News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by bhouston on Friday March 09, 2018 @02:16PM (#16554119)
He was so obnoxious that I guess it is easy to be happy about that, but he was so small time in the grand scheme of things.

But nearly no bankers responsible for the 2008 financial crisis ever went to jail:

https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/09/how-wal...

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by birken on Friday March 09, 2018 @03:35PM (#16554774)
Like it or hate it, this is what the SEC does. You think Martha Stewart deserved jail time for making 50k in an insider trading scheme she didn't really care about?

The SEC finds very public cases and then brings the hammer down in order to act a deterrent. Martin Shkreli broke the law, something he didn't have to do. It isn't like it was mob justice and some hugely biased jury convicted him of all the crimes he was committed of without thought. The jury by all accounts fairly deliberated his actions and convicted him of crimes that he did, while letting him off for crimes he didn't do.

Then all Shkreli had to do was show some remorese and kiss the ring a little bit, but he continued to be a troll and mock the justice system. He downplayed his crimes literally minutes after being convicted of them, which showed a lack of remorse (and maybe honestly so, but the justice system doesn't like that). He continued to be a troll, including the whole Hillary Clinton incident, many of these statements used against him in sentencing.

This isn't a case of the tall blades of grass getting cut first. It's a case where we have a subjective justice system that doesn't want to be mocked while it is doing it's job. Shkreli went out of his way to mock it, he went out of his way to mock the SEC, all the while he actually did commit a crime. Yes, it is a witch hunt in that the SEC will throw the book at some people while letting other people who committed worse crimes off the hook (Phil Mickelson vs Martha Stewart), but that how any limited investigative body works. If you don't want to be a target of a witch hunt, don't break the law. And if you do, kiss the ring. I'm not convinced it is a huge indictment of our society that people who break the law all the while trolling everybody get unfairly harsh punishments, though I admit it is unfair in the sense that life as a whole is unfair.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by danso on Friday March 09, 2018 @03:51PM (#16554921)
Well put. Just because O.J. was found not guilty and no big bankers went to jail in 2008 doesn't mean judges in other courtrooms are going to relax their standards when you flip them off

https://www.nbcmiami.com/news/local/Penelope-Soto-Woman-Who-...

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by wils1245 on Friday March 09, 2018 @09:07PM (#16556698)
OJ is an interesting example, as his sentence for armed robbery was considered extreme compared to the facts of his case, and influenced by the fact he away with murder.

I think it’s troubling that judges have the ability to hand down sentences far above some established norm, even if those sentences are legal.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by DanBC on Saturday March 10, 2018 @04:25AM (#16557834)
> I think it’s troubling that judges have the ability to hand down sentences far above some established norm

I agree, but that's not what happened in Shkreli's case. The crime he committed really does have a very long sentence.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by s73v3r_ on Friday March 09, 2018 @03:46PM (#16554877)
The SEC, DOJ, et al also have limited amounts of resources. They just can't go after everyone.
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by presidentender on Friday March 09, 2018 @04:54PM (#16555367)
The fact that they can't go after everyone doesn't mean that they should punish Shkreli extra hard for what amounts to being a jerk.
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by s73v3r_ on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:14PM (#16556218)
No, but the fact that Shkreli is a jerk, and showed no remorse for what he did, and disrespected the court mean that they shouldn't go easy on him, either.
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by candiodari on Saturday March 10, 2018 @03:31AM (#16557701)
One would assume however, that given the choice between

1) guy who lied to investors, still made them money (ie. Shkreli)

2) guy who lied to investors, lost 90% of their money (for example, ironically, Clinton's son in law [2], who has lost more money than the GDP of about 70 countries, and yet [3] happened)

They would have a strong preference for 2). But the SEC is a HUGE example of selective justice. Harsh "correct" treatment for whomever offends the elite, just for insulting and rejecting them (Shkreli IS an idiot, VERY publicly rejecting and insulting one of the elites WHILE she was running an election for president AND giving her an excuse ("threatening her") to send the law after him), or just by being poor. But nothing ever gets done about members of the elite, even if they're very low level.

And I get it, what Mr. Mezvinsky did was probably in a panic, and it was political decisions of someone else that did him in, nothing he could have done (as I'm sure is true for 90%+ of criminals of course, it never seems to count as an excuse). And it did do serious damage to his career. But he should be in prison, and owe hundreds of millions of dollars to people.

The issue I have with that is, if you or I, or probably anyone who may read this did what he did, we'd be locked in a maximum security prison for 40+ years, as well as being destitute.

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marc_Mezvinsky

[3] https://www.recode.net/2017/5/18/15660060/social-capital-hir...

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by detaro on Saturday March 10, 2018 @08:40AM (#16558429)
[2] and the links going from it don't suggest anything about "lying to investors", merely making bad bets in Greece shortly before the crisis, in a fund that was advertised as making bets in Greece. Got a source about that, or is the argument just that everyone loosing a lot of money has to be fraudulent?
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by refurb on Friday March 09, 2018 @06:26PM (#16555986)
It's pretty common for defendants who show remorse to get lighter sentences, no?
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by AFNobody on Friday March 09, 2018 @05:04PM (#16555423)
It does actually.

If you waste their time by trolling them and drawing excessive attention, it consumes their resources responding to comments from the media. Instead of y'know, performing their investigatory/judicial functions.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by psyc on Friday March 09, 2018 @09:59PM (#16556849)
Parent said should. This is not how law works, so it’s not how its enforcement should work.
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by charlysl on Saturday March 10, 2018 @12:18AM (#16557217)
They have limited resources precisely so that they can't go after everyone.

Add revolving doors to this and everything makes sense.

On top of this, Shkreli brought a seedy but commonplace practice in the mighty pharma industry to the front page during a presidential campaign and made powerful enemies, including public opinion.

He wasn't sentenced for that, just like Al Capone wasn't sentenced for gangsterism.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by gameswithgo on Friday March 09, 2018 @05:11PM (#16555459)
> I'm not convinced it is a huge indictment of our society

The indictment of our society is that hundreds of millionaires can enrich themselves further via dishonest and illegal means, wreck world economies, and suffer no consequences, while a regular joe can be chocked to death for selling cigarettes on the street (disruptive!)

This isn't an impossible problem to fix. We just start voting for politicians willing to execute white collar criminals.

[dead]
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by sctb on Friday March 09, 2018 @06:34PM (#16556046)
This kind of thing is a bannable offense on Hacker News, so could you please comment civilly and substantively instead?

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by mdpopescu on Saturday March 10, 2018 @02:41AM (#16557587)
> Then all Shkreli had to do was (...) kiss the ring a little bit

An American writes this and doesn't shriek in anger. 2018.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by stale2002 on Friday March 09, 2018 @04:16PM (#16555118)
So what you are saying is that he had his sentance increased because he hurt a judge's feelings?

That's basically what this comes down to.

Imagine if jay walking was punishable by death but it was only ever enforced against people who mocked Trump.

Inconsistent enforcement just allows the people in power to go after their political oponents for the "real" crime of hurting their feelings.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by danso on Friday March 09, 2018 @04:48PM (#16555329)
> That's basically what this comes down to.

The judge didn't create the law regarding securities fraud, nor did she instigate the charges of fraud, nor did she even have a voice when it came to deciding to convict (it was a jury trial). So how does this all boil down to a judge's feelings being hurt?

All crimes will be inconsistently enforced until we've built a policing apparatus that operates like the equivalent of red-light cameras but for every crime [0]. Hopefully we never get to that point, which means enforcement will continue to be resource-limited and inconsistent, so are you arguing for no enforcement at all?

[0] I'm being rhetorical of course. I don't mean to suggest at all that the enforcement of red-light violations, even when caught on camera, is anywhere near consistent: http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/watchdog/redlight/ct-met-...

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by daxorid on Friday March 09, 2018 @05:27PM (#16555575)
> So how does this all boil down to a judge's feelings being hurt?

The way I read the parent is that this conviction would almost certainly not merit seven years in a typical non-Shkreli case.

But the judge handed down seven years, not because of his crime, but because of his attitude. The OP even suggested as much, suggesting if he had just "kissed the ring", the sentence would have been substantially less.

I read the parent's outrage as being that justice isn't blind - it metes out sentences based on the feelings of a judge toward a defendant's attitude. The crime itself only matters insofar as judges must abide by minimum and maximum sentencing guidelines. Within those guidelines, how you feel about a defendant is fair game.

edit: I would also add that, for those of us with less than stellar social skills, it's easy for social incompetence to be misinterpreted by other people as being an asshole. For us, this aspect of the justice system is at least mildly worrying.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by danso on Friday March 09, 2018 @06:54PM (#16556133)
Why don’t we approach his sentence from the opposite direction: the prosecution proposed a 15-year sentence, which is less than a reported max of ~25 years under federal guidelines. 7 years is a fraction of what Shkreli could face, so why don’t we accuse her of being emotionally swayed to be lenient?

I agree that feelings are inextricably involved when human judges and juries make decisions. And all initiatives to correct for this — such as the 3-strikes law and mandatory sentencing guidelines — are likewise imperfect. I’m personally surprised at the severity of Shkreli’s sentence, but that’s because I don’t know this area of law or its precedent. And in the arguments I’ve seen asserting the sentence is too severe, I haven’t seen citations and evidence that contradict the precedent she used in her judgment.

Yes, much of Shkreli’s situation has no precedent. But we should consider that judges can act cautiously in extremely publicized trials, especially ones involving defendants who are rich enough to mount an appeal. You think the judge faces no risk if she decides to draw up a sentence without defensible legal basis?

I agree that we should worry if justice is meted out by judges who aren’t aware or empathetic toward defendants who are socially incompetent or otherwise social/psychological outliers. But just because popular media/opinion seems to hate Shkreli doesn’t necessarily mean we can ascribe such bias to the judge without empirical evidence.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by ameister14 on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:01PM (#16556162)
>Why don’t we approach his sentence from the opposite direction: the prosecution proposed a 15-year sentence, which is less than a reported max of ~25 years under federal guidelines. 7 years is a fraction of what Shkreli could face, so why don’t we accuse her of being emotionally swayed to be lenient?

Because other, similar cases seem to have lesser sentences, not greater. This case has a larger sentence compared to other actual practical cases, though clearly it wasn't as large as it could legally have been.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by danso on Friday March 09, 2018 @08:16PM (#16556525)
I’m ready to be convinced, but which similar cases are we talking about?
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by daxorid on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:03PM (#16556168)
Thank you for this response. I'm genuinely curious about this, though:

> You think the judge faces no risk if she decides to draw up a sentence without defensible legal basis?

What are the risks that judges face? My understanding is that Federal judges are appointed for life, with no chance of removal outside of impeachment. Is this not the case?

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by danso on Friday March 09, 2018 @08:27PM (#16556563)
I didn’t mean to imply an obvious direct risk (e.g. impeachment or being voted out), but I do assume the judge is not completely uninterested in moving up the federal circuit. Being called out, or having a decision overturned due to impropriety, on a very famous case, may not be necessarily nothing to the judge. Of course it works both ways — a too lenient sentence puts her under scrutiny too. But I think burden of proof is on those who think she is being too harsh when it specifically comes to Shkreli.
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by mwfunk on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:34PM (#16556333)
That's not at all what's being said. There are far more possible cases that could be prosecuted than there are resources to prosecute them, so to better discourage all crime they will tend to go after higher profile targets, in particular those who flaunt their criminality.

Similarly, cops don't spend all their time giving out tickets to every single jaywalker or every single speeder. That would be a waste of their time. But they need to give out some tickets every once in a while or else the law becomes meaningless. Given a choice between giving a ticket to a random person spotted jaywalking, vs. giving a ticket to someone who took out a full page ad the day before declaring the time and place in which they plan to jaywalk and taunting the police for being unable to do anything about it, the police will choose to give the ticket to the latter person, and that totally makes sense to me.

That's very different from going after socially awkward people who don't know when they're being assholes.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by mdpopescu on Saturday March 10, 2018 @02:55AM (#16557625)
> But they need to give out some tickets every once in a while or else the law becomes meaningless.

This has actually been shown to be a very bad idea. It is way better to punish immediately, even if lightly, every single transgression than to do it randomly but more severely. (Probably because we're all thinking "it won't happen to me".)

What you're saying afterwards is "the mundanes should not taunt their rulers". True in the world-as-is, but that reinforces a caste system. No. The cops and the judges are NOT nobility. They should NOT be treated as superior to the little people.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by danso on Saturday March 10, 2018 @08:25AM (#16558394)
Shkreli is one of the “little people”?
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by jkaplowitz on Friday March 09, 2018 @06:49PM (#16556115)
In the US federal justice system, the US Sentencing Guidelines are officially advisory as of several years ago. Judges have to consult them and are expected to explain any deviation they adopt, but they can impose any sentence allowed by the statute which was violated.

I guess the statute text has embedded minimum and maximum sentencing guidelines in a sense, but the term Sentencing Guidelines in the US federal judicial context means something specific.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by kbenson on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:29PM (#16556294)
The interesting thing about this casae, if I recall the facts correctly (I'm sure someone will fact check this, I'll attempt to and update this in a bit), is that in this case the breaking of the law was mostly an attempt to make sure his investors were left whole.

Here's the facts as I understand them:

1) He ran a hedge fund, and lost a lot of money.

2) He didn't disclose to his investors that he lost the money, and falsified reports.

3) In an effort to make sure people didn't lose money (whether to protect himself or to make sure his investors were made whole) he took profits from another company he ran and used them to pay these investors.

4) Almost all investors in the hedge fund ended up making a profit because of this.

It's fairly easy to interpret this as someone that screwed up bad, and then broke the law to cover it up and try to make it right, and by lucky happenstance was actually able to get people's money back, but still ended up breaking the law. That's a fairly good story to have, and I would think lends itself towards a mitigated sentence.

On the other hand, he repeatedly presented himself in an unsympathetic way that antagonized the judge and the regulatory bodies involved.

It is, to put it mildly, a fairly complex and (to my layman eyes) unique situation, compounded by the fact that his behavior may or may not have to do with being socially inept (is it right to punish someone for a social disability, if that is indeed the case here?)

There was a discussion about this when the guilty verdict was announced[1]. Much of my info comes from that article and this other one[1] from the same time period.

1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14931004

2: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/04/business/dealbook/martin-...

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by loggedinmyphone on Saturday March 10, 2018 @01:05AM (#16557348)
Punishment seldom if ever fits the crime. There's a strong case that punishment exists to give society a chance for collective catharsis. Otherwise it makes little sense to imprison someone for 7 years. If they can be rehabilitated then do so; if they need to be removed from society permanently then do that. Public ostentatious punishment is really a form of vicarious group sadism directed at the unpopular.
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by adventured on Friday March 09, 2018 @04:47PM (#16555326)
> But nearly no bankers responsible for the 2008 financial crisis ever went to jail

That is a myth. Dozens of bankers were arrested and put in prison over crimes related to the 2008 financial crisis. That includes a number of bankers at large enterprises. It excludes the very top tier bankers, at the systemically important financial firms, who all managed to skate.

It's not illegal, generally speaking, to make dumb investment decisions, and or to take a lot of risk, and lose money. The responsibility for the 2008 financial crisis is spread across both the public and private sector, from Congress & multiple Presidents to the Federal Reserve to hundreds of banks, thousands of bankers, and tens of thousands of mortgage brokers and realtors. Spurred on by low interest rates, it was collective financial insanity that millions of people willfully, cheerfully, participated in.

"The idea that no bankers went to prison for crimes related to the financial crisis is a myth, according to the watchdog overseeing the federal government's bailout fund. There have been 35 bankers sentenced to prison, said Christy Goldsmith Romero, the special inspector general for the Troubled Assets Relief Program (SIGTARP), in a report to Congress released Thursday."

"There have been 59 bankers convicted of crimes, including two executives at NOVA Bank in Philadelphia who were convicted on Wednesday of fraud conspiracy related to TARP funds. An additional 19 bankers have been charged with crimes, with many awaiting trials."

http://money.cnn.com/2016/04/28/news/companies/bankers-priso...

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by jogjayr on Friday March 09, 2018 @09:22PM (#16556740)
I'm no expert on the financial crisis, most of my knowledge comes from The Big Short. But wasn't there actual fraud also being perpetrated? E.g. the ratings agencies that knowingly assigned A grades to bundles of decidedly low-grade debt just to keep clients happy?
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by solatic on Saturday March 10, 2018 @02:40AM (#16557584)
The agencies' ratings are essentially protected by the First Amendment, as the rating represents the agency's opinion on whichever security offering.

Fraud isn't purchasing a house that's advertised as "clean" only to discover that there was asbestos in the basement. Fraud is advertising as such after a legal definition for the word "clean" has been established to include "asbestos-free" and yet the house has asbestos anyway.

There aren't any strict legal definitions for what "BB" and "BBB" and "A" and etc. mean, and that's why the ratings agencies could rate them as AAA, because the subjective expectation (as unfounded as it was) was for the housing market to keep booming forever, which was enough to slap a AAA rating without it being fraudulent.

(note I'm not trying to excuse or justify the ratings agencies behavior, only to explain)

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by acornax on Saturday March 10, 2018 @03:18AM (#16557674)
It's a bit more complicated too - rather than the AAA ratings being completed unfounded, they often seemed to have justification (at least on the surface), as various kinds of CDOs were typically packaged with insurance baked in, to make them appear less risky to the ratings agencies' models. One big problem ended up being that a lot of those insurance payouts were theoretical, as the entity on the other end (often ultimately AIG) didn't have have the money to pay out when so many mortgages were defaulting.

But, yeah. The agencies didn't really have much incentive to be skeptical of their models.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by daxorid on Friday March 09, 2018 @06:25PM (#16555978)
Yes, some small-time traders were put away. The odd CEO or CFO of a bank that's decidedly not TBTF. The poor shmuck who gambled outside his capital allowances with house money.

But if you are Jon Corzine - well, you can abscond with $1.2B of your customers' money, tell Congress you just don't know where it went, and then pay $5MM to avoid an embarrassing and inconvenient trial, all the while throwing that sucker Edie O'Brien under the bus for being dumb enough to miss that "getaway" at the Hamptons last year. (yes, this was a bit later than the 2008 blowup, but the cause and effect were the same)

Or you can be Lloyd Blankfein, who testified to knowing full well that their MBS desk was shorting the very products they were selling to their clients with sales pitches containing materially false claims. But Lloyd is a great guy, and he's had a rough go if it what with losing his hair and all. So we're not even going to prosecute, er, actually, we won't even bother to investigate the captain of who was privvy to the fraud on his ship, but didn't technically commit the fraud himself. So we'll go after that dumb trader Fabrice Tourre instead. $800k is a pretty stiff fine for someone who earns double that in a year. I'm sure he'll learn his lesson.

Or you could be Dick Fuld....

Perhaps you see a pattern here?

In the 1980s, when regulators and prosecutors didn't regularly get together for drinks with each other at Valentino, over ONE THOUSAND bankers were convicted, with roughly a third going to prison, with an average sentence of 3.2 years for the crimes. Not only including, but ESPECIALLY the captains of the ships.

And they went after EVERYTHING - even violations of campaign contributions laws unrelated to the S&L crisis itself.

Fast-forward to today. For a crisis arguably MORE fraught with fraud, with substantially worse fallout for the country: 59 convictions. Most were traders, in security sales, or ran tiny local banks. ZERO of them were Wall Street C-suite, directors, vice presidents, or anyone else who signed off on the fraud at a higher-than-upper-management level.

In most cases, regulators and prosecutors are hesitant to even INVESTIGATE.

This is to say nothing of the fact that nearly all large Wall Street banks are regarded by Federal regulators as recidivist banks, meaning that they keep breaking the law, getting fined less than the profits made from the crime, and doing it again. And again. And again.

Nobody at HSBC went to prison for facilitating the murder of thousands of Mexicans by cartels. And nobody ever will. There are plenty of statutes on the books to criminally prosecute the bankers responsible. But we won't. Because some people are more equal than others.

These constant apologetics for the parasites are, frankly, sickening.

Same with the constant apologetics for arbitrary enforcement of law. What exactly is the point of having laws if the existential importance of the criminal to a bank is a critical deciding factor in whether or not to investigate, charge, prosecute, or convict?

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by camelite on Saturday March 10, 2018 @05:33AM (#16557971)
As far as I can make out from that article all the executives were jailed for tarp-related crimes. Since tarp post dates the crisis, it's not really accurate to cure it in response to a claim about bankers responsible for the crisis. They admit most of those jailed were low level. Certainly the one top executive using cited was tarp related. Which makes sense, since there were quite good anti fraud controls in tarp.

> It's not illegal, generally speaking, to make dumb investment decisions, and or to take a lot of risk, and lose money

You're not going to find criminals if you don't look for them. Bill black:

> All right so you have massive fraud driving this crisis, hyperinflating the bubble, an FBI warning and how many criminal referrals did the same agency do, in this crisis. Remember it did well over 10,000 in the prior crisis. Well the answer is zero. They completely shut down making criminal referrals

http://neweconomicperspectives.org/2011/09/william-black-why...

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by toomuchtodo on Friday March 09, 2018 @02:31PM (#16554248)
One banker did. For 30 months.

I think Shkreli was obnoxious and crude; the sentencing should've aligned with the crime. But America, so vengeance porn.

https://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/04/magazine/only-one-top-ban...

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by danso on Friday March 09, 2018 @03:44PM (#16554857)
He was also obnoxious and crude in a manner that made it near impossible for the judge to be generous in mitigating his sentence with regards to acceptance of responsibility. He couldn't even wait for an hour after being convicted before going on YouTube and bragging about how he thought he wouldn't face any prison time: https://www.marketwatch.com/story/martin-shkrelis-lawyers-fa...
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by Angostura on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:01PM (#16556157)
What were the specific laws that you believe the 2008 crash bankers broke?
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by MaysonL on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:49PM (#16556413)
Fraud, securities fraud, and forgery would do as a start.
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by edanm on Saturday March 10, 2018 @05:00AM (#16557914)
Who committed fraud, specifically? This always comes up and, while I agree that maybe things possibly weren't investigated enough, I don't think there are any clear examples of people who committed fraud and got away with it.

A lot of people being stupid does not equal fraud.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by beagle3 on Saturday March 10, 2018 @03:50PM (#16560101)
I recommend reading Karl Deninger at https://market-ticker.org/ ; I don't know if his archive back to 2007 are available to non-subscribers, but he's been documenting these issues, quite well presented, since 2007.

The bottom line is, for the 2007/8 crisis, there are hundreds if not thousands of people guilty of fraudulent misrepresentations, and for inventing their own laws, with no reprecussions. I think the most egregious case is the "robo-signing" and MERS case (which are intertwined), which appear to involve thousands of cases of perjury, non of which were prosecuted, or even investigated -- but the publicly available evidence is damning enough, even if no justice official decided to investigate.

But why go back so far? So far, the recent wells fargo fraudulent account opening case [0] has resulted in a slap on the wrist and no one being charged. I don't know who committed fraud specifically, and it seems no one who can find out wishes to find out either. In 8 years, someone like you is going to ask "but who specifically committed fraud? this always comes up". There are clear examples of fraud; if there aren't clear examples of who committed that fraud, it is only because the powers that be decided they do not want to know.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wells_Fargo_account_fraud_scan...

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by MaysonL on Saturday March 10, 2018 @09:00PM (#16561295)
Efery single banker who submitted forged documents in foreclosure cases. Possibly every banker who blacklisted honest real estate appraisers in order to find ones who would give them an appraised value high enough to justify the loans (to people whom the bankter assisted in fraudulently applcations for) which they would sell off profitably securitised to investors duped by credit rating agencies lyingly giving them AAA ratings.
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by jjeaff on Saturday March 10, 2018 @05:19AM (#16557946)
Which laws did the bankers break?

The 2008 financial crisis was very complex and had many bad actors on many sides, but the majority of outright fraud was committed by small time mortgage originators (or employees of large originators) and the individual homeowners who lied to get loans.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by brucephillips on Friday March 09, 2018 @03:42PM (#16554839)
Nowhere in that article does it describe an actual crime that went unprosecuted.

Shkreli broke the law. The financiers causing the financial collapse did not. Perhaps the laws should be changed.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by theo775 on Friday March 09, 2018 @04:13PM (#16555095)
"The financiers causing the financial collapse did not."

They weren't prosecuted. That doesn't mean they didn't break the law.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by rayiner on Friday March 09, 2018 @04:15PM (#16555112)
Likewise, just because they caused the financial collapse doesn't mean they broke the law.
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by toomuchtodo on Friday March 09, 2018 @04:26PM (#16555201)
CDO (Collateralized Debt Obligation) origination fraud is a crime. The GFC was not caused by law abiding activities. It was fraud, plain and simple.

https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/bank-america-pay-1665-billion...

As part of the RMBS Working Group, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of New Jersey conducted a FIRREA investigation into misrepresentations made by Merrill Lynch to investors in 72 RMBS throughout 2006 and 2007. As the statement of facts describes, Merrill Lynch regularly told investors the loans it was securitizing were made to borrowers who were likely and able to repay their debts. Merrill Lynch made these representations even though it knew, based on the due diligence it had performed on samples of the loans, that a significant number of those loans had material underwriting and compliance defects - including as many as 55 percent in a single pool. In addition, Merrill Lynch rarely reviewed the unsampled loans to ensure that the defects observed in the samples were not present throughout the remainder of the pools. Merrill Lynch also disregarded its own due diligence and securitized loans that the due diligence vendors had identified as defective. This practice led one Merrill Lynch consultant to “wonder why we have due diligence performed” if Merrill Lynch was going to securitize the loans “regardless of issues.”

Disclaimer: I was privy to this having known several mortgage underwriters who identified this fraud, and despite reporting it with extensive documentation (which I personally collated and delivered via FedEx) to the SEC, DOJ, and OCC, were ignored.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by rayiner on Friday March 09, 2018 @05:20PM (#16555523)
"Fraud" can be civil fraud, or criminal fraud. Criminal fraud is something like "they said they were going to sell me something, but just took my money instead." Civil fraud might be something like "they sold me 10-inch sandwiches as 12-inch sandwiches."

What you're describing in the paragraph above is even one step removed from the sandwiches. Knowing that "loans had material underwriting and compliance defects" doesn't prove that Merrill Lynch lied when it said "the borrowers ... were likely and able to repay their debts." It might lead to an inference to that effect, but it's not indisputable proof. Likewise, the fact that it "rarely reviewed the unsampled loans to ensure that the defects observed in the samples were not present throughout the remainder of the pools" might lead to an inference of negligence, but is not indisputable proof of fraud.

Everything described in that paragraph is classic civil fraud and negligence, not criminal fraud.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by kbenson on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:02PM (#16556164)
> Criminal fraud is something like "they said they were going to sell me something, but just took my money instead." Civil fraud might be something like "they sold me 10-inch sandwiches as 12-inch sandwiches."

Is it purely a matter of partial delivery, or does magnitude matter? What if it's "they sold me 10 tons of gold as 12 tons of gold?" Because that's a big difference.

Then again, 10 inch sandwhiches sold as 12 inch sandwhiches allows you to save over 15% of materials, which if you're a nationwide chain could be quite a lot of money as well.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by rayiner on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:30PM (#16556305)
Civil fraud versus criminal fraud is very fuzzy. it often comes down to what you think you can prove about fraudulent intent. I gave the sandwich example because you can create “reasonable doubt” by saying the mistake was due to bad QA, rather than fraudulent intent. The fact that the sandwiches are shorter, by itself, does not prove fraudulent intent.

The mortgages are even harder. The banks are accused of lying about whether borrowers could pay. The fact they couldn’t pay doesn’t prove that. The fact that the banks ignored warning signs doesn’t prove that. The fact they knew about underwriting failures doesn’t prove that. Not beyond a reasonable doubt.

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by kbenson on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:44PM (#16556385)
Thanks, that makes sense. It's less of a it broke these specific laws" and more "can you prove intent" (IIUC).
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by rhizome on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:31PM (#16556311)
OK now do SarbOx. Let's use Jamie Dimon as our example.
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by rayiner on Friday March 09, 2018 @09:46PM (#16556824)
I assume you're talking about this: https://www.salon.com/2013/12/18/jamie_dimons_perp_walk_why_....

The article is garbage.

The author's theory is that Dimon is liable under SOX Section 906, because he certified that JP Morgan has "adequate internal controls" under SOX Section 404, but admitted that their controls need some work a month later.

But Section 404 is addressed to "internal control structure and procedures for financial reporting." I.e. do you have controls in place to address the Enron-style situation of people using creative accounting to cook the books. What Dimon was talking about, in the context of the London Whale, were risk management controls. The author tries to lump them together, but the statute clearly addresses accounting controls, not risk management controls. See 15 U.S.C. 7262(a). There's lots of different kinds of "controls" in a company. E.g. there are controls to make sure employees don't pay bribes in foreign countries so as to expose the company to FCPA liability. SOX only addresses controls in connection with financial reporting.

Even if you got past that hurdle, the article is wrong to suggest that you could bring a SOX 906 prosecution for violation of a SOX 404 requirement.

SOX 906 states:

> The statement required under subsection (a) shall certify that the periodic report containing the financial statements fully complies with the requirements of section 13(a) or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (15 U.S.C. 78m or 78o(d)) and that information contained in the periodic report fairly presents, in all material respects, the financial condition and results of operations of the issuer. That's the result of the Enron debacle, where the company and its auditors were misrepresenting the financial status of the company (revenues, liabilities, etc.).

Securities Exchange Act Sections 13(a) or 15(d) don't say anything about adequate internal controls. That's part of SOX Section 404. By the plain terms of the statute, Section 906 liability doesn't attach to misrepresentations directed to Section 404 requirements.

There is a separate certification provision that covers the Section 404 requirements, SOX Section 302.[1] But to bring a criminal action for violation of the Section 302 certification, you have to get a little creative, applying the other securities criminal statutes: http://dodd-frank.com/u-s-brings-criminal-charges-for-false-....

The problem is, those other criminal statutes are directed to protecting people who own or are considering buying JP Morgan stock, not people who bought financial products from JP Morgan. They're designed to prevent Dimon from misrepresenting JP Morgan's financial health to JP Morgan's investors, not to prevent JP Morgan employees from lying to transactional counterparties.

[1] https://www.mofo.com/resources/publications/sec-requires-ceo...

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by camelite on Saturday March 10, 2018 @06:31AM (#16558089)
This article [1] states that the nature of the offense doesn't necessarily distinguish civil from criminal fraud, but rather the party pursuing the legal action:

> A single act of fraud can be prosecuted as a criminal fraud by prosecutors, and also as a civil action by the party that was the victim of the misrepresentation.

> It might lead to an inference to that effect, but it's not indisputable proof.

Again we're back to the lack of evidence not implying innocence if the supposed crime wasn't adequately investigated. That's what an investigation is for, to find and assemble evidence for a suspected crime.

Its a common belief that no serious effort to incriminate top bankers was initiated. To me it is beyond argument at this point. Do you still believe that is a questionable supposition?

[1] http://bochettoandlentz.com/criminal-fraud-vs-civil-fraud-wh...

Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by ansible on Friday March 09, 2018 @04:34PM (#16555253)
Indeed. There was fraud committed at all levels which lead up to the crash.
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by throwaway613834 on Friday March 09, 2018 @04:04PM (#16555030)
I like how absolutely critical little 'details' like this get missed on HN so easily, by people speaking with extreme confidence. Thanks for the reality check!
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by Super_Jambo on Friday March 09, 2018 @06:07PM (#16555838)
Madoff went to prison, but then he foolishly made rich people the victims of his ponzi not the economy at large.
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by purplezooey on Saturday March 10, 2018 @12:15AM (#16557208)
Excellent point. 0 bankers went to jail (other than that one BofA dude). One of the great travesties of this decade.
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by stevenh on Friday March 09, 2018 @05:52PM (#16555748)
You think people should go to prison for being obnoxious?
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by DoreenMichele on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:06PM (#16556183)
Cases like this always use expressions like "showed a lack of remorse." It speaks to how likely they are to reoffend.
Re:Martin Shkreli has been sentenced to seven years in prison by Retra on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:04PM (#16556176)
That's not what was said at all.