News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by lovich on Sunday March 18, 2018 @03:52AM (#16610897)
As a response to several people stating that free trade is better for everyone.

I've taken economics courses, I understand how free trade is better overall. However, those calculations only work when both sides follow the same rules. Once you have different groups of people with different values, whether it's the EU valuing privacy, China valuing domestic production, or the US valuing intellectual property, absloute free trade seems to break down.

You can't freely trade if you're using different units

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by whb07 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @12:17PM (#16612642)
No it never breaks down. Milton Friedman commented some 30 years back to the typical "we should have higher tariffs on steel, because its unfair that the japanese are subsidizing their exports".

His response? "Well that benefits the American consumer tremendously... we are sending them pieces of paper(dollar) and we are getting hard goods in return at a significant discount". If you think in in the absolute terms, wouldn't you want to trade a silly paper for steeel/cars/whatever?

Also, where does the Chinese go with these dollars? Definitely not the Chinese store, they take Yuan. How about Japan? Nope, they take Yen. So...who takes dollars? At some point they have to come back and spend it either directly(investing/purchasing american goods) or indirectly(trading dollars -> random currency) which then leads the other party holding dollars to go out and buy American goods.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by dahdum on Thursday March 22, 2018 @02:34PM (#16651318)
It breaks down when near monopoly is established, which is often the goal of these government subsidization programs.

Whether that is acceptable depends on your opinion on global interdependence and national security. If the USA is dependent on Chinese and Russian steel to survive, it’s that much harder to defend against provocation. See EU and Russian gas for a great example.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by whb07 on Thursday March 22, 2018 @06:11PM (#16653181)
ooh way late response! That is actually the opposite. Friedman also addressed that point. The case you are presenting is essentially "we shouldn't rely on foreign XYZ too much, we should have our own manufacturing".

Well sure we should have our own if its able to compete freely. But its never been the case that if we go to war with China, the Japanese/India/whomever couldn't start producing more steel and selling it to us. Sure it might be slightly more expensive but it wouldn't paint the picture that you are proposing. If anything MORE producers of steel would pop up willing to sell at a higher price. Crazy theres this thing called supply/demand.

As for the EU/Russian gas example, Russia isn't the biggest producer of gas in the world. According to wiki[0] its the U.S, there are other non-Russian actors in the top 10 list who I'm sure would be willing to provide gas at a higher price.

As to why you mentioned EU/Russia is that Russia so happens to have a nice giant pipeline ready to provide gas into the EU. Well...last I checked there were millions of barrels of oil being shipped globally by ship. Would you have to pay a bit more for energy ? Sure. Is national security critically dependent on Russia ?

No, because I guarantee you if Germany started paying $200/barrel of oil(or natural gas/whatever) all the oil ships around the world would reorient themselves to deliver to Germany. Crazy world called supply/demand. You now have near infinite suppliers.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_natural_g...

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by dahdum on Thursday March 22, 2018 @10:34PM (#16654640)
Given time industry would adapt, but the impact can be devastating in the short term. EU gas dependence was and still is a big factor in the annexation of Crimea and politics across the region.

The BBC reports that this dependence is still growing, further tying the hands of the EU against Russian aggression.

Now if Russia itself was just another western style free market democracy, dependence wouldn’t be such a national security risk.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by wallace_f on Sunday March 18, 2018 @08:16AM (#16611587)
Also an education in econ.

Unfortunately with econ, our tools are maths, stats, logic and reasoning. We can almost never do actual experiments, which is fundamentally necessary for science. In my opinion, an unpopular but correct description of the state of economics is that the best economists are the ones who are able to make the arguments which others value the most.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by bulatb on Sunday March 18, 2018 @01:46PM (#16613151)
Goodhart's law in action.
Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by marcosdumay on Sunday March 18, 2018 @11:55AM (#16612512)
The more diverse are the people trading, the better trade works for improving everybody's life.

Where it fails is when there are market failures. Like when you have a naturally the winner takes all dynamic, asymmetric information, and some shady government intervention.

And, of course, the communications market is full of all of those.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by Faark on Sunday March 18, 2018 @08:36AM (#16611659)
Isn't it still free trade having to comply with local regulation? As long as those regulations treats foreign companies/products the same as local ones, of cause.

Import taxes or valuing domestic production/owners are not, but i don't see a problem with requiring food not to contain toxic stuff, no matter what country it comes from.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by tracker1 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @08:25PM (#16615346)
Exactly... I'm in favor of free trade, but only when it's reciprocal. I'm also in favor of breaking down regional locks or limits in sales... if you as a company are allowed to produce in a cheaper country, then I should be able to buy/import at the price you sell in those countries.
Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by barry-cotter on Sunday March 18, 2018 @06:14AM (#16611217)
That’s not true and if you can believe that after taking several economics courses it speaks poorly of your teachers.

The main benefits of free trade are in specialisation. People specialise in what they’re good in and trade for other goods and services. Specialisation leads to greater efficiency, meaning you can do the same with less, or more with the same amount. Notice the complete lack of the words domestic production or intellectual property.

The case for free trade is that in the long run specialisation makes us richer. Units have nothing to do with it. Metric or imperial, services and goods are what they are.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by asdfaoeu on Sunday March 18, 2018 @06:45AM (#16611291)
He is admitting those benefits. His point is that with different tax rates and regulations the market is distorted and if anything imposing tariffs / revenue taxes is just equalising the market.

I don't think he's talking literally about units.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by barry-cotter on Sunday March 18, 2018 @06:59AM (#16611332)
If other people do stupid things you don’t have to do stupid things too. Market distortions, different tax rates and regulations do not change how returns to specialisation and gains from trade work.

Anti-dumping tariffs are stupid because it not notnto your benefit to punish people for giving you cheap stuff that should be expensive. Being able to have different tax rates is part of the power to tax, which is part of being sovereign. Equalising the market is a fool’s game. The market is what it is. If you want to help some people or groups by all means do it, but tariffs are a very inefficient way to do it. Transfer payments ftw!

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by danbruc on Sunday March 18, 2018 @08:41AM (#16611679)
Anti-dumping tariffs are stupid because it not notnto your benefit to punish people for giving you cheap stuff that should be expensive.

That is only true in a very simplistic model. If a country sells for example cheap subsidized steel you may lose your steel production capability because you are not able to compete with that price. But once you lost that capability it may become prohibitively expensive to regain it because the initial costs to rebuild the knowledge and infrastructure is going to be much higher than the marginal costs for an established industry and you would have to accept, at least to some extend, which ever price they ask for. The other country may also be able to offer a lower price due to externalities, for example exploitation of their workers or environmental destruction, and you may want to compensate for that.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by barry-cotter on Sunday March 18, 2018 @09:07AM (#16611772)
If you’re not able to compete with a price that’s the market saying you’d be better off doing something else with those resources. If you suspect that the price is due to subsidy, great, free money. If you want to maintain domestic production capacity subsidise it. If you want to reduce startup costs pay to mothball a plant. If you want to maintain expertise subsidise the salaries of citizens who go abroad to learn about or work in those industries.

As far as externalities go you certainly have a point but if you feel you have a right to tell other people and countries what to do, go ahead. I don’t think there’s any reason to stop anywhere between sovereignty and colonialism. Those positions are coherent, the ones in between aren’t.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by danbruc on Sunday March 18, 2018 @09:28AM (#16611828)
Well, it is not free money if I have to spend money to protect me against potential future negative outcomes of that free money. And where would the money come from to mothball a plant? Naturally that would be from anti-dumping taxes on the subsidized goods causing the issue, wouldn't it?

And I would almost never suggest to tell any other country what to do - even though I would consider that legitimate within the right framework because sovereignty is not an absolute right - but I certainly have no objections against and am actually for putting taxes on foreign goods if those were produced according to standards I do not agree with.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by barry-cotter on Sunday March 18, 2018 @10:04AM (#16611951)
The free money is the subsidy that is the reason usually avowed for anti-dumping tariffs. Choosing to mothball a plant is a choice, not something that automatically happens if some other country chooses to subsidise one of their industries.

Revenues and expenditures are both fungible. In the end one goes into the state’s coffers and the other goes out. In no sense worth mentioning would taxes from anti-dumping tariffs fund subsidising domestic production or mothballing a plant. The costs, benefits and consequences of tariffs, subsidies on domestic production and mothballing should be considered not as a unit but as three separate policies with no necessary relations. If one, two or three of them make sense by all means do them but the idea that one can fund the others is just a desire for retribution looking for a justification.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by danbruc on Sunday March 18, 2018 @10:44AM (#16612145)
The free money is the subsidy that is the reason usually avowed for anti-dumping tariffs. Choosing to mothball a plant is a choice, not something that automatically happens if some other country chooses to subsidise one of their industries.

Sure, in the general case, but I don't think we are debating the general case, at least I wasn't. If this other country just had a ton of useless money laying around and felt particular altruistic wanting to provide cheap steel to the entire world, nice of them. Also people would probably not be too worried about imposing tariffs.

But that is not really the case that people worry about, they worry about countries subsidizing goods to hurt or even destroy your industry and making you dependent on them even if prices rise above what you own industry was able to provide before. Unless you are willing to accept this or at least take the risk of this happening, you now have a link.

If the price difference is small enough, tariffs will equalize the difference and you might not actually collect that much money from them because buying from the local industry does not cost more. If the difference is large enough, you might decide to capture part of it with tariffs and use that to mothball your plants as protective measures and still profit from the additional difference.

Also note that I am assuming that production costs are comparable before any subsidies and that there are no other strategic interests for maintaining an industry locally which of course will change the equation again. Even if that other country can legitimately produce steel at a better price than you, say because it has a lot of easy to mine iron ore, you might still put a price sticker on becoming dependent on that country. If you consider the relation potentially unstable, then you might not want to put all your eggs in that basket.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by bobcostas55 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @08:44AM (#16611689)
> But once you lost that capability it may become prohibitively expensive to regain it because the initial costs to rebuild the knowledge and infrastructure is going to be much higher than the marginal costs for an established industry and you would have to accept, at least to some extend, which ever price they ask for.

This has literally never happened. People keep bringing up this objection, but nobody can point to a single instance of it ever happening. It's irrelevant.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by andosa on Sunday March 18, 2018 @09:02AM (#16611756)
How has it not ever happened? China, who essentially blocked Google, Amazon et al, now have Baidu, Alibaba, Tencent and other massively successful tech companies, while EU is stuck with aforementioned monopolies with near-zero chance of a local competitor competing with them.
Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by barry-cotter on Sunday March 18, 2018 @09:18AM (#16611805)
Google, Amazon, Microsoft etc. are still there. The US can still produce steel and computer chips. Other countries subsidising domestic production of software, steel and computer chips did not lead to the US being unable to do so.

And amazon is pretty big in China, taobao and jingdong are just bigger and better.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by andosa on Sunday March 18, 2018 @09:45AM (#16611888)
Yes, they are still there, but the protectionism is what allowed the local companies (Baidu, Tencent, Alibaba etc) to compete initially and be better in the end. Whereas in EU, local competition has been crushed and it is now stuck with the monopolies.
Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by barry-cotter on Sunday March 18, 2018 @10:14AM (#16611986)
Baidu is still not better than Google, even in Chinese, for what it’s worth.

Infant industry protection may make sense in some cases but it’s more commonly used as a smokescreen for corruption. It was used as a justification for high tariffs and low quality domestically produced goods all over the world throughout the 50s to at least the 80s.

If the EU doesn’t have much in the way of domestic IT companies so what? They’re still rich. The fact that others are getting rich in other, different ways does not make them poorer.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by dahdum on Thursday March 22, 2018 @02:38PM (#16651352)
It makes the EU asymmetrically dependent, which is not a good position in a competitive world.
Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by ameister14 on Sunday March 18, 2018 @10:55AM (#16612212)
It's happened multiple times. Companies attempting to reshore manufacturing have run into major problems with skilled labor and with modernizing lines and processes.
Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by cgag on Sunday March 18, 2018 @06:32AM (#16611259)
I notice that domestic production seems to be implicitly valued at zero which seems likely to be wrong to me.
Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by barry-cotter on Sunday March 18, 2018 @06:50AM (#16611302)
The case for free trade does not care about borders. It cares about consumption, which there will be more of if things can be produced most efficiently. Things can be produced most efficiently with maximum specialisation, which is likeliest with free trade. Domestic production can be consumed more easily than foreign production so it is more valued because transport costs are lower.

The border between San Francisco is as relevant as that between California and Nevada, or the US and Mexico.

There are certainly things where it’s good to have domestic production, vaccines for one. But the argument is grossly overused. The wool of angora goats is protected in the US as of military value.

Trading for what you need has worked out well for plenty of countries. Switzerland, Luxembourg, Costa Rica, Bahrain, Singapore, Hong Kong, my native Ireland.

Domestic production is overrated.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by andosa on Sunday March 18, 2018 @07:19AM (#16611405)
Overrating domestic value creation is how you end up being a third world country. I think you are oversimplifying free market dynamics. Free market doesn't magically create optimal results for consumers (see monopolies and the resulting lack of competition and suboptimal results for consumers as one example). Similarly it doesn't magically create optimal results for maximising the well being of a country.
Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by TheAdamAndChe on Sunday March 18, 2018 @07:43AM (#16611496)
> It cares about consumption, which there will be more of if things can be produced most efficiently.

This is part of the problem. Production doesn't occur in a vacuum, and the most efficient methods of production are often either terrible for the workers, terrible for the environment, or terrible for society.

Pure, unfettered globalization would be ideal if the goal was production and wealth generation maximization because it maximizes the labor pool and capital allocation efficiency, but those shouldn't be the only things that governments and economists worry about.

Re:Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan by barry-cotter on Sunday March 18, 2018 @08:45AM (#16611693)
If you look at where most of the world’s wealth is produced and how your worries may be allayed. The US and the EU are almost half of the world economy by themselves. Add Canada and Japanand you’re comfortably above half.

If there are problems caused by economic growth the products of said growth can buy solutions to them.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuznets_curve#Environmental_...