News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by sweden on Sunday March 18, 2018 @02:50PM (#16613551)
Sensanionalist article. So Tesla makes sure to manually fix flaws in the parts of cars that are manufactured before using them. Sounds like every manufacturing line ever.

Is it an efficient manufacturing process? Probably not but I don't see how the end costumer should care about this. The problems in the manufacturing line are already well known and commented by Elon Musk. This is a company that have been mass producing cars for only 5 years, it's normal that they are still catching up with the process.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by kazen44 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @03:18PM (#16613713)
> This is a company that have been mass producing cars for only 5 years, it's normal that they are still catching up with the process.

this, getting a production line optimized can take years, especially if you are relatively new to the field and the company has little instituted knowledge at hand.

I know in Europe for instance, many plants that fabricate parts for the big three have been doing so since the early 50's, and thus have an amazing body of knowledge on what works and what doesn't in terms or producing high quality parts in high numbers. Tesla does not seem to really have this knowledge.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by foepys on Sunday March 18, 2018 @03:29PM (#16613779)
Tesla tried to buy that knowledge by aquiring German robotics specialist Grohmann. When the acquisition was complete, Tesla in classic startup fashion tried to pressure employees into overtime and to cut all obligations Grohmann had to other, mostly German, car manufacturers. This resulted in Grohmann's CEO leaving the company in protest and unions threatening strikes. I image quite a few top execs and engineers left with the CEO and went to VW, BMW, and Daimler. Even lower level employees leaving would be hard on Tesla as those people, despite "just" doing blue-collar work, are highly trained specialists.
Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by gmueckl on Sunday March 18, 2018 @04:52PM (#16614257)
The overtime claim csme up a whule ago already and back then I could not find a supporting source. There was a payment negotiation shortly after Grohmann was bought, but thay did not seem out of the ordinary, either. Remember that Grohmann is a German company operating under German law, which is very different from U.S. labor laws.
Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by SteveJS on Sunday March 18, 2018 @04:21PM (#16614095)
How much of this is transferable? Is this institutional manufacturing knowledge a gigantic amount of potential energy for tesla’s competition that will put them in lead for EVs? Or is it a friction keeping a competitive EV from a big car manufacturer eternally around the corner?

Is the rework something that is actually comparable to normal automotive manufacturing lines? Or is it highly specific to EVs? If it’s EV specific it seems reasonable to believe there is no relevant institutional knowledge existing at Tesla’s competitors.

I have no background here .. how would one best decide if this is evidence Tesla is behind on a solved problem it’s competitors know how to solve or ahead on an unsolved problem it’s conpetitors are also struggling with outside of the limelight?

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by Rebelgecko on Sunday March 18, 2018 @08:57PM (#16615461)
From what I've seen, it includes lots of non-EV specific things like:

door has huge gap on one side, rubs against frame on other side

panels not fitting together correctly

screwed up weather stripping application

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by simion314 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @03:38PM (#16613828)
Is Tesla using fresh people without experience? I imagine they would hire people with experience to setup the factories and the processes, it would be much more expensive to use people fresh from the school without experience.
Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by user5994461 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @04:07PM (#16614007)
Where do you find them? There aren't that many people with experience, in any field, and they are usually not in the right location.

Also, the ones with a job in a decent company will not leave to a worse company.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by kjksf on Sunday March 18, 2018 @04:27PM (#16614111)
Tesla has no problem hiring industry veterans.

If you spend a bit of time on Linkedin you'll find that many Tesla executives have spent 5-10 years at other car manufacterers.

To give you a start: a guy in charge Tesla semi spent 8 years at Daimler (https://www.linkedin.com/in/jeromeguillen/)

A guy in charge in Tesla's Fremont factory (https://www.linkedin.com/in/gilbert-passin-74a36117/) spent 17 years at Renault, Mack Trucks, Volvo and Toyota.

Given how rapidly is Tesla's stock rising I'm sure they are pretty attractive employer especially compared to the likes of convicted criminal organizations like Volkswagen.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by user5994461 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @05:01PM (#16614313)
Executives are the easiest people to identify and to hire. You select them from your major competitors and you throw a bunch of money at them. It's easier done than said.

Then you're gonna need hundreds of people to design and manufacture the cars, in specific locations. These positions are a lot harder to fill.

A general is useless without his army. An executive is useless without employees.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by simion314 on Monday March 19, 2018 @02:21AM (#16616468)
Say you need some air filters for a new Tesla model, you do not need to make them inside Tesla, usually you make some requirements then show them to a few companies that make air filters, this companies will respond with a design and with an offer and you chose the company you want to make the air filters for you.

So you could source most of the parts that are not Tesla specific, then the problem is managing the efficient transport of this parts, storing them, and the hard problem of assembling them, for this problems you will have to hire people with experience to setup this processes, build the assembly lines, handle QA, unfortunately for Tesla they can't be cheep with the experienced workers(even here in Romania experienced engineers are expensive and if you do not pay them enough they leave because they get offers all the time from the competitors)

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by oblio on Sunday March 18, 2018 @08:27PM (#16615352)
Criminal organization? Just like Microsoft, Ford, Google, Apple, Goldman Sachs and most Fortune 500 companies? Also, Volkwagen is the #1 car company in the world, I think they’ll manage to hire top execs with their €11 billion profit.

I don’t like Volkswagen that much, but your perspective is kind of skewed by the Musk Distortion Field, in my opinion :)

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by icegreentea2 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @04:57PM (#16614288)
Tesla (like SpaceX) provides unique incentives to experienced people in their relevant fields. Here's an opportunity to greenfield not just a product, but an entire system and process! In these fields dominated by large incumbent companies with lots of process, history, and yes, cruft in place, it can be hard to fulfill the itch of 'doing it from scratch, and doing it right'.

By the time the Model 3 preplanning should have been in place, it was obvious enough that Tesla is short term here to stay. You're talking about probably 2 years of job security. I feel like thats enough for many of the less risk adverse (who will probably those who are itching for greenfield) employees to consider leaving.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by user5994461 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @05:21PM (#16614426)
I am sorry but "2 years of job security" is a joke. That's the sort of shit that's sold by web companies in the valley.

Some of the guys I knew who are working as engineers in electronics, mechanical, software have more than a decade in the same company. That's in Europe and outside of the major tech hubs. They have the unions, unheard of in tech companies, and the accrued benefits with age.

They won't move to an unknown company just to disrupt some processes, but it doesn't matter because Tesla doesn't exist on this continent anyway.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by icegreentea2 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @05:26PM (#16614462)
Oh, I more or less agree with you. Like 2 years is basically useless, especially if the person has a family to consider.

I don't think that 2 years is enough to entice many people in the field, but I feel like it's enough to entice enough.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by user5994461 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @05:34PM (#16614514)
Well, it's the norm for a growing company to do with not enough employees, not enough experience and not enough resources. We can both agree on that.

I'm not sure where Tesla is recruiting but I don't think they have much footprint even in the USA. If so, they are certainly cut from the vast majority of the talent pool that compose their worldwide competitors.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by greglindahl on Monday March 19, 2018 @04:47AM (#16616927)
There are tons of engineers in the Valley who have families to consider and still swap jobs every 2 years.
Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by user5994461 on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:17PM (#16622091)
Because it's software development. The projects are super short and you can be out of a job every year. Automotive and aerospace have longer cycle. It takes years to ship anything.
Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by greglindahl on Monday March 19, 2018 @05:55PM (#16623585)
No, it's not just software development.

However, the main thing I was trying to comment on is that "especially if the person has a family to consider" doesn't play out the way the person I responded to thinks, with actual middle-aged Silicon Valley engineers, in my experience.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by icegreentea2 on Monday March 19, 2018 @06:44PM (#16624014)
I was saying it in the context of what Tesla has to offer to experienced automotive production engineers. Most of them are probably located nowhere near the Bay Area, making the move a bigger deal, especially for families.

Anyhow, my original claim was never that it was impossible for Tesla to get the right experienced people, just that what they had to offer was probably enough to get their hands on some of the right people, but not most.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by greglindahl on Monday March 19, 2018 @09:06PM (#16625021)
Ah. As my reply makes clear, I was only talking about people already living here. Obviously choosing to move to a place with a high cost of living and a modest amount of automotive engineering job choices is a whole 'nother kettle of fish for everyone, including those with families.
Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by simion314 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @04:37PM (#16614169)
You pay enough to get them, it would be more expensive to hire people without experience.
Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by Spooky23 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @07:02PM (#16615011)
The thing to be concerned about is that in going for the full vertical integration play, they have folks worried about things like lock buttons and door handle production.

It’s pretty obvious that the magic of Tesla is the battery and the in-car “avionics” and telemetry. For every $1 worrying about lock buttons, a dollar is lost to batteries and other, material things.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by avs733 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @10:05PM (#16615741)
and 'disruption' as a goal is why they get lost in those mistakes.
Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by skybrian on Sunday March 18, 2018 @03:19PM (#16613722)
How do you know this happens on every manufacturing line ever? I'm no expert, but it doesn't sound like something Toyota would do.
Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by swimfar on Sunday March 18, 2018 @04:33PM (#16614154)
I don't have any experience with Toyota. But it definitely happens at the German manufacturing plants I've been to. There is an established process for pulling a vehicle off the line and reworking it. Sometimes there are specific "backup" stations for a process that isn't yet proven to be reliable.

I mostly worked in getting new models and lines up though, so it may be something that nearly never happens after the first 5k-10k cars or so.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by refurb on Sunday March 18, 2018 @10:31PM (#16615833)
It less about a car needing rework and more about Tesla knowingly delivering cars with major issues to customers.

But as someone else mention on HN, they have a customer base that will accept it, so i can see why they do it.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by SteveGerencser on Sunday March 18, 2018 @03:36PM (#16613816)
No, it isn't. Generally, in mass production, there is an acceptable failure rate where x parts are simply binned because they fail a quality check. It's built into the process. I would assume that Tesla does not over the available overhead to simply toss parts that can be fixed to work rather than tossing them out.
Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by serf on Sunday March 18, 2018 @05:34PM (#16614515)
it's extraordinarily common on production lines with very high value items.

aerospace is a good example of such an industry.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by objclxt on Sunday March 18, 2018 @04:23PM (#16614103)
It's no more sensationalist than Tesla's own claims about how many Model 3s they could get off their production line, claims they have completely failed to hit.
Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by Someone on Sunday March 18, 2018 @05:57PM (#16614664)
I don’t think this article is about whether Tesla can make its customers happy, but about whether it can make so many customers happy that it can make its investors happy.

Extra work means higher per unit costs and, likely, lower production numbers, both of which would impact what the company is worth.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by lttlrck on Sunday March 18, 2018 @03:37PM (#16613825)
I imagine customers on the reservation list care about this very much. When will get their Model 3? Can they wait that long? If they wait will it have problems? Will it be out of date compared to what else is on offer at that point, with depreciated value?
Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by dragontamer on Sunday March 18, 2018 @04:14PM (#16614049)
> Sensanionalist article. So Tesla makes sure to manually fix flaws in the parts of cars that are manufactured before using them. Sounds like every manufacturing line ever.

What should our expectation of Tesla's manufacturing process be when the CEO makes tweets like this: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/881757617416056832 ???

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by kjksf on Sunday March 18, 2018 @04:33PM (#16614151)
How does Musk's ambitious goals relate to manufacturing quality?

He made similarly over-optimistic predictions about SpaceX. They were several years late with their rockets and yet SpaceX crushes competition today.

If you seek some objective measure of Tesla's engineering capabilities, maybe the fact that Model S was named best overall car 2 years in a row by Consumer Reports should be more pertinent that Musk's tweets (http://time.com/3721049/tesla-model-s-consumer-reports-car/).

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by dragontamer on Sunday March 18, 2018 @05:22PM (#16614431)
That's nice and all, but the investor is interested in whether or not a company makes money.

For a company like Tesla which is on the order of LOSING $1.8 Billion / year, the fact of the matter is that ramping up Model 3 production ASAP is incredibly important.

https://www.marketwatch.com/investing/stock/tsla/financials

Tesla's cash flow is in a poor state, and the company is relying upon hypothetical Model 3 shipments to carry them over. It doesn't matter how good a car is if they can't build it.

With that said, maybe a bank will sponsor them some debt, or maybe the investors will throw more money in another stock dilution. As long as the banks / investors are happy, Tesla isn't really at risk of going bankrupt. But with that said, its unlikely for the share price to increase or to issue a dividend.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by krrrh on Monday March 19, 2018 @07:15PM (#16624278)
Apparently 25% of Tesla’s cash on hand is reservation deposits for model 3 cars.
Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by jotm on Sunday March 18, 2018 @03:44PM (#16613867)
Another 10 years and it will be easy to see a pretty accurate rate of failure for Teslas. People can make up their minds then.

So far it seems to be average - for a mid-class sedan. The price is almost twice as high as it would be for an average ICE car in the same class, because you're paying for early adoption of EVs.

If the above comment on stock shorting and reputation war is true, then you can only trust actual drivers, not the news or even Tesla itself.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by mikeash on Sunday March 18, 2018 @03:56PM (#16613925)
Your comment seems to imply that more expensive cars are more reliable, which as far as I know is not true.
Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by Spooky23 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @07:13PM (#16615068)
Huh? An Accord or Camry is the benchmark for quality. Fancy cars are usually less reliable.

Teslas are like a Prius circa 2006. Mostly about projecting your eco-consciousness and hipness except it’s a luxury car.

GM and now Honda already beat them to an affordable midsize car, it just looks like a Chevy and is missing the hype. Nissan beat them to an economy EV.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by refurb on Sunday March 18, 2018 @10:33PM (#16615843)
There might some "eco-consciousness" going on, but it seems to me most Tesla buyers would fall into the car/tech geek category.

The car is viewed as so bleeding edge that it attracts a lot of these folks.

Re:Tesla employees say automaker produces flawed parts requi... by krrrh on Monday March 19, 2018 @07:16PM (#16624292)
...and Jauguar is months away from to shipping a strong competitor to the Model S in volume.