't because of potential free speech restrictions or unnecessary regulation. It upset social media business, because it would have crushed their business model.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viacom_International_Inc._v._Y....
Here is the text: https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/1865...
The key is 18 U.S.C. 1591. That statute creates criminal liability for those who use force or coercion to cause someone to engage in a commercial sex act, or anyone who "benefits, financially or by receiving anything of value, from participation in a venture" to do so. 18 U.S.C. 1591(a)(2). So far so good. You can get the guy who runs the sex trafficking business, not just the grunt who uses the force.
The bill amends 18 USC 1591(e) to state: "The term ‘participation in a venture’ means knowingly assisting, supporting, or facilitating a violation" of the foregoing provision.
One, this is grammatical lunacy. "Participation in a venture" means what you think it means: people who participate with intent to further the criminal enterprise. The bill amends section 1591 to define "participation in a venture" quite differently from its plain meaning. It's like a law that says: "as herein used, 'green' means green as well as blue and purple."
Two, what the heck does "knowingly facilitate" mean? Is it enough to know that, in the abstract, your service is used to facilitate sex trafficking? Because its guaranteed that services like gmail are used to facilitate sex trafficking. You couldn't say otherwise with a straight face. Or do you have actually intend your service to facilitate sex trafficking (like backpage arguably was doing)? If that was the intention, the drafters really screwed up because "knowing" is a lower standard than "intent." You learn that in the first year of law school.