Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A...
by rayiner on Thursday March 22, 2018 @02:23PM
(#16651189)
“Knowingly participate” is the existing language. I agree it’s clear. “Knowingly facilitate” is the new language. That has a much broader meaning, especially when you’re talking about Internet services, which are designed to “facilitate” whatever the user wants to do.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A...
by incompatible on Thursday March 22, 2018 @05:47PM
(#16653022)
"Especially" Internet services, but the same argument would apply to offline services, like vehicle rentals or building roads. Presumably the law isn't intended to go that far.
Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A...
by jstarfish on Thursday March 22, 2018 @02:39PM
(#16651370)
I see your point, and I don't necessarily disagree, but for whatever facilitate does actually mean, you'd still have to be a knowing participant in the matter.
In this context, I can only speculate the language was added wrt the editing of specific ads. They weren't assisting in their publication, they weren't supporting their publication, but they did know what they were and made changes to...facilitate...those ads staying published and under the radar of authorities.
But I do see your point, and agree that it will likely be used for some unforeseen interpretation.
Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A...
by rayiner on Thursday March 22, 2018 @02:45PM
(#16651439)
You keep saying “participant.” The law basically removes the word “participation” by defining it to mean things other than what everyone would consider “participation.”
You just have to be a knowing “facilitator.” Toyota can’t deny that it “knows” that it’s cars are used to “facilitate” drug deals. It’s not a “participant” in those drug deals, but the whole point of this law is to get rid of the “participation” requirement.
Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A...
by ewrong on Thursday March 22, 2018 @04:01PM
(#16652173)
Surely there is still a distinction between knowing that people use your product to do bad things & knowing that specific people are doing specific bad things and continuing to allow it.
Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A...
by cft on Thursday March 22, 2018 @05:04PM
(#16652685)
The problem is that the cost to argue this legal distinction in a civil court could be in the $500,000 - $1,000,000 range. Fine for Facebook, deadly for your gaming or crypto forum provider.