News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by tabeth on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:28PM (#16572917)
This is great for the winner, but how would you prevent collusion here? Suppose all winners of every lottery were anonymous -- how would you know the lotteries are even legit?

1. You might argue that auditors and other government officials would enforce integrity. However, it would be trivial to bribe them. In addition, without total transparency you couldn't have confidence in what they're saying, anyway. It's too easy for them to lie.

2. Perhaps the real winners name would be in some book somewhere, e.g. a tax log, but the real name is out of public sight. This would also be easy to rig. If it's anonymous what's stopping the lottery commission and state government from creating a fake winner?

3. Perhaps the biggest argument in favor of a pro-anonymous lottery is that you already can be anonymous by setting up a trust. This is true, but doesn't answer the question -- how do you know it's legit?

Maybe we should just cap the winnings at 10K, an amount that people wouldn't bug you so much for and change the odds such that the revenue the state gets is the same.

Then everyone wins, no? So, in this case, instead of a single winner of 580M you could've had 60 thousand people win 10K instead. Sounds pretty good. An amount high enough that you'd give it a shot for a buck, but not so high that you'd annoy them if they won.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by CGamesPlay on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:30PM (#16572923)
> 1. You might argue that auditors and other government officials would enforce integrity. However, it would be trivial to bribe them.

This seems like a very casual way to dismiss governmental integrity. Can't you apply this argument to any financial gain you could get from the government? e.g. "You might argue that auditors and other government officials would force people to pay taxes. However, it would be trivial to bribe them."

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by tabeth on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:33PM (#16572942)
Apologies for my cynicism, but given that this happens pretty frequently [1] I can't ignore the incentives when dealing with such large amounts of money.

[1] http://www.oregonlive.com/business/index.ssf/2018/02/tax_cre...

[2] http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/maryland/harford/aegis/ph-a...

[3] http://www.wjcl.com/article/chatham-area-transit-contractor-...

Transparency is a good way of preventing corruption. I don't have a citation off hand, but I'm pretty confident that this is true. I'll dig one up if you're curious.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by CGamesPlay on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:44PM (#16573558)
I still am not sure that "trivial" is the right level to rate the ability to bribe government officials is at. After all, each of those links points to a person charged or convicted of bribery, meaning that the people privy to the situation raised it with the authorities deliberately or through incompetence.

Thinking about what the collusion would look like here, I think faking the drawing (which is a well-publicized event) is more difficult than having a ticket printed after the numbers are drawn. In the latter case, who has to be "in on it" for it to succeed? It seems like an audit trail on each ticket would be sufficient, proving the time that it was purchased. It seems like this would require a lot of forged evidence in order to successfully pull off that scheme, and it doesn't require that the audit log be publicly disclosed.

Or at least, who is the winner of the lottery hidden from? Is it hidden from the IRS? Is it hidden from the disbursement department at the lottery? Is it hidden from the issuer of the original lottery ticket? These all represent groups of people who you would have to buy out in order to successfully collude.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by alsetmusic on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:23PM (#16573694)
> After all, each of those links points to a person charged or convicted of bribery, meaning that the people privy to the situation raised it with the authorities deliberately or through incompetence.

This logic is flawed. Any time you hear about someone getting caught, there are additional instances in which someone got away with it. You don’t read about a murderer getting caught and conclude that the problem of murder is not in effect.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by doorbumper on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @12:31AM (#16573876)
Trivial appears to be the right word. In the linked cases of bribery government officials were bribed for a hundred to hundreds of thousands of dollars. When public officials are bribed, they all tend to be in that ballpark. What happens when you can offer dozens of millions of dollars, or a hundred million or more to the right official? Most likely, no one would ever need to offer that high of a number.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by drawkbox on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:24PM (#16573480)
> This seems like a very casual way to dismiss governmental integrity.

Government is a group of humans, we know that human nature says probabilistically that anything with lots of value/gain that isn't regulated, measured or public/validated will probably be manipulated by a certain percentage of people for various reasons. When out of view and no chance to get caught, greed is a natural part of some people if not all.

Government and police for instance are composed of humans, and can easily be compromised if the price is right and it is easy to hide. Anything out of view and of value will be manipulated. If you say, Why why? tell 'em that it's human nature...

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by lotsofpulp on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:38PM (#16572971)
Yes, which is why we need a transparent government. The only way to win the fight against corruption is to shine a light on it.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by Bud on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:44PM (#16573001)
You need to read up a bit on recent history if you think there is any record of "integrity" in this field.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hot_Lotto_fraud_scandal

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by eli on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:34PM (#16572949)
I mean, isn't that why property tax assessments are public record most places?
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by vkou on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:56PM (#16573609)
Yet, income tax filings are not - at least in the United States. (A number of European countries function just fine with public tax records, though.)
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by acct1771 on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:39PM (#16572976)
...governmental integrity?

Very curious what nation you reside in.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by ralfn on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:53PM (#16573050)
In Dutch we have a saying: As is the inkeeper does he trust his guests.

I'm always surprised by this pattern of extreme paranoia. In most of the world lottery winners are anonymous, because people wouldn't even consider cheating with this sort of thing. It would just not come to their mind. Perhaps because we don't all default to immediately assume the worst of each other? Because that pattern of thinking makes it easier to morally justify when you screw some one over as well. If enough people think somebody would cheat like this, enough people would have the moral flexibility to cheat.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by refurb on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:05PM (#16573104)
Are you arguing lottery fraud is rare? Seems pretty common to me and not just in the US.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by HarryHirsch on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:42PM (#16573299)
How do you even rig the lottery? If the numbers are drawn the usual way (machine, spinning drum, balls) you'd have to use weighted balls, but of course the weights are checked before and after and the balls are in strict custody.

But in the US, where even the elections are computerized, anything is possible.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by DrScump on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @03:17AM (#16574334)
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by refurb on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @01:59PM (#16578195)
There was a recent one in Canada where the folks running the lottery were arranging for themselves or their friends to win.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by HarryHirsch on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @09:25PM (#16581492)
Google doesn't have anything pertinent, although there are plenty of cases of the fellow at the lotto counter stealing tickets. That's why you always, always sign the back of the ticket and keep copies.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by nerfhammer on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:54PM (#16573350)
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by Hnrobert42 on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:18PM (#16573457)
That link is not at all relevant to a lottery of balls drawn from a hopper.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by JaumeGreen on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @06:07AM (#16574879)
Rigging lottery is rare.

What is more common is to pay a winner more money for the ticket than the prize, to claim the prize for oneself, as a money laundering scheme. But this is not solved by removing anonymity, as it's hard to prove the scheme without the other person saying anything.

An probable example of this (in Spanish): http://www.levante-emv.com/comunitat-valenciana/2012/02/19/c...

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by thadk on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @12:38PM (#16577449)
See this investigative article from last week which lays out at least 8 or 10 people who figured out how to rig the lottery for certain types of games: http://highline.huffingtonpost.com/articles/en/lotto-winners...
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by robotsonic on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @03:54PM (#16579204)
They didn't rig the lottery, they figured out how to beat the odds. The former makes it sound like they colluded to change the game, when all they did was play by the rules, albeit in an extreme manner.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by mobilefriendly on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:33PM (#16572943)
This case is actually far more narrow in scope-- unlike most states, NH allows private trusts to receive the award, but the woman had already signed her real name to the ticket (the standard advice since the ticket is essentially a bearer bond). Most states don't allow a trust to claim the winnings. So this case is more about the spirit of NH law applying to her situation.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by jkaplowitz on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:42PM (#16573549)
Regarding your point #2: I'm pretty sure that even anonymous winners of lottery prizes are identified in some way to the applicable US / state / local tax authorities, when the prize is $600 or more.

For those sorts of prizes, US federal law requires the payor to collect a taxpayer identification number, to file an IRS Form W-2G with the federal government, and to furnish a copy of that form to the payee. Therefore they can ensure that taxes get paid on it.

Now, the payee on Form W-2G can be a trust or a legal entity - they get taxpayer identification numbers just like individuals do. But if the government doesn't see a tax return come through corresponding to a $560 million lottery jackpot, you can be sure the IRS will use all their investigative power, including the ability to pierce through the entity to the humans responsible for it, to track that down.

The main point of lotto anonymity is to hide from unwanted public harassment and invasions of privacy, not from paying taxes.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by dfrey on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:47PM (#16573024)
A $10K lottery is a horrible idea. Most people know that on average you will lose money by buying lottery tickets. What makes it worth playing (for some people) is the (very small) chance of winning fuck you money. If I win $10k, I would be excited and happy about it, but it's going to have very little long-term effect on my lifestyle.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by bluedino on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:58PM (#16573080)
People play 4-digit and 3-digit as well as the scratch offs that win $10k and smaller prizes
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by tabeth on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:59PM (#16573085)
I won't say that I thought about the numbers too much, so I'd agree that it's a "horrible" idea, however I want to point out a few things:

> Most people know that on average you will lose money

I don't think most people know this. Perhaps you do. Perhaps most of us here on HN know, but I strongly doubt most people who play do, given that most people who play are poor [1].

> What makes it worth playing...

This isn't true either. Most people who play play it for the smaller winners [1].

Finally, I just want to reiterate that the point of this is exactly what you mentioned. By making the amount small enough such that it wouldn't have a huge effect on your lifestyle, you make it safer to disclose who won.

[1] https://www.vox.com/identities/2016/1/13/10763268/lottery-po...

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by jcranmer on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @12:24AM (#16573867)
I suspect that many of the people who play the lottery don't view money as having a strictly linear value. Spending a dollar a day on lottery tickets is a cost that is easy to absorb (think of how many people think nothing of buying a cup of coffee from Starbucks every day). Winning the lottery means getting a relatively large infusion of cash at once, at that infusion has a higher value to power people than the loss of a small amount of money.

Put another way, as a one-time deal, would you consider spending $1 for a 1-in-a-million chance to win $100,000? For many people, that isn't a totally unreasonable bargain. But if I ask you that 10,000 times, the cost becomes spending $10,000 for a 1-in-100 chance to win $100,000. That's the real problem with the predatory nature of the lottery.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by lwansbrough on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:42PM (#16573302)
> I don't think most people know this.

You don't think most people know they're gambling when they buy a lottery ticket?

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by adventured on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:25PM (#16573488)
I grew up around some businesses that sold various lottery products. I'm not trying to sound mean or dismissive at all when I say this, just strictly matter of fact: I talked to a large and incredible variety of idiots and uneducated people that bought lottery tickets, whether scratch-offs or traditional Powerball type. They all universally knew the odds were bad. Universally.

They also figured that for a few dollars - which most of them could easily afford here and there - those were the best odds they were ever going to have.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by jstarfish on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @01:59PM (#16578196)
I concur with this, and also add that the smaller winnings accrued along the way adds to their sense of validation.

They spend $1000 on tickets, and the day where their next $5 ends up winning them $100 on a scratch-off makes it all worth it.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @04:55PM (#16588217)
You don't think that the people who play the lottery every day but only win an occasional $20 or so realize they're losing money?

Most lottery ticket buyers may be low income, but that doesn't mean they're stupid.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by fred_is_fred on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:41PM (#16573747)
One counter example is that knowing names didn't stop collusion in the past - in 2016 someone was arrested for setting up their brother to win:

http://www.businessinsider.com/ap-lottery-insiders-brother-a...

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by mikeash on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:59PM (#16573084)
One potential solution is to have an independent third party verify that the winner is legitimate and not linked to the lottery agency. The judge is essentially playing that role here.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by Klathmon on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:09PM (#16573418)
I think the commenters point is that with even a few tens of millions of dollars you could buy any 3rd party off.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by DaiPlusPlus on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:09PM (#16573652)
The identity of the auditors would be public information and they would be under a lot of scrutiny. They would have to go through a lot of trouble to launder any bribe money they received. What use is a few million dollars if you can only spend it as petty cash?
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by mikeash on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:12PM (#16573659)
Judges being a great example. There are huge incentives to influence them, but they’re generally pretty hard to buy off.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by noir_lord on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @01:32PM (#16577906)
And the penalties for doing so are draconian and applied by a different judge and historically judges frown on attempts to subvert the judiciary.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by technofiend on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @01:54PM (#16578140)
>This is great for the winner, but how would you prevent collusion here?

Well the implication here is by publishing the person's name you have a public / crowdsourced validation process, right? But how do you prevent collusion and abuse by the general public if they're really part of the validation process? Both have the same solution - you need trusted parties to validate the process, people who were themselves validated and vetted to do the work. Isn't that already in place? I believe so.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by sschueller on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @04:35AM (#16574561)
You don't need the name of the winner. You need to verify the drawing is not rigged, the machines printing the ticket etc. But who in the end has the ticket is irrelevant.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by jack9 on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:52PM (#16573337)
> a tax log, but the real name is out of public sight

of course all of the money is tracked by the IRS and state.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by dnautics on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @09:22AM (#16575864)
Don't let the winners keep private, but put a label on the ticket saying in big letters that you can't keep your winning the lottery private.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by intopieces on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @11:57AM (#16577153)
The solution is even simpler: abolish lotteries altogether. They are a tax on the poor and a fraud on the taxpayers.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by iratewizard on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @01:40PM (#16577995)
Easy in theory, but you can't just abolish the gambler's mentality. Cunning people with a loose moral compass will find a way.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by intopieces on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @04:30PM (#16579507)
The government ought not be sanctioning it by saying things like "the money that we get goes towards schools" (https://www.texastribune.org/2017/07/07/hey-texplainer-does-...).
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by joeblow9999 on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @10:24PM (#16581781)
Indeed. This is indeed a scam. Well maybe not a scam but at least a prevarication. Government of all entities should not be engaging in tricks like this.

All the monies are fungible. "This money goes to schools, this money goes to road" is a farce.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by joeblow9999 on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @10:25PM (#16581786)
Just because you don't want to take that risk doesn't mean others shouldn't be allowed to do so.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by stonemetal on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:45PM (#16573010)
What do you see as the difference between a trust and the person as far as transparency goes?
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by tabeth on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:01PM (#16573089)
A trust is obviously less transparent, but marginally preferable to full anonymity.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by txsh on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:29PM (#16573715)
What makes you believe any lottery is legit even when we are given names?
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by dpweb on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:04PM (#16573097)
Blockchain?

- Public source code program used to pick a random winner among public keys.

- Private key holder has access to the winnings.

- Govt takes their taxes before disbursing the funds.

- Everyone can verify funds were disbursed.

- Winner can stay anonymous.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by tomcatfish on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:09PM (#16573122)
Verifying disbursement doesn't verify the program run actually picked a fair winner. The parts left out of your bullet points are what the other posters are discussing.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by Simon_says on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:16PM (#16573166)
That's a strange criticism. Once everything is online, there are verifiably fair ways to pick a winner at random.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by DaiPlusPlus on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:12PM (#16573657)
How? PRNGs come to mind, but they need a true random seed - something like a lava-lamp, but who controls the lava-lamp?

Doesn’t a distributed, transparent system naturally lead to a deterministic system?

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by Simon_says on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @01:01AM (#16573952)
Here's how to do it: Let's say there are N parties who want to generate a random number between 0 and M-1. None of the N parties trust each other. Each party individually generates a random number r_1, r_2, ..., r_N and keeps it a secret. Each party generates a hash of this number plus a suitably large salt. These hashes are publicly announced so that everybody can see everybody else's hash. After this, the original random numbers r_1, ..., r_N are published. Add them together modulo M to get R, the resulting random number. All it takes is a single party to randomly generate their number to ensure that the result is random. For extra shits and giggles you can add in a Bitcoin block hash (provided that it's in an appropriate range in order to avoid bias).
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by solatic on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @06:32AM (#16574993)
Have a public drawing based on physical randomness, which is then videoed and broadcasted.

For example, a ball bouncing around a chamber, where the floor of the chamber is divided between contact pads representing different digits. Each time a ball bounces off a contact pad, add that pad's digit to a list, after X bounces concatenate the list to a seed value.

In a perfect world, with a perfect launching mechanism, you may be able to predetermine which pads the ball will land on and thus guess the seed value ahead of time. But the world isn't perfect. Just give the ball to a four year old who doesn't understand the meaning or consequences of the ball launch, and let the kid throw it into the box.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by gibybo on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @12:04AM (#16573824)
You can just use the last x bits of hashes for the last y blocks to generate a random number.
Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by fgonzag on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @12:46AM (#16573913)
If you have the seed and the algorithm for the PRNG before the random number is drawn, then anyone can calculate it and pick the number.

The seed would have to be picked as the number is drawn if the system is public.

Re:$560M Powerball Winner Can Keep Her Name Private, Judge R... by gibybo on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @04:05AM (#16574466)
You would commit your guess in a block prior to the random bits being determined.

This is actually a popular scheme used by a lot of 'provably fair' gambling sites/smart contracts.